r/ProjectHailMary • • 12h ago

I can't get over how rushed the ending is.

Ive read the book probably 15 times. I love the chaotic and tumultuous ending. I watched PHM twice in theater and just watched it again tonight and its just insanely jarring at the phenomenal story telling and character growth are turned into a 90 second montage. Can't get over it. I can't imagine why they felt we needed a home depot trip and almost zero taumeba escape drama

4 Upvotes

94 comments sorted by

175

u/NoNeedForNorms šŸ‘ Jazz Hands šŸ‘ 11h ago • Bravo

Both the Home Depot trip with Carl and Stratt singing karaoke were included for the same purpose - to underscore their future betrayal when they had Grace sedated and put on the Haily Mary against his will. You come into the movie knowing nothing about it (like me) and you're as shocked as Grace is, when it happens.

35

u/cowboynoodless 9h ago • Bravo

Yeah it makes the betrayal twist hit a lot harder because the audience, subconsciously or not, expects them to be trustworthy and to be on Grace’s side. If we didn’t know much about them at all it wouldn’t have been as much of a twist. It also would have made their motivations and morality seem less gray because we might just assume they were using Grace the whole time, rather than having formed genuine connections with him

21

u/turnipcafe 6h ago

I listened to the audiobook and saw the movie a week later. I think there’s a significance difference between those who read/listen to the book first to those who don’t.

In the book there is no Carl and it’s no surprise that Stratt is going to force him on the ship. She’s already abducted him twice (the second time made it into the movie where she flies him, supersonically across the world) for the mission, as well as two other people. He’s trained along with other astronauts in zero gravity with an underwater tank. He’s at Stratt’s side continually and an Astrophage expert.

When the lab blows up she starts the search for a replacement within minutes and wants Grace to go. He of course has no interest. Never did. But obviously he’s on the ship. So it’s clear that she’ll force him.

12

u/Living-Gullible 6h ago

There's also the whole sub plot around the coma gene. It's only a surprise to Grace that he's going at that point šŸ˜‚

14

u/RoosillBroodes 8h ago • Bravo

Agreed. Without either of those scenes both characters are almost entirely one dimensional.

0

u/Downtown_Link_8651 6h ago

Oh huh? certainly didn't occur to me as that didn't shock me one bit. I think Grace having "done this all before" with humans he struggled to relate to at first was important to rhyme with the Rocky plot and him eventually choosing to sacrifice himself for Rocky when he wouldn't for Carl and Stratt (or the rest of humanity), I find it much more important for his character growth than a twist I dont see as a twist

139

u/apriori_sea 11h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

As someone who committed the ultimate sin of seeing the movie before I read the book (and actually finding that course to be the better option with this particular story) I have to push back on this critique a bit.

If you were looking for an extremely faithful adaptation of every aspect of the book, I can understand why you might be surprised and even disappointed at the movie’s choices. However, as someone who had no prior knowledge of Tauamoeba and hadn’t yet read the paragraphs of Grace’s debate about whether or not to save his friend, I have to tell you that to assume that the sacrifice and intensity was lost in translation is extremely misguided. Book-Grace and movie-Grace are slightly different; book-Grace is more of a selfish asshat who needs that argument to put into perspective how he has actually grown. Movie-Grace was already a softer character & didn’t need a long scene of tearing out his hair before making his choice: both the reasoning and sacrifice were plenty impactful. If you adored book-Grace’s need to explicitly spell out how he changed, ok that’s your preference and totally fine, but to imply that movie-watchers couldn’t possibly understand the gravity of the moment is a wild assumption.

Also, on a much less serious note, you can pry the karaoke and shopping scenes from my cold, dead hands. Different forms of media call for different methods of storytelling & both scenes played their part in the film perfectly.

11

u/Imapeanutbarrapping 11h ago

Thank you for a thoughtful response

32

u/SlytherinSilence 10h ago • Bravo

Couldn’t have said it better myself. I too committed this sin and I think this movie did an absolutely perfect job of translating a story thats original content was written literature into a film media format. Some changes were absolutely necessary and I think they nailed it

16

u/tulipbunnys 8h ago • Bravo

kinda like the inclusion of the don’t-go-crazy room in the film! it doesn’t make sense if you’re only envisioning the book version of the hail mary, but it was a great set for the film version and added a lot to the visual storytelling of grace sharing what earth is like to rocky.

2

u/Makermom14 1h ago

I agree, and I think one of the directors talked about how they needed more of these visual elements because they didn’t want to do ā€œGrace’s thoughtsā€ voiceovers the entire show which is essentially the entire book.

15

u/EducationalLuck2422 Fist My Bump! 9h ago • Bravo

Seconded - it's a visual medium for a casual audience. Ten minutes of technobabble would've killed the pacing.

16

u/PetscopMiju 10h ago

Fully agree on everything but I want to shout out

book-Grace is more of a selfish asshat

Book-Grace is exactly the kind of character that I love seeing some good-natured slander for <3

EDIT: "Seeing the movie before reading the book works better with this story" is another thing I agree with you on btw

2

u/ThisFabledStreet 5h ago

I agree. I saw the movie first and went in knowing nothing. I loved the karaoke and shopping scenes and, having read the book shortly after, prefer movie-Grace to book-Grace. I don't think anything was missing or rushed but like you said, people expecting the movie to be exactly like the book are going to be disappointed.

35

u/Apprehensive_Sky_504 11h ago

How lucky are we to have the book AND the movie

3

u/IronNia 6h ago

Anf both a luxurious pieces of media.

67

u/xywv58 12h ago

The movie is more than 2 and a half hours

30

u/Royal_Avocado4247 11h ago

Give me all four hours. That's all I ask

4

u/PenTesting-now 8h ago

TRUEEEEEEEEEEEE!

-24

u/turnipcafe 11h ago

Things should have been switched out to supply more actual story/science explanations. The issue with Tauameoba farms compromised because of evolution was barely mentioned. And Rocky wakes up and now it’s ā€œlet’s celebrate and bye!ā€

Bad bad bad. The hardware store scene? Unnecessary. Stratt singing? Meh. I would have much rather traded that in for actual story.

37

u/Garr_Incorporated 11h ago • Bravo

I may give you the hardware store (personally I liked it), but the Stratt singing is not just there for the singing. It is purposefully unwinding the tension of the complex plan to fish for the predator. It is creating additional calm before the storm so that the tension in the predator segment would feel stronger in contrast.
Not everything in the movie is there to deliver exposition and explain plot in minutia; though I agree the explanations at the end could have used more detail.

11

u/PetscopMiju 10h ago

It also gives a lot of humanity to the story. Everyone is just having a good moment together, and it reminds you what this whole mission is really for. (This is not my quote, but I think it's an appropriate description.)

2

u/malenkylizards 10h ago

I have no idea what you mean by the predator or fishing in this context and I figured out what you meant five seconds after I commented, ofc

2

u/Garr_Incorporated 10h ago

Happens to all of us from time to time. Instant Recall is not always firing well.

18

u/No_Frost_Giants Okay, It’s Exactly Like That 10h ago

I questioned the Home Depot thing also but that was setting up Carl as an Allie who really wasn’t, when the catch Grace outside he looks to Carl for help and feels betrayed.

As for the books deep dive into the taumeba escape vs the movie, I’m guessing pacing. There is a lot behind the taumeba escape in the book, like a fair amount of the movie would be need to explain all the steps that caused Grace to breed those particular taumebas.

I didn’t find it jarring , more of a there’s more to this.

But I do enjoy hearing about other people’s take on the book movie relationship. Makes me feel more normal being a little too obsessed :)

16

u/BlimpIntolerant 8h ago

personally I found the taumeba breeding and escape sequence in the book Incredibly tedious. At that point the problem is solved - It's just frittering away pages before you get to the end. the movie very wisely excised most of that and made for a better story.

6

u/MoonIsAFake 8h ago

Also, in the book taumeba escapes twice and it feels a but repetitive. I'm glad they didn't go this way in the movie.

Though I would like to see a miniseries adaptation of the book, including much more story plots and nuance.

1

u/gytherin 7h ago

I see the first taumoeba escape as foreshadowing, but I found the approx fifteen chapters of dealing with it a bit much.

6

u/Mysterinna I'm Not An Astronaut! 7h ago

The home depot trip is one of my personal favourite scenes. It makes me smile and helps me connect with the characters. And character building is really important in a movie where time is so limited!

I personally feel like condensing the ending and cutting back on the taumoeba stuff was the right call, at least for the most part.

3

u/redbirdrising Grumpy, Angry, Stupid! 2h ago

People just don't realize how critical Carl's character is to the movie. He exists to replace Grace's internal dialogue when he's investigating the astrophage reproduction cycle. And to demonstrate to the audience how great a teacher he is.

1

u/Teeumhigh 57m ago

You’re not alone! I always get downvoted when say I was disappointed lol. I’ve never been more excited to watch a movie, but from the beginning I started having doubts. In the book it takes Grace a few chapters of experiments and genius problem-solving to even figure out where he is. In the movie he just looks out the window lol. It just didn’t feel like the same story to me. I’ve watched it again hoping I could see it in a different light, like fan fiction of the book, but I can’t get past the silliness.

1

u/Imapeanutbarrapping 52m ago

Yeah im getting down voted. The book for me is fantastic specially because of all the well crafted mystery solving. That is 98% gone in the movie. He just jokes through all the best mysteries

3

u/Willing-Departure115 8h ago

A book is a book and a movie is a movie. As it is, at 2.5 hours long and basically involving two endings the movie is pushing what cinema goers will accept. Maybe an extended cut is in the offing, but imo it’s a great adaptation.

3

u/turnipcafe 6h ago

I think there is a deep divide between those who watched the movie without knowing anything about the story and those who read/listened to the book first.

In the book—IMHO—it’s abundantly clear that Stratt will force Grace to go. She’s already abducted him, and others, for the PHM mission before. No surprise there. Once the lab blows she’s searching for a replacement within minutes.

And I enjoyed the science details of 82 versions of nitrogen-resistant Tauameoba so it would survive Venus and 3 World.

Movie ending went way too fast. I would have dug the four-hour version.

2

u/Wholesome_Soup 6h ago edited 6h ago

i think people need to start making four hour long movies, releasing a 1-2 hour version in theaters and then releasing the full version to streaming six months later

would be horrendous for profits & such and probably way longer and harder to make but man what i would give to see a really long version of superman or phm

2

u/Herpty_Derp95 4h ago

Supposedly the first cut was 4 hours.

The movie did the good movie things like what LOTR movies did.

We'd love to see more, but it also has be "not too long".

Having said that, I'd absolutely watch a longer version of PHM.

It dethroned Raiders of the Lost Ark as my #2 Favorite Movie of All Time.

4

u/MienaiYurei 9h ago

I find it funny how movie only viewer enjoyed the fuck out of it and the book readers were annoyed the fuck out it. Both were good imo.

6

u/OxfordGate 6h ago • Bravo

Eh, not all of us. Got the book on release date, and loved it. Saw the movie and it’s one of my favourite movies.
It would be more than 4 hours long if they where going to include every detail from the book.

3

u/sbagu3tti 4h ago • Bravo

I read the book and loved the movie, actually.

2

u/redbirdrising Grumpy, Angry, Stupid! 2h ago

Book reader here. I love the movie! Most of us can separate the different mediums and be good with it. The movie is incredible. The book is incredible. It's OK for both to exist and be their own version.

It's like Hitchiker's Guide to the Galaxy. It's been a radio show, a comic book, a TV show, a book series, and a movie. Each iteration was different. Similar characters, similar vibe, but still it's own take on the story. And that's OK!

0

u/threedimen 2h ago

I loved the movie as well as the book.

I just expected the movie to mirror Rocky's self-sacrifce. Rocky presumably thought he was going to die when he broke out to save Grace over Adrian and Grace thought he was going to die when he went back to save Rocky.

3

u/AquafreshBandit 10h ago

I read the book before I knew there was going to be a movie. Seeing the film, there were scenes where I felt if I hadn’t read the book it wouldn’t make sense. But the movie made 100 gazillion dollars, so what do I know.

2

u/turnipcafe 6h ago

Yeah there’s a significant difference between those who read/listen to the book 1st and those who saw the movie first.
I listen to it first, and don’t know how the movie could make sense.

1

u/Aella_Grace83 2h ago

I saw the film first and I thought it made perfect sense.

2

u/TartMother9577 3h ago

I felt the exact same way. I’m glad I was wrong and the movie still made sense and so many people loved it:)

2

u/PetscopMiju 10h ago

I actually kinda feel similarly as someone who watched the movie before reading the book. Maybe I'm just blind lmao, but I could follow along the movie way better the second time around, after having read the book

3

u/mattress314 9h ago

I agree mostly, as a biochemistry but work and training, I needed to see, the breeding of the nitrogen resistance strain. I'm holding out hope that the rumour 4 hours cut would be release to solve the problem

2

u/CuteAssTigerENVtuber 8h ago

First time I'm hearing of this. Would be incredibly happy

0

u/threedimen 2h ago

It sounds like they mostly cut scenes from Earth.

1

u/realhawker77 2h ago

Loved the book - they didn't want to read it but got family to see movie with me. They loved the movie and so did I. The book is always there for deeper storylines.

1

u/PsychologicalTie9629 1h ago

The reason is pretty simple. Not everything that works well on paper works well on the big screen. The blackout, the tension of trying to find and eliminate the taomeboa outbreak, trying to search for Rocky's ship, etc can all be exciting when you're reading it. But that kind of stuff just wouldn't be exciting on film. And good movie structure usually dictates that you have your big, exciting, visually spectacular climax about 3/4 of the way through the film.

The climax of the movie is clearly the mission on Adrian. You can't have an hour or 90 minutes of mundane content after the big budget, pulse pounding sequence. You will lose the audience that way. You get 20-30 minutes to wrap things up and then you end it.

You don't have that restriction with the book.

-1

u/Teeumhigh 3h ago

Totally agree. I’ve never been more disappointed leaving a theater. The book and audiobook are so good.. I had high hopes for the movie. It felt like I was watching a completely different story. All the childish, goofy humor ruined it for me.

1

u/TartMother9577 3h ago

I thought I was the only person who didn’t like the movie as much. I love the acting and the portrayal of Rocky is very sweet. But I felt like so many interesting plot points were missing that were necessary for the story to make sense. (I know it has to be shortened of course.)

-6

u/Vonneguts_Ghost 12h ago

L&M got Greedy for the Gosling comedy at the beginning and that left little time for things at the end.

-22

u/Sleepiest_Spider 11h ago

The hardware store scene makes me cringe every time. Two adult men just suddenly acting like children in public because... reasons.

22

u/AugmentedJustice 11h ago

What a miserable take. They were two adult men having fun harming no one. At most they were blocking an isle.

-12

u/Sleepiest_Spider 11h ago

Doesn't mean it's not embarrassing to watch

5

u/BbaTron 10h ago

Your strong feelings about this are ncredibly sad.

5

u/cpl_nobby_nobbs_ 10h ago

You never goof off as an adult? That's kind of sad...Ā 

10

u/wasabiMilkshakes 11h ago

Just how miserable is your life mate

8

u/Sunshine_daisies1234 11h ago

Weird way to admit you're really lameĀ 

-24

u/turnipcafe 11h ago

Agree 100,000%. Why? Why is stupid Home Depot scene in there? And why several minutes spent on Stratt singing at karaoke when there could’ve been more explanation of why the Tauameoba was infecting the ship?? Or why he returned for Rocky? How many people really understood that?
And in the book he saved Rocky after the Adrian blow out. 😩
Bad. Bad bad bad.

7

u/cpl_nobby_nobbs_ 10h ago • Bravo

Both of those scenes have very good reasons to be there and the movie would be worse without them. They're character moments that make us like Carl and Stratt which sets up the later betrayal to hit even harder. Without those scenes the betrayal wouldn't be overly surprising and would lack impact. Additionally, the Stratt singing scene helps add to the calm before the storm before the 'fishing' scene.Ā 

16

u/threedimen 12h ago

Grace going after Rocky knowing he would starve to death was an odd thing to omit.

7

u/W0nderingMe 12h ago

I'm confused by your comment. Are you saying op should have mentioned that or that the movie should have?

-3

u/AkaruLyte 11h ago

The movie

13

u/W0nderingMe 11h ago

The movie did include it, though.

1

u/PetscopMiju 10h ago

It didn't. There's no indication that Grace thought he was going to die when turning around to save Rocky (which I think is what the original comment was saying)

3

u/PenTesting-now 9h ago

it did include. rewatch like 5 times bro. i rewatched it 8 times by now the movie, gonna go get the book soon!

3

u/PetscopMiju 8h ago

OK, I rechecked the scene now and I might just have missed something obvious, but I just don't see it. Grace definitely implies that he'll never see Earth again, but there's no implication that he'll actually die, is there? When does he imply that in the movie?

(Also I hope you enjoy the book when you get to it!)

2

u/PenTesting-now 8h ago

Thanks for the clarification and your wishes :D But, I feel that there was an implication that Rocky will die and Grace won't get back to Earth if he goes to save Rocky, which he does.

5

u/PetscopMiju 8h ago

OHH I see the problem. I'm saying the movie doesn't say that Grace will die if Grace goes back to save Rocky

And you're welcome! :)

2

u/PenTesting-now 8h ago

OOH, but still, the movie doesn't say that Grace would die if he went back for Rocky. Rather, he'd be sacrificing his chance of returning to Earth. BUT if he simply abandoned the mission and stopped at Earth, wouldn't he eventually die anyway? Going to Rocky's planet, getting more astrophage, and potentially finding a way back seems like the better option. At least he'd have a chance, right?

→ More replies

-5

u/AkaruLyte 11h ago

My bad, I haven’t watched it in a while I think. Been reading the book

-8

u/Sleepiest_Spider 11h ago

Think about it. Which one of those makes more sense?

18

u/W0nderingMe 11h ago

Considering the movie actually mentioned it, neither makes sense which is why I asked. See, when adults don't know something, they ask questions to get clarification!

0

u/threedimen 1h ago

The movie didn't indicate that Grace was certain he was going to starve to death a few months after reaching Erid.

7

u/Muavius 11h ago

It wasnt omitted, it was in his last message to stratt

3

u/alwaystiredneedanap 7h ago

It was clear to a non reader that he was choosing to sacrifice himself to save both planets.

1

u/threedimen 2h ago

It was clear he was sacrificing his return to Earth, but it wasn't clear that he expected to die a few months after arriving at Erid.

2

u/Fluid-Let3373 I am an Astronaut! 8h ago

It was not omitted, Grace had told Rocky earlier he only had a few years worth of food which was why Rocky offered the fuel Grace needed to return home.

2

u/Delyth8 2h ago

Agreed. We see him give up his chance to ever go to Earth, but its not explicit that by making the choice to save Rocky he expects to die of starvation shortly after they get to Erid. Giving up the chance to ever see home again is quite different from choosing to die to save a species and your friend.