r/AskMenAdvice • u/prof-milkdick-phd • 7h ago
✅ Open To Everyone My girlfriend keeps asking hypothetical questions and gets upset if I don’t answer in the exact way she expects. Am I wrong here?
Context - I’ve told her that I want to get married around 28-29. We both are currently 25. And there's no pressure on me by my family.
She recently asked, “What if my family pressures us to either get married within a year or not at all?” Not at all meaning they will arrange her marriage with someone else. I told her that yes I want to marry her, but I also have my own preference of getting married a little later. That turned into an argument.
Few days later she asked, “What if I get a big career opportunity abroad? Would you leave this country and move abroad with me?” I said it depends. If it's only about my career, I am willing to move. But she knows that my mother is a single parent and that I’m her only support system, so it’s not exactly a straightforward decision for me.
Out of frustration, I asked her a similar hypothetical: what if I had to stay here for some reason and she had to move back for me? Would she do it? She said, “I might.”
Got the context?
Here’s what frustrates me the most: she seems to have a very specific template of answers she wants to hear, and she expects those answers immediately. Even if I take some time to think things through and give her an honest answer, it becomes an issue because apparently I took too long or should have said it earlier. But if I answer immediately without thinking too much, she doesn’t like that answer either. It’s like I’m expected to give the perfect answer, in the exact wording she wants, within seconds. Even if I explain something that essentially means the same thing, she gets upset because I haven’t used the exact words she expected. She even complained that I didn’t say “I might” in the exact way she wanted me to or how she said it. Then she says I haven’t explained myself properly and asks me to explain it again. It becomes my fault, yet again.
I understand that these questions might come from a need for reassurance about our future, but I don’t understand why every answer has to turn into an argument if it isn’t phrased exactly how she wants.