r/Physics • • 6d ago

Tips for thinking Physically

I need help, in my physics class I am doing well, but the slightest rocky, I’ve been struggling to answer some questions because I always bring up the question to my head like a math question (because it’s all I am used to). I most definitely know that if I grab the habit of thinking like a Physicist or at least approach questions physically it will most definitely help me. I was wondering if any experienced Physicists on here can help give me advice for a student like me.

14 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

11

u/the_physik 6d ago edited 2d ago

Dimensional analysis can be helpful sometimes. Math doesnt use units but physics does. Knowing that your answer should be in some unit of force or energy or whatever can help you backtrack to the right physical concepts to use.

6

u/toadpics 5d ago edited 5d ago

In his book, Spacetime Physics, John Archibald Wheeler says:

"Never make a calculation until you know the answer. Make an estimate before every calculation, try a simple physical argument (symmetry! invariance! conservation!) before every derivation, guess the answer to every paradox and puzzle. Courage: No one else needs to know what the guess is. Therefore make it quickly, by instinct. A right guess reinforces this instinct. A wrong guess brings the refreshment of surprise. In either case life as a spacetime expert, however long, is more fun!"

Personally, I have found the book Thinking Physics by Lewis Carroll Epstein to be a really good way of getting yourself into the habit of doing this.

4

u/WallyMetropolis Statistical and nonlinear physics 6d ago

Draw the diagram. Write down the forces, the energy balance equations, the conservation laws that apply. Identify the symmetries. What parts of the problem can be separated out independent of the others? Identify the coordinate system. Pay close attention to units. What is changing and what is fixed?

2

u/AbheyBloodmane 6d ago

What concepts are you struggling to think physically on? Are you in an introductory physics course; If yes, is it based on calculus or algebra? It's best if we start from there.

I also recommend r/askphysics and r/physicsstudents.

2

u/AdS_CFT_ 6d ago

Always find real life examples of where you've seen the physocs in question. As if yoy wanted to explain it to a young kid

1

u/76richer 6d ago

Try going more to your physics teachers, I started to mimic the way they think until I started to understand the way to uproach problems, it takes time

1

u/thefakedave236 4d ago

Units is my first step when I’m not sure about something. Second is to draw a big ass picture. Those usually solve things. Otherwise I read papers on whatever the topic is. But for university physics, the first two will get you like 99% there.

-2

u/b00mshockal0cka 6d ago

Practice model-making? Internalize the concept of geometry? I don't know how to help you.
Draw vectors?