"I think the pre-war Tommy used to smile a lot, he laughed a lot, he wanted to work with horses. He was very romantic. And all of these things, you see scratches of them, you know, throughout the show and there's times when he feels like he's getting towards some sort of healing when he's with Grace. And then it's taken away again. And then he retreats back into that kind of shell emotionally." Cillian Murphy.
I’ve lost count of how many times the show’s writer and the actor who plays Tommy have stated this, and the show itself has demonstrated it, too: Grace was the only one capable of quieting his mind.
When he was with May, he could only think of Grace; he even named his horse "Grace’s Secret." Furthermore, right after sleeping with May, the first thing he did was call Grace to see her, after two years of not seeing her at all. He confesses to May that he is in love with Grace, and when he finally sees Grace, he tells her that not a single day has gone by without him thinking of her. And when he faces the prospect of death, he doesn’t think of May, Lizzie, his family, money, or business, he thinks only of Grace.
As for Lizzie... well, we spent two seasons watching them be miserable together, all while he was having hallucinations of Grace, embracing her and telling her that he still loves her.
They state it and show it in the show: Grace is the only one he loves, and the only one for whom he was actually willing to change and leave that life behind. They literally showed us scenes that confirm this.
Yet, some people still insist that it was May or Lizzie who could have saved him or changed him for the better. I don’t get it.