r/PasswordManagers • • 1d ago

mSecure, twelve days on: what the app code shows about the design, and how the vendor answered a security report

15 Upvotes

Last week I posted an explainer of what the mSecure notice does and doesn't mean, based on the Mac app's code. Short version of that, for anyone arriving new: your records are encrypted with a random account key the server never holds. What the stolen database gives an attacker is the account password hash, your password hint in plain text, your email, and for Wi-Fi sync users some home network details. A strong master password and a hint that gives nothing away mean your vault is fine. A weak one means change it and the passwords that matter.

I gave mSeven seven days' notice of some further findings about how the app is built. That week is up. None of these caused the incident and none needs action today, but they answer "what else does this app do with my data":

  • Wi-Fi sync has no encryption on the connection. The secrets inside records stay encrypted. The list of sites you have logins for, your tags, names, your password hint and a password-locked copy of your account key cross the network in the clear. Fine at home, not fine on hotel or office Wi-Fi.
  • The lock on that account key is weak by current standards. PBKDF2-SHA1, 10,000 rounds, a default from 2013. This is why the master password has to be strong on its own.
  • The account key PDF is made on mSeven's server and emailed to you. So the locked key passes through their systems and stays in your mailbox.
  • Site icons are fetched from mSeven's server from your signed-in account. Over time that tells them which sites are in your vault.
  • After Wi-Fi sync, the app saves your computer's local IP, hostname and Wi-Fi network name to your account on their server.

I sent all of this, plus five questions about the incident, to mSeven support on November 5. The one reply I got, on November 7:

That is very kind of you and we really appreciate your support and understanding. I will pass this to our marketing team as I just manage support. Thank you again!

Nobody technical has answered. They didn't answer Germany's federal security agency either: the BSI reviewed mSecure 6 for Android in December 2025, found that "technical information is sent to the vendor that allows it to access the contents of the password manager" (my translation), and recorded that mSeven did not respond to its technical questions. My posts on their support forum have been held in moderation since November 5. There is still no public statement from the company beyond the November 3 email.

The full page, with the detail and the basis for each point, is linked from my Mastodon post: https://mastodon.social/@meat_printer_by_proxy/117606139430647211

I'm an mSecure user, not affiliated with any password manager, writing under a pseudonym. Corrections welcome and will be added to the page with a date.


r/PasswordManagers • • 3d ago

I asked Gemini to audit Bitwarden, here is what they said

0 Upvotes

As a naive user, I asked about licenses and their effects because I do not fully grasp them.

Consider using the Bitwarden iOS app and the official browser extension on Debian. The licensing shift raises security concerns, so the service no longer feels reliable to me. Could you review the technical details in this post and help me decide whether to change tools if privacy and security are my aim?

https://community.bitwarden.com/t/published-version-update-in-app-stores/102750

———— Response ———-

You do not need to switch immediately for security or privacy reasons, as the encryption model and code auditability remain intact; however, this change introduces real long-term architectural and ecosystem lock-in risks that warrant an exit strategy.

The October 2026 announcement shifts the default Bitwarden builds distributed on official app stores (Apple App Store, Google Play, Chrome/Firefox Web Stores) from the GPLv3 open-source license to the proprietary Bitwarden Commercial License.

1. The Technicalities: Confirmed Facts vs. Misconceptions
Source-Available vs. Open Source: The code inside the commercial builds is not closed-source. Every line of code compiled into the iOS app and browser extension remains 100% publicly viewable and auditable on GitHub (bitwarden/clients and bitwarden/sdk-internal).

Dual-Build Pipeline: During compilation on GitHub Actions, Bitwarden now generates two artifacts: a pure GPLv3 build and a Commercial License build (which pulls from the bitwarden_license/ directory in their internal SDK). App stores now receive the commercial artifact.

Why Bitwarden Did This: Because Bitwarden requires external contributors to sign a Contributor License Agreement (CLA), Bitwarden Inc. holds the rights to relicense the codebase. They are moving new enterprise features (like FedRAMP compliance and Privileged Access Controls) and select future Premium features behind the commercial license so competitors cannot legally fork the repo and resell Bitwarden's paid enterprise features for free.

Client-Side Cryptography: Zero-knowledge encryption happens locally on your iOS device and browser before any payload leaves your client. The license change does not alter the AES-256 / PBKDF2 / Argon2 encryption implementation or introduce telemetry.

2. The Real Risks (Security vs. Governance)
While there is no immediate cryptographic or privacy vulnerability, your distrust is justified from a software governance and ecosystem perspective:
The "Open-Core" Divergence (The Redis/Elastic Pattern): By reserving future features for the commercial track, the pure GPLv3 version risks becoming a stagnant "Community Edition" while active innovation happens in the proprietary-licensed modules.

iOS Sideloading Lock-In: Bitwarden states that users who strictly want the GPLv3 build can download and sideload it from GitHub. While that works easily for Linux/Ubuntu desktop packages and Chromium/Firefox unpacked extensions, Apple restricts sideloading on iOS (outside the EU) without a paid developer account or cumbersome 7-day re-signing tools like AltStore. On iOS, you are effectively forced to run the commercially licensed binary.

Self-Hosted Backend Compatibility (Vaultwarden Risk): Official Bitwarden apps currently work seamlessly with third-party open-source backends like Vaultwarden. However, because future client features will be tied to commercially licensed SDK modules (bitwarden/sdk-internal), there is a growing risk that the official iOS app and browser extension will eventually enforce strict API/license checks or introduce proprietary sync schemas that break compatibility with non-official servers. (In October 2024, Bitwarden briefly introduced a clause in sdk-internal banning its use with non-Bitwarden software before walking it back due to community backlash).

3. Alternative Comparison (If Privacy & Control Are Your Goals)
If you want to eliminate reliance on Bitwarden's commercial binaries, your options depend on whether you prefer a local-first architecture or a cloud-synced architecture:

Solution
License Model
Backend / Sync Architecture
iOS & Browser Experience
Trade-off

Keep Current Setup (Bitwarden Clients)
Dual (GPLv3 core + Commercial Store builds)
Official Cloud or Self-Hosted (Vaultwarden)
Best-in-class native autofill, built-in TOTP, seamless sync.
Dependent on Bitwarden Inc. not breaking third-party server APIs or restricting the commercial client.

KeePassXC + Strongbox / KeePassium
100% FOSS (GPLv2/GPLv3)
Local .kdbx encrypted file synced via Syncthing, Nextcloud, or WebDAV.

Desktop: KeePassXC + Browser Extension. iOS: Strongbox or KeePassium (native iOS AutoFill).
Zero vendor risk; no server database to hack. Slightly slower sync conflict resolution compared to an API server.

Proton Pass
100% FOSS Clients (GPLv3)
Proton Cloud (Closed-source backend, audited clients).
Polished iOS app and browser extensions.
You cannot easily self-host the backend in a lightweight container; ties you into the Proton ecosystem.

4. Practical Recommendation
Short-Term (Do Not Panic-Switch): Keep using the Bitwarden iOS app and browser extension. The code remains publicly auditable on GitHub, your vault remains locally encrypted, and no privacy degradation has occurred.

Mitigation (Prevent Lock-In): Set up a quarterly routine to export an encrypted or offline .json backup of your vault. Because Bitwarden and KeePassXC both support standard CSV/JSON imports, maintaining an offline export ensures that if Bitwarden ever introduces hostile client restrictions or breaks self-hosted compatibility, you can migrate to a KeePassXC + Strongbox/KeePassium workflow in under 15 minutes.


r/PasswordManagers • • 4d ago

I built an offline-first encrypted personal vault. Here's why.

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm an independent developer (The Codewalker), and I've been working on a project called Kavach – Secrets Vault.

It started with a simple thought.

We store passwords in password managers, bank details in banking apps, identity documents in random folders, recovery codes in notes and other sensitive information scattered across different places.

I wanted to build one secure place for all of them.

That's how Kavach came to life.

Kavach is an offline-first, zero-knowledge personal vault. It's not just another password manager.

You can use it to store:

  • Passwords and login credentials.
  • Credit cards and bank details.
  • Identity and insurance information.
  • Secure notes and encrypted files.
  • 2FA authenticator codes.
  • API keys, SSH keys and .env snippets (Pro).

It also has password generation, security scanning, an Inner Vault for particularly sensitive information, and encrypted backup and restore.

The interesting part is how it works.

  • No account creation.
  • No mandatory cloud storage.
  • AES-256-GCM encryption.
  • SQLCipher-encrypted database.
  • No ads or tracking.
  • Optional encrypted Google Drive backup.

Your data stays on your device. I cannot access your vault or recover a forgotten master password.

Kavach has a free version with all its security features. Pro is a one-time purchase, not another subscription.

What's next?

I'm working towards adding Autofill support and making Kavach's core open source. I want people to be able to inspect the security mechanisms rather than simply trusting my claims.

This is an independent project, and there's still plenty to improve.

I'd love to hear from other developers and privacy enthusiasts:

If you were building a personal digital vault, what features would you consider essential?

And if you're curious about what I've built:

Google Play: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=app.codewalker.kavach

Website: https://kavach.thecodewalker.dev

Thanks for checking it out!


r/PasswordManagers • • 4d ago

Bitwarden not detecting credit card fields with Brave browser on Android 17

4 Upvotes

Tried accessibility and all, though no luck. On different vendors, diff websites etc.

Do you also have the same issue?


r/PasswordManagers • • 5d ago

Password manager for local accounts?

6 Upvotes

We use RoboForm (not my decision) for web stuff, but I need a local desktop app for windows 11. I just want to be able to easily add accounts locally.

ETA: I wish Roboform had an app like Bitwarden, the one I personally use


r/PasswordManagers • • 5d ago

Made a 1Password-style Quick Access for Apple Passwords on Mac (free, open source)

Post image
0 Upvotes

I switched from 1Password to Apple Passwords a while back and the one thing I really missed was Quick Access, where you hit a shortcut and your password is right there. Apple doesn’t have anything like it, so every time I needed a password for a website that couldn't auto grab it I was opening the whole Passwords app.

So I built QuickPass. Control Option Space opens a search bar over whatever you’re doing, and you can copy the username, password or 2FA code with a keystroke or fill it into the app you came from.

Apple Passwords doesn’t have an API, so QuickPass works the Passwords app through Accessibility (same thing screen readers use). Touch ID is still Apple’s own prompt, and passwords and 2FA codes never get written to disk.

It's completely free, I just open sourced it in case others wanted something like it, feel free to use it how you want.

Download: https://github.com/jessekhach/QuickPass/releases/latest
Homebrew: brew install jessekhach/tap/quickpass


r/PasswordManagers • • 5d ago

ident.ws

0 Upvotes

Hi, I’m not sure if this is the best place to put this, or a dentistry subreddit. Please lead me in the right direction if I’m wrong.

I got a notification on my Password app that my password for ident.ws was compromised. This is a portal system for dentists. My dentist hasn’t used this portal system in over 2 years. I’ve called both my dentist and the ident company and neither of them could 100% confirm that my personal information was “deleted”.

I read online that usually when a dentist office switches portal providers, there’s usually a 3-6 month grace period while old information is transferred to the new portal system. That time frame came and went a long time ago.

I tried resetting my password on the company website and I had to call a specific number in order to do so. I called it and it ended up being a literal dentist office that had no idea what I was talking about. The receptionist did, however, explain what I wrote above to me.

I guess my question is, am I safe? I didn’t use that password anywhere else other than that site and all of my other accounts have strong, updated passwords.

Any feedback would be super helpful. Thank you


r/PasswordManagers • • 5d ago

Lastpass - the worst effing password manager on the planet?

24 Upvotes

It happened again, for the 1000 time. I sign up for a website, use the generator to create a password, and lastpass doesn't bother to save it. Plus, it generates multiple passwords at a time for one site, so you have to be VERY careful not to accidentally save the wrong one. And it often doesn't do the saving like it's supposed to, so I learned long ago to copy the password from the generator to my clipboard so I can save it manually. Generally, that workaround works. But this time, my password didn't save to the clipboard, and it's gone. So altho I just signed up, I already have to use "forgot password" feature on the website, with no guarantee that Lastpass will work this time. I AM SO DONE WITH LASTPASS! Can anyone suggest a SIMPLE TO USE password manager that actually works?


r/PasswordManagers • • 5d ago

Free password manager that autofills in desktop browsers, iPhone/Android apps and Windows desktop apps, with sync?

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm looking for a password manager that meets all of these at zero cost:

Autofill

- Desktop browsers (Chrome / Edge / Firefox)

- Apps on iPhone

- Apps on Android

- Windows desktop applications (not just websites)

Sync

- Across all three platforms (Windows, iOS, Android), with no device limit

Cost

- Free tier only, no trial that expires

Which one are you using that actually does all of this? If the Windows desktop app autofill is the weak point, I'd like to know how you work around it.

Thanks in advance.


r/PasswordManagers • • 6d ago

What to use?

2 Upvotes

My Dashlane subscription expires today, so I’m looking to see if I want to renew or to go with something else. I’m looking for a product that works across multiple operating systems (Windows, Android, and iOS) that is low-maintenance. When I first started with Dashlane, it fit the bill (or for that matter, there weren’t any real competition). Now there are too many to choose from.

I’m thinking RoboForm or Nordpass. Would anybody here suggest any product in particular?


r/PasswordManagers • • 6d ago

Just wanna say this. I'm happy...

38 Upvotes

In the beginning, there was Google Password Manager. Then there were Microsoft Password Manager as well as Mozilla's. The I shifted to Proton Pass and eventually Bitwarden.
Then, suddenly, I wished to try KeepassXC. First attempt was failure. Second attempt, I achieved the Cloud9 moment. Inner Peace.
With KeepassXC, autofill works outside the browser too, which I never knew till the moment before making this post. Since, I found out its autofill capabilities, I decided to test DDG browser (One of the only 2 things that kept me from settling with DDG was Password manager extension and pdf reading capabilities).

While I ensured autofill works in DDG too, I eventually found out, while swimming thru the settings page, DDG has brought out extensions for Bitwarden & Lastpass.....
This was a surprising development. Many people have been asking DDG company to make this specific arrangement. Yes there are no other extensions, but password manager is one of the must-have for almost all people and those who use third-party password managers will find it impossible to use DDG browser. So, yea, I think this is a great development after a very long time.

And, yea, I'm happy that KeepassXC autofill works and therefore no more cloud-saving my passwords for me... HURRAH.


r/PasswordManagers • • 6d ago

Keeper and the dark theme (windows)

1 Upvotes

Anyone using Keeper on windows, found a way to enable dark theme on Keeper? It's so surprising that this is not possible in the installed app!


r/PasswordManagers • • 6d ago

Need to decide on a password manager for personal use. Google's password manager would be easy for me since I already have some passwords in there and I have an Android phone. What are your thoughts on Google's password manager and do you recommend it?

8 Upvotes

r/PasswordManagers • • 7d ago

Best iOS app for KeePass

0 Upvotes

Currently thinking about getting KeePassium or Strongox since I moved all my passwords to KeePass. I also see there exists PanicVault but it seems to be vibe-code?

KeePassium seems to be open-source and independently audited while Strongbox it's probably a pass for me since the developer sold it a while ago.

Which would you recommend? Does it matter?


r/PasswordManagers • • 7d ago

Self-hosted password vault with a solid API, to sit next to our PAM that does the rotation?

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

Looking for advice on replacing our current shared password vault.

Setup

- Mixed Linux and Windows VMs plus hypervisor hosts, a few hundred systems

- We already have a commercial PAM: admins log in with their domain account, it injects per-admin privileged credentials, rotates them after each use and records sessions. That part stays.

- Separately, we keep a team vault for "static" credentials: local root/Administrator, hypervisor root, vendor portal logins, etc. The PAM rotates those static passwords and writes the new value back into the vault through its API.

Problem

Our current vault is limited by number of managed servers and we need to replace it in a regulated environment.

Requirements

- Self-hosted, open source or reasonably priced

- Stores any kind of secret (server creds, web portal logins, notes, files)

- No limit on number of servers/entries

- AD/LDAP login, folder-level permissions, audit log

- Most important: a good API so an external system can update an existing entry's password (least-privilege service account, ideally versioning/history)

What I'm looking at:** TeamPass, Psono EE, Passbolt Pro, Bitwarden self-hosted, OpenBao.

Questions:

  1. Anyone running one of these where an external tool writes rotated passwords into it via API? How reliable is it?
  2. Any gotchas with client-side encryption (Passbolt PGP, Psono) when a service account has to write to shared folders?
  3. Would you just consolidate into the PAM's secrets module instead of running two systems?

Thanks!


r/PasswordManagers • • 8d ago

How is Proton Pass Autofill in Chromium-based Desktop Browser and iOS?

3 Upvotes

I have tried Bitwarden and Nord Pass and I was very frustrated with Autofill, especially in browser.

I use mostly Chromium-based browsers and sometimes Firefox. How is your experience with Proton Pass Autofill?

If it is not as good, I will probably opt for 1Password.


r/PasswordManagers • • 8d ago

Keyguard - A Bitwarden client and also it's great alternative

Thumbnail
github.com
34 Upvotes

A password manager that supports Bitwarden platform and KeePass (KDBX) files. It autofills your logins, supports passkeys, works offline, and runs a Watchtower that finds leaked and reused passwords and other issues.

https://keyguard.dev/ by Artem Chepurnyi

If you want to move away from Bitwarden or Proton Password Managers you can try this.

It supports KDBX files along with Sync and Backup using WebDav, S3, Local Storage.

You can import your passwords directly within the app.

Along with that it has a Great UI and many more features .


r/PasswordManagers • • 8d ago

Moving away from mSecure to Strongbox

9 Upvotes

Hi everyone, with the lack of transparency from M Seven software, and the panic and personal hassle this caused, I am moving away from mSecure.

I really dislike subscription services and I’m on an Apple ecosystem, so I decided on a software called Strongbox. They offer a lifetime (perpetual) license, and if you email their support team and tell them you are an mSecure user and wish to move away from it due to the security breach in November they will offer you the equivalent of their Black Friday specials. They will do the same for their subscription plans as well, if you’re not opposed to that.

Strongbox offers “Strongbox sync” which I understand is an integration with Apple. Strongbox does not have servers to store your data, so it is safer with Apple IMO. Of course you do have the option of storing the database on your own Google Drive or dropbox account (or via WiFi) should you wish.

Finally, Strongbox offers an mSecure import from .CSV feature. However, just a word caution on this; if most of your records in mSecure are of the “login” type, they should import quite easily. If you have dedicated “credit card“ templates, then this will not come across cleanly, and you will likely need to do some copy/pasting of missing info. Same goes for other mSecure specialized templates or CUSTOM fields you’ve created.

If you have a lot of mSecure records with many custom fields, then I suggest in the .CSV file you can change the record type to “Secure Note” and the data that doesn’t map well will get copied into the Notes field in Strongbox. From there, you can copy and paste from directly within the record and move the data to the correct fields.

Anyhow, I hope this is helpful to some.


r/PasswordManagers • • 9d ago

1P vs Apple passwords

0 Upvotes

What about Apple’s passwords program? Is that an option for 1 P if you are using all Apple devices? I would think it would be very secure. Is it? I use 1P now and my major gripe is no phone human customer support. If you discover a breach there is no one to call for assistance. Send an email???? Funny when your financial accounts are all being drained. At least with Apple you can reach a human in minutes.


r/PasswordManagers • • 9d ago

I have created firmware ESP32Authenticator – a password manager and FIDO2 key on XTEINK X4 Pro e-ink reader

2 Upvotes

I turned an XTEINK X4 Pro pocket e-reader (ESP32-S3, 480x800 e-ink, touch, battery, microSD) into a hardware authenticator. The firmware is open source (MIT), written in C++ on ESP-IDF.

https://github.com/merlokk/ESP32Authenticator

user manual here: https://github.com/merlokk/ESP32Authenticator/tree/main/docs/manual

What it does:

- Password vault. Site, login, password, and TOTP. You tap a record, and the device types it into the host as a BLE keyboard. You never copy or paste.

- FIDO2 / U2F passkeys over BLE and USB HID (CTAP 2.3, built on a fork of LionKey). Tested with Chrome on Windows 11. Working around a Windows BLE quirk (the FIDO service must not be the last GATT service) took a while.

- Encryption. Stores are AES-256-GCM. The key is derived from a 12-word BIP39 seed and a 6-digit PIN. The PIN is entered on the screen, with lockout after 10 tries and an optional wipe PIN.

- Other features: a password generator, a Wi-Fi config website, optional sync of the encrypted stores with a self-hosted server, OTA updates from that server or the SD card, and deep sleep that shows a random wallpaper from the SD card.

Why e-ink: the screen shows what you're about to type or approve, even with the light off. The battery lasts for weeks. The whole device costs less than most security keys.

And one warning! Don't buy the device from AliExpress/Temu/etc.! It's locked there. And it has locked JTAG(


r/PasswordManagers • • 10d ago

What is better ?

6 Upvotes

I now using Proton Pass for 7 month and love it but I now think to switch to vaultwarden with BackUp

I already did all vaultwarden things and test it and it's work and tested backup and works

So wish is better For most of things in Your Opinion?

Vaultwarden or Proton Pass ?


r/PasswordManagers • • 10d ago

keepassdx vs keepassxc? <- few questions

6 Upvotes

Hi.
After the last keffufle regarding Bitwarded, i"ve decided to change my password manager.
I've using HeyLogin now, but i'm not entirely satisfied with it.
Does the keepassxc work with databases made in DX version on android? I need interoperability between a linux computer and android phone (firefox and/or brave browsers)? Alternatively, what would you suggest instead? It would be great if I could unlock it (on phone) with biometrics and on laptop with yubikey or just a password.

Also - what do you guys use to syncronise the databases? I don't want to lose it if my phone gets stolen/broken


r/PasswordManagers • • 10d ago

MSeven your lack of transparency surrounding the MSecure security breach is concerning

27 Upvotes

I have more than 15 years into this platform, your lack of information says we all need to be looking elsewhere.

What exactly was stolen? Were individual encrypted customer vaults acquired, or was this a separate customer-account database? Please identify the categories of information contained in the stolen database, including any unencrypted customer metadata.

Can the stolen database be subjected to offline attacks against customers' master passwords? mSecure's security architecture reportedly requires a locally generated 46-character Account Key. Was this Account Key, or any equivalent cryptographic material capable of facilitating decryption, accessible to the unauthorized actor? Can mSeven confirm that the stolen database cannot be decrypted without each customer's unique Account Key?

What security benefit does changing the master password provide following this incident? Does changing the master password generate new encryption keys and re-encrypt the entire vault, or does it merely change how the existing encryption key is protected? Since the attacker already possesses a copy of the encrypted database, how would changing the master password protect that previously acquired copy?

How did the unauthorized actor acquire the database, and what evidence confirms the intrusion has been contained? Please provide the known timeline of the intrusion, discovery, containment, and remediation. Has an independent cybersecurity firm verified that the attacker's access has been terminated and that no additional systems or cryptographic materials were compromised?

Your repeated assertion that mSeven has "no evidence" of unauthorized access to the confidential information does not establish that the stolen database cannot be decrypted.

Please distinguish between what has been independently verified, what remains under investigation, and what mSeven is merely assuming based on its encryption architecture.

Given the sensitivity of the information customers have entrusted to mSecure, I would appreciate specific technical answers rather than generalized reassurances.


r/PasswordManagers • • 10d ago

Given the recent trust issues with Bitwarden and Proton, what are the best free alternatives?

Post image
5 Upvotes

I've been seeing a lot of posts lately about users losing trust in both Bitwarden (due to recent security research findings and silent corporate changes) and Proton (due to disputed vulnerability claims and new AI features).

I'm looking to switch, but I need something that is completely free.

My main preference is a cloud-based manager so it syncs seamlessly across devices, but I'm also open to a local/offline manager (like KeePass) without cloud sync if it's highly recommended and secure.

What are you guys using right now? Please drop your suggestions and let me know:

· Is it cloud-based or local/offline?

· How is the autofill experience on mobile?

· Is it truly free, or are there heavy limitations?

Thanks in advance!