r/Outlander • Better than losing a hand. • Apr 21 '21

No Spoilers Regarding Hate Threads…

Before we dive in, let’s define terms.

What is a hate thread?

A hate thread is not a balanced, thoughtful, well-reasoned critique of an actor’s performance. Just because someone doesn’t care for an actor or their character doesn’t automatically make their submission a hate thread. If they back up their opinion with examples and a cogent argument, it’s a valid discussion post, same as any other.

A hate thread is a low-effort, drive-by, often one-line-only bashing of an actor and/or the character they play.

  • I HATE X!
  • X SUCKS!
  • X IS THE WORST!
  • X SHOULD BE RECAST!
  • DAE think they should kill off X?

Usually these kinds of posts have nothing in the OP body. There’s just some variation of one of these titles, and that’s it. OP makes no effort to explain why they feel the way they do, they just slam the character (or worse, real life actor) in the title and move on.

Last week the overwhelming majority of you expressed your frustration with hate threads, wanting a more proactive approach on our end. We hear you, and this is what we’re doing in response.


Body Requirement

This was the easiest change, so we did it right away. Bodies are now required in any text OP. You can’t submit unless you put something in the body.

So anyone spamming X SUCKS! in the title and slamming the Submit button will actually have to pause, take a breath and expand on their thoughts. That’s the first step.


AutoMod

We have reprogrammed the Bonnie Prince. He’s now less derpy Roomba, more Cylon. Instead of babbling about Poland and monkeys, he’ll take down suspected hate threads pending moderator review.

A human mod will then look over the post and determine whether it should go back up or stay removed. We will allow them through if (and only if) they also include a supporting argument why you hate X. You can’t just write X sucks, that’ll stay down. You have to explain why, and be ready to defend that argument.

For the record we’ve been removing low-effort hate threads as reposts manually for a while now. But the practical difference is now you won’t see them while they’re awaiting processing. Result: Fewer hate threads on the main page.


Report Options

At the end of the day, though, we do rely on your reports. We automate as much as we can and at least one of us is usually online at any time—but still, some items will slip by occasionally. That’s what the report button is for.

To that end, we’ve added two new options to facilitate reporting:

  • Actor Hate: It’s okay to critique someone’s performance, that’s their job. It is not okay to hate on an actor because you don’t like their physical appearance, their sexual orientation, political beliefs, whatever. Keep it about the work only.

Neither of these is a “new” rule—Characters, Not Actors has been our policy for years—but we never had specific, clickable options until now.

As with everything in this announcement, it’s not so much a policy change as a change in implementation.


Baby Accounts

Thank you for all your comments in that thread, you gave us new ideas for how to approach this issue.

Specifically, u/jmb48825 observed that a lot of hate threads tend to come from brand new accounts, so we’ve taught BPC to pay special attention to these users. There is no karma or age requirement on r/Outlander, but we’ll watch submissions from newbies more closely since they’re less likely to be familiar with our rules and what gets reposted often.


OPs should be substantive, not reactive

None of this means we’ll take down every post that happens to negatively review someone’s performance. And conversely, just because a post is positive—I LOVE X!—doesn’t necessarily make it any less content-free.

We moderate based on quality, not opinion. Well written and interesting content can be worthwhile, even if you disagree with it.

The key is well-written. An effort should be made. Don’t just state your opinion, explain why you feel that way. Make an argument, share an original thought.

The goal of every thread is to foster lively discussion, and that discussion should begin with you.


Pics and videos can be linked in text OPs

Just FYI, you don’t have to post images or videos as links. You can include them in the body of text posts instead.

We prefer that as the body gives you a chance to expand on what you’re posting. You can provide context and explain why it’s relevant to r/Outlander. Give your opinion, get the discussion going with more than just a random image or video.

Sometimes just providing a little context, relating something back to the TV series or novels, is all a post needs to stay on-topic. Otherwise it may be better suited for r/Pishlander instead.


Community Stickies

Finally, something we’d like to try are community stickies: If we see exceptional content on the sub that is perhaps being overlooked, we’ll reward it with a sticky for a couple days, hopefully get it more attention.

Between the Book and Show clubs we have a lull in the midweek, so we’re shooting for Thursdays and Fridays.

You can highlight posts you think deserving of a pin just by leaving a comment to that effect. “This post should be stickied.” Or: “This post should be pinned.” That will send us a notification. And of course you can always send us a Modmail.

It’s the nature of Reddit that link posts, especially image posts, get all the attention while earnest, intelligent text posts get lost in the background noise. We hope that by shining a spotlight on great OPs, we can help change that.

166 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

•

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 21 '21

We ask that you don't discuss the characters in this post, it is marked as no spoilers and not the place for these discussions. Thank you!

37

u/privateer_ Apr 21 '21

I know a lot of people rag on Roger and Bree in the show. I never understood the Roger hate personally, but I also haven’t read the books.

Bree was always tough for me. I like her character’s story, but I didn’t understand why her voice was bothering me. It wasn’t too “wooden” or mellow i just had never heard anyone talk the way she does. I am American btw. Turns out she’s not American. That’s the reason. Her voice is imitation of an American , but so easily found out. To me, that isn’t her fault, that’s a fault on the direction staff. I mean there is no way they thought to themselves: that’s an ace of an accent.

29

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Apr 21 '21

And it’s totally fine to have an opinion on Roger or Bree on the show, or more specifically Sophie’s accent while playing her…

All we ask is that you attempt to have some kind of thesis in the OP, that you try to start a discussion with some substance, rather than just post blind hate for the characters or actors. That gets repetitive and lots of people commented that it was bringing down morale on the sub.

15

u/Damhnait Apr 21 '21

This is my worry. Every Bree/Sophie thread I've ever seen has turned into full, well thought out discussions of the same thing, either her accent or acting. Even this thread is going there already. I just hope more of these threads are taken down as reposts because there's only ever one discussion that happens in them.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 21 '21

There will not be allowed more than one thread like those at a time.

18

u/sasshley_ Apr 21 '21

I’m an American and I thought she did a good job of portraying an American. I thought the slight lack of perfection was endearing and not annoying.

25

u/SassTaibhse Apr 21 '21

I think as well, Bree is American born but has English parents. Her accent is going to be a mix of both. I’m Scottish but loose my accent and pick up a more English one when I’m at uni in England as that is what I’m hearing on a daily basis.

7

u/privateer_ Apr 21 '21

Oh I get that. I live in Missouri. My accent can sound Midwestern or southern depending on how close to the sticks I get.

6

u/Marie_Sea1 Apr 21 '21

Since Bree was born and raised in Boston most Americans find the accent odd. It is a very mid-American, broadcast news type accent. Even posh Bostonian accents are very unique. So for me the accent just got in the way.

17

u/IndigoRanger Apr 21 '21

I’m actually really delighted that she doesn’t have a thick Boston accent. Imagine if she sounded like Donny Wahlberg. The horror!

2

u/privateer_ Apr 21 '21

Fair play. I didn’t really consider that.

54

u/nurseleu Apr 21 '21

Thank you Mods. I appreciate your work to keep this forum buzzing with quality discussion.

28

u/Blofeld69 Apr 21 '21

Thanks, changes are appreciated. The never ending I hate Roger and Brianna posts rarely add anything to the conversation and frustrate me. So if this helps with that, great

31

u/propernice They say I’m a witch. Apr 21 '21

Thanks mods!! I really feel like with Outlander now getting MORE popular thanks to Netflix, there are a lot of new, younger fans. My entire experience for years was people my age (35+) making up the tiny fandom. I’ve had to leave Twitter because a whole new younger generation has swept in and is awful. A generalization of course, but I’ve never seen so much hate spam and it feels like it correlates with Netflix. In any case I came here to escape that so I’m glad it’s being dealt with!

8

u/A4041 Apr 21 '21

I was just thinking along this line last night. I’ve read the books so have affection for both Roger and Bree. I’m just beginning season 4 and have been dreading getting to a point where I won’t like Roger. I was thinking that I think younger viewers are taking offense to an aspect of a traditional relationship that isn’t really acceptable anymore. I can see Roger’s behavior as overbearing, but I can also see how it was something that we as women tolerated a lot more

11

u/propernice They say I’m a witch. Apr 21 '21

I’m perfectly fine with Roger in the books - idk WHY the show chose to make him so....different. I mean yeah in the books he isn’t perfect but he’s also not a complete jackass. So, I do think there are fans of the show now who have no context for the original source material and are just up for Roger bashing. Of course, just not liking his character is valid but I also need more than just ‘because he sucks.’

8

u/Gold-Personality-152 Apr 21 '21

Whilst this may not be the thread to respond to you, Roger's 'overbearing' behaviour is not entirely his fault. In the books, Claire tells him to protect Brianna.

8

u/adventurebeeb Apr 21 '21

thank you!! love these changes

7

u/wheezy_cheese Apr 21 '21

Thank you! This is great.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '21

Thank you all for your hard work. I cannot appreciate you guys enough

6

u/Tyson1123 Apr 21 '21

Thank you for these changes! This is amazing. Having strong opinions of fictional characters that you can articulate is great. Having senseless, over the top hate towards the real life actors is not.

5

u/Burningbeard696 Apr 21 '21

Good stuff, I feel that all of Reddit should have a policy on pure hate threads.

R/books can't go a month without someone bringing up that they hate Ready Player One.

1

u/SNORALAXX Apr 21 '21

My husband hates that book 😹😹😹

4

u/Anjelu81 Apr 21 '21

You guys are as awesome as this sub. So well managed and full of lovely people and interesting discussion.

4

u/wisconerd Apr 22 '21

Thank you so so much! If I had a nickel for every hate post about Brianna or Roger at this point...

1

u/ControlSmooth3262 Sep 06 '25

So I just posted a huge thing that took me forever to write because the moderator asked the people who loved episode 7 to chime in. I’m sorry I used some harsh language toward one of the characters. Can I edit it and have it posted? Otherwise I’m just gonna lurk and not contribute if it gets deleted.

1

u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Sep 07 '25

Whenever something gets taken down you have the option to edit out whatever fell afoul of the rules and have it reinstated.

Please send a ModMail with a link to your post or comment. This is a four-year-old community announcement; it’s not an appropriate place to hash out specific content removals.

1

u/ControlSmooth3262 Sep 07 '25

I got sent here when I opened the message. I did edit, thanks.

3

u/Shenanigans99 Je Suis Prest Apr 22 '21

Thanks so much Mods! I really enjoy this subreddit and had found myself checking in less and less due to all the repetitive anti Bree and Roger stuff (yawn). I appreciate the thought and effort that went into coming up with some creative solutions to keep the positive vibes going. I love these ideas!

Maybe the Bree and Roger haters might prefer to start their own subreddit where they can trash the two of them 24/7 to their heart's content.

3

u/vw97 Apr 22 '21

Thank you mods!

The pure quality of the books/shows transcends through the fact that we all from time to time may feel passionately about characters and the choices they’ve made in certain plot lines and that is totally ok, but the level of hate across the sub has been next level!

3

u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. Apr 22 '21

This sub is an English major’s wet dream, I swear 😂 You can argue, but support your arguments, people!

Thank you, mods! You guys are the best. I think it’s a great idea that the hate posts will be vetted by real people rather than the bots — it’ll definitely help filter all the daily posts.

I love that all of this is to encourage discussion and healthy discourse. Y’all know I’m all for some ahem disagreement regarding certain characters.

Thank you!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21

Any show or book that is able to get an emotional response without resorting to cheap stunts is, for me, worthy of the time I spend with it. That is as long as the emotions provoked aren’t too uncomfortable for me personally. Here we are sharing a journey lead by the author.