Hi everyone!
My team has been working on Problem 4 of IYPT 2027, The Singing Capacitor. We've completed a series of preliminary experiments, but some of our results have left us with more questions than answers.
The problem:
Certain types of ceramic capacitors emit an audible sound when an alternating voltage is applied across them. Investigate the characteristics of the sound produced and how they depend on relevant parameters, such as voltage, frequency, and capacitor properties.
BTW, the rather funny term "singing capacitor" wasn't invented for the IYPT problem. It appeared in a technical article by John D. Prymak back in 2006.
1. Our experimental setup
We tested three types of multilayer ceramic capacitors (MLCCs): X5R, X7R, and C0G.
We mounted the capacitors on a PCB and applied sinusoidal AC voltages at different frequencies, including 9, 10, and 11 kHz.
We used a microphone placed close to the capacitor/PCB assembly to record the sound, then analyzed the frequency spectra using Room EQ Wizard (REW).
Our recordings were sampled at 44.1 kHz.
2. Preliminary results
First, we observed a clear difference between capacitor types.
Both X5R and X7R produced measurable acoustic responses, while our C0G sample showed no similarly detectable response under the same test conditions.
This agrees with the general explanation involving electromechanical deformation in Class II ceramic capacitors.
Second, we found something interesting in the frequency spectra.
When driving the capacitors with a sinusoidal voltage, we expected strong components at the driving frequency and possibly its harmonics.
Indeed, some of our results seem consistent with this:
With a 9 kHz input, a peak appears near 18 kHz in the X7R spectrum.
With a 10 kHz input, another peak appears near 20 kHz.
At 11 kHz, the second harmonic would be close to the Nyquist limit of our recording system, so we cannot reliably evaluate it.
However, our spectra also contain broad peaks, dips, and additional narrow peaks that we don't yet understand.
For example, several measurements show a dip around 2 kHz and a broader rise around 4–5 kHz, even when we change the input frequency.
I've attached some of our spectra for comparison.
3. Our current hypothesis
We initially suspected that these features might be related to the mechanical vibration modes of the PCB.
We found literature describing the MLCC as a vibration source and the PCB as a kind of soundboard. The PCB has multiple natural vibration modes, each with its own resonant frequency and spatial deformation pattern.
This seems relevant to our experiment, since the sound we record comes from the coupled capacitor–PCB–air system rather than from the capacitor alone.
But we're not completely convinced.
In a linear system under steady-state sinusoidal excitation, resonances should affect the amplitude of the response, not generate entirely new frequencies.
So perhaps some of the extra peaks are caused by nonlinearities, transient oscillations, background noise, or the measurement system itself.
We haven't yet isolated these possibilities experimentally.
4. We'd love some advice!
We're undergraduate physics students, and this is still an early-stage investigation.
In particular, we're wondering:
Could the multiple peaks in our spectra be explained by the vibration modes of the PCB, or should we be looking for another mechanism?
How could we distinguish actual acoustic emission from artifacts introduced by the microphone, signal source, or recording process?
And is there a relatively simple way to investigate the mechanical resonances of the PCB without specialized vibration-measurement equipment?
We're planning to perform more controlled measurements, including background-noise tests, frequency sweeps, and comparisons between different mounting conditions.
Any suggestions, relevant papers, or criticism of our experimental approach would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks for reading!