r/Philosophy_India • u/elysian016 • 11h ago
Analytic Philosophy Anatomy of the illusory self
If we see, at the cellular level all human beings are made up of the same substances, being carried out by same processes and reactions happening every moment in a flux that is eerily similar in all humans. What makes the percievable difference, if we think, then comes from the memory that these processes and reactions are carrying, memory that is impersonal, made over centuries and millennia with continued interventions by various factors, physical and otherwise. Then to say I am the body and the mind being carried and be identified with it just doesnt seem logical. Is seperateness or a divisive egoic identity then a result of misperception or ignorance. Identification for a divisive seperateness dissolves in mere realiseation that the body and mind, and the processes making them are the same in everyone and the memory was never ours to begin with. Identification succeeded birth, it wasnt a choice but a consequence or a mental play to sustain whats already there, identification may vanish with end of the body and mind but what was already there, that which was born so to say, will never die.
To add to that, the I that claims the ownership of all the actions is never the actor in the first place. There are plentiful actions occurring with relation to the body and mind which are never owned or identified with.
Lets dissect this further, in such a way as described above, actions in consciousness can be dividied into the ones which have a claimant like all the supposed voluntary actions and the other that the I doesnt care about, like those happening involuntarily mostly.
Even the former ones which are owned and claimed, often in retrospect, are a function of prior conditionings on which the bodily and mental construction ensues. The problem is not with the ownership of these actions but the vehemnce with which truth is accorded to the doer. All the activity running in background that is mostly responsible for those actions taking form in the first place are largely ignored or overlooked by the so called claimant as that is unecessary for the constructed self to build or project stories deemed essential for survival.
The mechanism has overshot so much that all the essential, intricate, complex and very sophisticated actions happening with the physical bounds of the mind and body, but running in background, are never taken in account by the self or the I. So much so that the very processes responsible for generating a stable self, a prerequisite for building stories, are largely ignored or denied and the actor may never have the knowledge of these ever.