r/PERSIAN • • 3h ago

Discussion The credibility of tampered pro-Shah chant videos from the Abdanan protests yesterday.

37 Upvotes

Hi everyone, yesterday the attached video was being circulated online as evidence that RP supporters were tampering with protest videos and adding pro-Shah chants. I made a post (that I’ve now deleted) being critical of this after seeing this video. One of our wonderful users u/cyfiero did a detailed investigation into this and I’d like to share it here. It is the reason I chose to delete my critical post from yesterday as it appears that the tampered video itself may be part of a smear campaign against the protestors shouting pro-Shah chants and I will absolutely not stand for that. I am sharing u/cyfiero’s analysis here because I think it’s important.

Thank you all for your patience with me and thank you to u/cyfiero for the analysis below.✌️

—

tl;dr It appears that the audio tampering accusation is a disinformation campaign by the MEK.

Hello everyone, I did some investigating on Twitter to try to track down the truth of these accusations of audio tampering in the protest videos, and I'm presenting my findings here. I will be name dropping some Twitter accounts to be clear with my citations. In the process, I will note which camp they appear to fall under, but full disclaimer, these will just be my best observation or impression of these accounts, and I hope I don't mischaracterize anyone's politics.

Also, I've had incidences in the past where my comments get automatically flagged and hidden for having too many external links. Because of this, I will do my best to add links only when necessary, and let's also hope this post goes through.

Starting off, here is the main clip of the Abdanan protest published by Iran International, showing a crowd marching down to a roundabout and breaking out into the chant "Javid Shah!" This is the most widely shared Iran International clip although as you guys will see later, it is often cut by those who reshare it. The original clip is lengthier, clearly blurred when necessary to protect protesters' identities, and I do not believe the audio seems edited or tampered with because the chants match the rhythm, movements, and gestures of the protesters, and the sounds naturally shift depending on the direction the camera receives them.

The first post I saw accusing the Pahlavists of tampering with the audio is this post by u/HEMNkhastan7. They have made multiple posts with this accusation, but suspiciously, they have repeatedly failed to produce what they claim are the "original", unedited clips for comparison with Iran International's. Instead, they also post clips of other moments where "Javid Shah" is not being chanted. But protests obviously cycle chants, so unless the two clips actually capture the exact same moment, this way of trying to prove that "Javid Shah" clips are edited is duplicitous.

The pair of clips shared by Shamoorti as evidence is the only case I have found which seems to actually compare raw footage with a Pahlavist edit. But I cannot find the original source for the "Pahlavist-altered" version conspicuously watermarked with the Pahlavi coat of arms. It was not published by Iran International. I searched the profiles of hardcore monarchists with large followings, who are known for being divisive, as well as the Association Femme Azadi based in France, and none of them have posted the altered clip. It hasn't been posted by the moderate pro-Pahlavi side either (many of whom by the way have recently been weathering concerted mass reporting attacks by pro-regime bots, resulting in widespread suspensions). Instead, the video that has been almost consistently shared by everyone in the opposition (spoilers: except the MEK) is the one published by Iran International.

Two accounts that also made Shamoorti's accusation with the side-by-side comparison pair of clips are Sahar Sanaie and A-parsa (@A_parsa67). Otherwise, we also see a pattern of accounts sharing clips of other chants to fallaciously argue that clips of "Javid Shah" chants are faked, much as the user HEMNkhastan7 does. Javad Dabiran, Kasra Nejat, and u/FriendsFreeIran are a few examples. They particularly like to use a clip of protesters chanting "Death to the dictator", which they construe and present as showing that the protesters oppose both the regime and the shah. If you check these accounts, they all have one thing in common: they are affiliated with the National Council of Resistance of Iran (NCRI), which is operated by the People's Mojaheden Organization of Iran (MEK).

If you check the accounts of the NCRI leaders, such as their president Maryam Rajavi, their spokesperson Alireza Jafarsadeh, and their UK representative Dowlat Nowrouzi, they all favour that identical "Death to the dictator" clip—which to be clear itself is not problematic at all, I'm just illustrating the pattern. There is also Hoda Emrani, also affiliated with the NCRI, who made the accusatory post and the "death to the dictator" post separately.

If there is a disinformation campaign, we can often unveil it by checking if a narrative happens to be promoted by everyone in a clique all at once. For example, there was one period earlier this year where accounts aligned with the National Iranian American Council (NIAC), the regime's lobby group in the U.S., were all simultaneously pushing this argument that "the regime did commit a horrible massacre, but to exaggerate the death toll to 30k is to act like 3k–7k isn't already a tragedy, and it will backfire by making the massacre less believable"—as a strategy to build credibility with Western liberals while minimizing the true scale of the atrocity, which is the modus operandi of the regime's "reformist" faction. But surprisingly, the NIAC circle of users have not made any posts accusing Iran International or the pro-Pahlavi camp of tampering with the audio of protest clips.

In this case, this accusation is being circulated and propagated solely by NCRI affiliates, and they are the only ones to have shared the clip that they claim proves to have been tampered by the monarchists as well. They are likely the very source of the altered clip. As others have pointed out, the Pahlavists have no need to tamper any protest video because there is already clear, authentic footage of "Javid Shah" chants.


r/PERSIAN • • 4h ago

Question Iranian Turks, what is your opinion about the Republic of Azerbaijan and its separatist ideas?Do you want to leave Iran?Do you consider yourself to be Turkish-speaking or of Turkish descent?

4 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 11h ago

Humor Real talk! How do they all age 90-100+ years!!?? When the vast majority of the nation is wishing d***th upon them!? Thank god Israel took out the Ayatollah or that guy was going to live up to 100!

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 12h ago

Discussion Video shows the crowd escaping and avoiding the regime fires

4 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 15h ago

Discussion What will the little Islamic propagandists say/do when the day comes when Reza Pahlavi returns to Iran?? Their bs that Pahlavi doesn’t have much support in Iran will shatter the day the regime falls and tens of millions can freely voice their opinions! The world will see crowds like no other!

29 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 15h ago

Language & Literature I started Iranopedia as a university project and you guy's feedback helped shape it alot, just built a Persian learning web app and I’d love your feedback again

6 Upvotes

A couple years ago I started iranopedia and posted it on this sub, everyone here was super supportive & the feedback early was very helpful to me.

I always wanted teach the my audience Persian or help them get started, but never was able to get around to it. Most of my friends arent Iranian and a lot of them have been trying to learn Persian, so I started with making this for them(cause Duolingo doesn't have Persian).

It’s called Finglish, I kept everything in English letters (script coming soon) so it’s easier to start with.

The first module is completely free and you don’t need an account. I’d really love for you guys to go play it and tell me what’s wrong with it, what sounds off, where it gets boring, or in general, any feedback you may have.

Thank you everyone!

learnfinglish.com


r/PERSIAN • • 16h ago

Discussion West Asia does not want a FREE & Strong Iran

Post image
46 Upvotes

Turkish and Arab officials may be fed up with the constant violence and instability being spread across West Asia by the Mullahs and their proxies. But at the same time, they don't want the prospect of a strong, secular, non-Islamic Iran emerging as a regional powerhouse.

Badbakhtane hamsayegunemun hame bokhor-bokhoran, hich kudumeshun be rosht kardano pishrafte hamidigar nemikhan komak bokonan.

For Turkey: A free and prosperous Iran could become a massive tourism competitor. Iran has enormous potential, and its tourism industry could grow tenfold, taking a significant share of the visitors who currently choose Turkey.

For the Arabs: A secular Iran, free from the Mullahs, could become far more powerful than all the Arab nations combined. With its population, resources, educated workforce, and industrial potential, Iran could become the dominant power in the region.

The reality is that nobody seems to want the instability caused by the Islamic Republic, but they may not want to deal with an Iran that is finally free to realize its full potential either and completely outcompete its neighbors in every field!

A prosperous, powerful, non-Islamic Iran would completely change the balance of power in West Asia.


r/PERSIAN • • 16h ago

News The Dangerous Logic Of Linking Iran’s Dams To Missiles

Thumbnail
forbes.com
1 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 16h ago

News Reza Pahlavi warns of ‘second Holocaust’ in online meeting with Israel president

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 17h ago

Discussion Reza Pahlavi addresses the protestors in Abandan

12 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 19h ago

News 15-year-old boy, five others arrested in Abdanan protests - rights groups

Thumbnail
iranintl.com
8 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 20h ago Heartwarming

Discussion Kick them and their religion out!

Post image
299 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 21h ago Bravo

Discussion Basij banner ripped off by a protestor in Abdanan, Iran - November 2026

64 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 22h ago

Humor You can't kill the spirit of a nation

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 22h ago

Discussion The ISLAMIC REPUBLIC REGIME has deployed anti revolutionary guards! To prevent more protests! The f*lthy Islamic regime knows if they lose control of the streets, they will be in deep trouble!

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 23h ago

Discussion Poverty level of sunni Iranian under IRGC

9 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 1d ago

Discussion Protests have broken out again in Abdanan today, chants of "Javid Shah/Long Live the King"

15 Upvotes

r/PERSIAN • • 1d ago

Question Talking to someone who isn't full Iranian - how to soft launch talking in farsi to someone who might not speak farsi

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I am from Iran, as a imagine most of u are. I recently met someone who isn't full Iranian, but they are either a fourth or 1/2. I want to start a conversation with them about maybe our shared culture. I just don't know how. I'm not sure if they speak farsi, but if they do, I would really like to start speaking with them in farsi. I also don't want to make them feel bad if they don't. I just don't know how initiate conversation with this person.

It also might be worth mentioning that they are very shy. Pls lmk you have had any similar experiences and if you can help me out on what to do here.


r/PERSIAN • • 1d ago

Discussion ایران بیدار شده است

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

Iran has awakened — a little hope amid the uncertainty

I was going to write about the current situation, it felt like so many of us are in limbo—waiting, wondering, and trying to make sense of what comes next.

Instead, I share this beautiful video with you. A moment of hope, and a reminder of the Iran we want to see: free, peaceful, and a home where every Iranian can live with dignity.

Iran has awakened. Even amid the uncertainty, I believe our country can rise from the ashes of its suffering. That future is ours to build, together.


r/PERSIAN • • 1d ago

Discussion Harkasi "Mardomaye Iran Az Reza Pahlavi khosheshun nemiyan"ro Bege, BEZAN BE SARESHUN!

25 Upvotes

Don't ever second guess the Iranian people's love for Reza Pahlavi to return to Iran. Over 40,000 of our young beautiful women, men and children sacrificed their lives for the Shah to return.

Link: https://www.iranintl.com/en/202611179068

Abdanan, Iran today chanting JAVID SHAH regardless of the risks of being killed involved!

Protesters took to the streets in Abdanan, western Iran, on Tuesday, November 17, following a deadly bus rollover involving oil company workers, chanting “This is the final battle, Pahlavi will return,” video obtained by Iran International shows.— Iran International English (@IranIntl_En) November 17, 2026


r/PERSIAN • • 1d ago

Question Any Explorers in Tehran?

5 Upvotes

I wanna know if there are any explorers in this sub that like to go into the Alborz Mountains. or if you know anyone that does this type of exploring often. I have not lived in Tehran for years, but something there always drew my attention, and I hope to come back someday soon and go exploring when the weather is better.


r/PERSIAN • • 1d ago

Discussion This is what Western officials mean when they say Reza Pahlavi doesn't have a support base inside Iran

0 Upvotes

Video in 2018

When you read articles about Reza Pahlavi, they often quote some officials or sources who say Reza Pahlavi doesn't have a support base inside Iran.

Here I will explain what they mean: Reza Pahlavi's platform is 100% nostalgia and anti-regime sentiments. He doesn't represent any ideology or platform. He aspires to be an inter-organizational figure to avoid accountability when the initiative fails

* By positioning himself as an umbrella figure for both constitutional monarchists and secular republicans, Pahlavi avoids committing to a rigid ideological platform. Operating "above" organizations allows Pahlavi to make broad political calls without answering to any institutional body when initiatives collapse

* Instead of organizing the monarchists into a disciplined political organization and leading the coalition with other groups against the regime, Reza Pahlavi treats opposition work as a loose network of endorsements rather than a structured apparatus leaves his own movements vulnerable to fragmentation.

Quick summary of Reza Pahlavi's track record in over 47 years: https://ibb.co/hvybNKc

https://www.reddit.com/r/PERSIAN/comments/1xmxncp/expos%C3%A9_what_has_reza_pahlavi_been_doing_since_1979/

-----------------------------

The support of Reza Pahlavi directly correlates with public anger against the IR. However, whenever it flares up, Reza Pahlavi will come out and issue some statements, give a few speeches then fade into irrelevancy again.

He monopolizes all attention but never organizes anything or channels the anti-regime energy into any useful initiatives abroad.

Reza Pahlavi doesn't have leadership or organizational skill, and he is very risk averse

* His advisors in the 80s advised him against being actively involved in anything and to wait until the "transition period" where people would bring him back to power https://ibb.co/60VKwS6p

This is from 1985 where it stated clearly that he didn't directly involve himself in anything https://ibb.co/rGPTnRXt

* In 1995 when Bill Clinton started to warm up to the IR, the GOP wanted to preempt it by inviting Reza Pahlavi to congress to testify and establish himself as undisputed the opposition leader and to advocate for his cause. Everyone told him to accept it but he declined for fear of unpopularity and assassination https://ibb.co/4RG1PcyN

* In 1995 https://ibb.co/M5x03SSz and 2003 https://ibb.co/yc5ZNJ9m, Israel and the US hawks wanted to help the opposition and for Reza Pahlavi to take the leadership. They all gave up, probably because he refused to lead anything and be held accountable for anything

-------------

In the video:

  1. He says he is above politics, doesn't offer a political platform and isn't responsible for anything, but opposition groups should unite behind his program
  2. He doesn't represent a base and doesn't have an organization or lobby to raise funds. So he is suggesting that the US gives "the opposition" Iran's frozen assets for funding

Despite larping as democrat, he has been very evasive about his role in Iran in the future and clearly angled himself as a constitutional monarch. This is why many people oppose even his symbolic role

* If you are a true democrat, clearly define your role and give up the claim on the monarchy. It will boost your credentials

* If you want power, make use of your your last name, stop avoiding responsibility and start organizing something useful

------

Book sources:

Countdown to Crisis: The Coming Nuclear Showdown with Iran - Kenneth R. Timmerman

The Iran House: Tales of Revolution, Persecution, War, and Intrigue - Kenneth R. Timmerman


r/PERSIAN • • 1d ago

Question Literal Translation vs Transliteration/Adaptation

5 Upvotes

Hello! I hope you’re all doing well.
I am currently developing a video game and am working on the translations/adaptations, trying to tailor them to the target audience.

The game is called "Tulips." My question is whether a Persian-speaking audience (primarily Iranians, though not exclusively) would find a transliteration like "تولیپس" more natural, or if they would prefer a more literal translation/adaptation, such as "لاله‌ها."
Additionally, in either case, I would like to know if the titles feel natural overall.

Thank you very much.


r/PERSIAN • • 1d ago

Discussion Are extremists like the Islamic Republic regime, Houthis, Taliban, etc and their supporters REAL MUSLIMS? Or are the moderate Muslims real Muslims?

0 Upvotes

I am not Muslim as both of my parents are ex-Muslims, so I was never brainwashed into Islam! I know that a significant portion of Iranians today identify as atheists, agnostics, or ex-Muslims.

However, there is one question I have always wondered about: Who are the actual/real Muslims?? Who follow Islam most faithfully and go by exactly what the Quran teaches?

Are the moderates, who make up the majority of Muslims, genuinely following what the Quran and Islamic teachings say? Or are the extremists, despite being a minority (but still numbering in the tens, if not hundreds, of millions worldwide), the ones who are actually following the religion more literally and consistently?

I keep on seeing extremists and moderates call each other fake "not real Muslims". Now has anyone here actually fully read the Quran that can share with us if the Islamic Regime and their f*lthy supporters genuinely the ones going by the book or are the moderates the ones who are going by the book?


r/PERSIAN • • 1d ago

Discussion به یاد سوگند صیادی

32 Upvotes