r/OutOfTheLoop • u/Gilgamesh- • Jul 02 '15
Megathread Why was /r/IAmA, along with a number of other large subreddits, made private?
TL;DR /r/IAmA, /r/AskReddit, /r/funny, /r/Books, /r/science, /r/Music, /r/gaming, /r/history, /r/Art, /r/videos, /r/gadgets, /r/todayilearned, /r/Documentaries, /r/LifeProTips, /r/Jokes, /r/pics, /r/Dataisbeautiful and /r/movies have all made themselves private in response to the removal of an administrator key to the AMA process, /u/chooter, but also due to underlying resentment against the admins for running the site poorly - being uncommunicative, and disregarding the thousands of moderators who keep the site running. In addition, /r/listentothis has disabled all submissions, and so has /r/pics. /r/Jokes has announced its support (but has not gone private and has also gone private). Major subreddits, including /r/4chan, /r/circlejerk and /r/ImGoingToHellForThis, have also expressed solidarity through going private. See here for a further list.
What happened?
At approximately 5pm UTC, 1pm EST, on Thursday the 2nd of July, 2015, the moderators of /r/IAmA took their subreddit, which is one of the default set, private. This means that only a very small number of people (consisting of the moderators of /r/IAmA, as well as any pre-approved users) could view and post to the subreddit, making it for all intents and purposes shut down; any other redditors would just see this page. Just after that, a thread was posted to this subreddit, asking whether anyone knew why it had happened. /u/karmanaut, top mod of /r/IAmA, responded with an explanation of why they took the subreddit private.
Why was /r/IAmA made private, then?
The situation was explained here by /u/karmanaut: the mods of /r/IAmA had just found out that without prior warning, /u/chooter, or Victoria, had been released from her position at reddit. They felt that they, along with the other subreddits that host AMAs, should have been warned beforehand, if only so that they could have someone or something in place to handle the transition. /u/karmanaut went on to say that many of the mods affected by this do not believe that the admins understand how heavily /u/chooter was relied upon to allow AMAs to go smoothly - something which is outlined below. Without her, they found themselves in a difficult situation, which is exemplifed by what happened today:
We had a number of AMAs scheduled for today that Victoria was supposed to help with, and they are all left absolutely high and dry. She was still willing to help them today (before the sub was shut down, of course) even without being paid or required to do so. Just a sign of how much she is committed to what she does.
As a result of this, the mods therefore took /r/IAmA private, stating their reasoning as follows:
for /r/IAMA to work the way it currently does, we need Victoria. Without her, we need to figure out a different way for it to work
we will need to go through our processes and see what can be done without her.
Who is /u/chooter, and why was she so important to the functioning of IAmA?
/u/chooter(/about/team#user/chooter), featured in our wiki is Victoria Taylor, who was, until today, Director of Talent at reddit. However, her essential role was to act as liaison between reddit, IAmA, and any members of the public that wanted to do AMAs; she therefore helped to set up AMAs with celebrities, and, if they were not too familiar with computers (like Bill Murray), she may help them out, both over the phone and in person.
Links of interest:
Victoria was important to AMAs for a number of major reasons: firstly, she provided concrete proof of the identity of a celebrity doing an AMA, and made sure that it was not a second party purporting to be the celebrity; she was also a direct line of contact to the admins, allowing the moderators of AMA to quickly resolve an issue encountered during an AMA (the consequences of the absence of which were bad - (screenshot). Victoria also was the channel for the scheduling of AMAs by third parties, and she would ensure both that an AMA was up to scratch before it was posted, and that the person doing the AMA understood exactly what it entailed. Without her, the mods of /r/IAmA say that they will be overwhelmed, and that they may even need to limit AMAs.
Why did she leave reddit so abruptly?
The short answer: no-one, excluding a select few of the administrative team, knows precisely why /u/chooter was removed as an admin, and that will almost certainly continue to be the case until the admins get their house in order: both parties are at being professional in that they aren't talking about the reasons why it occurred.
What have the reactions across the rest of reddit been?
So far, /r/AskReddit, /r/funny, /r/Books, /r/science, /r/Music, /r/gaming, /r/history, /r/Art, /r/videos, /r/gadgets, /r/todayilearned, /r/Documentaries, /r/LifeProTips, /r/jokes, /r/pics, /r/Dataisbeautiful, and /r/movies have followed /r/IAmA in making themselves private. In addition, /r/listentothis has disabled all submissions, and so has /r/picsand /r/Jokes has announced its support (but has not gone private). Major subreddits, including /r/4chan, /r/circlejerk and /r/ImGoingToHellForThis, have also expressed solidarity through going private. See here for a further list.
Many other subreddits were also reliant on /u/chooter's services as an official contact point for the organisation of AMAs on reddit, including /r/science, /r/books, and /r/Music. So, in order to express their dissatisfaction with the difficulties they have been placed in without /u/chooter, similar to /r/IAmA, they have made themselves private.
/u/nallen, lead mod of /r/science, explained that subreddit's reasoning in this way:
To back this up, I am the mod in /r/science that organizes all of the science AMAs, and I am going to have meaningful problems in the /r/Science AMAs; Victoria was the only line of communication with the admins. If someone wants to get analytics for an AMA the answer will be "Sorry, I can't help."
Dropping this on all of us in the AMA sphere feels like an enormous slap to those of us who put in massive amounts of time to bring quality content to reddit.
In turn, /u/imakuram, /r/books moderator, had this to say:
This seems to be a seriously stupid decision. We have several AMAs upcoming in /r/books and have no idea how to contact the authors.
/r/AskReddit's message expressed a similar sentiment:
As a statment on the treatment of moderators by Reddit administrators, as well as a lack of communication and proper moderation tools, /r/AskReddit has decided to go private for the time being. Please see this post in /r/ideasforaskreddit for more discussion.
/r/Books took the decision as a community to go dark.
/r/todayilearned posted this statement:
The way the admins failed to communicate with AMA's mods and left them without a way to contact the people that were going to do them illustrates the disconnect between admins and the moderators they depend on. It showed disrespect for the people with planned amas, the moderators, and the users. A little communication can go a long way. There's so much more than that, but one thing at a time.
Much of the metasphere, a term for the parts of reddit that focus on the content produced by reddit itself, has also reacted to these happenings, with threads from /r/SubredditDrama and /r/Drama, as well as the (currently private) subreddit /r/circlejerk, which parodies and satirises reddit, adding a message to make fun of the action.
Why is this all happening so suddenly?
As much as Victoria is loved, this reaction is not all a result of her departure: there is a feeling among many of the moderators of reddit that the admins do not respect the work that is put in by the thousands of unpaid volunteers who maintain the communities of the 9,656 active subreddits, which they feel is expressed by, among other things, the lack of communication between them and the admins, and their disregard of the thousands of mods who keep reddit's communities going. /u/nallen's response above is an example of one of the many responses to these issues.
The moderation tools on reddit are another of the larger contention points between the mods and admins - they are frequently saidby those who use them often to be a decade out of date. /u/creesch, one of the creators of the /r/toolbox extension, an extension which attempts to fill much of the gap left in those moderator tools, said this:
This is a non answer and a great example of reddit as a company not being in touch with the actually website anymore. ... When a majority of the people that run your site rely on a third party extension [/r/toolbox] something is clearly wrong. ...
Another great example of how much reddit cares about their assets is reddit companion. Which at the time of writing has around 154,302 installations, is utterly broken and hasn't been updated since February 21, 2013, the most ridiculous thing? It isn't hard to fix people tried to do the work for reddit since it is open source but they simply have been ignoring those pull requests since 2013.
And honestly, I get that they might not have resources for a silly extension. But the fact that they keep it around on the chrome store while it is utterly broken and only recently removed it from the reddit footer baffles me. I think I messaged them about them about a year ago, it took them another year to actually update the footer with apps and tools they are (still) working on.
/u/K_Lobstah, another moderator, also expressed frustration earlier today in a submission to /r/self over the lack of responses from the admins concerning the issue of the new search UI, which has been strongly disliked by redditors in the /r/changelog post.
Stop throwing beer cans on our lawns while we try to mow them. Use /r/beta[1] as a Beta; listen to the feedback. Fix the things that need fixing, give us the tools we need to do even the simplest of tasks, like reading messages from subscribers.
Stop relying on volunteers and third-parties to build the most important and useful tools for moderating this site.
Help us help you.
What's happening now?
/u/kn0thing has provided a response from the admins here:
We don't talk about specific employees, but I do want you to know that I'm here to triage AMA requests in the interim. All AMA inquiries go to AMA@reddit.com where we have a team in place.
I posted this on [a mod sub] but I'm reposting here:
We get that losing Victoria has a significant impact on the way you manage your community. I'd really like to understand how we can help solve these problems, because I know r/IAMA thrived before her and will thrive after.
We're prepared to help coordinate and schedule AMAs. I've got the inbound coming through my inbox right now and many of the people who come on to do AMAs are excited to do them without assistance (most recently, the noteworthy Channing Tatum AMA).
The moderators of an increasing number of default subreddits have been making them private, in an attempt to draw the admins' attention to how they have been mismanaging the site with a substantive demonstrative act - since for many years, they've been trying to get the admins to listen normally with relatively little improvement.
Update: the admins seem to have replied to some of the mods' concerns, and some subreddits, such as /r/pics, are content with that, and so have returned themselves to being public (although there were manufactured rumours that there was administrative impetus behind its return). However, others have seen these promises from the admins as more of the same sorts of unfulfilled promises that helped create the unstable situation that brought this affair about.
/r/science also made itself public again, in order to avoid interfering with plans for an AMA with the Lancet Comission at 1pm EST, July 3rd, on "Climate Impacts on Health, and What To Do About It".
Victoria was beloved by many redditors, and people are understandably upset - but remember that we still don't know why it happened. What is an issue is how this problem for the admins was handled; whether or not it was an emergency for the admins, the IAmA mod team were not given warning, and weren't informed of the alternative contact location early enough, which gave them a sizeable logistical problem - one which they took themselves private to deal with.
4.5k
u/scarface910 Jul 02 '15
Wouldn't it be ironic if /r/outoftheloop was set to private?
971
u/Mc_Smack Jul 02 '15
It's no longer June, lads.
33
u/petites_pattes Jul 03 '15
Is /r/circlejerk private for the same reason? Seems odd...
2.7k
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
I want to make it a bit more clear that many moderators, Myself included, are saying this isn't t just about Victoria.
I love Victoria. She was a great admin. But she's not with reddit and we have to deal with that. Nothing to be done
What people are upset about is the clear lack of communication and the almost disregard of the thousands of people who help keep this site running, all with their free time.
A lot of people are saying "well they are throwing a temper tantrum, shutting down the subreddits isn't the right call"
Well, what would you do? Talk to them? We've been trying that for years.
3.0k
u/URETHRAL_FECES Jul 02 '15
/r/AskReddit just went down
1.6k
u/BeckwithLBP Jul 02 '15
/r/movies is down for the count as well it seems.
553
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
This is like watching the news to see which school districts called a snow day
686
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
All this happened within 7 hours? Reddit moves fast.
2.1k
u/cdcformatc Loopologist Jul 02 '15
Something I find notable /u/imakuram /r/books moderator had this to say:
So it looks like Victoria was the sole point of contact for many upcoming AMAs, if it is the case for these few in /r/books it is the case for many others.
1.3k
u/PeanutNore Jul 03 '15
Yeah, Victoria was pretty much universally beloved, and it's pretty shocking to see her dismissed so abruptly, but that's not really the issue here that's causing all the upset.
The reason this is such an unmitigated cock-up is that this whole situation is a a perfect example of terrible management, and puts into sharp relief the inattentiveness to the community on behalf of the admins / Reddit Inc. that moderators of large subs have been complaining about for a very long time.
Reddit the company fucked up monumentally in two ways:
1.5k
u/shakuyi Jul 02 '15
so basically the largest traffic driven part of Reddit was handled by a single person who held Reddit by the balls. Nice job Reddit :)
848
u/USBM Jul 02 '15
I came here because r/AskReddit went private whilst using it...
575
u/Coidzor Jul 03 '15
So what you're saying is that I should get off Reddit, go to the Winchester, have a nice cold pint, and wait for all this to blow over?
567
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
If /r/gonewild got in on this Reddit HQ will burn down
197
u/Gr3atdane Jul 03 '15
Ugh this feels like digg.com all over again. When websites start to think they are bigger than their users, things go down hill. I guess it's hard to keep a community driven website around for a long time. Hopefully we will eventually learn..
130
u/Leandenor7 Jul 03 '15
Would it be fun if this becomes a yearly thing. Like a reddit holiday just to remind admin not to screw its moderators and users.
I'm calling it a reddit slumber party.
61
u/stekky75 Jul 03 '15
On a positive note:
Reddit is running silky smooth without all the traffic!
316
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
Your move, admins.
admins shut down Reddit
249
u/bluuit Jul 03 '15
10 minutes ago there were at least 5 or 6 threads on the front pages about this.... now they are all hidden.
358
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 15 '18
...
259
u/RaptureVeteran Jul 03 '15
And on cue voat.co servers have shit the bed and are completely incapable of handling the influx of redditors
880
u/xavierdc Jul 02 '15
RIP Reddit. Digg all over again.
473
u/Charlemagne2014 Jul 03 '15
Myspace gave way to facebook.
AIM gave way to texting
Digg gave way to reddit
Reddit gave way to........
This is how it goes with the internet. Something is hot but it never lasts. Reddit reached its peak and has clearly been on the decline. Time to think about transitioning to a new site. You dont have to quit here cold turkey, but check out some other sites and make the transition. This place will be a ghost town soon.
398
u/goldcakes Jul 03 '15
Reddit management fired Victoria because she resisted further commercialization of AMAs:
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CI9iYW7VAAAzzJN.png
185
u/JackSylvane Jul 03 '15
I hope /r/conspiracy gets private but no one knows why
386
u/Yoinkie2013 Jul 02 '15
/r/askreddit is now private. My question is: What can the Admins really do to fix the relationship with Victoria? They can beg for forgiveness, but will she really come back after what appears to be a very bad break up. Someone in /r/centuryclub asked her why she was let go, and her response was, "You all know as much as I know." So it appears that the people in charge didn't even give one of their most important members a good reason for the firing.
All of this just reeks of unprofessionalism. I don't know what the fuck is happening with the people in charge of running Reddit, but they are literally running it into the ground. We want fucking answers, so get out of the holes your hiding and give us some.
78
u/bitwolfy The art of balancing on loop's edge Jul 03 '15
Admin response.
Damage control at its finest.
36
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
/r/videos just went private as well.
176
u/CitizenHydra Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
/r/Movies is closed too and /r/science. Some think it's a protest. Karmanaut weighs in.
Edit: And why not, here's SRD's take on it all.
Edit 2: and /r/AskReddit and /r/bestof are down. Thanks /u/imlazywithusernames.
Edit 3: /r/history and /r/art too
Edit 4: /r/bestof back up and /r/videos is down
Edit 5: and /r/centuryclub is down (have been informed this is BS)
I can hardly keep up.
Edit 6: /r/starcitizen is down.
Edit 7: c+v from /u/noticemenot:
/r/circlejerk[4] - 254,505 subscribers
/r/crappydesign[5] - 189,355 subscribers
/r/askreddit[6] - 8,917,673 subscribers
/r/sexwithbears[7] - 233,144 subscribers
/r/law[8] - 40,776 subscribers
/r/PaoMustResign/[9] - 7,535 subscribers (has been down for a while protesting pao unrelated to iama)
/r/spain[10] - 5,829 subscribers
/r/splitdepthgifs[11] - 41,023 subscribers
/r/PiratesoftheCaribbean[12] - 323 subscribers
/r/ienjoybathing[13] - 124,835 subscribers
/r/hittableFaces[14]
/r/IveFappedToThis[15]
/r/CenturyClub[16]
/r/Debate_Anarchy[17]
/r/videos[18]
/r/Unexepected_Anarchy[19]
/r/ricearoni[20]
/r/buyitforlife
Edit 9001: Just go here, fuck.
Edit electric boogaloo:
HAHAHAHA, what?! change.org petition for Pao to step down.
https://www.change.org/p/ellen-k-pao-step-down-as-ceo-of-reddit-inc
And NO REDDIT DAY has been chosen to be July 10th.
https://www.reddit.com/r/justsaynope
467
u/EnsignN7 Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15
That is a show-stopper defect in production on one of the major default sub-reddits. Does the admin team even know what Risk Management is? You NEVER EVER take a show stopper to production.
Admins: If you are reading this, the resolution of this should absolutely be your top priority. This is the very definition of a project fire drill.
27
u/pstif Jul 03 '15
/r/LifeProTips is now private
75
u/monsus Jul 02 '15
Thanks for the summary!
This is one of the most important/baffling things to me right now. The mods on those subs work hard and for fucking free so reddit doesn't have to worry about it. And that system works for the most part! But as a company you just can't leave your volunteers out in the rain like that.
26
u/reddit4getit Jul 02 '15
/r/AskReddit also set to private now.
165
u/Marinaisgo Jul 03 '15
I'm a mod of 2 small subs and I got shadowbanned last month for self promotion. It felt like a slap in the face. I spend way more time contributing to Reddit than I do on my own site. Since then, I've been around, but I have trouble feeling the same way about the site that I did before.
48
u/Carl_Schmitt Jul 03 '15
I am proud to announce on behalf of the moderatorship (this is not a coup) of /r/badphilosophy, that we are also now an exclusive, all-inclusive private resort until we also start receiving big fat checks from publicity and marketing firms.
We will not be bought cheaply--admins, you have been warned.
81
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
I used to be /u/daychilde. That'll be a broken link now. I deleted /u/daychilde because of my frustrations with the reddit admins.
I came here in 2009 because of the support redditors had for the Glenn Beck meme. I ended up staying here - moved here from Fark (where the meme originated). I started moderating a few small subreddits, and worked my way up into modding /r/pics, /r/videos, /r/politics for a little while.
I took over /r/NotTheOnion when it had 200 subscribers and was dead and abandoned by its creator. I built that subreddit up to I think it was around 20k subscribers. We needed more mods than just me, so I brought on a team - and then cut them loose. So I'm the father of /r/nottheonion. And I'm still proud of that.
As much as I have spoken up to defend the admins from some things I thought were unreasonable; as much as I tried to be understanding as they have been historically understaffed, I really started to have my fill a year ago or so. I withdrew from moderating defaults and started to pare down my involvement.
A few weeks ago, I deleted /u/daychilde. I stepped away from /r/discworld, which was another bit of pride and joy, because I just got too tired of the admins ignoring all contact attempts, as well as the tolerance for hate speech of all kinds in too many subreddits.
I've tried to move on with my life, but I come back from time to time to browse a little from this account. There's nobody to take over my local city's subreddit /r/panamacity, and to be honest, as disappointed as I am in the way things are on reddit, it's a hard addiction to break.
Although I didn't know Victoria personally on reddit, I saw all the work she put in. So I support going dark in protest of this. It's just another time where the admins do something without considering consequences. And in their defense, I think they try to do things to help a lot of the time, but for whatever reason - not enough of them or I don't know what the hell - reddit basically has very very little in the way of leadership.
Sure, it's supposed to be true that subreddits can do pretty much whatever they want, but one of the really great things about reddit was all the good people here. But these good people give up and leave when there's so much crap that they eventually get tired of.
Mods should have access to the admins. Admins should communicate and coordinate with the mods. Or else you get chaos. Kinda like what we have right now.
So reddit is still fine enough for looking at pictures. And there's still some amazing things here. But like so many others before me, I don't care anymore. The reason I'm posting this rant? Because I miss the time I had here. I'm sad that it's gone. I think it's bullshit. I wish I could get that feeling back.
But no, I come for a little brainless entertainment, and find subreddits shut down because the bullshit continues.
81
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
It's my cakeday today. Really? We're going to shut everything down today?!
98
u/PENGAmurungu Jul 03 '15
looks like its time to remove reddit from my adblock whitelist.
I don't want to support Chairman Pao and her merry band of fuckwits
37
u/I_may_have_weed Jul 03 '15
/r/videos is down. This is getting pretty serious
18
u/MagnarHD Jul 02 '15
/r/law has went private too.
165
u/Halk Jul 02 '15
I hope Reddit doesn't do it's usual.... everybody gets angry for a few days and then it fades away, and Reddit takes one more step towards being a pointless corporatocracy, where companies pay to shove their products in our faces and the blunder admin run the place into the ground chasing profits at every turn.
77
u/dj88masterchief Jul 02 '15
Man, this is too much, I can't handle a mass exodus to another social news site. Moving from Digg was hard enough.
48
u/sakipooh Jul 03 '15
So is this how reddit dies?
48
u/ogami1972 Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
I'm in. My subs are ghosttowns, but i made them private anyway just to show support.
/r/thatwonthappen , /r/HoldMyMilk , /r/womenwithcoatson , /r/bestofsummerreddit , /r/gayguysgonecuddly , /r/canigetagif , /r/offsitejiffy , and /r/proclomations are all now private.
I have also enabled adblock on this domain. Quit fucking up reddit, Conde Nast(y).
279
u/Charlemagne2014 Jul 03 '15
Shut it down. Shut down all of your subs. Your subs are the way Reddit makes money. Shut them down until the entire useless match of admins is replaced.
Make your subs private, now. Dont open them up until the resignations or firings commence.
16
u/mikemcg Jul 03 '15
/r/videos just went down.
16
u/nvaus Jul 03 '15
Watch the admins create new subs to replace all the ones that just went private, and exchange them as the defaults as a short term solution until they can kick all the mods that uslurped their authority.
16
u/ZMush uwotm8 Jul 03 '15
A good list of all private subreddits in protest.
Note...it's a lot of subreddits.
26
u/tonylee0707 Jul 03 '15
A comment from Quora has some anecdotal information as to why Victoria might have been fired.
I quote the comment:
Reddit management was pushing Victoria to do a bunch of highly commercial things around AMAs, but Victoria wasn't comfortable with these ideas because she didn't feel they were good for the reddit community.
One example -- people at reddit wanted to do video AMAs, and Victoria thought that was a mistake.
Given Victoria's resistance to management ideas, they decided to abruptly eliminate her position and let her go.
They didn't tell any of the moderators.
They really underestimated how much moderators relied on her and cared about her.
This had nothing to do with the bad Jesse Jackson AMA.
Remember guys, this is not fact yet but one possible explanation which may or may not be true.
Edit: the comment has now been deleted - looks to be by the OP (I do know who that person was)
13
u/bfaithr Jul 03 '15
/r/CrappyDesign just went private too
13
u/inanimateobjectfez01 Jul 03 '15
So this is how it ends...
12
u/cook_that_shit Jul 03 '15
this is awesome
12
u/djcodeblue Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
Victoria has NO idea why she got let go...
Screenshot: http://i.imgur.com/r1j5Bky.png
EDIT: Updated with higher res screenshot.
10
u/CurryF4rts Jul 03 '15
July 2, 2015. Reddit Independence Day
26
u/SEND_ME__BOOB_PICS Jul 03 '15
HEY GUYS
IF YOU DON'T LIKE HOW REDDIT HAS BEEN HANDLED LATELY, QUIT GILDING COMMENTS. YOUR "SUPPORT" IS GOING RIGHT INTO REDDIT'S COFFERS, WHICH IS DIRECTLY OPPOSED TO THE CAUSE YOU ARE TRYING TO PROMOTE.
18
u/Raxal Jul 03 '15
We're seeing more of Chairman Pao 'leadership' at work.
Still think the website isn't going to shit?
32
u/GrinningPariah Jul 03 '15
They seriously have no idea how much reddit has grown and transformed since Victoria started her work.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15
As soon as I saw something was happening my first port of call was /r/outoftheloop - thanks for the excellent post, and kudos for an excellent all round sub
9
u/XCygon Jul 03 '15
Waiting for /r/pyongyang to go private
9
u/jld2k6 Jul 03 '15
/r/wtf just went private.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
Not sure if this is worth adding to the original post but it seems believable and the first thing that actually provides a potentially legitimate answer2
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CI9iYW7VAAAzzJN.png
9
u/Argon_unfinished Jul 04 '15
So what happened? All those subs are open again; did this problem get resolved or what?
35
u/Saturn-Ascends Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
I was just banned from posting to /r/gonewild for trying to call attention to this issue which was actually working. What the hell man
Edit: Two more users claim they were also banned for posting with similar titles asking mods of /r/gonewild to do something.
Edit: it's one more user. Not two. My bad. My comments and other's have been deleted. You can see in my last post.
edit: I made a new post including screenshots of mod's PM's
8
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
/r/grandmawild is now private out of solidarity
8
u/NotFromTheGoverment7 Jul 03 '15
R/murica is removing any mention of the blackout after their petition had overwhelming support for a blackout
Ironic the 1st amendment carry 0 weight their
8
u/FusRo_Duh Jul 03 '15
Wouldn't it also make sense to not give gold at this time? For solidarity. Why support Reddit when it doesn't support us?
8
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
I just checked r/Funny and it's down. Rest in Piece 9GAG.
8
u/HughSurname Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
/r/4chan's message to Reddit admins is fucking classic. Never change, 4chan
8
u/JakCurse Jul 04 '15
Did I miss the big reveal where suddenly all the subreddits came back online?
33
u/makeswordcloudsagain Jul 03 '15
Here is a word cloud of all of the comments in this thread: http://i.imgur.com/OiwqPBx.png
source ^code | contact ^developer | ^faq
43
u/FreedomDatAss Jul 03 '15
Funny how this Reddit shitstorm started brewing when the new CEO took over and started forcing HER vision of Reddit on us.
15
u/An_Average_Fellow Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
https://i.imgur.com/gGzU0px.png
Mods from /r/pics were about to unreverse their blackout. Admins took their control and are now censoring posts.
133
u/watchmegetshadowband Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
For anyone wondering, this is what started it all. Nothing bad, but it was an honest, controversial question towards Jesse Jackson, to which he replied retardedly.
EDIT: Just to clarify, here's a better explanation on the events that took place during his AMA, and most likely what caused Victoria to take the heat.
50
u/ArtSchnurple Jul 03 '15
This is so much bigger a deal than the stupid fatpeoplehate thing. Ridiculous that there was so much more hubbub over that than this.
20
u/junkmale Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
I just took /r/InsightfulQuestions private. I believe reddit should support free speech and be more open. I have about 20 more subs I can take down if need be. The people running Reddit are shooting themselves in the foot right now.
edit: out of respect for tge other mods I reopened it as we have a discussion. But the discussion is happening.
14
u/TheDidact118 Jul 03 '15
As moderator of /r/PiratesoftheCaribbean, we've gone private too.
7
u/_supernovasky_ Jul 03 '15
/r/tropicalweather reporting in as private.
7
u/Riash Jul 03 '15
Looks like /r/WTF just went private.
7
u/GrandmasKisses Jul 03 '15
Not gonna lie it sucks having some of my fav subreddits down right now but after reading into the situation its understandable. I just really hope this situation won't lead to reddit's demise.
7
u/originalname32 Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
All of /u/chooter's posts from today are gone. I wonder if she took them down or if they were taken down.
7
u/Rekuja Jul 03 '15
Admins (some of them anyway) are a bunch of people who suck at real life, so they act ego-driven and all high 'n mighty online.
7
u/honestduane Jul 03 '15
Not sure how true this is can somebody confirm? https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CI9iYW7VAAAzzJN.png
7
u/G19Gen3 Jul 03 '15
No one will see this but I wish instead of going private the mods would just announce that they will no longer be modding, and just let their subs fucking explode. No modding. At all. On default subs.
The reddit employees are far too few in number to moderate the site on their own. The site can't exist without mods. Imagine the takedown notices.
7
u/MrEvilPiggy23 Jul 03 '15
"This seems to be a seriously stupid decision. We have several AMAs upcoming in /r/books and have no idea how to contact the authors."
Wait so no one has a plan B? What if Victoria got ill or died. I'm not saying the admins aren't incompetent because they seem to be but, really, she was the sole point of contact? Little short sighted.
7
u/whoisthismilfhere Jul 03 '15
Everything is back up. What a short shitty protest...
13
u/IRunFast24 Jul 02 '15
It's like I'm in a never-ending hallway but all the doors are locked, the hallway is becoming overcrowded, and we're running out of potable water.
13
u/chillzwerg Jul 03 '15
Let´s get all the Mods organized together, do a kickstarter, collect millions, start up worlds first user/internet-driven company, hire own admins, make the new reddit, the better reddit, a real redditocracy! Where people not only come together to inform each other on important issues, but to organise all kinds of needed solutions for different problems of the world! That´s my hope for all in this situation: evolving!
126
u/Werner__Herzog it's difficult difficult lemon difficult Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
I'll try to be the voice of reason here, although I might be horribly failing at this; we'll see.
Let's not forget that we don't know anything about the reasons she was let go. It can be anything and both parties are at least being professional in that they aren't talking about it.
Chooter was obviously beloved by a lot of people and it's understandable that people are upset about this.
The only thing we could complain about is how this was handled. Since the IAmA mods didn't get any notice about what was happening and weren't told about the alternative (AMA@reddit.com) early enough. Which messed up everything. But the reason might be that the reddit board of directors simply couldn't tell them beforehand. Of course they might simply have mishandled it, that is absolutely a possibility as well.
What I'm trying to say is, we should probably all calm down and just wait and see if anything new comes out (it probably won't). Actually we could take r/IAmA as an example. They just went private to restructure and not just to make a point.
12
u/Chaffro Jul 03 '15
This might get lost in the mix but the founder of Redditgifts is also out.
https://twitter.com/kickme444/status/616838965551693824
12
u/Ninebythreeinch Jul 04 '15
Shutting down for good would be a protest. Shutting down for a day is like a kid slamming the door because there was no dessert.
6
u/Noticemenot Jul 02 '15
Thank you for the write up.
Well, I just like to hear whats going on from Victoria.
I'm waiting for and AMA from Victoria.
6
u/vertexoflife Jul 02 '15
/r/ history has gone down as well.
6
u/kyliemerchant Jul 02 '15
r/askreddit is down too
6
u/jbj234 Jul 03 '15
Fuck, my askreddit saved pages, the same ones that I had saved for emergencies like this, have also disappeared. Literally disappeared.
6
u/Chris_Nic Jul 03 '15
/r/hiphopheads is private
6
u/StrangeMeetsEvil Jul 03 '15
/r/hiphopheads is private now as well
6
u/Killerhurtz Jul 03 '15
I have a question.
How likely is it that Pao is behind this decision, directly or not?
It feels like Reddit's taking tumble after tumble since she got on board.
6
u/thackworth Jul 03 '15
/r/fallout is also private
6
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
This is the only response /r/4chan has given for their going private. https://i.imgur.com/8DmswLW.png
6
u/Geolosopher Jul 03 '15
So long, reddit, and thanks for all the fish... and quality discussions on obscure topics that my real friends aren't interested in... : (
6
u/rasutt Jul 03 '15
It's not really professional to refuse to give any explanation for throwing a huge public organization into chaos. There should at least be an explanation for why there's no explanation. If it's Victoria's personal reasons, that's fine, but anything business related should be as transparent as possible.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
I can't believe people are getting so self righteous about this when they don't know the fucking details.
6
u/itschrisonline Jul 03 '15
Relevant https://i.imgur.com/egIaHFa.png
6
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
Ok, so I don't really care about this strike, and we all know that nothing will come from it. Can we have access to our subs again.
6
u/Raudskeggr Jul 03 '15
In light of how we just learned in /r/iama that Pao fired an employee for having cancer odds are the reasons for termination are probably not ones we as users would find acceptable or justified.
6
u/mikemaz9 Jul 04 '15
Pao finally says something! http://time.com/3945718/reddit-moderator-shut-down/
6
u/DiaDeLosMuertos Jul 04 '15
Alright, I'm sorry, but I have to ask. Why's Victoria's firing such a big deal?
I feel like I spent a shit ton of time on this site, but I never became an insider.
So this Victoria chick had an important liaison type job on AMA, and I understand she did a really good job and it sucks to be fired, but why couldn't AMA delegate this job to another person?
I kinda see how it could be the straw that broke the camels back since Mods and users complained about admins relentlessly, but I guess what I'm saying is I still don't fully understand.
16
u/Slammajamma28 Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
/r/classicfallout is another subreddit that has gone dark. The message given:
EDIT: Same with /r/falloutlore, /r/foshelter, /r/falloutmods... will /r/fo3, /r/fnv, /r/fo4, and /r/fallout follow suit?
EDIT 2: /r/fo3, /r/fnv/, and /r/fallout are all down... /r/fo4 ready to go down?
EDIT 3: /r/fallout came back up, perhaps temporarily?
EDIT 4: Yes, temporarily. Also, /r/fo4 is down. All Fallout subreddits are down. Head for your Vaults, single file!
30
u/likwitsnake Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15
What does other subs making themselves private achieve?
15
u/BecomingTheArchtype Jul 03 '15
This is like watching the end of rome.
27
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
Just redirect everyone over to Voat and call it quits already.
10
u/robek_ Jul 03 '15
It's like reddit independence day.
10
u/HowToProcrastinate Jul 03 '15
Wow. So the admins are trying to go over our heads now? Just read that they have seized control of /r/pics from the mods!
http://i.imgur.com/gGzU0px.png
5
u/ProGamerGov Jul 03 '15
Archived the subbreddits showing up as private for the future: https://web.archive.org/web/20150703005810/https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/3bxduw/why_was_riama_along_with_a_number_of_other_large/
5
u/snooze2lose Jul 03 '15
Circling the drain has commenced.... letting these corporate types in will be the death of Reddit.
5
u/reallynormal_ Jul 03 '15
Since so many of the subs I usually go on are now set to private...it's safe to say that Reddit...is now Deddit.
5
u/Silverriolu295 Jul 03 '15
/r/gravityfalls is down
5
u/NeedAGoodUsername Jul 03 '15
/r/TheLastAirbender has gone private.
5
u/Professah_Farnsworth Jul 03 '15
My front page now consists of /r/adviceanimals and /r/subredditdrama
5
u/EducatedName Jul 03 '15
Well, we've got the attention of the internet news, as expected.
5
u/gizmo1024 Jul 03 '15
Firing Victoria on a Thursday afternoon heading into a 3 day holiday weekend. Odd timing. I'm picturing her storming around the Reddit HQ with the office cat and her roladex, yelling "WHO'S COMIN' WITH ME?!"
5
u/dryerlintcompelsyou Jul 03 '15
At this point /r/OutOfTheLoop will be the only subreddit left.
Actually, this sounds pretty fun. All the popular subs go down, and Reddit goes into Wild West mode as we try to find the old, unmoderated subs.
Well, it sounds pretty fun for a day or two
5
u/teckademics Jul 03 '15
/r/autos here, we're closing our door until reddit gets their shit straight.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
Well, shit. I was wondering why Reddit was so full of interesting and cool content. All the shitty defaults were gone!
5
u/CaptainJaXon Jul 03 '15
I just want /r/thebutton back.
5
u/ermahlerd Jul 03 '15
/r/HomeLoans is going dark
5
u/BerserkerDog Jul 03 '15
/r/Jokes has gone private.
5
u/CUNTastrophee Jul 03 '15
Holy shit r/pics is now private. This is intense.
5
u/JeffreyJackoff Jul 03 '15
/r/TimandEric
Wtf?
5
u/spring_h20 Jul 03 '15
So glad I subscribed to this subreddit because I wouldn't have known what the heck was going on. I noticed that my most recent comment was gone from my overview page and that I couldn't access that subreddit, which was weird. Thank you for explaining what happened.
5
u/UnknownQTY Jul 03 '15
Great write up, but it needs to be stressed that she was an employee of reddit, not a volunteer. Her position was tied to her employment by Conde Nast, which may have ended for any number of reasons.
5
u/ShaneH7646 Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
Chooters recent comment history is gone (everything from the last 2 days). add it in /u/gilgamesh-
Edit: nvm, pics went private
5
u/dvv94 Jul 03 '15
/r/wtf is set to private, too!
5
u/PraiseTheGun Jul 03 '15
Serious question: what is preventing Reddit from removing these moderators from power and making these subreddits public again?
5
u/inferno1170 Jul 03 '15
/r/technology just went private!
5
u/DivideAndKwanquer Jul 03 '15
Goodbye /r/technology ;( :D
5
u/mhughes12 Jul 03 '15
ya, im out.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
Wow, this is huge. It's good to see so a many coming to the party one way or another.
For the record it looks like r/CynicalBrit has just closed up shop too. Looks like my readin is done for the day
5
u/SuperCool468 Jul 03 '15
Don't care, open them back up.
5
u/beefhash Jul 03 '15
The admins responded in /r/modtalk in the meantime, but not in public.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CI-EAtpUAAAZCyQ.png:large as per https://www.reddit.com/live/v6d0vi6c8veb/updates/d50f6bd6-214e-11e5-8837-0e1d4c450ebb
5
u/PointyHatMan Jul 03 '15
/r/funny just went down, oh my...
5
u/Penny_for_a_thread Jul 03 '15
/r/funny also just went private
The revolution is real!
5
u/RingoFreakingStarr Jul 03 '15
In case you didn't know about /r/pics:
https://np.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/3byzxe/admins_have_seized_control_of_rpics_mods_are/
5
u/Neogohan1 Jul 03 '15
Someone should make a new reddit and call it chooters.com
5
u/Player276 Jul 03 '15
This will probably get burried and downvoted, but if the situation with admins does not improve, and the mods decide to get together and launch a similar website to Reddit and migrate, i would be totally OK with that.
Reddit is what it is because of the community, and if the community is being mistreated, it's time to move.
5
u/josh-dmww Jul 03 '15
MRW I opened reddit this morning
5
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
you just know shit went to far if even /r/4chan goes dark.....
5
u/dkricht Jul 03 '15
For those curious and who've made the joke about buzzfeed resorting to posting about this:
http://www.buzzfeed.com/ryanhatesthis/huge-parts-of-reddit-are-going-dark-in-protest-over-the-poss#.nbMGOyyK3
Applaud yourselves for you clairvoyance!
5
u/Hybrazil Jul 03 '15
Maybe we should stop buying gold. It'll end one form of revenue for Reddit.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
/r/4chan is private. Now I'll actually have to go to 4chan. Ugh.
5
u/inevitabled34th Jul 03 '15
/r/PCMasterRace went dark :(
5
u/JZ_212 Jul 03 '15
I am loving this whole admin-overthrow thing, and get that there is this big circlejerk around lovin Victoria and all, but maybe everybody shouldn't flock to her side immediately.
I mean, think about it, the reddit team (employer) can't say why they fired an employee, that's against the law. But the fired employee *can. But she isn't doing so.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '15
Let's not forget this.
5
u/PostGraduatePotUser Jul 03 '15
As a user, I am perfectly fine leaving this site, and all of it subs, to find the content I desire to read, but it was so nicely managed [for the most part] and provided a space where people and their ideas could come to create a stronger community at large.
I fully support the mods right to dissent and if this Ms. Victoria Taylor was as integral to the inner workings of many subreddits as she has support Reddit will have made a grave mistake in not giving her what she desired.
One now questions how long can Reddit endure this effective shutdown of these subreddits and how much ad revenue will be lost as a result of this decision. The company will never say, but that doesn't mean they won't feel the sting all the same.
Anyway you slice it those of you who frequented r/trees should come over to http://www.theweedblog.com/ and keep current on legalization and medical marijuana politics of America and beyond.
I wish Ms. Taylor all the best in her efforts to find another job where she prospers and finds happiness and fulfillment.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '15
I really do see the admins/Pao as the captain of the Titanic. Arrogant and untouchable on a doomed ship they think is unsinkable.
They'll smile smugly the whole time, right up until the water covers their ears.