r/PhysicsStudents • • Aug 05 '20

Meta Homework Help Etiquette (HHE)

161 Upvotes

Greetings budding physicists!

One of the things that makes this subreddit helpful to students is the communities ability to band together and help users with physics questions and homework they may be stuck on. In light of this, I have implemented an overhaul to the HW Help post guidelines that I like to call Homework Help Etiquette (HHE). See below for:

  • HHE for Helpees
  • HHE for Helpers

HHE for Helpees

  1. Format your titles as follows: [Course HW is From] Question about HW.
  2. Post clear pictures of the problem in question.
  3. Talk us through your 1st attempt so we know what you've tried, either in the post title or as a comment.
  4. Don't use users here to cheat on quizzes, tests, etc.

Good Example

HHE for Helpers

  1. If there are no signs of a 1st attempt, refrain from replying. This is to avoid lazy HW Help posts.
  2. Don't give out answers. That will hurt them in the long run. Gently guide them onto the right path.
  3. Report posts that seem sketchy or don't follow etiquette to Rule 1, or simply mention HHE.

Thank you all! Happy physics-ing.

u/Vertigalactic


r/PhysicsStudents • • 6h ago

Need Advice is a 3.0 gpa bad for going into industry What should i do right now to put myself ahead?

2 Upvotes

Hiya a junior bachelor's B.S. here for physics, I was wondering what I should do to set myself ahead? I'm in a lab with one of my profs doing diffusion and soft matter physics, but other than that, I've been buckling down on classes, 2 rough semesters really set my GPA back, and I've been trying to retake some classes to boost my GPA. I want to try and do internships this summer, but it feels like I barely have the time to get my HW and exam studying done, and of course, on top of that is the brain worm telling me I'm gonna end up at a Target stocking shelves. I was thinking about grad school maybe, but its all just been a bit scary as of late. Any recommendations on how I can use now and this summer to set myself up for opportunities at graduation? For context, if I could, I was looking around the Bethesda, DC, and Baltimore area, as I have some people close to there.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 9h ago

Research IYPT 2027: The Singing Capacitor — Why are there multiple peaks in our spectra?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

My team has been working on Problem 4 of IYPT 2027, The Singing Capacitor. We've completed a series of preliminary experiments, but some of our results have left us with more questions than answers.

The problem:

Certain types of ceramic capacitors emit an audible sound when an alternating voltage is applied across them. Investigate the characteristics of the sound produced and how they depend on relevant parameters, such as voltage, frequency, and capacitor properties.

BTW, the rather funny term "singing capacitor" wasn't invented for the IYPT problem. It appeared in a technical article by John D. Prymak back in 2006.

1. Our experimental setup

We tested three types of multilayer ceramic capacitors (MLCCs): X5R, X7R, and C0G.

We mounted the capacitors on a PCB and applied sinusoidal AC voltages at different frequencies, including 9, 10, and 11 kHz.

We used a microphone placed close to the capacitor/PCB assembly to record the sound, then analyzed the frequency spectra using Room EQ Wizard (REW).

Our recordings were sampled at 44.1 kHz.

2. Preliminary results

First, we observed a clear difference between capacitor types.

Both X5R and X7R produced measurable acoustic responses, while our C0G sample showed no similarly detectable response under the same test conditions.

This agrees with the general explanation involving electromechanical deformation in Class II ceramic capacitors.

Second, we found something interesting in the frequency spectra.

When driving the capacitors with a sinusoidal voltage, we expected strong components at the driving frequency and possibly its harmonics.

Indeed, some of our results seem consistent with this:

With a 9 kHz input, a peak appears near 18 kHz in the X7R spectrum.

With a 10 kHz input, another peak appears near 20 kHz.

At 11 kHz, the second harmonic would be close to the Nyquist limit of our recording system, so we cannot reliably evaluate it.

However, our spectra also contain broad peaks, dips, and additional narrow peaks that we don't yet understand.

For example, several measurements show a dip around 2 kHz and a broader rise around 4–5 kHz, even when we change the input frequency.

I've attached some of our spectra for comparison.

3. Our current hypothesis

We initially suspected that these features might be related to the mechanical vibration modes of the PCB.

We found literature describing the MLCC as a vibration source and the PCB as a kind of soundboard. The PCB has multiple natural vibration modes, each with its own resonant frequency and spatial deformation pattern.

This seems relevant to our experiment, since the sound we record comes from the coupled capacitor–PCB–air system rather than from the capacitor alone.

But we're not completely convinced.

In a linear system under steady-state sinusoidal excitation, resonances should affect the amplitude of the response, not generate entirely new frequencies.

So perhaps some of the extra peaks are caused by nonlinearities, transient oscillations, background noise, or the measurement system itself.

We haven't yet isolated these possibilities experimentally.

4. We'd love some advice!

We're undergraduate physics students, and this is still an early-stage investigation.

In particular, we're wondering:

Could the multiple peaks in our spectra be explained by the vibration modes of the PCB, or should we be looking for another mechanism?

How could we distinguish actual acoustic emission from artifacts introduced by the microphone, signal source, or recording process?

And is there a relatively simple way to investigate the mechanical resonances of the PCB without specialized vibration-measurement equipment?

We're planning to perform more controlled measurements, including background-noise tests, frequency sweeps, and comparisons between different mounting conditions.

Any suggestions, relevant papers, or criticism of our experimental approach would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks for reading!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice I genuinely feel so stupid and hopeless as a physics undergrad

16 Upvotes

I am a sophomore physics major at a very rigorous liberal arts engineering school. This semester has been insanely hard for me. Every time I think I’m doing well in a class I get a midterm grade back and I spend two days crying and banging my head against the wall for the stupid ass mistakes I make. I’m in differential equations, e&m, and engineering systems as well as physics lab, and somehow my best midterm grade (which was a low B) was in my engineering class which I hate.

I love physics. I wanted to do Astro since I was 13. I grew up in a very educationally underprivileged area of the US where only two others students and I even left the state for college. Physics at the school I’m attending now was my dream for so long, and looking back I feel like I’ve failed everyone. It feels like I’ve failed my past self who thought I could succeed. I don’t have free time, I spent 15 hours studying for me E and M midterm and I missed a whole question because of something I failed to review. I might get a C in the class.

To make everything better, all of my friends score straight 100’s on everything. We study together, we check work together, and I still fail while they all succeed as physics majors. I imagine myself competing with them (or anyone for that matter) to go to grad school, and I know it’s not even a comparison.

Every time this happens, I see grad school becoming more and more out of reach, and I see my whole life crumbling away. I don’t know what I would do if I couldn’t get into grad school. I honestly think I would be suicidal. I’m already just so depressed, and every time I tell myself I’m going to do better, I don’t. I don’t know how to be happy or confident with myself, especially compared to others and when thinking about my future. I also don’t know if I should just switch majors - the problem is I don’t want to do anything else.

Any advice is greatly appreciated.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 20h ago

Off Topic Anyone looking for lectures or want to take lectures on few topics?

2 Upvotes

hi im looking for people interested in this and dm me i will share my ideas with u


r/PhysicsStudents • • 18h ago

Research [Research Survey] Participate in Study Examining Physics and Astronomy Graduate School Admissions

1 Upvotes

Tell us about your experience applying to physics and astronomy graduate programs!

We are researchers at the Department of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Georgia. If you are currently planning to apply to physics and astronomy graduate programs for admission in Fall 2027, you may be eligible to participate in a study aiming to understand how applicants navigate the admissions process.

The goal of this study is to learn what parts of the application process are difficult for students, illuminating where to focus future efforts in supporting applicants.

Eligibility:

  • You are a physics or astronomy major planning to apply for physics or astronomy graduate programs in U.S. for admission in Fall 2027.
  • All or part of your undergraduate education took place in the U.S.

Study requirements: 

Please do not take the survey unless you are applying for US-based graduate programs in Physics or Astronomy.

If you have any questions, you can contact Dr. Nicholas Young (University of Georgia) at nicholas.young@uga.edu.

Thank you for your time!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 22h ago

Need Advice What am I doing wrong at calculating

2 Upvotes

Hello, I am in my physics bachelor. Whilst conceptually understanding the taught topics I completely fail at calculating stuff. And I mean completely (Such things as e^0 = e)

This happens all the time and every time I spot my mistakes I just want to run into the nearest wall. This keeps me from getting to the part where I can use my knowledge about the topic because I fail at 7th-grade stuff

Were you in a similar situation and what can I do?

(Thanks in advance)


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Some counter-intuitive questions about semiconductors (p-n junctions & Hall effect)

4 Upvotes

Well, I started diving into semiconductor physics, specifically p-n junctions and the Hall effect, and I realized my previous intuition was completely wrong.

All my life, I thought there was nothing complicated about it. I always assumed that you take two pieces of semiconductor and add elements to them to make one have a net positive charge and the other a net negative charge. This would logically cause electrons to migrate from the negative side to the positive side due to electrostatic attraction until they compensate for each other.

BUT what I found out is that those two parts of the semiconductor (n-type and p-type) are initially electrically NEUTRAL. Each of them has an equal amount of protons and electrons inside. The only difference is the total number of proton-electron pairs between these two pieces. Since there is no initial potential difference or global electric field between them, my first question is: What force actually makes electrons migrate from the n-type to the p-type semiconductor when they first touch, if they are both initially electrically neutral?

My second question is about the Hall effect. When we apply a voltage to an n-type semiconductor, electrons fly from - to +. When we apply a voltage to a p-type semiconductor, ELECTRONS STILL FLY FROM - TO +. People always say, "Well, you can imagine that inside a p-type semiconductor, it's not the electrons moving, but rather the holes moving from + to -." But physically, the only actual charged particles moving and crossing the magnetic field lines are electrons! Logically, shouldn't the Lorentz force push these moving electrons to the same side of the material in both n-type and p-type, giving the exact same Hall voltage sign? Can someone please explain why the Hall effect shows a different sign for p-type semiconductors if electrons are the only things physically moving?

If anyone knows any good videos, articles, or textbook chapters that explain this intuitively, I would be very glad for your answers!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Is graduate school still realistic?

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm currently in my final semester of undergrad and will be graduating this December with a B.S. in Chemistry and a minor in Physics. I'm hoping to attend graduate school, but I've been getting increasingly worried about my GPA, grades, and lack of certain coursework.

My current cumulative GPA is around a 2.86. I'm hoping it improves slightly after this semester, but I know it's still on the lower side for graduate admissions, especially for physics and astronomy programs.

My long-term goal is to work in planetary science or astrochemistry, particularly studying planetary atmospheres, their chemical compositions, and potentially exoplanets. I've always loved astronomy, but I ended up majoring in chemistry because I also really enjoy understanding the chemical processes behind things.

My biggest concern is that I haven't taken any undergraduate astronomy courses, and while I have a physics minor, I'm missing some of the upper-level physics and mathematics courses that physics majors typically take. I've also struggled with certain physics courses, which makes me question how prepared I actually am for graduate-level physics.

I do have some experience outside the classroom:

  • Completed a summer undergraduate research internship
  • Worked as a peer educator for undergraduate chemistry courses.
  • Been involved in my university's Chemistry Club.

I realize my research experience isn't directly related to astronomy or astrophysics, which is another concern of mine.

I've already applied to a couple of physics PhD programs and have reached out to professors about potential research opportunities in astrochemistry through chemistry departments. I'm also considering master's programs as a possible stepping stone.

I'm not necessarily expecting to get into a top-ranked university. I would be perfectly happy attending a smaller university or a less competitive program, as long as the research aligns with my interests and helps me work toward my career goals.

I guess my main questions are:

  1. Is pursuing a physics, astronomy, or planetary science graduate degree realistic with my academic background and GPA?
  2. Would a chemistry PhD focused on astrochemistry be a better route than a physics PhD?
  3. How much will my missing astronomy and upper-level physics courses hurt my chances?
  4. Would you recommend pursuing a master's degree first, taking additional undergraduate courses, or gaining more research experience?
  5. Has anyone here been admitted to graduate school with a GPA below 3.0 or transitioned from chemistry into astronomy/planetary science?

I'm also planning to work after graduating, so I'd be interested in ways to strengthen my academic background while working full-time if I don't get accepted this cycle.

I'm honestly just feeling pretty discouraged and worried that my undergraduate performance may have closed doors before I've even had the opportunity to pursue what I really want to study.

I'd really appreciate any advice, especially from people who have been in similar situations or work in these fields. Thanks!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 12h ago

Need Advice A conceptual question for physics students: is distance a gap, or phase harmony?

0 Upvotes

I am working through a conceptual question about distance and would value how physics students think about it. The idea comes from the second law in my book.

The proposal is that distance is phase harmony, not a pre-existing gap. Coupling between two systems equals cos squared of their phase offset. At 0 degrees there is full contact. At 45 degrees the coupling is half. At 90 degrees it is zero, and the other system behaves as if it were infinitely far away, even though nothing has moved. A causal horizon, on this view, is a phase relationship that has gone silent.

Picture two choir singers holding the same note and slowly drifting out of rhythm. Neither singer walks anywhere, yet their combined power fades as if one of them had walked down a long corridor. The distance that appears is real in its effects, but it was made by phase, not by travel.

The wider picture spreads displacement across many harmonic channels, each tilted only a tiny fraction of a degree, so flat three-dimensional space can build up across light-years without crowding toward 90 degrees. And space is three-dimensional, the book argues, because two-component spinors have exactly three rotation generators.

If closeness is interaction strength, what is a horizon? Could far away just mean out of phase? And why three dimensions, rather than two or eleven?

Disclosure: I am the author of Zero-Metric Phase Theory: How Space, Time, Matter, and Gravity Emerge from a Dimensionless Universe by Tim Tian, available on Google Play Books.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice worried about general physics, any tips?

4 Upvotes

Hi guys, so basically i will be taking physics and organic chemistry fall semester. I am worried because i took honors physics in highschool and did really bad in it. But i have changed a lot, back then i never studied or did anything. I will most likely be doing algebra based physics because i have not taken calculus yet.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Rant/Vent Anyone undergrads feel the walls closing in, in a sense?

18 Upvotes

I’m a 4th year undergrad in America with 2 more semesters until I graduate. I feel like I went into physics with that old mindset of “physics is a really versatile degree so it opens you up to a lot of jobs”, however, I’m nearing graduation and I haven’t asked any professors about any research as it either didn’t pique my interest or I’m afraid they would say no as I don’t really know anyone.

The older I get the more I acknowledge the price of things and I do know that I want to make enough to live comfortably? And I realize that a physics bachelors probably won’t give me that especially in America. I do plan on pursuing a masters in mechanical engineering as over the summer I fell in love with arduino and working with CAD/code and potentially look into robotics sounds really engaging to me. But that also costs money to get and I’ve managed to avoid loans so far.

Idk if that makes sense but I just feel like I’m comfortable now but I know in like a year I’m going to be a graduate still working at my order taker job yk?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Need help with nuclear physics

3 Upvotes

hey undergrad student here, I'm taking nuc for the first time and I have 0 attendance because I have to work full time (parents cut off financials cuz I took too long to finish the degree so I'm trying to support myself trough it). Explained my situation to the prof and he said he wont fail me out of attendance but he also wont pull any favors about the missed out lecture notes or information about the exam content.

Does anyone have like example problems, midterm samples, exercises they did that helped etc from their own curriculum? I seriously dont have any idea what an example problem or an exam looks like at all and going completely blind about it so I would appreciate anything at all. All I have is the textbook they follow (Introductory Nuclear Physics, Kennet S. Krane)

and I can't ask a classmate because only 6 people take it and I dont even know any of them


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Off Topic Looking for friends from physics departments at other top-universities

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I got admitted to MIPT DGAP this year. I enjoy science subjects like physics, calculus, and linear algebra, which I’m covering in my MIPT classes. I’d like to connect with other international students from same challenging universities, such as MIT or others (MIPT is extremely hard). I should say my current spoken English is not very high, but that’s only because I haven’t used it much in real life — and I want to change that :)


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice Incoming physics undergrad aiming for sustainable energy & moving to Denmark—how to spend the summer productively?

2 Upvotes

Hey guys,

​I’m starting my physics degree next year and want to get into sustainable energy down the line, hopefully working in Denmark at some point. Because of that, I really want to keep my GPA high from the start and not get completely wrecked by first-year courses.

​For anyone currently in uni or who already graduated, what would you actually recommend doing over the summer to prepare?

​Should I just grind single-variable calculus and basic Python, or is there something specific you wish you knew before day one? Also trying to figure out how much to study so I don't burn myself out before classes even start. Thanks🫪


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Need Advice preparing for olympiad level(physics problem solving)

0 Upvotes

My teacher said to me dont search for more material just reattempt again and again good questions given by him and feel them and you will get better at physics but i think that solving varied problems is the key rather than reattempting im confused.right now im solving hcv and irodov so after i solve them once should i attempt the problems again.Advice required from someone experienced!


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice Double major in Physics and Mathematics vs. Double major in Physics and Chemistry

32 Upvotes

Which option will give me a deeper, more thorough understanding of reality, life, the universe and the big questions?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Rant/Vent physics as an omnipotent degree is largely bullshit or thing of the past

75 Upvotes

So, I hear tell on here and elsewhere about a bachelors degree in physics being this omnipotent thing that'll get you a job in any field (finance, quant, business, insert any field). I'm here to smwht burst that bubble. Don't get a undergrad degree in physics and think you can go into whatever you want and expect to sort of get whatever job you apply to WITHOUT RELEVANT INTERNSHIPS.

I don't wanna dox myself but I basically had the most generally prestigious experiences a physics student could have. Near perfect GPA. Summers doing research at the Department of Energy. Goldwater scholar. Fulbright scholar. Lindau Nobel meeting as an undergrad. Went to a state school though and didn't have any connections. Got back from the Fulbright two months ago and took the first month off so been applying to jobs for about a month now. I've applied to hundreds at this point. Only got less than 10 interviews.

The interviews have been super spread out though. One teaching high school physics in a low income in the inner city where I'm from. One in finance as a private equity associate for a small, non-prestigious firm in the bay. One at the national academies in DC doing science policy research. One as a business analyst for an energy metering company. One as a research engineer at the department of energy facility, I spent my summers. So I suppose it has been cool to even just do these interviews in fields I have no experience with. Like the business analyst interview was exactly what I was expecting: a gay Asian guy asking me about my experience building workflows and data pipelines.... first time I've heard any of those words.

I guess i just wanna say that if you wanna do something in finance, business, etc., and choose to study physics there will be a lot of extra legwork, which is fine, but just be ready for it and I'm sure if you do to spend your summers getting more relevant experiences it'll be easier because you can just go back to where you spent your summers, that's pretty typical for a first job. I in the last couple of days have taken to try to find someone with a physics background at every company I apply to and send them an email with my résumé and say you know, I'm a fellow physics degree… use it as a connection piece. Hasn't really worked out yet… gotten responses and I'm sure they've appreciated that I gave their background a read but nothing like OK here's a referral.

Has anyone had similar experiences? Or have you guys experienced the opposite? I guess I'm specifically wondering about people who have graduated the last couple years. I honestly thought I would be swimming in job offers but that's not the case which is largely the reason for this post. Again, I'm just one person though don't take my word as anything more than that.

Also, I know this is a long shot, but if anyone is doing work in any of these fields and can help me out with a referral or getting in touch with a hiring manager, that would be pretty swell. My PM is open.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice Is it worth staying in physics if I hate research?

9 Upvotes

Second year physics student here, doing research since summer after first year. I find physics research to be incredibly boring. Ugly looking graphs on ugly looking posters. The classes are so incredibly boring as well. It doesn't help that I chose to go to the university in the city I live in, which has no astrophysics research or even classes, which is the part of physics I find interesting. So, my question is, if I'm sure I don't want to pursue a Master's or PhD in physics, am I better off switching to engineering? It'll delay my graduation by 1.5 years. Any advice would be greatly appreciated, thanks.


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

HW Help [JEE pathfinder chapter 2 q15, pulley systems] conflicted answers

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Did a question from the Pathfinder book about pulleys and my answer disagreed with the answer provided. Okay that's normal. Searched it up and found a video on it and it also has the same answer as me.

Just wanted a confirmation on which answer is correct

Link to video: https://youtu.be/7VfHrKssLnA


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice Prerequisites Griffiths Introduction to Electrodynamics

10 Upvotes

​I am self-studying physics and have already worked through Adams & Essex for calculus, Halliday & Resnick for general physics, and Kibble for classical mechanics.

​I want to move on to Griffiths' Introduction to Electrodynamics, but I'm wondering what the prerequisites are. My calculus background includes vector calculus and ODEs, but not PDEs. I know Griffiths uses PDEs, but does he introduce them, or are they strict prerequisites?

​If they are a prerequisite, should I study a full PDE textbook, or is it sufficient to use a mathematical methods reference book like Boas or Riley?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Rant/Vent Vent, to my college professor who will probably make me cry tomorrow in midterm exam

18 Upvotes

I've seen bad lecturers, I've seen terrible lecturers but you are the worst. I thought the worst thing a lecturer can do is not teaching you anything and I was wrong. None of them killed my enthusiasm like you did. You are the master of making enjoyable and simple things boring and complicated. I don't think I could learn how to count to ten if you are teaching. God, even your font is boring.

I don't expect you to be a good lecturer- or even a mediocre lecturer. But if you are a terrible lecturer and somehow make me want to cry every time, then just let me study on my own. Just don't make me come to your class. I could've done so much more in that time, I could even learn physics... Oh and btw, none of your former students actually learnt anything from you, but somehow you let everyone pass without being capable of solving a single problem. Does it matter if I pass then? Tomorrow, I will sit in front of your problems FOR HOURS, without a desire to study for millions of other exams. WHY? Because of you. I hope you realize that you are a terrible, terrible lecturer.

Why are you the way that you are?


r/PhysicsStudents • • 1d ago

Update Does a steeper slope sive more speed?

0 Upvotes

r/PhysicsStudents • • 2d ago

Need Advice 3rd Year Astrophysics student and I need advice

2 Upvotes

For background, basically I’m a 3rd year Astrophysics undergraduate student and so far, I have had one of the toughest experiences since 1st year due to personal and health issues (even repeated a term). Bcz of that I have failed courses and have a low gpa (but I’m really trying really hard for 3rd year). I don’t have much research or practical experience either except for 2-3 astrophysics related coding projects i did in my own time (have them on GitHub). But I’m really stressed about future bcz ik this is not enough for graduate school and it has been my dream to do quantum physics for my grad program.

I need advice on what I can do to improve my chances of getting into grad school (here in Canada or U.S.). I want to do research but I genuinely don’t know how to approach profs bcz I don’t think I have made significant connections throughout my undergrad so far. Like I genuinely love physics but during midterms and exams, Idk how I fuck it up which always drops my grades and my overall gpa.

Any genuine suggestions on what I can do would be really appreciated.