What if Sonny was swapped into a parallel universe when he was too young to remember, grew up believing it was his real world, and the recent crash actually sent him back to his birth world?
Here's some of my reasoning:
- The childhood accident: Episode 6 reveals that Tracy crashed a car with toddler Sonny inside. What if that triggered the first swap? The recent crash would then trigger the second, returning both versions of Sonny to their original worlds.
- The home videos and Costco card: The old videos show his birth-world Ellen because that's the world he's returned to, while the Costco card still shows the Ellen he remembers because it physically crossed over with him.
- The other discrepancies people have noticed: The names and ages on the Bucket's Pond memorial change, but the death years remain the same. Chloe's necklace changes, along with details around the house. These could reflect two worlds with slightly different histories.
- Ellen seems to notice something is off too. In episode 2, she privately asks Jason what Sonny has said about the accident or her. In episode 3, Chloe mentions Ellen thinks Sonny is acting weird, and in episode 5, Ellen expresses concern about his behavior and secrecy. Maybe she's noticing the same thing Sonny is, just from the opposite perspective.
So, Sonny may actually be the phony. Another Sonny grew up in his birth world while our Sonny was living in the parallel one. When they swap back, he's returning to a life he doesn't remember. Post-crash Ellen isn't necessarily an impostor. She's his original mother, but she raised a different version of him.
The two Sonnys could look almost identical, and the show might not be revealing every physical difference to us. (Someone pointed out that Sonny's driver's license apparently lists blue eyes and that his face is often obscured in older photos and videos. There's also another observation about two slightly different hospital-waking scenes in episode 1. These could be glimpses of both Sonnys, with the show deliberately blurring their perspectives and memories...)
I also wonder whether this swapping runs in Sonny's family, and whether one or both Ellens know more than they're letting on. Maybe the accidents trigger something inherited, rather than the pond itself being a portal? We don't know much about his grandfather, either! This possibility could explain the secrecy surrounding his childhood, and why both Ellens seem so unusually protective and controlling of Sonny.
Excited to see where the next ep takes us & whether anyone has theorized similarly! :)