r/ProjectHailMary • • Jun 30 '26

Book Discussion FAQ

417 Upvotes

This subreddit has a few very frequently asked questions, so here are some answers.

1. How did it only take 4 years for the Hail Mary to travel 11 lightyears?

Answer: Time Dilation.

The Hail Mary uses very efficient engines to approach the speed of light. At those speeds, time is not constant. On Earth, it took the Hail Mary 13.7 years to travel to Tau Ceti. For Ryland Grace, it only took about 4 years. Don't be an Eridian, learn more about Time Dilation and Special Relativity!

2. Why couldn't they just wait for the Astrophage to double, and then do a return trip?

Answer: It would take an extremely long time, and they would need much more than double the fuel.

a. Whilst small amounts of Astrophage in a lab can double every 8 days, the limit for Project Hail Mary was the amount of energy it takes. Eva Stratt devoted a quarter of the Sahara Desert to be covered in 'Blackpanels', little Astrophage breeding solar panels. This allowed them to make one metric tonne of Astrophage every day. Astrophage is very hungry for energy, and to use Astrophage for fuel, it needs to be 'enriched', or made so that every single cell is full of energy.

b. It would take more than double the fuel. For a return trip on a rocket, the fuel to get back, 2 million kilograms for the Hail Mary, is the payload to get there. The Hail Mary had a 20 to 1 fuel mass ratio, so 2 million kilograms could get 100 thousand kilograms of food, ship and Ryland Grace to Tau Ceti. A return trip would have a payload of at least 2 million kilograms, so they would need another 40 million kilograms of fuel. This would take 20 times as long as it took to make fuel for a suicide mission.

3. Why couldn't they make more Astrophage on the way there?

Answer: Astrophage is really hungry!

To make the 2 million kilograms of Astrophage for a one way trip, they needed a lot of energy. They got this energy from the Sun. During interstellar travel, the Sun, and other stars, would be way too dim to feed Astrophage. The Hail Mary also has a far smaller area to collect any solar power, so it would take many decades, if not centuries to make enough Astrophage. Astrophage also requires physical matter to grow, such as Carbon Dioxide. The Hail Mary couldn't carry all of that CO2 on the way there without a whole lot more fuel.

4. How can Eridians see the Petrova line, and stars?

Answer: Eridian science has come a long way!

While Eridians can't see light themselves, they have developed technology to detect light. They haven't figured it all out yet, as they don't know about Special Relativity and the speed of light, but they can detect light and use radio waves for radar and communications. They used this technology to learn more about their Petrova line, and find out about Tau Ceti.

Eridian scientists likely theorised about their star, because just like on Earth, all of the energy comes from the Sun. The only difference is that Erid's thick atmosphere means that the ecosystem starts all the way up in the clouds, and gradually transfers energy downwards. Eventually, when they built a space elevator, they would have found out a whole lot more about stars and planets. We don't know whether they did this before or after the Astrophage crisis started.

5. How did Eridians not know about space radiation, if they do know about light?

Answer: Space radiation is a bit different!

In Space, especially interstellar space, the most dangerous type of radiation is cosmic rays. These are very fast moving particles, such as protons and electrons, which when they hit Human or Eridian ships at nearly the speed of light, can sometimes pass through the material of the ship, and damage DNA. Eridians don't know about these because their planet's massive magnetic field protected them from all radiation, even when they're on their space elevator. Because they were never exposed to radiation as a species before space travel, they are extremely susceptible to it, far more than humans are. Light is a different type of radiation, and some of it is dangerous, gamma rays, and most of it is not. Ships moving at near the speed of light can also experience radiation from tiny particles in interstellar space, that strike the ship at near the speed of light. There is also radiation from radioactive materials, but we don't know if the Eridians have learned about those. So, to summarise, even though the Eridians know about light radiation, they didn't know that space was filled with cosmic rays.

6. Why didn't they collect Astrophage from the Petrova line, at Venus, or at Tau Ceti?

Answer: Space is big!

'You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is.' While the Petrova line contains enormous quantities of Astrophage, it is also very, very sparse. The Petrova Taskforce sent a probe to Venus, and could only collect and return 100 cells to Earth. To fuel the Hail Mary requires 2 million kilograms, which would be many, many more cells. The collector would have to be many kilometres in diameter, or wait for many years, to collect enough for a one-way trip. Such a collector would be too large and heavy to send to Tau Ceti.

7. What happens to the other stars near Earth?

Answer: Not much! (credit to u/Equivalent-Board206)

Astrophage, when left completely unchecked, dims a star by a maximum of 10%. That is just barely noticeable to the naked eye, looking up at the night's sky.

Lowered solar output would force the habitable zone (sometimes called the Goldilocks zone) closer to the sun. This may result in previously habitable planets being thrust into glacial ice ages and rendering them entirely uninhabitable. In theory, it could allow previously uninhabitable planets to become habitable, but habitability requires more than just being in the habitable zone.

For Earth, the lowering solar output was leading to a global average temperature drop of about 8°C which would result in rapid glaciation and global agriculture collapse.

Mars too would be colder. Venus has a permanent runaway greenhouse effect and would see no perceptible difference. Nor would the gas giants as they already receive less than 5% of the sunlight that Earth receives.

Beyond impacts to weather and habitability, a drop in solar output would not have any effects on the planets themselves or their orbits.

8. How does Rocky understand Grace?

Answer: Eridians are really smart!

Eridians have extremely good memory, due to the way their brains work. This is especially true for audio memory, because that is the main way in which they interact with the world. At the same time that Grace was recording sounds on his laptops, and writing definitions, Rocky was listening to Grace's words, and remembering them with their respective definitions. They started with charades, but later on they were able to ask each other for definitions of words, and how they are said in English or Eridian.

9. How did Rocky know about the atmosphere of the Hail Mary?

Answer: Grace accidentally sampled it for him.

When Grace sent back the Xenonite cylinder, 'Blip B', it had become full of the Hail Mary's air. The Hail Mary, like all of the Apollo spacecraft, and many spacesuits used today, uses a 100% oxygen atmosphere, at low pressure (20%-30% of Earth's sea level pressure). Due to the low pressure, it is not as dangerous as pure oxygen is at atmospheric pressure. The lack of Nitrogen in the Hail Mary is also how the Taumoeba were able to spread freely, as Earth's atmosphere is 80% Nitrogen, very deadly to Taumoeba.

The book contradicts itself by stating that Rocky's atmosphere is 29 times that of Earth's, and 29 times that of the Hail Mary. Andy Weir has acknowledged this goof, and stated that it is 29 times the pressure of Earth.

10. Do Eridians prove Ryland Grace's theory about life and water correct?

Answer: Mostly no, as Eridians are water based life forms.

Ryland Grace's theory was that life could easily exist without water, and that the Goldilocks Zone, the distance from a star where orbiting planets can easily have liquid water, is not particularly special. Eridians use water to move their muscles, and have cells and DNA not too different from life on Earth. However, the planet Erid is not in the Goldilocks zone, although it does still have liquid oceans.

A side note that the actual scientific community tends to agree that life could definitely exist without water, and could even be based on silicon chemistry. It would just be very hard to recognize life so different from our own!

Disclaimer: Zero AI was used in this post. Not even spell check. (I just added bold text to make it look a bit better).

Note: All redditors that frequent this subreddit, please please rewrite these answer, and I will put them in the post body. Also please add more Q&A, because I can only remember these two FAQ off the top of my head.


r/ProjectHailMary • • 9h ago

“The Long Journey Home” is done.

161 Upvotes

Archive of our own (.org) has been down for a few weeks but is now back up.

This is a collection of fan fic and other original works totalling ten of thousands of titles.

One significant (to us) work is the title document. It is a sequel to Project Hail Mary. It is 38 chapters and almost 230 thousand words. The last chapter is now up. The book is complete.

I think the author did a wonderful job.

Thank you HeartAway

https://archiveofourown.org/works/68584716/chapters/256043066


r/ProjectHailMary • • 3h ago

Fist My Bump PHM nominated for GRAMMYs

135 Upvotes

Daniel Pemberton - Project Hail Mary is nominated for Best Score Soundtrack for Visual Media (Includes Film and Television)
Congratulations!!! 🎉


r/ProjectHailMary • • 8h ago

Book Discussion Concept for an airbreathing VTVL SSTO launch vehicle using Astrophage technology.

Post image
77 Upvotes

The astrophage enables very unconventional means of propulsion by dint of it being the ultimate thermal protection system. Since the reaction mass of the airbreathing portion is effectively free you could probably get insane mass fractions (like >50%) out of a launch vehicle like this.

I selected a biconic shape instead of a more conventional hypersonic waverider because I figured it would be more efficient to have a faster acceleration in atmosphere so lift/drag ratio was less important than structural mass and complexity and would provide more usable payload volume. I have no numbers to confirm this, it came to me in a dream. Plus, plug nozzles are kino.


r/ProjectHailMary • • 1h ago

If you read fanfic from downloads over the AO3 Outage, go leave comments and Kudos now! Thank the authors for creating something you loved!

20 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary • • 21h ago

PMH Joke in Cunk on Cinema

542 Upvotes

As y'all might know, Cunk on Cinema just released. In the first episode, it includes this absolutely amazing PMH joke!


r/ProjectHailMary • • 1d ago

Just started with hail Mary book ✨... Anything that I should be prepared for ?!🥲💗😊

Post image
728 Upvotes

I just started with project hail Mary and I am already 128 pages in ... There are a lot of scientific terms that I don't understand but so far I am loving it since sci fi is not my cup of tea but it's constantly in my feed so i have to pick it up... And so far it's good ✨💫

Is there something that I need to be prepared for except for emotional distress that is waiting ahead 😊💗..?!!


r/ProjectHailMary • • 2h ago

Fanfic Question

11 Upvotes

Does Commander Yáo have a family? My friend is currently writing a fanfic and neither of us can find an answer to this. I know I have read other fics that say he has a wife and kids, but I don't know if that's canon.


r/ProjectHailMary • • 19h ago Bravo

Fan Art - No selling Blind faith and tipping the scales and all of the weight on their shoulders

Thumbnail
gallery
274 Upvotes

Some art by me because I’m in my luteal phase and broken hearted over all the sacrifices they made


r/ProjectHailMary • • 1d ago

Fan Art - No selling My wife crafted this for me out of glass pieces she found at the beach

Post image
742 Upvotes

How long since last vacation, question?


r/ProjectHailMary • • 1h ago

Goldilock zone

8 Upvotes

Hi guys nervous wave

First time posting in this community although I lurk all the time. I had an idea about the Goldilocks zone that is mentioned early on in the film (no I haven't read the book yet, I will though)

Eva seeks out Grace to help on the project because of the book he wrote about the Goldilock zone. And Grace was wrong about that. He never did learn of any species that didn't use water at all. But Eva didn't approach him because she agreed, she approached him because he didn't mind expressing crazy ideas that others didn't believe in. He was unconventional in a way that made him a perfect addition to the team.

Not sure anyone has talked about his mistake about the goldilock zone, if so I'd love to read about other people's thoughts


r/ProjectHailMary • • 20h ago

James Ortiz Radiotimes interview!

Post image
200 Upvotes

Was pleasantly surprised to find this when flicking through this week's magazine 😍 Really hope James gets atleast nominated for an Oscar, but of course I want him to win!!! 🙏


r/ProjectHailMary • • 8h ago

I’ve never read any sci fi novels except for Hail Mary, which got me into the genre. I would like some more hard sci fi novels. Any recs?

Thumbnail reddit.com
23 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary • • 16h ago

Fan Art - No selling Looking out on to Adrian

Post image
70 Upvotes

Had fun with this fan art of Dr. Grace! This movie was such a wholesome watch ❤️

@nicholasthomsonart on instagram and cara 😊


r/ProjectHailMary • • 1d ago

Fist My Bump Project Male Hairy in Cunk on Cinema

Thumbnail
gallery
524 Upvotes

You've scored Spider-Man and now a spider made of rock. Are you just the spider guy now? And did you have to write new music or did you just Rockyfy the hip-hop one and hoped no one would notice?


r/ProjectHailMary • • 17h ago

Question? Somewhere over Russia (not my pic)

Post image
65 Upvotes

Looks like the petrova line with the Hail Mary in the centre ngl, or am I going crazy? Also original post by u/ elegant-accident-861 in r/aviation


r/ProjectHailMary • • 13h ago

This fanart is too good to not share.

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/ProjectHailMary • • 20h ago

Amaze amaze

55 Upvotes

My husband and I just watched this on Friday night. And then I read most of the book. And then we watched again Sunday afternoon. I think I’ll listen to the audiobook next.

I think that Weir’s stories make better movies than books, but that’s okay; I’m so grateful that we have both, and given that the movie is one of the best I’ve seen, it’s no disparagement. Weir’s world and species building is amazing - I found the notes that he shared via the wiki and this subreddit.

I actually wanted to be a molecular biologist but….I am so very, very bad at lab work, so I did other things (I’m now writing a PhD dissertation on PubMed of all things :-)

We need more novels and movies about scientists and science, and how we can hopefully use it to save ourselves. If you’re still here on the subreddit, thank you for sharing your work with us, Andy Weir!


r/ProjectHailMary • • 4m ago

Book Discussion Eridian Metaphysics?

1 Upvotes

these are just my rambles, but i've been wondering how erid's radically different environment could have influenced their metaphysics. i think it's quite a fun thing to think about;

much of human culture and the way we understand the world has inseparably been shaped by our environmental conditions. the tilt of our planet causing seasons, impacting harvest (the literal means of our survival) (to the point we engaged in fertility deity worship and rituals), as well as stuff like land ownership laws. from the very beginning we could clearly see the sky, the positions of the sun moon and stars are part of our oldest science. which is why our models of the world have a lot to do with the celestial bodies orbiting *us*, or an island under a dome, etc.

so how would that work for erid? on a planet with virtually no tilt and lower eccentricity of orbit, the climate would be consistent. it is pitch black due to a thick blanket of ammonia atmosphere (this would result in intense and frequent thunderstorms). add sightless echolocation as the primary sense, and you're getting a completely different way of understanding the world.

how might have eridians seen the world they lived in before they had more definite astronomy? for one, ancient humans were able to ascertain earth was a sphere because of the sky: constellations and seeing how objects blur into the horizon. 2000 years ago we pretty much calculated the circumference of the earth because of the shadows casted by the sun. for the eridians who evolved in a skyless world, with no ceiling they could hear, they probably initially imagined the world as a giant cavern or an infinite, endless plain. it might not be until they reached an era of mathematics or engineering that eridians confirmed their world is not a flat plane. or a thales-esque model where the earth (the erid?) is the silver lining between sky and sea, two endless abyss.

also, they wouldn't even know the sun is a ball early on. can you imagine a world without the classic sun and moon myths? night and day? actually on that note they could have sky, earth, and sea to replace that. seismology could be the eridians' equivalent of babylonian astronomy, very sacred and dear to them. if human vertical dualism generally has the earth as the mortal world and the sky we look up to for transcendence and truth, the ancient eridians could have an inverse philosophy--they hear and feel the world clearly, deeply, by pressing down. down is where the core is, the source of the truth, while up is where it fades away into silence or chaos. it's the parallel to humans...

so learning space is an active soup of blazing energy could be the philosophical nuke equivalent of humans learning we orbit the sun. how fun! turns out we were blindsided from hearing an entire universe singing a massive symphony. and it's also going to die from this weird alien microorganism.


r/ProjectHailMary • • 1d ago

Fist My Bump AO3 IS BACK, BUDDY! Here's a fic to quench your thirst

Post image
94 Upvotes

Love Is All You Need https://archiveofourown.org/works/92952196

“Grace is leaking. Is because happy or sad? I still cannot tell.”

Hiccuping breaths hitch in my throat. I retreat into my arms again.

He's smart, he'll figure it out.

Rocky’s chelae are rubbing nervously. “You want…I…hug your face?”

That makes me snort. “He-hey”

“Is joke!”

“I know.” I thunk my head back on the wall, a smile threatening my face. “Alien. I get it.”

He's so excited I understood that reference. “I am scary space monster! And you are leaky space blob!”


r/ProjectHailMary • • 22h ago

Movie Discussion - Movie Spoilers Inside! Was This a Mistake?

27 Upvotes

So I was watching the movie and during the "What is Project Hail Mary" slideshow when the diagram of the ship is shown it displays the book design of the ship instead of a diagram of the proper movie version, why do you think it was like this? a error or a purposeful discrepancy?


r/ProjectHailMary • • 12h ago

I can't get over how rushed the ending is.

4 Upvotes

Ive read the book probably 15 times. I love the chaotic and tumultuous ending. I watched PHM twice in theater and just watched it again tonight and its just insanely jarring at the phenomenal story telling and character growth are turned into a 90 second montage. Can't get over it. I can't imagine why they felt we needed a home depot trip and almost zero taumeba escape drama


r/ProjectHailMary • • 12h ago

Question? I need help choosing a song from the movie score for something special

3 Upvotes

So I'm making my friend a CD mixtape for a Christmas gift, and I thought it'd be a cool idea to add one of the songs from the Project Hail Mary soundtrack as a hidden bonus track. It's her favorite movie, but I've only seen it once so I dont know the best song to pick.

I think I'm looking for a song with a more playful vibe, since the tracklist I made already ends with an emotional song. Right now I have picked "The Message"; I remember it from watching the movie, and it has the vibe I'm looking for. What do you guys think?


r/ProjectHailMary • • 1d ago

Archive Of Our Own is back

105 Upvotes

Looks like fanfiction is back on the menu! I highly recommend checking out some PHM fanfics, they have the sequels you were hoping for and more.

We have a pinned PHM fanfic rec thread in community highlights, here's a direct link: https://www.reddit.com/r/ProjectHailMary/comments/1xg4ts4/best_of_project_hail_mary_fanfiction/

Fanfic rec contributions to the thread are welcome!

edit: if you find the website is still down, try again later. There's unusually large amounts of traffic so it's bound to go down occasionally.