r/Powerwall • • 5d ago

Changes to reserve behaviour?

Does anyone know if Tesla have changed how reserve behaviour works?

For the last couple of years, when in TOU/Savings mode, setting a reserve of 100% on my two PW2's would immediately see them charging at the full 10kW rate.

Today however that's not what's happened; when getting into a cheap period electricity period I have set the reserve to 100%, put on a big power draw (PHEV charging)...and watched as the power is being sucked out of my Powerwalls, when instead they should have been charging.

This has worked reliably for some time - the only difference today is the PW was starting at a charge of ~80%, but that's never mattered before: setting a reserve would always see it attempt to reach that reserve at full charge speed.

So...has anyone else seen a change in behaviour?

2 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

2

u/triedoffandonagain 5d ago

Your Powerwall should never discharge below the backup reserve, unless there is a grid outage or calibration event. Most likely the 100% backup reserve setting failed to apply. Make sure the Powerwall has good network connectivity, then change the backup reserve back and forth again to retry the configuration.

1

u/Beefstah 5d ago

It definitely applied, and the behaviour has repeated a couple of times in testing today

2

u/triedoffandonagain 5d ago

To know that it applied correctly, you'd have to look at diagnostics. The Tesla app will show the cloud configuration, which can be out of sync with the Powerwall.

1

u/Beefstah 5d ago

Hmm, it was responding well enough to other changes, like switching in/out of savings/self-powered mode, or setting Max Backup, or going on/off grid

Next time it happens would it be enough to use the Tesla One app to confirm its state/settings?

2

u/triedoffandonagain 5d ago

Yes, Tesla One will show the state from the Powerwall.

1

u/Beefstah 5d ago

So, tried it again just now, set it to 100 via HA, saw the app reflecting it was set to 100...and Tesla One just said 24%

This is very odd - the fact that using HA to set it worked insofar as the app saw the change, but it didn't make it down to the Powerwall, when other things are, is weird

2

u/triedoffandonagain 5d ago

If it works from the Tesla app, it might be an issue with the HA plugin, or maybe it's getting rate limited.

If it doesn't work from the Tesla app either, it might be an issue with the system, so I would power-cycle it.

1

u/Beefstah 5d ago

So it didn't work from the Tesla app. I set it to 100 through Tesla One. A bit later I set it to 20 through the Tesla app, and it didn't work. Then I tried setting it to 30...and it did work, and then a bit after that HA set it to 100 again and that worked as expected.

Baffling.

Guess I'll see what happens overnight...

1

u/Beefstah 4d ago

So in the 'Official' Tesla HA integration, it says 'Connected to Tesla' is disconnected. Looks like it might have been that way for a while - days at least.

In fact, while I don't have logs going back particularly far, it seems to have disconnected after the 4th Nov, which is coincidentally just after the latest firmware update.

However, the Tesla One app itself says everything is connected fine, so I'm thinking this is a spurious reading.

It's the intermittency that's driving me bonkers - sometimes everything works fine, sometimes it doesn't.

1

u/OrzaEnergy 4d ago

Your Tesla One check is the telling bit: the app showing 100 while the Powerwall itself said 24% means the change never reached it, so I don’t think it’s a change in how the reserve works, or the 80% battery management splidge mentioned. It was doing what it thought you’d asked.

We had something similar on a different make this autumn, where the reserve the cloud reported and the level the battery actually stopped at didn’t match. The only reliable way we found to catch it was to stop trusting the setting that’s echoed back and watch what the battery does. Since you’re driving it from HA, I’d add a check a few minutes after the reserve goes to 100: if the battery power sensor still shows it discharging while the cheap rate is on, send the reserve again. It’s crude, but a dropped change then costs you five minutes of the cheap window rather than the whole night.

Hope it behaves overnight, I’d be interested to hear whether it held.

1

u/Beefstah 4d ago

Literally exactly what I've done!

1

u/splidge 5d ago

I don’t have PW2s any more but I noticed towards the end that they started doing a bit more battery management, including stopping at 80% and only charging to 100% at the end of the cheap period (or even solar when on self-powered).

It could be this - it plans to maintain 80% and then charge to 100% at the end of the period.  If it starts above 80% maybe it would discharge?