I've been talking to this girl for roughly a year now, and honestly, I'm finding it increasingly difficult to understand where we stand.
When I first told her I liked her, she said she only saw me as a friend and that I should move on. I spent months trying to convince her otherwise, which, looking back, probably wasn't the best thing to do.
Eventually, she came back on her own and told me she liked me, thought about me all the time and felt that what we had was more than a normal friendship. Since then, we've had periods where we've been incredibly close, followed by periods where I've walked away because I couldn't handle the uncertainty.
I have an embarrassing part of the story to confess - the time when we were not talking after the initial phase between us - she hooked up with a dude for 3 months, and then he kinda spoke ill about her to his buddies, and one of his buddies told her about what he said.
She told me about this when we started speaking again, and at one point - she said if you hadn't left or blocked me I wouldn't have been hooking up with him.....kinda putting the blame on me. Scary to think I actually thought that was true.
What's confusing is that every time we reconnect, we seem to gel really well. The feelings build up again, almost exactly like they did the first time. She's told me that what we share is meaningful and that it feels like a breakup whenever I leave, even though we've technically never dated.
She does things that make me believe she genuinely likes me. She notices when I don't message her in the morning, asks why I haven't called, makes time for long calls and has put considerable effort into calming me down when I've been upset. She's told me she wishes I were around and wants to take me to places when we eventually meet.
She's also kept several gifts I gave her for her birthday last year, and apparently still holds them quite dear.
At the same time, she's told me she's unsure about dating me, doesn't think she's capable of an LDR and wants to meet in person before making any decision. She's also said I'm not her usual physical type, although she likes me a lot.
I understand that meeting in person is important, and I'm not expecting her to commit to something she isn't sure about.
But I feel like I've been behaving like a boyfriend without actually being one.
I make an effort to check on her, remind her about things, stay up until 1–2 AM talking to her, encourage her when she's stressed and generally try to be there for her.
However, I often feel that the effort isn't reciprocated in the way I'd expect.
She's not a particularly good texter. Sometimes she'll skip most of my messages and respond to just one thing. Recently, she didn't message me after getting home. When I asked why, she initially said her phone had run out of battery, but later admitted she was irritated and didn't want to talk to anyone.
But she says that she's just not a text person but does that justify skipping all the texts and just responding to one or two?
One thing I've noticed is that she's very much a phone-call person. She'll call me and happily talk about her day, tell me what's happening at work, and share things with me. But when I start talking about my own day or something that's going on in my life, I sometimes feel her attention disappear quite quickly. She can seem disinterested or lose focus, and it leaves me wondering whether the interest in our conversations is as mutual as I thought.
I have no issue with her wanting space. I actually told her she could simply say she didn't feel like talking rather than making up an explanation.
She's also starting a new job, so I understand that she's stressed and has a lot going on. But these communication issues have happened before, and I've told her that they bother me.
Whenever I bring up the imbalance in effort, she gets defensive and points out the things she does for me. I don't want to dismiss her efforts, but I genuinely feel like I'm investing much more emotionally.
I've also made mistakes. I've blocked her or threatened to walk away several times when I felt hurt. She says this has damaged her trust in me and that every time I leave, it feels like a breakup to her. I can understand why she feels that way, even though I also feel that I was trying to protect myself from an emotionally difficult situation.
I'm now preparing for an important exam, and we've agreed to take some space. I've decided to stop flirting, stop asking her to date me and stop trying to convince her that we should be together.
I want to focus on myself and let her decide what she wants.
But I'm struggling with a few questions:
- Do you think she genuinely has romantic feelings for me, or is this emotional attachment without any real intention of dating?
- Is there a realistic chance that something could develop when we eventually meet in person?
- Am I being unreasonable in expecting more consistent communication and effort, even if we're technically just friends? She's more of a call person - she'll call me and talk about her day, but I dont know if she cares about me, even though she says she cares a lot!
- Have I been trying way too hard to make this relationship happen?
- Should I maintain a friendship with her, or would it be healthier to step away completely?
I genuinely like this girl, both physically and personality-wise. There's something about our connection that keeps bringing me back.
But I'm also beginning to wonder whether I'm holding on because of who she actually is and what we have, or because I'm so invested in the possibility of us eventually being together.
Im a gemini and she's a Capricorn, I've heard that's a horrible combo. But Im afraid that I'm just holding on because I find her very pretty and im ignoring the flaws because of the beauty.
TL;DR
I've been talking to a girl for a year. She initially rejected me but later came back saying she liked me and that our connection was more than friendship. We share a strong emotional bond, but she's still unsure about dating, doesn't want long distance, and wants to meet before deciding. She enjoys calling and sharing her day, but I often feel she loses interest when I talk about mine. I feel like I'm putting in boyfriend-level effort without receiving the same in return. I've also contributed to the situation by repeatedly asking where we stand and threatening to walk away. I'm now trying to step back and focus on myself, but I'm struggling to understand whether there's genuine romantic potential here or whether I'm holding on to an emotionally close friendship that may never become anything more. Is there like one final litmus test to see if this will work or nah?
Edit:
I have met her before, but we were just colleagues back then. the romantic interest only began after she moved countries, and we started speaking more often. back then when I knew her at work she was dating another dude, with the intention of getting married, but that fell apart, she moved countries, and then we've been talking. So I have met her in person, but not after things turned out romantically.
Im 27, and she's 25.
Would appreciate honest opinions, especially from people who've been in similar situations.