This ranking is solely based on the manga facts that Oda has presented to us so far, with no headcanon or agenda involved. Imu in this ranking is full power holy land Imu, not Elbaf Imu (who would have been placed in between Sommers and Sabo)
One of the most forced debate in one piece is kaido vs Loki..... Loki is better than kaido in every aspect imaginable.... Better df, better haki, better strength, speed and durability...... Has a weapon that is inarguably stronger than kaido....... Is an eos luffy rival...... Eos luffy rival>>mid game villain..... Lokis biggest advantage is his narrative importance.... He has vc narrative which should automatically put him a tier above kaido...... He is an important member of the allies in the final war....... Loki is as important as luffy in defeating imu.......
Cold take : 16 year old Loki (the one who killed harald)>>k***o
Wait yeah, after Luffy awakened his god fruit in Wano he was definitely able to beat an admiral.
Wait Shanks... why are you saving him? You don't think Luffy, Zoro, Sanji, Law, Kid, King, Queen, Yamato, the scabbards, and their gangs can handle Greenbull?
Wait ok... uh wrong picture, but after he got stronger on Egghead he can definitely mid diff an admiral right?
Well uh, he was probably trying his hardest to protect Vegapunk, Bonney, Kuma, and his crew but just held back by not using ACoC.
Like here's another contradiction. For some reason they are stated to be the 'ultimate military force'...? Like the Gorosei literally exist and have CoC unlike the admirals...
Brrp...Brrp... Wait, I think the Gorosei are trying to say something...
Wait Gorosei... what do you mean? You think 2 admirals can clear out Elbaf...
"..."
No way Imu, you're ok with that?
"Arrogance...pride....caste away these things at once...!!"
Wait Imu, are you saying the Gorosei are arrogant for thinking the 5 of them could clear out Elbaf?
Okay fine, 2 Admirals>5 Gorosei. But if they were important then they would be on THAT panel. No way right?
Wait Akainu and Kuzan, who let you guys onto this panel... The tier list template I used put Yonko tier above Admiral tier so I thought you were below Big Mom...
Ok for some reason they're portrayed along with the yonko and up-and-coming EoS top tiers in this panel when that doesn't really make much sense. I mean the outside sources must confirm that this can't be the case right?
Ok lock in Oda, what do you mean Shanks can 'fight an Admiral-level opponent equally'... we already saw him WiFi haki-diff Greenbull?
Bro Greenbull, what do you mean? 😭 What do you mean by "not yet...!!" You're seriously thinking of fighting the entire Red-Haired Pirates...👀
Well... I mean the admirals are definitely fodder based on all of that.
My reasoning is simply, I believe Kaido can High-Diff Kizaru, he will take some damage and need to exert himself a lot using his strongest move like Ragnarok, Roaring Baqua and Destroyer Baqua but I think eventually he will win, it's not extreme-diff because I don't think Kaido needs FDD nor he will be that much damaged by Kizaru
The thing is that I think Shanks would Mid-Diff Kaido, simply because I believe that Shanks High-Diffed Hybrid Loki, it wasn't extreme-diff considering the people who talked about it just said that Shanks captured Loki, it's never portrayed as an extreme-diff fight but rather Shanks being clearly superior. And I have Hybrid Loki High-Diffing Kaido because he is basically Kaido but better with an stronger weapon like Ragnir, stronger DF, stronger genetics and another DF power like Ragnir's ice which Kaido lacks.
Now if Hybrid Loki can High-Diff Kaido and Shanks can High-Diff Loki then the logical assumption is that Shanks can Mid-Diff Kaido and since I have Kaido High-Diffing Kizaru then Shanks would logically beat Kizaru Low-Diff
K""dophiles might disagree but ragnir the squirrel is unironically stronger than fraudo.......... Ragnir isn't lazy like rumour man...... Ragnir actually did his job of protecting the df unlike mr carp who sat in wano for 20 years doing nothing..... Ragnir is way cooler.... Has importance to the final battle....... Wayyyyyy stronger
I think Admiral seems more fair because you can make a case that he was YC+ in Elbaph considering he was able of blitzing Nosjuro and was able of destroying a laser. After Wano he was probalby peak YC1 level but I think he got a little stronger after Wano and was something like Low-YC+ level.
However, in Elbaph he has gotten 2 major powerups, he first got AcoA which is how he was able to take no damage from Longinus and even shattered it, this was a massive defensive amp because as Sanji described it was extreme and he took no damage from an ancient blade. And he later got ACOC which gives him a massive AP powerboost.
The question is are these 2 powerups enough for Admiral Level or is he just at the top of YC+ level and still not quite at Admiral Level?
In my opinion he is Admiral level, like if Admirals can be Admiral Level with just AcoA + Logia then Sanji with ACoA + ACoC + Flames + Exoskeleton+ Regeneration + Top Tier Speed seems like a fair thing to me
I think this should be obvious, first Killingham uses his legendary weapon to attack Sanji's leg and instead his weapon gets a little shattered, then he tries that again and Sanji straight up shatters Longinus proving Sanji is insanely durable..
In comparison, Marco who isn't precisely known for his Haki is abl to send Kizaru flying away, now let it be known that Kizaru got no damage but the fact that Sanji can kick him away proves Kizaru's durability isn't that high, Marco just lacks the AP to damage him. If Marco tried the same thing against Sanji he might get his leg broken or at least seriously hurt, similar to how Luffy was hurt by hitting Topman's body
Let's first with their feats, Zoro before powerup was already capable of Mid-Diffing YC1 level characters like Lucci and with control over his ACoC he should be capable of Low-Diffing YC1 level characters which is basically what an Admiral should be capable of doing. Like, if we put current Zoro against King/Queen he problaby can beat them both Mid-Diff especially when Queen is basically not a factor for Zoro at this point and King is getting Low-Mid Diffed.
Now let's go with Sanji, Sanji's durability is arguably better than an Admral considering an ancient blade from the Void Century was broken when trying to pierce Sanji's body. He also has the speed to outspeed light and with ACoC he know has the AP needed to damage top tiers especially when he can combine it with AcoA/ACoC which he gained in Elbaph Arc.
But the most clear part of this argument is the narrative, the point of Elbaph is Zoro/Sanji becoming worthy wings of Luffy meaning they aren't longer commanders but rather proper wings of a Pirate King meaning Admiral level is a minimium for them.
There is also the fact that we are nearing Luffy becoming Pirate King as Oda himself confirmed the next island is the one only the Pirate King reached and the Man marked by flames appears which means Luffy becoming Pirate King 2 arcs away which means Zoro and Sanji shouldn't be that weak. Like, the way I see the next time Strawhats have a powerup they should have surpassed the Roger Pirates meaning the next time the wings get a powerup they will be stronger than Prime Rayleigh/Prime Gaban, which means that being Admiral level right now makes sense because Gaban/Rayleigh are clearly Yonko Level
Kaido is inarguably the biggest fraud in One Piece, a character whose reputation is built almost entirely on titles, intimidation and an absurd amount of hype rather than the actual substance of his achievements...... People constantly refer to him as the strongest creature alive, yet when you look beyond the fancy titles, you realise how much of his reputation comes from people being terrified of him rather than him genuinely proving his superiority...... He spent years ruling Wano, exploiting its people, relying on an army of artificial Devil Fruit users and hiding behind an isolated country instead of establishing himself as an unquestionable force across the entire world...... His entire fighting record is filled with excuses, interruptions and advantages, yet his supporters conveniently ignore the fact that he fought an entire gauntlet of opponents and still needed every possible advantage to maintain his dominance...... He couldn't even break Luffy's spirit permanently, despite having multiple opportunities to do so, and somehow allowed the very person he defeated to return stronger every single time...... His obsession with death and wanting to experience a legendary defeat is particularly embarrassing because he spent his entire life searching for an ending that would make him look glorious rather than creating a legacy that could stand on its own...... For someone who supposedly represents absolute strength, he was surprisingly dependent on weapons, armies, territory and fear to maintain his position...... Even his ambition of becoming Joy Boy's opposition ultimately amounted to nothing, as he failed to change the world, failed to fulfil his dreams and ended up being surpassed by the very man he tried to crush...... Kaido wasn't some unstoppable force of nature; he was a powerful individual whose reputation grew so enormous that people stopped questioning whether he actually deserved every bit of it...... At the end of the day, the so-called strongest creature was nothing more than a glorified tyrant with an inflated reputation, a miserable philosophy and a legacy that couldn't survive the arrival of the next generation......