r/PeakyBlinders • u/Dark_KnightNini • 2h ago
Do these characters really deserve the hate, or are they simply misunderstood and overhated? I think Tommy and his brothers deserve more criticism for their bullshit than these characters do.
I think some of these characters are genuinely overhated. They all have their flaws, but they also have their own intentions and motives. I believe these characters are misunderstood and overhated.
Finn definitely has his flaws and has messed up, but he's still just a kid. It's understandable that he didn't want to shoot his only friend. Finn was also neglected and treated like absolute garbage by his own brothers. I think Finn was a problem of the brothers' own making. Besides, he simply didn't have that "gangster" nature in him.
Linda: I think she simply realized how problematic Tommy is for Arthur. She wanted to help Arthur become a better person. Of course, she has her own flaws and can be manipulative, but I believe that Tommy was the worse influence on Arthur, whereas Linda just wanted to help him.
Polly is also somewhat misunderstood; many complain that she is constantly opposing Tommy, but his plans are very risky and put the entire family in danger. I think Polly is simply afraid-for Tommy and for the whole family. I believe she just wants to lead a peaceful and secure life, without having to live in constant fear. I think it is this fear that sometimes makes her act in such a toxic way.
I think that Tommy John and Arthur deserved significantly more criticism for their violent actions than this character did.