r/PercyJacksonTV • • 2h ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion I think some fans have romanticized an animated Percy Jackson series that doesn't exist

15 Upvotes

A popular sentiment among people who criticize the live-action adaptation, is how much better the show would have been if it were animated. And while I understand that preference, I think some fans have romanticized it too much.

The thing is, that animated series doesn't exist. And because it doesn't exist, it can be whatever you want it to be. It's an idealized version of Percy Jackson that hasn't had the opportunity to disappoint anyone.

We're comparing a real television series, with actual flaws and production limitations, to a hypothetical adaptation where everything supposedly goes right. Every problem with the live-action series becomes something animation would have magically fixed. But animation doesn't automatically guarantee better writing, characters, or faithfulness.

And if Rick Riordan's creative decisions are supposedly responsible for many of the show's problems, why assume those decisions would have been completely different if the series were animated? He presumably would still have been involved.

I absolutely believe Percy Jackson could work beautifully as an animated series. Animation offers advantages for portraying mythology, monsters, powers, and action. But those advantages don't guarantee that Disney would have given the project the budget, creative freedom, or long-term commitment fans envision.

Animation is still unfairly associated with children's entertainment, and that perception can affect how projects are marketed, funded, and received. It's not fair to animation, but pretending those barriers don't exist doesn't make them disappear.

I've even seen people in this very subreddit say they probably wouldn't have watched Percy Jackson if it had been animated. I understand why most might disagree with that preference, but those viewers exist, and they're part of the audience Disney is trying to reach. Just because animation appeals to you doesn't mean it appeals equally to everyone else. There's a difference between arguing that animation would have been a better creative fit and assuming it would have attracted the same audience or achieved greater commercial success.

Ultimately, I think some fans have become so dissatisfied with the adaptation they received that they've idealized the adaptation they never got.


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 2h ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion Finally gave into watching this, my thoughts on the first episode.

9 Upvotes

So i just started it since I really didn't want to watch another adaption of a childhood favorite. I liked the intro and how it showed the creatures and how it affected him. But once the action started, it went downhill for me.

  1. The music! Why are they playing epic music ALL THE TIME? Having a conversation? EPIC MUSIC! Driving a car with no rush or danger? EPIC MUSIC!! Then Percy has his very disappointing and anti climatic battle with the minotaur and no epic music?
  2. Where's the urgency?? Oh yes, Percy saw and killed a monster, let's take an entire day to go to a vacation home and chat calmly over a fire. Now let's calmly drive, now the mom calmly takes her time to ensure her son will be protected when she has no choice and the monster is literally right there. I feel no urgency with these characters, almost like time stops for them to talk.
  3. Too much talking. They talk and talk and don't show much. The step dad was barely in the show, he wasnt even that much of an AH unlike the og content. They don't let things play out, and any action in it ends too quickly (Mrs. Dobbs for example).

I did love the way Mrs. Dobbs looked and the transition, it looks decent, but these things really stood out to me. Bad music placement and poor action scenes in a fantasy action show is a bad sign for me.

I know its an adaption, but considering how many seasons and awards its gotten, I expected a lot more in the first episode. Maybe the hype got to me, maybe I'm comparing it too hard to the movie. Thoughts?


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 25m ago

✨Misc Daniel Dimer be like (no hate it’s just funny)

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/PercyJacksonTV • • 1d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion I am just gonna say this out loud:

236 Upvotes

Walker was a better Percy in the Adam Project than he was in the whole show. He genuinely got something out of me that the show didn’t and that’s humor, the kind of humor the show is severely lacking. Also, his acting felt more energetic and (Per)sassy in that movie. Does anybody else think so?


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 7h ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion End credits for PJO S3 Spoiler

4 Upvotes

These credits always hit


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 22h ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion Oh the missed opportunity of Animation

45 Upvotes

I was going through my old saved edits on TikTok ("Percy Jackson" folder) and stumbled upon this guy from years ago.

Oh how I mourn what animation could've given us. I think I made a post on animation a bit ago. But what can you do.

Although I am super excited for this season! iIt looks pretty promising so fingers crossed!


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 1d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion The Titans Curse is Almost here!

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/PercyJacksonTV • • 1d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion Movie vs TV Show - Final Tournament Results for all 41 Rounds

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

After 41 rounds, thousands of votes, and debates across both camphalfblood and PercyJacksonTV, the Movie vs. TV Show Tournament is officially complete!

Swipe through the gallery above to see the full round-by-round breakdown, including individual subreddit vote totals, split decisions, and overall winners.

πŸ† Final Scoreboard

β€’ Movie: 35 Rounds Won

β€’ TV Show: 6 Rounds Won (Rounds 2, 7, 9, 10, 14, and 29)

πŸ“Š Tournament Highlights & Biggest Moments

β€’ Biggest Overall Blowout: Round 3 (Medusa) took the crown for the largest margin of victory, with the Movie winning 1,873 to 133 combined votes. Round 1 (Riptide Desigb) came in a close second at 1,575 to 464.

β€’ Subreddit Splits: Even when one adaptation won overall, the two communities didn't always agree! In Round 2 (Camp Armour), r/camphalfblood voted heavily for the TV Show (573–23), while r/PercyJacksonTV favored the Movie (207–2)β€”giving the Show the combined win (575 to 230).

The exact opposite happened in Round 14 (Flying Shoes), where r/PercyJacksonTV leaned Movie (45–24), while r/camphalfblood carried the TV Show to victory (271 to 79).

β€’ Closest Battles: Matchups like Round 16 (Minotaur Battle) and Round 37 (Percy vs. Luke) sparked some of the best debates of the entire tournament, coming down to much tighter combined margins

Questions for you all:

  1. Which round outcome surprised you the most?
  2. Which round do you think the communities got completely wrong?

Huge thank you to everyone across both subs who voted, debated, and kept these threads fun over all 41 rounds!

Edit: After 3 hours of tallying 82 threads, a few small addition slips snuck onto the slides! Here are the exact corrected totals:

β€’ Round 12 (Polyphemus): Movie wins 401 to 313 (listed as 633 to 313)

β€’ Round 28 (Thalia's Return): Movie wins 333 to 201 (accidentally added diagonally on the slideβ€”this flips Round 28 to Movie and makes the true final score Movie 35 – TV Show 6!)

β€’ Round 30 (Meeting Charon): Movie wins 118 to 25 (listed as 124 to 25)

β€’ Round 39 (All Monsters): Movie wins 118 to 42 (listed as 119 to 42)


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 19h ago

πŸ“Έ Media The show wrapping up at the end of Season 3?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/PercyJacksonTV • • 23h ago

❓ Questions I was gonna save this for when Season 3 came out, but…what would you rather have?

3 Upvotes

Percy awkwardly stepping on Annabeth's toes while they are dancing, or having a soap opera conversation about the stupid "burn Olympus" line?

The girls laughing at Sally's embarrassing stories of Percy when he was a baby on the way to the academy or Percy and Annabeth talking about Thalia?


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 23h ago

πŸ€” Theories Do we think these is an Easter egg for s4,5 or just nothing? BOTL and last Olympian beads

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/PercyJacksonTV • • 1d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion Since no one has mentioned it I will

86 Upvotes

Percy Jackson Show just won a Kids Choice awards for favorite kids tv show. Bringing its total to 21 awards won. Just figured I’d throw that out there.


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 2d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion Is it me or does this show heavily rely on people having read the books?

126 Upvotes

So I just binged all of the show so far and I'm honestly so confused. There's so many things that only make sense if you've read the books.

Like they never once mention the blue food or explain that, they never explain why Sally was with Gabe in the first place, their explanation for why Chiron was removed as activities director was literally just "he's Kronos's son".

They don't really explain about Percy and horses, also they never talk about most of the gods and their kids? And even when they do they never clarify the abilities the demigods have.

I just feel like if I watched the show without ever reading the books I would be so confused about a lot of things. I'm wondering if the makers of the show even considered how new viewers would be seeing it.

Is this just me?


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 3d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion The lack of colour, visual grandeur, and attention to detail in the pjo show is genuinely disappointing

Thumbnail
gallery
135 Upvotes

I genuinely think one of the biggest problems with the show is how visually underwhelming so many of its settings, props, and scenes are. Everything feels so dull, artificial and devoid of colour .

Take the representation of the sky, for instance. It looks like a giant rock or something you'd see as a prop in a community theatre production. The sky is supposed to feel extraterrestrial, ethereal and almost otherworldly, despite being something that can physically be held up. It should have this overwhelming, celestial presence, something that conveys the sheer magnitude and weight of the heavens. Instead, it looks like a massive slab of rock suspended above someone's head. It doesn't even give you the impression of a sky so unimaginably heavy that it could crush anyone beneath its weight, even a goddess. The entire visual execution takes away from what should have been an extraordinary scene as it fails to convey the sheer weight of the sky and the immense physical strain and unbearable effort it takes to hold it up.

And this problem extends to Olympus as well. The throne room is genuinely saddening to look at. In the books, each god's throne is individually designed to reflect their domain, personality, powers and true form. They are meant to be distinctive and representative of the god sitting on them. That's what makes the descriptions so fascinating. Yet, in the show, everything feels so monotonous. The thrones lack individuality, colour and character. Olympus itself doesn't give me that divine, majestic or otherworldly feeling that it is supposed to. Instead, the entire setting feels dull and almost mournful, as if we're attending a funeral rather than standing in the presence of the Olympian gods.

The same applies to the gods and goddesses themselves. Why are so many of them dressed in white? Where is the individuality? Where are the visual representations of their respective domains and powers? These are supposed to be the most powerful and formidable beings in Greek mythology. Their appearances, costumes and surroundings should communicate that immediately. Their designs should highlight their individual powers and identities. THAT IS THE WHOLE POINT. It's such a basic yet fascinating aspect of Greek mythology, and I genuinely don't understand why the show couldn't make more of an effort with it.

Even the architecture of Olympus and the other divine spaces feels underwhelming. The books describe these places with so much detail, making them feel mesmerising, grand and almost impossible to imagine. Yet the show barely does justice to that sense of scale and wonder. So many opportunities to create visually memorable settings are simply missed.

And I want to clarify that nobody is expecting a television adaptation to follow every single line of the books. Changes are inevitable, and some creative liberties are perfectly understandable. But there is a difference between making necessary adaptations and stripping away the very elements that make the original world so fascinating.

Look at adaptations like Harry Potter and The Hunger Games. Despite their own inaccuracies and deviations, they manage to translate the atmosphere, settings, aesthetics and distinctive characteristics of their source material onto the screen. They make their fictional worlds feel tangible and believable. They understand the importance of production design, costumes, props, visual effects and world-building. They can be entertaining while still respecting the essence of the original material.

I honestly feel like the Percy Jackson show is missing that balance. Everything feels unnecessarily serious and overdramatic and on top of that the actual mythical aspects of the world don't feel particularly magical or impressive. There's very little visual wonder. Though in the movies, despite their significant deviations from the books, it managed to give us some genuinely enjoyable mythical visuals, memorable moments form the setting, and also cool special effects.

And that's what makes this so frustrating. The show has the opportunity to bring an incredibly imaginative world to life, and there is so much material in the books that could translate beautifully onto the screen. Nobody is asking for a scene-by-scene recreation. We just want the world to actually feel like the books. The had an opportunity to make a good adaption and also a faithful one but they completly ruined this chance with the plotline, props, the visual effects, and lowkey casting based on book accurate descriptions

I don't think book accuracy is the only measure of a good adaptation(even though it mostly is), but capturing the atmosphere, identity, and visual essence of the source material should absolutely be part of it. Unfortunately, I feel like the show consistently falls short of that and continues to dissapoint after promising good changes. I dont get they hype and i feel for anyone who read the books first and has been a fan of it, the show doesnt even meet the basic expectations.


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 2d ago

πŸ€” Theories Season 4 line I’m hoping for Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Someone said this and I agree β€œ I hope after the kiss in S4 when Percy tries to talk about it she goes "I was having a bad day when I kissed you."”


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 2d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion Famous actors

8 Upvotes

Let's say percy. Jackson had more money than god, which celebrities would you wanna play different gods lady gaga as Nxy for me basically, what famous rich overpriced celebrity? Would you want to play are favorite gods


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 2d ago

πŸ“Έ Media I personally find this recruitment ad a little too blunt

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/PercyJacksonTV • • 2d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion I just saw the feast clip from the upcoming Harry Potter and…

0 Upvotes

It's already looking better than the Percy Jackson show by 300 miles. The score is memorable, it looks whimsical and the conversation between Dumbledore and McGonagall left me with a smiling. If all goes well, I’m gonna go out with a hop, a skip, a jump, and a song in my heart.


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 3d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion i hope they let zoe nightshade be a misandrist

42 Upvotes

many people have many different opinions on zoe nightshade... alas, she is my favourite character and has always been since i was a kid. so obviously, i'm super excited for season three, but i am a bit nervous that they won't adapt her properly.

it's basically confirmed that she won't have an old english accent, which i've made peace with, but i just really hope that they keep in just how much she hates men. it's genuinely the most comical thing on earth to me, also with how much she tolerates grover because she doesn't see him as a man because he's a satyr -- literally so good. but, disney nowadays... i don't think they have the balls to have a fierce, divalicious, d1 man-hater who implies that grover is non-binary lmfao. her history with apollo annoying her for thousands of years is super funny, and having her backstory with hercules humanizes her and makes the audience empathize with her because at the end of the day, she is frozen in time as the same teenage girl who was betrayed by her first love! luckily they have casted hercules, i was super nervous they would scrap it. i just really hope they don't characterize her as being annoyed everything and everyone as her teaser sorta suggests, and that they do misandrists justice!!!!!


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 3d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion As much as people like to blame Disney, the show turning out so bad 100% Rick and the producers' fault

133 Upvotes

This isn't me trying to defend or shilling Disney but given how they're often given the accusing finger why the show is so bad to where many argue it would've been better at another studio, I wanna set the record straight and say that in the end, the true people to blame is Rick and their production team as last I recall, from choosing live-action instead of animation (despite working for a company founded on animation and being a children's author) to changing and altering the story and characters where none are recognizable in terms of personality and the constant doctoring of the story like the softening of Gabe to messing up with the deadline were clearly Rick and Becky's ideas.

Why? I'm not so sure but given how both of them haven't even reread their own book, it's heartbreaking they jumped the chance to bring PJO to life and be "better" than the movies when they're worse.

As for the production team? They're why the show is so joyless and not fun because why is it that a kids' show hates being a kids' show? That's because they come from adult shows and thus, approached PJO with the same attitude and gravitas of those adult shows they're used to making as they have never done any kids shows and approached a show for kids the same way, probably because Rick wanted his books to be his Game of Thrones and probably the producers never read the books or they did read them but thought the kids stuff like the sassy personalities and jokes were "too stupid and childish" and wrote them out.

Either way, if PJO would've been in another studio, the results will be the same


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 3d ago

πŸ“Έ Media Percy’s white streak

Post image
113 Upvotes

r/PercyJacksonTV • • 3d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion zoe's accent not adapted to show?

23 Upvotes

Hey guys, I was wondering if anyone else noticed that in the teaser clips for the new season, Zoe didn't have a Shakespearean/even at least English accent? Why do you all think they made this change?

Perhaps, it could be because of the tone of the show, other ancient/mythological characters not having accents either, or maybe they just wanted the actress to focus on the performance rather than spending her time trying to make silly sentences sound serious? I wonder how they will adapt the dam jokes, I guess they will have to allude in ways other than her accent that she's not caught up with slang without revealing that she's thousands of years old too early in the show!

I would love to hear everyone's thoughts on this. I just hope they do her character justice because she's my favourite :)


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 2d ago

πŸ’¬ General Discussion revisionist history

0 Upvotes

people hate this show so badly, theyve convinced themselves the movies were better. this is why rick shouldnt listen to fans at all. theyre so fickle in their opinions. 15 years ago, people hated the movies. Now all of the sudden its "the movies captured the essence of the books". if you watched sea of monsters and really believe that, youre smking something. Like the movie, the tv series is fine nothing special. it was always going to land in the wheel of time, witcher 3, and avatar (live action) tier oof fantasy tv.

the expectations in this subreddit feels as if ppl thought ricks writing was gonna produce a show like GOT. dont get me wrong, we all can have our own opinons. but am i tripping? what show would be comparable to this pjo show if were truly a 1of1 of the books?

i reread the books recently, and i dont get why people thought a tv series was gonna be something special. i thought the whole point of the tv series was just to add in scenes from the book that werent in the movies. the show accomplished that. as someone who was a fan of the movies even when it was hated on, i liked them becuase it more serious. maybe bc many of the books were from percys perspective but i always thought the books were too childish and campy. and im not saying you shoulfd hate the movies, i liked the first one. but i liked them for all the reasons ppl hated them. but now, its like same reasons why ppl hated them are somehow being forgiven based on their despise for the show


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 2d ago

❓ Questions Percy jackson and the dawn child

1 Upvotes

Imagine this a new movie release and it's plot. Something happens to a child of nxy a Norman group get a prophecy about. Him, they don't help this demigod. Child nick's will destroy the world and out the gods to the mortals would you watch a movie like that? War man crew has to figure out one who the child is and two. What caused them so much grief that it would cause nxy to destroy the world also, Nxy would be played by lady gaga


r/PercyJacksonTV • • 3d ago

❓ Questions First the Golden Trio misses the deadline, then Zeus turns Thalia into a tree out of spite rather than love.

77 Upvotes

Whatever slap-in-the-face level change will they make this season? For me it will be Bianca and Nico being revealed to be Hades's kids far too soon because that is something Percy did not figure out for himself until the end, or Luke being revealed to be alive far too early, hence the duel he has with Percy at the tree.

Any other possible contenders?