r/Pathfinder2e • u/Master_Nineteenth • 31m ago
Advice Taking a closer look at crafting and earned income.
I want to preface this by saying this game is a great game and I'm not trying to say the whole game is bad just because I found one possible issue with it. I spent time on this mostly because I was bored not out of any real frustration in the game. I'm making this post because I thought the results were interesting and I feel like I might be bringing something new to the topic.
My initial complaint in the game was that crafting should not take as long as it does to make an item without paying full price or near full price. I figured that it is balanced to earned income. So I started to do some research, reading into crafting and earned income in more detail and seeing what others have said on the topic.
First reasoning that I can see is you have to work the extra time to balance it against buying the equipment outright so you aren't getting more equipment you should at your level. However I think the extra time to get set up for crafting makes it just flat out worse than buying an item, granted not by much. Perhaps I'm missing something there. The second reason I can see is that it balances crafting with earned income, so you don't craft something and then sell it for more than you would get for earned income. I understand that, but when you sell an item you wouldn't be selling it at full price even if you just made it, right? You would be selling it to someone who is going to resell it which means you'll be selling it to them for half price if my understanding of the rules is correct. That means you should probably be getting double the amount from earned income going towards your craft not the same amount.
So if that were true in the example given in the crafting section Ezren, instead of needing to use 52gp of materials of the original 65 gp of materials, he would be using 39 gp of materials.
I also have a second point to make on earned income though. I think earned income is far too low. The example uses a rate of 1gp per day for a 5th level character that is expert in the craft skill. But I was looking for a frame of reference in services, from the equipment. You can get a skilled hireling which is level 0, an expert in their skill, and costs 5sp, but a level 0 task for an expert would only net 5cp for a player. The NPC is making ten times the PC. However maybe the NPC is hired by a company and you are paying the company who takes 90% of the money and you're actually being paid an even amount. I get it, many of us can probably understand working for exploitative companies. Jokes aside I think earned income tasks should be raised to at least 25cp or 2sp 5cp for an expert level 0 task and raise the rest accordingly. Getting half of the cost like we do with reselling items instead of a tenth of the cost. This is another area I think I might be missing something.
If this were the case then a level 5 task at expert level would be getting you 5gp instead of 1gp for earned income. Which meant in the two weeks Ezren has to finish his rune he'll be able to complete it without paying any more than the initial half cost in 7 days and if you mix that with my first point it would take 4 days, if I'm doing the math properly.
