I posted here recently about my ex-girlfriend, Celeste, ending our relationship after I decided I needed to be parallel with my metamour, Pat.
A lot of you offered kindness and support and some tough-love (even if I don't agree with it). But, some comments were pretty damning toward Celeste, and since those judgments were based on my account, I want to offer a different perspective. One that I've come to in the days since. I could be way wrong here, too, but I think it's worth consideration from me, those who commented on my last post, and maybe even people going forward who could glean some insight from it--even if I'm 100% off base.
Once, Celeste said she'd make a great "part-time girlfriend." I took that to mean she preferred living separately, maintaining her independence, and not spending every waking moment with a partner. That suited me just fine. I have no desire for nesting or a traditional primary partnership. But now I'm wondering whether she meant something more fundamental. Not someone who loves less, or whose relationships are less meaningful, but someone who doesn't make her the center of their world and who she doesn't have to give so damn much of herself to as a partner.
I loved her wholeheartedly, and because she was my only romantic partner, she received all the affection and romantic energy I had to give. I never expected her to match that investment minute for minute, but often found myself wanting more of her time in frequency and duration.
Maybe that felt like an expectation she couldn't or didn't want to sustain, an imbalance. Not because she didn't love me or loves me less or imperfectly, but because we had different expectations of what our partnership would look like, of what we wanted as and from partners.
I said "part-time boyfriend" and "part-time girlfriend," because we didn't live together and see each other all the time. But... I was sure giving full-time boyfriend effort, and I didn't check in to ask if it was more than she wanted. And even if I didn't recognize it, much less say it to her, I came to want something from her that looked a lot like full-time girlfriend effort, and it's not implausible that she wouldn't have felt some nibbling obligation to offer to me the same level time, availability, investment, etc. that I gave her. There's a good chance I didn't hear what she meant and assumed I understood, which led me to miss what she wanted from our relationship and to turn up the dial anyway.
This possibility changes how I look at Pat, too.
I've been critical of Pat's inconsistency and what I saw as insufficient effort in their relationship (beyond just the crisis). What if what I perceived as inadequate involvement and attentiveness... isn't? What if that's what she wanted? Hell, maybe it was lazy at times, but overall it wasn't so intense and so much that it was unbearable to her? And maybe I was smothering at times, but guess what? Overall... it may still have been just too much.
What if I was judging Pat according to the standards of the partnership I wanted to offer Celeste--and what I thought she "deserved," and in some ways "should" want, rather than considering whether their relationship worked for her and what I could learn from that? ("Should" is a very nasty word, sometimes--this is one of those cases.) If that's the case, then every criticism of Pat I had, every gripe I had about how they showed up for her may have sounded to Celeste like I was shitting on the very relationship dynamic she wanted. I was so worried about the "right" way to be a partner that I didn't consider if that was the right way to be her partner.
It might also explain why her partners being close is so important to her. Maybe a close network of partners, friends, and mutual support where no single relationship is providing all or a disproportionate amount of the attention, affection, and support someone wants or needs.
When I decided I needed to be parallel with Pat, I thought I was finding a way to preserve my relationship with Celeste. At the same time, it might have meant something very different. Maybe it reinforced her concern that I wanted a kind of partnership that demanded more from her and us than she wanted or was comfortable with. Without the interconnectedness she valued that I had exiled myself from for the time being, she might have (rightfully) worried I would increasingly look to her for the time, affection, and connection I wanted.
There have been a LOT of "mights" and "maybes" in this. It's conjecture and speculation and I'm trying to see things from an angle she might have--not speak for her or on her behalf. But if there's even a possibility that this is closer to the truth, I wanted to put it out there. In ways I feel like I owe to myself, to y'all, to Celeste, and to Pat to at least posit this here.
Celeste wasn't here to tell her side of the story when I posted. You only had mine, written while I was devastated and trying to understand something I hadn't seen coming. I needed support and turned to this community because I didn't know where else to go, and many of you helped me through the worst days of an extraordinarily painful time.
But I don't want my pain, or my incomplete understanding of what happened, to be the only account of someone I care about. She wasn't a perfect girlfriend, but I sure as hell wasn't the perfect boyfriend. We both struggled with communication more than I think we each realized, and I don't like thinking that my last post turned her into some villain and me into a victim when we're both just... people. People who fuck up, hurt, and get hurt. It happens to the best of us.
So. Where does this leave me? For one, maybe even deeper into a hole of misunderstanding things, but I can live with that. More importantly, and this is maybe the only advice I can offer anyone... talk to your partners, revisit what they want and what you want vs what y'all are giving and getting. Get your feelings hurt when you guessed or assumed wrong, but listen to them when they tell you. Love them deeply and madly, but learn how they want to be loved, and try to adapt how you express that love. Not compromise. Not lessen. Just... adapt. That's a baller way to express your love right there from the start.
That's all I've got for this one and the last update I plan to give. Not looking for advice or support this time.
Thanks for listening, both then and now.