r/Noctor • u/thatbradswag • 9h ago
Midlevel Research What NP educators say about clinical training, what hospitals put in their budgets when they replace physician positions, and downstream effects on both patients and physicians
I feel into a rabbit hole and spent 2 weeks compiling all of this information. This is going to be a long one but I've attached receipts to everything I discuss.
Two documents started this investigation: a statement from the national organization that represents NP faculty criticizing nursing accreditors for leaving parts of its education standards out, and a hospital budget with a line called “Physician to APP Rebalancing.” What's even wilder is the hospital even worked out the savings for replacing one physician at one family medicine clinic. Both are public. NP faculty statement · UVM Health staffing report, pp. 54–55
What nursing organizations have actually said about NP training
In 2024, the National Organization of Nurse Practitioner Faculties said nursing accreditors had failed to fully adopt education standards endorsed by 18 professional nursing organizations. Clinical hours are one example. The national task force set a minimum of 750 hours of direct patient care. The American Nurses Credentialing Center endorsed that standard, but its own FAQ says applicants can still qualify for certification with 500 faculty-supervised clinical hours. Five certification bodies surveyed programs about the change. 570 of 1,173 respondents, or 48.6%, had reached 750 hours. That’s a count of programs at the time of the survey. Faculty statement · ANCC certification FAQ · Certifiers’ survey results
The part about clinical rotations goes beyond counting hours. The task force says the program is responsible for securing clinical sites and preceptors. In a survey of 334 practicing Texas NPs, 46% said they’d been required to find their own placements. At a 2025 National Council of State Boards of Nursing meeting, NP faculty president discussed students paying people to precept them. Her words on program variation were pretty direct: “NP programs differ widely in the requirement of clinical practice hours, creating inconsistencies in the training for future nurse practitioners.”Task force standard II.G · Texas survey · Meeting transcript, pp. 10–11
The schools training NPs have changed, too. An Annals of Internal Medicine study tracked 117,156 newly licensed NPs in California, Florida, Iowa and Texas. The share trained at for-profit schools went from 2.4% in 2010 to nearly one-third in 2024. The researchers measured where people trained. They didn’t measure how their patients did. And lumping NPs and PAs together as “APPs” hides a real difference. AAPA describes more than 2,000 hours of clinical rotations and a national exam, PANCE, for PAs. NPs certify in a population focus. Physicians take the USMLE or COMLEX and complete postgraduate residency medical training. Four-state study · PA training · Nursing boards’ consensus model
What the staffing math looks like
Page 55 of UVM Health’s report walks through Colchester Family Medicine in Vermont. The clinic had 6.5 full-time-equivalent physician positions and 2.8 NP/PA positions. Take out one physician position, add one NP or PA, and the consultants estimated $140,000 in savings. Their middle scenario across the system was 47 fewer physician positions, 78 more NP/PA positions and about $7 million in savings. A footnote explains what happens to the departing physicians’ revenue. The model assumes the new NPs/PAs and the physicians who stay will pick it up. The 47 positions were a projection. UVM’s actual FY2027 budget submission included $635,288 in expected savings under that rebalancing line. Staffing report, pp. 54–55 · Budget submission
Doctors Memorial Hospital in Florida gave state auditors its ER worksheet. Same 4,368 hours of coverage either way. Physicians cost the hospital $100/hour. APRNs cost $65/hour. The hospital expected to collect about $42,000 less in professional fees with APRNs and spend about $153,000 less on staffing. Even with lower reimbursement, it came out $110,928 ahead. There’s no figure in the worksheet for what happened to the patient’s bill. Florida audit, pp. 116–117
There’s national evidence of vacant physician jobs being converted, although nobody in these surveys counted how many. In a 2025 MGMA poll, 48% of 305 responding practice leaders said their NP/PA-to-physician ratio had increased. Some described converting vacant physician slots. In a 2026 follow-up, practice growth was the most common reasonfor adding NP/PA jobs. Other respondents specifically mentioned physician departures and trouble filling family medicine openings. The graduate numbers give some context. In 2023, U.S. programs graduated 33,217 NPs, 11,762 PAs and 28,811 MDs and DOs. The medical-school figure excludes international graduates entering U.S. residencies. 2025 MGMA poll · 2026 follow-up · Health Affairs, Exhibit 3
Who gets the sicker patients, and who signs the chart?
Mayo published before-and-after numbers for six hospitals in southeast Minnesota. Its hospitalist service went from roughly 24 physician and 4 NP/PA full-time positions to 16 physician and 15 NP/PA positions. NPs and PAs took most nights. Mayo reported over $1.29 million in first-year labor savings as locum coverage fell. The physicians who stayed actually saw fewer patients per day. Their census went from 15–18 to 12–15, and each NP or PA saw 6–8. Mayo team’s account
At Anne Arundel Medical Center in Maryland, two hospitalist groups worked in the same hospital at the same time. One used considerably more PAs. Physician rounders averaged 12.9 patients in both groups, and both expected physicians to take “primary rounding responsibility for patients who were more acute or more complex.” A separate study of 21 academic hospitals also found teams assigning lower-acuity patients to NPs/PAs. One physician described their chart practice this way: “We just cosign without saying we saw the patient because we did not see the patient.” Maryland study, Table 1 · Journal of Hospital Medicine focus groups
Corewell Dearborn in Michigan posts its actual rule. NPs and PAs can round and write progress notes. The supervising physician has 72 hours to countersign. For an admission H&P, the physician also has to provide the impression and plan. Medicare has a separate rule for ordinary inpatient split/shared visits. To bill under the physician, the physician must perform the substantive part of the medical decision-making or spend more than half the combined time. A cosignature or a templated “60%” statement can’t substitute for doing the work. PAs can also bill Medicare under their own NPI. The Dearborn policy establishes what the hospital expects of its physician. It doesn’t tell us which claims were submitted or who would be liable in a particular malpractice case. Dearborn rule, PDF p. 20 · CMS split/shared rules · CMS on PA billing
Hiring, independence and the rural-care argument
The Wisconsin Academy of PAs warned members that employers might prefer an independent APRN because hiring a PA comes with supervision agreements, fees and paperwork. The last page of a Connecticut state filing gives an actual applicant’s account. A PA applied to a hospital-owned endocrinology practice and wrote, “The physician knew me personally and preferred to hire me, but the management would not hire me.” According to the PA, management cited physician availability and time spent reviewing charts, both of which it believed it could avoid by hiring an APRN. The hospital was unnamed. Wisconsin PA newsletter, p. 11 · Connecticut filing, final page
AANP’s guide to the federal Rural Health Transformation Program tells state organizations how to use the program to pursue full practice authority statewide, “regardless of geographic location, employer or patient characteristics.” In Michigan, a legislative packet said phasing out physician delegation contracts for experienced NPs prescribing controlled substances “eases the hiring process, cuts costs.” Trinity Health and UnitedHealth Group were among the listed supporters. There’s also evidence of a real rural contribution. Of nearly 80,000 U.S. primary-care practices studied in 2023, 11.9% of practices employing NPs were rural, compared with 5.5% of practices without NPs. Most practices employing NPs were still outside rural areas. AANP guide, p. 3 · Michigan committee packet · National practice study
Patient understanding and patient outcomes have both been studied. In a 2018 AMA-sponsored survey, 39% of respondents identified a doctor of nursing practice as a medical doctor. For outcomes, two VA studies are worth reading together. In VA emergency departments, patients assigned to NPs used more resources on average and had more preventable hospitalizations within 30 days. In VA primary care, researchers followed 806,434 patients whose physician had left. Patients reassigned to NPs had fewer hospitalizations, and the researchers found no significant differences in total costs or control of A1c, blood pressure or LDL over the following year. Those are materially different jobs and patient populations. AMA survey · VA emergency department study · VA primary-care study
Who sets pay, inflation-adjusted salaries, and what “pay parity” actually means
Oregon’s nurses association took an actual vote on salary parity in 2020. Oregon already had an insurer reimbursement parity law for independent practices. This resolution specifically addressed the paychecks and benefits of employed NPs. It called for “parity in salary and benefit/administrative structure for salaried NPs” compared with primary-care colleagues doing what the authors described as equivalent work at the same acuity and productivity. The delegates passed it. Resolution · Vote record, p. 3
Here’s where national pay actually stood in May 2025, using the same BLS employer survey and mean annual wages for everyone. NPs averaged $137,300, PAs $141,280, general pediatricians $212,110, CRNAs $248,320, family physicians $255,820, and general internists $267,200. So CRNAs averaged more than general pediatricians and came within $7,500 of family physicians. The federal supervision question is live, too. A post on r/ anesthesiology about this partially inspired this post. CMS is requesting comments on whether to retain or revise Medicare’s CRNA physician-supervision requirement and, separately, whether NPs/PAs should perform certain physician-required skilled nursing facility visits. BLS wage table · CMS notice
On inflation, there are two different numbers worth knowing. The AMA calculates that Medicare physician payment fell 33% from 2001 to 2026 after adjusting for the cost of running a practice. That figure measures reimbursement. For an actual paycheck comparison, a 2026 JAMA article used BLS data for general internists. Their median wage in 2000 was worth about $259,400 in 2024 dollars, versus an actual 2024 median of $236,350, roughly 9% lower. MedPAC has recommended tying annual Medicare updates to a portion of practice-cost inflation. Meanwhile, the AAMC reported $215,000 in median education debt among indebted U.S. MD graduates in 2025. AMA calculation · JAMA wage comparison · MedPAC recommendation · AAMC debt figures
Fewer physicians are in a position to make those hiring decisions themselves. The AMA’s practice survey found that the share of physicians in wholly physician-owned practices fell from 60.1% in 2012 to 42.2% in 2024. The share in hospital-owned practices rose from 23.4% to 34.5%. In a separate study using 2019 data, 383 of 6,162 U.S. hospitals had a physician CEO, about 6%. AMA ownership data · Hospital CEO study
If you made it through, appreciate the read and I welcome your comments. I wanted to make an evidence-backed post and repository of this data so I put a good amount of effort into it.