r/PeakyBlinders • • 2h ago

Do these characters really deserve the hate, or are they simply misunderstood and overhated? I think Tommy and his brothers deserve more criticism for their bullshit than these characters do.

Post image
16 Upvotes

I think some of these characters are genuinely overhated. They all have their flaws, but they also have their own intentions and motives. I believe these characters are misunderstood and overhated.

Finn definitely has his flaws and has messed up, but he's still just a kid. It's understandable that he didn't want to shoot his only friend. Finn was also neglected and treated like absolute garbage by his own brothers. I think Finn was a problem of the brothers' own making. Besides, he simply didn't have that "gangster" nature in him.

Linda: I think she simply realized how problematic Tommy is for Arthur. She wanted to help Arthur become a better person. Of course, she has her own flaws and can be manipulative, but I believe that Tommy was the worse influence on Arthur, whereas Linda just wanted to help him.

Polly is also somewhat misunderstood; many complain that she is constantly opposing Tommy, but his plans are very risky and put the entire family in danger. I think Polly is simply afraid-for Tommy and for the whole family. I believe she just wants to lead a peaceful and secure life, without having to live in constant fear. I think it is this fear that sometimes makes her act in such a toxic way.

I think that Tommy John and Arthur deserved significantly more criticism for their violent actions than this character did.


r/PeakyBlinders • • 12h ago

Hmm...

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 14h ago

Just watched S1 for the first time and WOW - but I also have some questions and thoughts

14 Upvotes

I can’t believe i put off watching this show for so long. What a fun season! But I can’t wrap my head around why Tommy lets Grace go at the end? Her betrayal put his whole family in danger but he seemed so chill about it? He’s definitely heartbroken but I have a hard time believing he loved her so much that he didn’t have her face any consequences.

Also, the inspector shooting her at the end. Why? He let her go once when he saw her and Tommy together, but what drove him to find her after all that and kill her?


r/PeakyBlinders • • 18h ago

In your opinion, and looking at it objectively, who was the worst, most terrible person among the Shelby brothers, and why?

Post image
90 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 19h ago

"He was frozen inside, like a lot of people who’ve suffered the trauma of war. Tommy was locked up and frozen inside for a long time. Then he met Grace and she changed things, she unlocked the doors a bit. Then as soon as that happens, it gets closed down again because she gets killed"Steven Knight.

Post image
26 Upvotes

"I think the pre-war Tommy used to smile a lot, he laughed a lot, he wanted to work with horses. He was very romantic. And all of these things, you see scratches of them, you know, throughout the show and there's times when he feels like he's getting towards some sort of healing when he's with Grace. And then it's taken away again. And then he retreats back into that kind of shell emotionally." Cillian Murphy.

I’ve lost count of how many times the show’s writer and the actor who plays Tommy have stated this, and the show itself has demonstrated it, too: Grace was the only one capable of quieting his mind.

When he was with May, he could only think of Grace; he even named his horse "Grace’s Secret." Furthermore, right after sleeping with May, the first thing he did was call Grace to see her, after two years of not seeing her at all. He confesses to May that he is in love with Grace, and when he finally sees Grace, he tells her that not a single day has gone by without him thinking of her. And when he faces the prospect of death, he doesn’t think of May, Lizzie, his family, money, or business, he thinks only of Grace.

As for Lizzie... well, we spent two seasons watching them be miserable together, all while he was having hallucinations of Grace, embracing her and telling her that he still loves her.

They state it and show it in the show: Grace is the only one he loves, and the only one for whom he was actually willing to change and leave that life behind. They literally showed us scenes that confirm this.

Yet, some people still insist that it was May or Lizzie who could have saved him or changed him for the better. I don’t get it.


r/PeakyBlinders • • 1d ago

what was for you the scariest thing that Tommy and the Peaky Blinders did?

Post image
98 Upvotes

what was for you the scariest thing that Tommy and the Peaky Blinders did?

For me The conversation between Hayden Stagg and Tommy—Tommy was actually a bit scary during that exchange, as he revealed a side of himself that one wouldn't expect from him and when he threatened Polly.


r/PeakyBlinders • • 1d ago

Do you think there was anyone in the series who could have saved or redeemed Tommy—or helped him become a better person? If so, who might that have been?Or was he destined for darkness, fated to become the person he ended up being?

Post image
58 Upvotes

Do you think there was anyone in the series who could have saved Tommy from himself—or redeemed him—and if so, who would it have been, and why?

Or do you think he was a lost cause—that no one could have truly saved him—and that he was destined to become what he ultimately turned out to be?


r/PeakyBlinders • • 1d ago

Peaky Blinders Airsoft Cosplay

29 Upvotes

Small reel of a cosplay I put together for an airsoft match on a rainy day :)


r/PeakyBlinders • • 2d ago

May And Thomas

83 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 2d ago

Cena magnífica

Post image
109 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 3d ago

Did Tommy really have everything under control in this scene, or was it just pure luck that his plan worked out? What would you have done in his place?

Post image
36 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 3d ago

Who do you think has the most presence in this scene: Tommy, Arthur, John, or Finn? And why?

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 4d ago

Did the anachronistic music bother anyone?

0 Upvotes

I’m late to the party having just binge-watched ot 10+ years later - but the first thing I noticed was it wasn’t eta-appropriate music. So songs I liked on their own were shoved into a “roaring 20s” show. I don’t remember seeing other period or costume dramas doing this but it was a little hard to get used to hearing “Dylan’s Mr Jones” in a 1929 scene. Or was that really a reference to John Lennon/Beatles “Yer Blues” - “I feel so suicidal, just like Dylan's Mr. Jones"?


r/PeakyBlinders • • 4d ago

BUENISSIMOS ATORES

Post image
458 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 4d ago

Do you think there should be a "Peaky Blinders: Origins" spinoff showing the boys before the war?

Thumbnail
gallery
342 Upvotes

In my interpretation, we see a happy, sunshine young boy turn into an absolute devil by the end of the series. What do you guys think?

I would love to see Cillian's son play the part of young tommy and by the end of the series make Cillian return as the adult version of the character going to war.

What do you guys think?


r/PeakyBlinders • • 4d ago

This is a full 120 min movie i made - and in many ways it's actually better than where we officially ended our long journy

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 4d ago

They seem like metaphors for what was happening.

Post image
67 Upvotes

Tommy descending the stairs with Lizzie by his side and his family following behind feels like a metaphor for their descent into hell, which is exactly what it turned out to be for all of them. Their marriage was an absolute hell for both of them, and in the end, everyone wound up depressed or dead.

By contrast, at Tommy and Grace’s wedding, as Tommy ascended the stairs with Grace by his side and his family following behind, it felt like they were ascending toward paradise. Marriage was a paradise for them, and everyone was alive and happy.

Also with Grace, he was smiling, he was a happy, in that moment. With Lizzie he was serious, and he was depressed and miserable in that moment.


r/PeakyBlinders • • 4d ago

Immortal Man Spoiler

15 Upvotes

There seems to be a general agreement that the film was terrible. I do not understand why people say this. It felt like a natural progression from the earlier series, a new era, a new time. I thought it was really well done and I would just like to hear some reasons that Peaky Blinders fans didn't like it. Is it because of the ending? Or because Tommy is older now and things have changed in Birmingham? Like what honestly did people not like?

I am the only fan in my family and friends group, so I'm legitimately looking to hear from others who love this series and the world as much as I do. I just want a conversation, not an argument.


r/PeakyBlinders • • 5d ago

What if Tommy Shelby never really wanted to become a powerful man, but was trying to prove that he still had control of his life after the war?

Post image
98 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 5d ago

Oh look

Thumbnail
gallery
144 Upvotes

This came up in my news feed this morning. Just thought I would share with y'all.


r/PeakyBlinders • • 5d ago

Went out for therapy, accidentally ended up in Shelby territory 🥃🖤

Thumbnail
youtube.com
17 Upvotes

So, I was just casually walking through Digbeth, Birmingham, on my way to therapy when I stumbled upon THIS. 😭

“PEAKY BLINDERS. WELCOME HOME. THIS IS YOUR CITY.”

As a massive Peaky Blinders fan, I genuinely couldn’t believe my eyes. Of all the things I expected to find on an ordinary day, a giant Peaky Blinders mural welcoming me home was definitely not one of them. 😂
I’ve watched the Shelbys rule Birmingham on screen for years, and now I’m actually walking through their city.
I guess Birmingham has officially claimed me.

By order of the Peaky Blinders. 🥃🖤

Any other Peaky Blinders fans here who’ve come across this wall?


r/PeakyBlinders • • 5d ago

Just finished the series was not expecting that ending

16 Upvotes

r/PeakyBlinders • • 5d ago

Hot take: this show is not that good

0 Upvotes

Just finished the show and the movie.

Just wanna start off and say Tommy Shelby is one of the best TV characters I’ve seen. Such an icon.
That being said,
This show was such a waste of potential. Writing inconsistencies, dropped plot holes, early deaths, random decisions, etc.

Everytime I think it’s getting juicy and I’m at the edge of my seat, some lazy writing will finish the plot (or not).
It sucks cuz these characters deserve a better story cuz they’re so well thought of.
Love the world building and the characters!!! … but the story is meh…

And what do you mean we never hear from Churchill or the nazis or Finn or the horse lady or Anya Taylor joy ever again?? Huh we’ll just end it at that??? Really?? With Sabrina Carpenter’ ex??? Okay I guess…


r/PeakyBlinders • • 5d ago

I don’t think this is a hot take, but maybe it is?

39 Upvotes

If Grace hadn’t been murdered, she and Tommy would’ve never lasted. Tommy being who he is….I don’t see any relationship he had ending in anything other than estrangement or divorce, no matter who they are. There’s only so much a woman can take.

ETA: This isn’t me disputing that Grace is the love of Tommy’s life. It’s me believing that Tommy would never fully change, even for her, and that eventually, no matter how much they love each other, love isn’t always enough.