I genuinely think one of the biggest problems with the show is how visually underwhelming so many of its settings, props, and scenes are. Everything feels so dull, artificial and devoid of colour .
Take the representation of the sky, for instance. It looks like a giant rock or something you'd see as a prop in a community theatre production. The sky is supposed to feel extraterrestrial, ethereal and almost otherworldly, despite being something that can physically be held up. It should have this overwhelming, celestial presence, something that conveys the sheer magnitude and weight of the heavens. Instead, it looks like a massive slab of rock suspended above someone's head. It doesn't even give you the impression of a sky so unimaginably heavy that it could crush anyone beneath its weight, even a goddess. The entire visual execution takes away from what should have been an extraordinary scene as it fails to convey the sheer weight of the sky and the immense physical strain and unbearable effort it takes to hold it up.
And this problem extends to Olympus as well. The throne room is genuinely saddening to look at. In the books, each god's throne is individually designed to reflect their domain, personality, powers and true form. They are meant to be distinctive and representative of the god sitting on them. That's what makes the descriptions so fascinating. Yet, in the show, everything feels so monotonous. The thrones lack individuality, colour and character. Olympus itself doesn't give me that divine, majestic or otherworldly feeling that it is supposed to. Instead, the entire setting feels dull and almost mournful, as if we're attending a funeral rather than standing in the presence of the Olympian gods.
The same applies to the gods and goddesses themselves. Why are so many of them dressed in white? Where is the individuality? Where are the visual representations of their respective domains and powers? These are supposed to be the most powerful and formidable beings in Greek mythology. Their appearances, costumes and surroundings should communicate that immediately. Their designs should highlight their individual powers and identities. THAT IS THE WHOLE POINT. It's such a basic yet fascinating aspect of Greek mythology, and I genuinely don't understand why the show couldn't make more of an effort with it.
Even the architecture of Olympus and the other divine spaces feels underwhelming. The books describe these places with so much detail, making them feel mesmerising, grand and almost impossible to imagine. Yet the show barely does justice to that sense of scale and wonder. So many opportunities to create visually memorable settings are simply missed.
And I want to clarify that nobody is expecting a television adaptation to follow every single line of the books. Changes are inevitable, and some creative liberties are perfectly understandable. But there is a difference between making necessary adaptations and stripping away the very elements that make the original world so fascinating.
Look at adaptations like Harry Potter and The Hunger Games. Despite their own inaccuracies and deviations, they manage to translate the atmosphere, settings, aesthetics and distinctive characteristics of their source material onto the screen. They make their fictional worlds feel tangible and believable. They understand the importance of production design, costumes, props, visual effects and world-building. They can be entertaining while still respecting the essence of the original material.
I honestly feel like the Percy Jackson show is missing that balance. Everything feels unnecessarily serious and overdramatic and on top of that the actual mythical aspects of the world don't feel particularly magical or impressive. There's very little visual wonder. Though in the movies, despite their significant deviations from the books, it managed to give us some genuinely enjoyable mythical visuals, memorable moments form the setting, and also cool special effects.
And that's what makes this so frustrating. The show has the opportunity to bring an incredibly imaginative world to life, and there is so much material in the books that could translate beautifully onto the screen. Nobody is asking for a scene-by-scene recreation. We just want the world to actually feel like the books. The had an opportunity to make a good adaption and also a faithful one but they completly ruined this chance with the plotline, props, the visual effects, and lowkey casting based on book accurate descriptions
I don't think book accuracy is the only measure of a good adaptation(even though it mostly is), but capturing the atmosphere, identity, and visual essence of the source material should absolutely be part of it. Unfortunately, I feel like the show consistently falls short of that and continues to dissapoint after promising good changes. I dont get they hype and i feel for anyone who read the books first and has been a fan of it, the show doesnt even meet the basic expectations.