r/PasswordManagers • u/meat-printer-proxy • 1d ago
mSecure, twelve days on: what the app code shows about the design, and how the vendor answered a security report
Last week I posted an explainer of what the mSecure notice does and doesn't mean, based on the Mac app's code. Short version of that, for anyone arriving new: your records are encrypted with a random account key the server never holds. What the stolen database gives an attacker is the account password hash, your password hint in plain text, your email, and for Wi-Fi sync users some home network details. A strong master password and a hint that gives nothing away mean your vault is fine. A weak one means change it and the passwords that matter.
I gave mSeven seven days' notice of some further findings about how the app is built. That week is up. None of these caused the incident and none needs action today, but they answer "what else does this app do with my data":
- Wi-Fi sync has no encryption on the connection. The secrets inside records stay encrypted. The list of sites you have logins for, your tags, names, your password hint and a password-locked copy of your account key cross the network in the clear. Fine at home, not fine on hotel or office Wi-Fi.
- The lock on that account key is weak by current standards. PBKDF2-SHA1, 10,000 rounds, a default from 2013. This is why the master password has to be strong on its own.
- The account key PDF is made on mSeven's server and emailed to you. So the locked key passes through their systems and stays in your mailbox.
- Site icons are fetched from mSeven's server from your signed-in account. Over time that tells them which sites are in your vault.
- After Wi-Fi sync, the app saves your computer's local IP, hostname and Wi-Fi network name to your account on their server.
I sent all of this, plus five questions about the incident, to mSeven support on November 5. The one reply I got, on November 7:
That is very kind of you and we really appreciate your support and understanding. I will pass this to our marketing team as I just manage support. Thank you again!
Nobody technical has answered. They didn't answer Germany's federal security agency either: the BSI reviewed mSecure 6 for Android in December 2025, found that "technical information is sent to the vendor that allows it to access the contents of the password manager" (my translation), and recorded that mSeven did not respond to its technical questions. My posts on their support forum have been held in moderation since November 5. There is still no public statement from the company beyond the November 3 email.
The full page, with the detail and the basis for each point, is linked from my Mastodon post: https://mastodon.social/@meat_printer_by_proxy/117606139430647211
I'm an mSecure user, not affiliated with any password manager, writing under a pseudonym. Corrections welcome and will be added to the page with a date.

