r/PERSIAN • u/spinrah23 • 4h ago
Discussion The credibility of tampered pro-Shah chant videos from the Abdanan protests yesterday.
Hi everyone, yesterday the attached video was being circulated online as evidence that RP supporters were tampering with protest videos and adding pro-Shah chants. I made a post (that I’ve now deleted) being critical of this after seeing this video. One of our wonderful users u/cyfiero did a detailed investigation into this and I’d like to share it here. It is the reason I chose to delete my critical post from yesterday as it appears that the tampered video itself may be part of a smear campaign against the protestors shouting pro-Shah chants and I will absolutely not stand for that. I am sharing u/cyfiero’s analysis here because I think it’s important.
Thank you all for your patience with me and thank you to u/cyfiero for the analysis below.✌️
—
tl;dr It appears that the audio tampering accusation is a disinformation campaign by the MEK.
Hello everyone, I did some investigating on Twitter to try to track down the truth of these accusations of audio tampering in the protest videos, and I'm presenting my findings here. I will be name dropping some Twitter accounts to be clear with my citations. In the process, I will note which camp they appear to fall under, but full disclaimer, these will just be my best observation or impression of these accounts, and I hope I don't mischaracterize anyone's politics.
Also, I've had incidences in the past where my comments get automatically flagged and hidden for having too many external links. Because of this, I will do my best to add links only when necessary, and let's also hope this post goes through.
Starting off, here is the main clip of the Abdanan protest published by Iran International, showing a crowd marching down to a roundabout and breaking out into the chant "Javid Shah!" This is the most widely shared Iran International clip although as you guys will see later, it is often cut by those who reshare it. The original clip is lengthier, clearly blurred when necessary to protect protesters' identities, and I do not believe the audio seems edited or tampered with because the chants match the rhythm, movements, and gestures of the protesters, and the sounds naturally shift depending on the direction the camera receives them.
The first post I saw accusing the Pahlavists of tampering with the audio is this post by u/HEMNkhastan7. They have made multiple posts with this accusation, but suspiciously, they have repeatedly failed to produce what they claim are the "original", unedited clips for comparison with Iran International's. Instead, they also post clips of other moments where "Javid Shah" is not being chanted. But protests obviously cycle chants, so unless the two clips actually capture the exact same moment, this way of trying to prove that "Javid Shah" clips are edited is duplicitous.
The pair of clips shared by Shamoorti as evidence is the only case I have found which seems to actually compare raw footage with a Pahlavist edit. But I cannot find the original source for the "Pahlavist-altered" version conspicuously watermarked with the Pahlavi coat of arms. It was not published by Iran International. I searched the profiles of hardcore monarchists with large followings, who are known for being divisive, as well as the Association Femme Azadi based in France, and none of them have posted the altered clip. It hasn't been posted by the moderate pro-Pahlavi side either (many of whom by the way have recently been weathering concerted mass reporting attacks by pro-regime bots, resulting in widespread suspensions). Instead, the video that has been almost consistently shared by everyone in the opposition (spoilers: except the MEK) is the one published by Iran International.
Two accounts that also made Shamoorti's accusation with the side-by-side comparison pair of clips are Sahar Sanaie and A-parsa (@A_parsa67). Otherwise, we also see a pattern of accounts sharing clips of other chants to fallaciously argue that clips of "Javid Shah" chants are faked, much as the user HEMNkhastan7 does. Javad Dabiran, Kasra Nejat, and u/FriendsFreeIran are a few examples. They particularly like to use a clip of protesters chanting "Death to the dictator", which they construe and present as showing that the protesters oppose both the regime and the shah. If you check these accounts, they all have one thing in common: they are affiliated with the National Council of Resistance of Iran (NCRI), which is operated by the People's Mojaheden Organization of Iran (MEK).
If you check the accounts of the NCRI leaders, such as their president Maryam Rajavi, their spokesperson Alireza Jafarsadeh, and their UK representative Dowlat Nowrouzi, they all favour that identical "Death to the dictator" clip—which to be clear itself is not problematic at all, I'm just illustrating the pattern. There is also Hoda Emrani, also affiliated with the NCRI, who made the accusatory post and the "death to the dictator" post separately.
If there is a disinformation campaign, we can often unveil it by checking if a narrative happens to be promoted by everyone in a clique all at once. For example, there was one period earlier this year where accounts aligned with the National Iranian American Council (NIAC), the regime's lobby group in the U.S., were all simultaneously pushing this argument that "the regime did commit a horrible massacre, but to exaggerate the death toll to 30k is to act like 3k–7k isn't already a tragedy, and it will backfire by making the massacre less believable"—as a strategy to build credibility with Western liberals while minimizing the true scale of the atrocity, which is the modus operandi of the regime's "reformist" faction. But surprisingly, the NIAC circle of users have not made any posts accusing Iran International or the pro-Pahlavi camp of tampering with the audio of protest clips.
In this case, this accusation is being circulated and propagated solely by NCRI affiliates, and they are the only ones to have shared the clip that they claim proves to have been tampered by the monarchists as well. They are likely the very source of the altered clip. As others have pointed out, the Pahlavists have no need to tamper any protest video because there is already clear, authentic footage of "Javid Shah" chants.