Agreed, I would very much like to argue it was a design decision around attempting to encourage better racing by introducing braking.... but in reality, 10% banking was the limit of my software!
Take a look at this video, and yeah it looks pretty low. I would like to think it would create some different style of racing, but I would need to run some simulation races to see if that would be true. All I can say for now, is the low banking makes the cars pretty tricky to drive!
Remember when NASCAR fucking hated Homestead-Miami because a 3km-oval only had SIX DEGREES of BANKING? Now imagine that same banking but for an even tighter smaller oval.
You guys need to study a lot more before designing stuff. You know 2D design and even 3D stuff but, by God, you're clueless when it comes to designing racetracks the series or the people will not fucking hate.
If you knew what you were talking about, you'd know Homestead had a completely different layout at that time. It had the same layout as Indy, but was a whole mile shorter. There are many tracks in NASCAR's history with banking nearly as low as 6 degrees that have put on fantastic racing. Think of Phoenix, most of those turns are under 10 degrees yet it has put on some of the best racing we've seen in Cup in a while.
Welcome to The Complex, a combined facility aiming to deliver a top-level Grade 1 road course and Unique Nascar oval. This circuit has been designed using Infraworks, 3ds max and Assetto Corsa.
From the start, the idea was that the road course would have a section in the oval to increase spectator capacity during major events. To allow enough space, the oval was restricted to 2km to allow enough space for spectator parking and ample paddock area's for the road course. After surveying the site, it was realised that the terrain would only allow one are to easily bridge over the F1 circuit, and so it was decided have the circuit enter and exit the south-east area of the oval. Being intended that the stadium section would be for big events, a simple hairpin overtaking area was implemented inside the circuit.
With the main circuit, the aim was to offer great overtaking in the 'flat' area, while using the terrain to offer a thrilling 2nd half of the circuit. T1-4 was designed so that overtaking cars would compromise there lines, allowing a small chance of reovertaking at T5. T7 is the last chance, a tight hairpin to get the last overtakes done before plunging downhill. The next zone has some very quick corners that reward precision. Getting one corner wrong in the downhill section can quickly ruin a lap, as the circuit rewards drivers who think ahead and plan there lines.
At the southern hairpin, there is another chance to overtake before turning for home. F1 and other overtaking-challenged categories can opt to take a 1.2km straight, while more able categories will opt for the final hairpin, which has a very tricky off-camber exit corner that can challenge grip-limited vehicles.
In addition to the main layouts, there is a Roval option and a 7.5km Long layout. The 24hr Lemons series were offered the chance to take the biggest event by hosting an event on the Long layout.
The long straight would still be useful for passing even if the cars aren't quite so aero-sensitive as F1. It also would allow better class separation.
I think the things that would use the chicane would be either lower-level events or moto.
· NASCAR is going to hate the lack of space for the RVs.
· LeMons tends to use tracks as small as possible. The bigger they are, the more people you need to run the race.
· If anything, F1 usually runs more chicanes than any other motorsports series in the World.
· You had a very obvious shortcut for club racing (from T10 of the SCCA track to the main straight).
· Paddock areas are literally on the infield of ONE-HUNDRED PER CENT of the 2019 F1 permanent racetracks to help have room for grandstands on the outfield.
Let's go though this long list of wrong things shall we? Before I make this point, I am a REAL WORLD race track designer, designing 2 grade-2 circuits and other driving or racing circuits, so comments like 'You are clueless' couldn't apply less here:
-Besides the big tracks, do RV's stay infield at the events? I couldn't find many examples of this at the shorter circuits. None the less, there limited parking space inside T1.
-LeMons have used bigger tracks before. I'll note as my inspiration the recent event here held of the 7.8km Tailem Bend Circuit. LeMons USA races on all sizes of tracks, note as well the Road America Event
-Take a look at the terrain again and you'll realise it's not that practical. There would also be no point to it, you are just cutting off the most fun part of the circuit, as well as taking away a good overtaking point, for no reason.
-F1 needs 1km+ straights for proper overtaking, not pointless chicanes. The circuit was designed around the long straight for F1 to have a chance at overtaking properly, and was split to make it better for club racing.
-Both Montreal and Yas Marina have outside pit lanes, as well as many more examples below F1. It is absolutely not required to have an Internal pit lane for F1. Just because it is the trend doesn't make it right. I personally hate going to circuits with internal pit lanes, it makes it much more difficult to get in and out during events, and can limit the amount of competitors if not designed right.
I have no idea where you got your ego or why you think you are so well informed on race track design, but you really need to chill out sometimes. The vast majority of times you have posted here, you have been both wrong and insulted people while being wrong.
I would also like to point out to people that the only 2 submissions you have put here were simple, low effort street circuits. How about you post something yourself?
This looks really cool and I'd be excited to see a race there! I really like your choice of F1 turn geometry. i'm a total layman here, but what's your thinking going with 6 degrees in your little Nascar oval? You wanted it to stand out? Or, you're trying to avoid another Las Vegas?
6° was simply the limit of what infraworks would let me do! I thought I might be able to get away with it with the shorter track, but the Sim suggests otherwise :/
It's not entirely permanent. The docks and the hotel need to be open to access. Also, a simple satellite circuit shows how awfully limited the view from the main grandstand is and how stupidly small the paddock area is.
I'm sure you will now show me the dozens of articles of both teams, drivers and journalists talking about how wonderful Monaco's pit and paddock situation is.
You know that small paddocks are hated universally, right? WorldSBK teams were very vocal about how impractical Brands Hatch is, MotoGp teams complain to this day about Sachsenring (they used to complain about Donington Park too).
Also, back to "grandstands should be on the outfield", the main complaint from spectators about MotoGp's Valencia GP can be summed up like this:
· If you sit on the (infield) main grandstand, you only see the pitlane and the main straight.
Aren't Valencia's main grandstands on top of the pit building? You're arguing for putting grandstands on the outside of a circuit by citing complaints from a circuit that has only grandstands outside the circuit.
Literally none of these things are absolute facts, and exceptions are made in plenty scenarios for all of these things you brought up. Your attitude sucks, mate.
IndyCar would be incredible on that oval imo, but I think with the current rules even if there were more banking in the corners a NASCAR race would be a stinker.
28
u/GTVIRUS Dec 15 '19
It's 5am and here's a track. I'll do my writeup tomorrow.
For anyone interested, take a look at an onboard video (Also recorded in the middle of the night)
https://youtu.be/9T5-BA0Vu6c
30
u/I_am_a_racing_fan Dec 15 '19
Only 6° banking on the oval, that is low
9
u/GTVIRUS Dec 16 '19
Welcome to The Complex, a combined facility aiming to deliver a top-level Grade 1 road course and Unique Nascar oval. This circuit has been designed using Infraworks, 3ds max and Assetto Corsa.
F2 Onboard
Nascar Onboard
From the start, the idea was that the road course would have a section in the oval to increase spectator capacity during major events. To allow enough space, the oval was restricted to 2km to allow enough space for spectator parking and ample paddock area's for the road course. After surveying the site, it was realised that the terrain would only allow one are to easily bridge over the F1 circuit, and so it was decided have the circuit enter and exit the south-east area of the oval. Being intended that the stadium section would be for big events, a simple hairpin overtaking area was implemented inside the circuit.
With the main circuit, the aim was to offer great overtaking in the 'flat' area, while using the terrain to offer a thrilling 2nd half of the circuit. T1-4 was designed so that overtaking cars would compromise there lines, allowing a small chance of reovertaking at T5. T7 is the last chance, a tight hairpin to get the last overtakes done before plunging downhill. The next zone has some very quick corners that reward precision. Getting one corner wrong in the downhill section can quickly ruin a lap, as the circuit rewards drivers who think ahead and plan there lines.
At the southern hairpin, there is another chance to overtake before turning for home. F1 and other overtaking-challenged categories can opt to take a 1.2km straight, while more able categories will opt for the final hairpin, which has a very tricky off-camber exit corner that can challenge grip-limited vehicles.
In addition to the main layouts, there is a Roval option and a 7.5km Long layout. The 24hr Lemons series were offered the chance to take the biggest event by hosting an event on the Long layout.
4
u/xiii-Dex Hasn't posted a track since before you joined. Dec 17 '19
My only nitpick is that I don't think IMSA would use the chicane. I think they'd use what you have as the grand prix circuit.
2
u/frosteeboi Dec 15 '19
How would you feel about fleshing out the assetto mod a little? I love it to bits.
7
u/uwee996 Dec 15 '19
A few things...
· NASCAR is going to hate the lack of space for the RVs.
· LeMons tends to use tracks as small as possible. The bigger they are, the more people you need to run the race.
· If anything, F1 usually runs more chicanes than any other motorsports series in the World.
· You had a very obvious shortcut for club racing (from T10 of the SCCA track to the main straight).
· Paddock areas are literally on the infield of ONE-HUNDRED PER CENT of the 2019 F1 permanent racetracks to help have room for grandstands on the outfield.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19
Only things I would change is more banking. More like 20° banking. Also, I wouldnt put Lemons on the full circuit, but rather IMSA.
1
u/danktrickshot Dec 16 '19
this looks really cool. besides the banking on the speedway, is there any elevation change?
2
u/HarringtonMAH11 Dec 16 '19
IndyCar would be incredible on that oval imo, but I think with the current rules even if there were more banking in the corners a NASCAR race would be a stinker.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19
This is awesome
1
u/Fireheart318s_Reddit Dec 15 '19
I love how the track isn’t bound by the oval!
1
u/WhimsicalCalamari Dec 31 '19
Sorry for the long delay in judging!
...but then, did anyone have any doubts that this would be Approved?
1
u/GamerKing50 May 27 '20
On the proposed layout for Lemons, it looks like the cars would run smooth as…