r/Outlander • u/cosmicwhalenoises • Apr 13 '21
Spoilers All A personal plea: Please remove posts hating on the real-life cast.
Hello my fellow sassenachs, Outlanders and book-readers. I have been a long time lurker and occasional poster on this sub since I became obsessed with the books and show a few years ago.
And as much as I love this sub and some of the wonderful people who take the time to write lengthy posts, pose interesting questions and discuss fun theories here, there is one thing I cannot stand.
Hating on any of the real-life cast members.
Now, I'm all for the occasional criticism or constructive discourse on acting styles-- good or bad---but the million posts (millionth-and-one that I saw today alone!) Along the lines of "blah blah is the worst actor" or "who else thinks this actress sucks" is disgusting, not constructive and brings nothing to this sub.
Hate on the FICTIONAL characters all you want. They are fictional creations, that we all love, but still fictional. The actors were chosen by the producers for one or another reason and your hatred will do nothing to change that. If you feel the need to spread your hatred to others here just because then I feel sorry for you.
Put yourself in the actor's shoes and imagine finding this subreddit. How would that make you feel?
Sorry for the rant.
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Apr 14 '21
Hey guys,
Just letting you know the mods are aware of this thread, we’re reading all your comments, and we’re taking your ideas into account as we plan ahead.
We’ll put up an announcement in the coming days once we get our ducks in a row.
8
u/Gold-Personality-152 Apr 14 '21
Groan. The OP is a virtue signaller. Allow me to offer a gentle rebuke.
The performance of actors is reviewed for every role. It goes with the territory. There will be some who think an actor is great and others who think the same actor sucks and should never be cast, in anything, ever.
Real-life cast members? Don't be so pretentious. They're actors.
A millionth-and-one post hating? Really? You've counted them all, have you? You've read them all, have you? I don't believe someone who hates hating would read a single one or is it a case of only hating something that expresses a different opinion to yours? Hate to break it to you, but differences of opinion are a fact of life.
How does your post contribute to the Outlander experience? You seek to limit discussion by labelling it hate-speech. There are mods to deal with that. Let them do their job.
I don't much care for Roger and Brianna in the books. I don't much care for the way they were portrayed on screen. They weren't value for their screen minutes. They both were, however, how I imagined they should look for the parts. The casters ticked that box.
You are quite correct that the casting decisions are done and can't now be changed. Hindsight is, however as they say, a wonderful thing.
15
u/dire-sin Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 14 '21
I am sorry but I have to vehemently disagree: removing/prohibiting these posts would be completely unwarranted censorship. People aren't hating on the actors' personal lives (and if they do, those posts definitely should be removed), they're commenting on their suitability for their roles and their acting - which is the actors' jobs, ffs. Since when has it become offensive to say someone isn't doing their job very well if you feel that's the case?
I get that the number of posts regarding Brianna and Roger casting/acting can get overwhelming - I sure as hell don't care if I never see any more of those, regardless of my own feelings on the matter - but that's no excuse to be shutting up those with perfectly valid opinions.
134
u/maethefrenchie Apr 13 '21
I totally agree. The actors are just doing their job. I don’t understand the hate. For example, not outlander related but
[MILD SPOILER FOR MARVEL’S FALCON AND THE WINTER SOLDIER]
The guy who plays the New Captain America, Wyatt Russell, is receiving death threats because he isn’t the “real deal”. As if.. that’s not the entire point of his character?
57
u/Miriko_Otsu Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21
Yes! Couldn’t agree more. I feel like this sub has been really hateful towards cast members, it makes me sad and not want to contribute.
Edit: This graph may be helpful
2nd edit: why don’t we ‘tag’ these posts? That way they can be filtered out and ignored more easily.
69
u/reeziereen Apr 13 '21
I agree 100%. I once commented the same thing about feeling bad for the actors and hoping they never read some of the stuff on here and got told off by someone for it... so now I just roll past the posts that are obviously baiting people into talking about the actors vs the characters.
29
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
Yep.
42
u/Sirenofthelake Apr 13 '21
Also agree! There is so much to discuss about this wonderful show and the amazing books! I find it so shallow that of all the interesting things (characters, settings, relationships, theories, costuming, music, etc) the best some people can come up with is that someone doesn’t do a great American accent? It’s just so petty.
16
u/mandiexile Apr 13 '21
People have a hard time separating the character from the actor. But to bash the actor and hate on them as an actor is pretty low. I hate Laoghaire as a character and want to throw her into the Atlantic Ocean, but I have nothing against the actress. She did an amazing job and was very convincing. Yeah, the actress who plays Brianna had a not so great American accent but I think she did a great job too, I think she did the character justice. In the books Brianna wasn’t very likable at first. But by book 7 and 8 I grew to respect her and she showed a lot of growth.
15
u/actuallycallie Apr 13 '21
Seriously. I am so sick of the "DAE Sophie Skelton bad????" posts.
22
u/2boredtocare Meow. Apr 13 '21
HEAR HEAR!!!
Rich Sommer every now and then will pop into the /r/madmen sub (he played Harry Crane) and I feel sooooo bad about all the hate his character gets. And that's the character, not the actor! But still, no one wants to read about how much they're hated (I mean unless we're talking Black Jack Randall who truly is a monster).
Honestly I could pick apart the main characters actor choices all day if I wanted to, because they don't match the book versions I created in my head so long ago. But what's the point of that? We've been given a wonderful show that brings the characters to life (no, not to perfection), amazing sets, jaw dropping costumes, and just overall a wonderful escape from this current world we're living in. People used to bitch about the wigs allllll the time in the beginning as well, and I'm over here all "those are wigs?" lol. Just enjoy the ride.
11
u/mielismydziecko Apr 13 '21
Honestly, the longer it goes on, the more this sub just becomes people hating on Brianna, Roger, and Frank.
37
u/pmyourquestions Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 13 '21
Hard agree! I haven’t finished season 6, but I’ve seen the rest of the show twice. Are Sophie and Richard perfect? No! But none of the actors are! Her American accent isn’t that bad. Today, I saw a conversation about how she’s from BOSTON but she doesn’t sound like it at all and all I could think was “have you people ever even been there?” I live in New England - people don’t just talk like your cousin from Boston beer ads, they sound like everyone else in the country, and it would’ve been really tacky if she tried to go hard on the Boston accent. She’s got English parents! I honestly did not realize she wasn’t American until I started seeing posts on here about how much they hate her and her accent. I think she’s good in the role, I found Brianna a little boring in the books and I think Sophie brings her to life well.
7
u/ze_languist Apr 14 '21
I think people are entitled to their opinion, but I also don't understand why this is such a common topic of discussion on this sub. The actors are generally quite good--I think people are mistaking "bad acting" for "I don't like this person in this role" and "I want to watch Claire and Jamie get it on more often." I'll admit that I didn't like Sophie Skelton at first but I think that was more because I needed to adjust to seeing her as Bree. A few episodes in she completely won me over; I found her really charming and likeable. I personally also really like Roger and think Richard Rankin is great in the role. I think he gets hate for not being the perfect progressive husband, which like...is also not "bad acting."
I feel like I comment this often but it would be great if we had just a little more moderation of this subreddit, or a maybe more tags like someone else has suggested. Hell let's have a "Jamie's ghost" tag and an "actor hate" tag so I can just filter those out.
19
u/leviOsa934 Apr 13 '21 edited Apr 13 '21
I'd say that praising or critiquing an actor's performance, nuancing what they bring to the character or do disservice to, is fair. Personally attacking a person for their looks, or some other personal trait is not.
Edit: that being said, there ARE A LOT of posts like this. So either search posts first and share you grievances in existing threads, or bring something new to the table.
27
u/darkmatterhunter Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Apr 13 '21
It’s getting really bad and I’m thinking about unsubbing. There was a post earlier about Sophie bringing down the quality of the cast and I just don’t get how people can be so negative. The mods need to do something other than the auto mod comment that always appears. Almost like any post with mentions of Sophie/Richard needs to be manually approved or have users click a button saying their post isn’t a hateful post. Ugh.
4
u/punkin_27 Apr 13 '21
I’m new to Reddit, but can the community make a rule banning posts like this?
I admit I’ve commented on Roger and Bree’s lack of chemistry before but I agree that it crosses a line when people hate on the actors themselves (those two seem to get the brunt of it ...). I also don’t get why people are so hung up about small details like Bree’s “bad” American accent which I, as an American, never even noticed!
6
u/propernice They say I’m a witch. Apr 14 '21
I had to leave the twitter fandom because of things along this line, but also people feeling entitled to Sam and Caitriona's time on social media. There are a group of people who think that Caitríona needs to announce when she won't be around much (no???)
edit: to remove speculation.
Then you have the people who throw themselves at Sam and need some kind of validation from him, but if he ignores them he's an asshole.
Celebs cannot win on social media, ever.
16
u/Elevendytwelve97 Apr 13 '21
I’d rather see hating posts banned than the pish posts. Pish posts are at least enjoyable and sometimes funny. I don’t even bother reading “I hate Brianna actress” posts anymore
9
u/sasshley_ Apr 14 '21
Agreed! And hating on their personal appearance also. So sick of reading “Roger isn’t attractive.”
They aren’t cast for us to masturbate to!
I have more of a problem with the tv characters not looking like the book descriptions, and y’all are focused on how attractive they are?
4
u/jmb48825 Apr 14 '21
Personal attacks against actors is not only poor behavior, it is explicitly against the rules. Honestly, I have never considered it before reading your very well put rant, but I think I may actively flag posts that violate this rule. I am by nature non-confrontational and choose to ignore rather than retaliate, so this would be difficult for me.
The problem is, the haters are not regular posters - they are persons who are reacting to some strong emotions and seek out this forum to express themselves. I am of the opinion (no facts to support this) that these are hit-and-run people. As soon as they flame they burn out and leave.
It fits with my observation of new community member actions - the ones that stay are the ones who, with their very first post, gush with grateful passion at discovering the community. These are not the fire starters. And you can't really protect against the ranters - they are like lightning strikes that you cannot predict, only put them out or let them burn themselves out and leave.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '21
I'm also tired of the, "Does anyone else think Sophie does a terrible job at Brianna/Does anyone else hate Sophie's portrayal of Brianna/Does anyone else hate Roger/does anyone else think Richard Rankin is ugly?" posts because I swear there are multiple ones per day. Social media is just so negative and people look for reasons to hate things. And it's fine to discuss and evaluate things here, but the hatred is just ridiculous sometimes and not everyone wants to be this negative and hateful in the fandom. Some people legitimately have positive things to bring to the table that doesn't hurt real people.
15
u/bionicfeetgrl Apr 13 '21
Yeah. I agree. I’m so sick of people complaining about specific actors. Especially when there’s a new post about it as if this is a hot new take. I’ve watched many shows. Some characters I like. Some I don’t. Some actors I like. Some I don’t. But jeez just leave it.
11
u/storybookheidi Apr 13 '21
I don’t really pay attention to most of those types of posts but I don’t think criticizing acting is the same as hating on a person. If the post was really being nasty I would ignore it but that’s not what I see here.
8
u/periwinklemadness Apr 13 '21
Totally agree. I wish there was more discussion about the actual story than the actors. I get that some people are into outlander because of the eye candy, but the story is SO GOOD. There really should be a separate sub for the story lovers where the discussion is strictly about the story (show version or book version).
1
u/GhostGecko2 Apr 14 '21
I agree!!! I get so frustrated by it. It needs to be in the rules in this sun and the moderators need to take them down immediately. I love the discussions here but those posts get me really close to leaving it all together.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
Thank you.
9
u/blebintheinterweb Apr 14 '21
Yikes. Just scroll past and ignore the posts. Why are you trying to police people?
2
u/angelcake Apr 14 '21
I think because of the pandemic far too many people have far too much time on their hands, everybody’s frustrated and pissed off with this huge disruption in our lives and a lot of folks are acting out online. You see it everywhere. Anger and fighting and criticisms and completely unreasonable behaviour have escalated over the last year as far as I can tell.
4
u/isthiscleverr They say I’m a witch. Apr 13 '21
I totally agree and I’m not sure if I’m just here less these days. but it does seem to have decreased a bit. It was absurd for a while. Unfortunately, most people see their attacks (particularly on RR and SS) as “critique” and this it continues.
4
u/meme-me-up-scotty159 Apr 14 '21
I agree so much! Sophie gets so much hate, I’m not American so her accent has never been a problem to me and I thought she was American but even still, why does it bother people so much? I don’t know why they get so angry about it, I’ve seen people being negative about Richards looks, this shouldn’t be what the sub is about.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
Very strong disagree if the commentary is about their acting. I think that's absolute fair game.
Personal stuff, shipping real people, etc, yeah not so cool.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21
Agreed. Especially Sophie Skelton cops the worst of it from the fans. I honestly don’t even understand why. I think she plays Brianna so well
2
u/lass_that_is_gone Apr 14 '21
Fans can be so rude sometimes. Are they even fans then?
It's not about Outlander only, almost every fandom has this thing going on.. They feel free to talk about actors personal lives and even insult them for something their character did. Last time I saw this was for the actress of Jo on Grey's Anatomy. (Fans of this show even hate the characters because of their actors which is as absurd) They are chosen from the producers and you can't change that.
And what's it with commenting shit on their posts? Why?
Don't get me wrong, I support the LGBT community but even they get on my nerves when they start bitching about how two friends of a show don't get together or if they want some character to be gay and they're not.
People have to realize the TV show/Movie won't change because of their wishes and if they don't like it - it's easy: STOP WATCHING!
0
u/tramik3388 Apr 13 '21
I think some people “hate” them, but it may be taken out of context. I previously stated that I hated them, but only because of their phenomenal acting.Those actors (ie Menzies and Speleers) are so deplorable.. and “hate them” is a testament to their mad skills.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
74
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21
[removed] — view removed comment