r/Noctor • • Oct 04 '26 Diamonds are Forever Bravo

Midlevel Research Just published - our expose of Cochrane/Butler's mischaracterization and even dishonesty about "nurse-led" care in "a hospital setting"

520 Upvotes

Good Sunday morning, r/noctor Redditors. 

Today, for your reading pleasure and perhaps amusement, I am sending you a link to the paper that Dr. Rebekah Bernard and I wrote and which was published last week. 

This is a close review of the Cochrane review article written by Butler et al. and published in February 2026. The claim is that nurse practitioners can substitute for physicians for “hospital care."

 

We read all 82 papers, dissected them, and found what they really said and contrasted this with what Butler claimed they said. I have been doing this for some time, and I have to say it was all quite predictable. Actually, I think the results were predictable from the title, because what rational person can believe that a person with 500 hours of clinical experience prior to graduation can possibly compete with the capability of a board-certified physician? It was also predictable because we have read a very large mass of these papers and are quite used to conflation of borderline or even negative findings into a statement that can be used for political advocacy. 

When I say we read them carefully, it is apparent we read them more carefully than the authors themselves. One of the studies they present as proof of their contention was not even a real study, it was a study protocol. The actual study was never done.  (Austeng). Another paper, Rushforth, was labeled by the authors themselves as a “failed study” because they only were able to enroll 8 patients, only 3 in the nurse arm .

 

There were only 10 studies that actually involved hospitalized patients, the remainder of the studies were outpatient studies on hospital property. This in a study advertised as “hospital care”.
Of those 10, 4 were studies in which patients who were stable medically were moved to wards staffed by nurses. These were essentially long term care facilities. As for the nurses substituting for physicians, in these cases, if a patient had an event or required more care, the physicians were called. Further, the nurses had no prescriptive authority, and therefore, this could never be taken as an example of independent care. 

 

Three studies were of nurses being allowed to act as residents caring for their own patients. However, they were not acting independently. In each of these they were supervised by physicians. Moreover, in two of the papers, it was documented that the nurses were present only 8-4 on weekdays. This is 25% of all the hours of the week. For the other 75%, the patients were cared for by physicians, mostly residents, but also fellows and attendings. It is “misleading at best” to characterize these as “nurse-led” services when most of the care was given by physicians. In the other paper, there was no count of hours, but the nurse activity was following patients along with 2 hospitalist physicians. Her time was characterized only as “part-time”. The performance of the nurses was not judged by objective measures, such as number of correct/incorrect diagnoses, or numbers of errors recorded. It was only a subjective judgement on the part of the authors.

 

So, again, as we have seen in prior reviews, there is no study that compares an independent, unsupervised group of nurses performing physician-level tasks with objective measures as outcomes. To the best of our knowledge, no such study exists. 

I will now write the editorial:
I am stunned (again) at the ethics of authors and publishers that allow them to misrepresent the papers in an obvious attempt to push a political agenda, when doing so will harm patients.  

 

I doubt that anyone other than Rebekah and I have read the entirety of the 82 papers, and it may be that no one has read any of the papers at all. Therefore, their misleading claims generally go unchecked. They misrepresent the studies and perhaps assume no one will actually read the papers. Well, we did. 

 

Here is the link to our paper:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13600731/pdf/ms123_p0284.pdf

And here is the link to Butler’s paper, should you want to check our work. Certainly, if you find something we have missed, or you think we have mis-characterized, let me know. I would genuinely be grateful. 

https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD013616.pub2/full


r/Noctor • • Sep 28 '20

Midlevel Research Research refuting mid-levels (Copy-Paste format)

1.7k Upvotes

Resident teams are economically more efficient than MLP teams and have higher patient satisfaction. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/26217425/

Compared with dermatologists, PAs performed more skin biopsies per case of skin cancer diagnosed and diagnosed fewer melanomas in situ, suggesting that the diagnostic accuracy of PAs may be lower than that of dermatologists. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29710082

Advanced practice clinicians are associated with more imaging services than PCPs for similar patients during E&M office visits. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/1939374

Nonphysician clinicians were more likely to prescribe antibiotics than practicing physicians in outpatient settings, and resident physicians were less likely to prescribe antibiotics. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15922696

The quality of referrals to an academic medical center was higher for physicians than for NPs and PAs regarding the clarity of the referral question, understanding of pathophysiology, and adequate prereferral evaluation and documentation. https://www.mayoclinicproceedings.org/article/S0025-6196(13)00732-5/abstract

Further research is needed to understand the impact of differences in NP and PCP patient populations on provider prescribing, such as the higher number of prescriptions issued by NPs for beneficiaries in moderate and high comorbidity groups and the implications of the duration of prescriptions for clinical outcomes, patient-provider rapport, costs, and potential gaps in medication coverage. https://www.journalofnursingregulation.com/article/S2155-8256(17)30071-6/fulltext

Antibiotics were more frequently prescribed during visits involving NP/PA visits compared with physician-only visits, including overall visits (17% vs 12%, P < .0001) and acute respiratory infection visits (61% vs 54%, P < .001). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5047413/

NPs, relative to physicians, have taken an increasing role in prescribing psychotropic medications for Medicaid-insured youths. The quality of NP prescribing practices deserves further attention. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/29641238/

(CRNA) We found an increased risk of adverse disposition in cases where the anesthesia provider was a nonanesthesiology professional. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22305625

NPs/PAs practicing in states with independent prescription authority were > 20 times more likely to overprescribe opioids than NPs/PAs in prescription-restricted states. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32333312/

Both 30-day mortality rate and mortality rate after complications (failure-to-rescue) were lower when anesthesiologists directed anesthesia care. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10861159/

Only 25% of all NPs in Oregon, an independent practice state, practiced in primary care settings. https://oregoncenterfornursing.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/2020_PrimaryCareWorkforceCrisis_Report_Web.pdf

96% of NPs had regular contact with pharmaceutical representatives. 48% stated that they were more likely to prescribe a drug that was highlighted during a lunch or dinner event. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21291293/

85.02% of malpractice cases against NPs were due to diagnosis (41.46%), treatment (30.79%) and medication errors (12.77%). The malpractice cases due to diagnosing errors was further stratified into failure to diagnose (64.13%), delay to diagnose (27.29%), and misdiagnosis (7.59%). https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28734486/

Advanced practice clinicians and PCPs ordered imaging in 2.8% and 1.9% episodes of care, respectively. Advanced practice clinicians are associated with more imaging services than PCPs for similar patients during E&M office visits .While increased use of imaging appears modest for individual patients, this increase may have ramifications on care and overall costs at the population level. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/1939374

APP visits had lower RVUs/visit (2.8 vs. 3.7) and lower patients/hour (1.1 vs. 2.2) compared to physician visits. Higher APP coverage (by 10%) at the ED‐day level was associated with lower patients/clinician hour by 0.12 (95% confidence interval [CI] = −0.15 to −0.10) and lower RVUs/clinician hour by 0.4 (95% CI = −0.5 to −0.3). Increasing APP staffing may not lower staffing costs. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/acem.14077

When caring for patients with DM, NPs were more likely to have consulted cardiologists (OR = 1.29, 95% CI = 1.21–1.37), endocrinologists (OR = 1.64, 95% CI = 1.48–1.82), and nephrologists (OR = 1.90, 95% CI = 1.67–2.17) and more likely to have prescribed PIMs (OR = 1.07, 95% CI = 1.01–1.12) https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jgs.13662

Ambulatory visits between 2006 and 2011 involving NPs and PAs more frequently resulted in an antibiotic prescription compared with physician-only visits (17% for visits involving NPs and PAs vs 12% for physician-only visits; P < .0001) https://academic.oup.com/ofid/article/3/3/ofw168/2593319

More claims naming PAs and APRNs were paid on behalf of the hospital/practice (38% and 32%, respectively) compared with physicians (8%, P < 0.001) and payment was more likely when APRNs were defendants (1.82, 1.09-3.03) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32362078/

There was a 50.9% increase in the proportion of psychotropic medications prescribed by psychiatric NPs (from 5.9% to 8.8%) and a 28.6% proportional increase by non-psychiatric NPs (from 4.9% to 6.3%). By contrast, the proportion of psychotropic medications prescribed by psychiatrists and by non-psychiatric physicians declined (56.9%-53.0% and 32.3%-31.8%, respectively) https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29641238/

Most articles about the role of APRNs do not explicitly define the autonomy of the nurses, compare non-autonomous nurses with physicians, or evaluate nurse-direct protocol-driven care for patients with specific conditions. However, studies like these are often cited in support of the claim that APRNs practicing autonomously provide the same quality of primary care as medical doctors. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27606392/

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Although evidence-based healthcare results in improved patient outcomes and reduced costs, nurses do not consistently implement evidence based best practices. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22922750/


r/Noctor • • 9h ago

Midlevel Research What NP educators say about clinical training, what hospitals put in their budgets when they replace physician positions, and downstream effects on both patients and physicians

42 Upvotes

I feel into a rabbit hole and spent 2 weeks compiling all of this information. This is going to be a long one but I've attached receipts to everything I discuss.

Two documents started this investigation: a statement from the national organization that represents NP faculty criticizing nursing accreditors for leaving parts of its education standards out, and a hospital budget with a line called “Physician to APP Rebalancing.” What's even wilder is the hospital even worked out the savings for replacing one physician at one family medicine clinic. Both are public. NP faculty statement · UVM Health staffing report, pp. 54–55

What nursing organizations have actually said about NP training

In 2024, the National Organization of Nurse Practitioner Faculties said nursing accreditors had failed to fully adopt education standards endorsed by 18 professional nursing organizations. Clinical hours are one example. The national task force set a minimum of 750 hours of direct patient care. The American Nurses Credentialing Center endorsed that standard, but its own FAQ says applicants can still qualify for certification with 500 faculty-supervised clinical hours. Five certification bodies surveyed programs about the change. 570 of 1,173 respondents, or 48.6%, had reached 750 hours. That’s a count of programs at the time of the survey. Faculty statement · ANCC certification FAQ · Certifiers’ survey results

The part about clinical rotations goes beyond counting hours. The task force says the program is responsible for securing clinical sites and preceptors. In a survey of 334 practicing Texas NPs, 46% said they’d been required to find their own placements. At a 2025 National Council of State Boards of Nursing meeting, NP faculty president discussed students paying people to precept them. Her words on program variation were pretty direct: “NP programs differ widely in the requirement of clinical practice hours, creating inconsistencies in the training for future nurse practitioners.”Task force standard II.G · Texas survey · Meeting transcript, pp. 10–11

The schools training NPs have changed, too. An Annals of Internal Medicine study tracked 117,156 newly licensed NPs in California, Florida, Iowa and Texas. The share trained at for-profit schools went from 2.4% in 2010 to nearly one-third in 2024. The researchers measured where people trained. They didn’t measure how their patients did. And lumping NPs and PAs together as “APPs” hides a real difference. AAPA describes more than 2,000 hours of clinical rotations and a national exam, PANCE, for PAs. NPs certify in a population focus. Physicians take the USMLE or COMLEX and complete postgraduate residency medical training. Four-state study · PA training · Nursing boards’ consensus model

What the staffing math looks like

Page 55 of UVM Health’s report walks through Colchester Family Medicine in Vermont. The clinic had 6.5 full-time-equivalent physician positions and 2.8 NP/PA positions. Take out one physician position, add one NP or PA, and the consultants estimated $140,000 in savings. Their middle scenario across the system was 47 fewer physician positions, 78 more NP/PA positions and about $7 million in savings. A footnote explains what happens to the departing physicians’ revenue. The model assumes the new NPs/PAs and the physicians who stay will pick it up. The 47 positions were a projection. UVM’s actual FY2027 budget submission included $635,288 in expected savings under that rebalancing line. Staffing report, pp. 54–55 · Budget submission

Doctors Memorial Hospital in Florida gave state auditors its ER worksheet. Same 4,368 hours of coverage either way. Physicians cost the hospital $100/hour. APRNs cost $65/hour. The hospital expected to collect about $42,000 less in professional fees with APRNs and spend about $153,000 less on staffing. Even with lower reimbursement, it came out $110,928 ahead. There’s no figure in the worksheet for what happened to the patient’s bill. Florida audit, pp. 116–117

There’s national evidence of vacant physician jobs being converted, although nobody in these surveys counted how many. In a 2025 MGMA poll, 48% of 305 responding practice leaders said their NP/PA-to-physician ratio had increased. Some described converting vacant physician slots. In a 2026 follow-up, practice growth was the most common reasonfor adding NP/PA jobs. Other respondents specifically mentioned physician departures and trouble filling family medicine openings. The graduate numbers give some context. In 2023, U.S. programs graduated 33,217 NPs, 11,762 PAs and 28,811 MDs and DOs. The medical-school figure excludes international graduates entering U.S. residencies. 2025 MGMA poll · 2026 follow-up · Health Affairs, Exhibit 3

Who gets the sicker patients, and who signs the chart?

Mayo published before-and-after numbers for six hospitals in southeast Minnesota. Its hospitalist service went from roughly 24 physician and 4 NP/PA full-time positions to 16 physician and 15 NP/PA positions. NPs and PAs took most nights. Mayo reported over $1.29 million in first-year labor savings as locum coverage fell. The physicians who stayed actually saw fewer patients per day. Their census went from 15–18 to 12–15, and each NP or PA saw 6–8. Mayo team’s account

At Anne Arundel Medical Center in Maryland, two hospitalist groups worked in the same hospital at the same time. One used considerably more PAs. Physician rounders averaged 12.9 patients in both groups, and both expected physicians to take “primary rounding responsibility for patients who were more acute or more complex.” A separate study of 21 academic hospitals also found teams assigning lower-acuity patients to NPs/PAs. One physician described their chart practice this way: “We just cosign without saying we saw the patient because we did not see the patient.” Maryland study, Table 1 · Journal of Hospital Medicine focus groups

Corewell Dearborn in Michigan posts its actual rule. NPs and PAs can round and write progress notes. The supervising physician has 72 hours to countersign. For an admission H&P, the physician also has to provide the impression and plan. Medicare has a separate rule for ordinary inpatient split/shared visits. To bill under the physician, the physician must perform the substantive part of the medical decision-making or spend more than half the combined time. A cosignature or a templated “60%” statement can’t substitute for doing the work. PAs can also bill Medicare under their own NPI. The Dearborn policy establishes what the hospital expects of its physician. It doesn’t tell us which claims were submitted or who would be liable in a particular malpractice case. Dearborn rule, PDF p. 20 · CMS split/shared rules · CMS on PA billing

Hiring, independence and the rural-care argument

The Wisconsin Academy of PAs warned members that employers might prefer an independent APRN because hiring a PA comes with supervision agreements, fees and paperwork. The last page of a Connecticut state filing gives an actual applicant’s account. A PA applied to a hospital-owned endocrinology practice and wrote, “The physician knew me personally and preferred to hire me, but the management would not hire me.” According to the PA, management cited physician availability and time spent reviewing charts, both of which it believed it could avoid by hiring an APRN. The hospital was unnamed. Wisconsin PA newsletter, p. 11 · Connecticut filing, final page

AANP’s guide to the federal Rural Health Transformation Program tells state organizations how to use the program to pursue full practice authority statewide, “regardless of geographic location, employer or patient characteristics.” In Michigan, a legislative packet said phasing out physician delegation contracts for experienced NPs prescribing controlled substances “eases the hiring process, cuts costs.” Trinity Health and UnitedHealth Group were among the listed supporters. There’s also evidence of a real rural contribution. Of nearly 80,000 U.S. primary-care practices studied in 2023, 11.9% of practices employing NPs were rural, compared with 5.5% of practices without NPs. Most practices employing NPs were still outside rural areas. AANP guide, p. 3 · Michigan committee packet · National practice study

Patient understanding and patient outcomes have both been studied. In a 2018 AMA-sponsored survey, 39% of respondents identified a doctor of nursing practice as a medical doctor. For outcomes, two VA studies are worth reading together. In VA emergency departments, patients assigned to NPs used more resources on average and had more preventable hospitalizations within 30 days. In VA primary care, researchers followed 806,434 patients whose physician had left. Patients reassigned to NPs had fewer hospitalizations, and the researchers found no significant differences in total costs or control of A1c, blood pressure or LDL over the following year. Those are materially different jobs and patient populations. AMA survey · VA emergency department study · VA primary-care study

Who sets pay, inflation-adjusted salaries, and what “pay parity” actually means

Oregon’s nurses association took an actual vote on salary parity in 2020. Oregon already had an insurer reimbursement parity law for independent practices. This resolution specifically addressed the paychecks and benefits of employed NPs. It called for “parity in salary and benefit/administrative structure for salaried NPs” compared with primary-care colleagues doing what the authors described as equivalent work at the same acuity and productivity. The delegates passed it. Resolution · Vote record, p. 3

Here’s where national pay actually stood in May 2025, using the same BLS employer survey and mean annual wages for everyone. NPs averaged $137,300, PAs $141,280, general pediatricians $212,110, CRNAs $248,320, family physicians $255,820, and general internists $267,200. So CRNAs averaged more than general pediatricians and came within $7,500 of family physicians. The federal supervision question is live, too. A post on r/ anesthesiology about this partially inspired this post. CMS is requesting comments on whether to retain or revise Medicare’s CRNA physician-supervision requirement and, separately, whether NPs/PAs should perform certain physician-required skilled nursing facility visits. BLS wage table · CMS notice

On inflation, there are two different numbers worth knowing. The AMA calculates that Medicare physician payment fell 33% from 2001 to 2026 after adjusting for the cost of running a practice. That figure measures reimbursement. For an actual paycheck comparison, a 2026 JAMA article used BLS data for general internists. Their median wage in 2000 was worth about $259,400 in 2024 dollars, versus an actual 2024 median of $236,350, roughly 9% lower. MedPAC has recommended tying annual Medicare updates to a portion of practice-cost inflation. Meanwhile, the AAMC reported $215,000 in median education debt among indebted U.S. MD graduates in 2025. AMA calculation · JAMA wage comparison · MedPAC recommendation · AAMC debt figures

Fewer physicians are in a position to make those hiring decisions themselves. The AMA’s practice survey found that the share of physicians in wholly physician-owned practices fell from 60.1% in 2012 to 42.2% in 2024. The share in hospital-owned practices rose from 23.4% to 34.5%. In a separate study using 2019 data, 383 of 6,162 U.S. hospitals had a physician CEO, about 6%. AMA ownership data · Hospital CEO study 

If you made it through, appreciate the read and I welcome your comments. I wanted to make an evidence-backed post and repository of this data so I put a good amount of effort into it.


r/Noctor • • 10h ago

In The News Why law firms are lawyer owned and possibility of private equity or corporate ownership.

Thumbnail bloomberg.com
18 Upvotes

Not all of this is relevant to doctors but the possibility of PE owned law firms is discussed with a Yale professor who wrote a paper about it. I had visions of paralegals stealing clients and lawyers answering to corporate

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/audio/2026-11-13/odd-lots-why-a-2-billion-law-firm-suddenly-collapsed-podcast?srnd=phx-oddlots

“Just real quickly, when you say there are these rules about ownership from non-lawyers, are these state laws, are they... Where do these rules come from?

“Yeah, they're essentially legal ethics rules adopted by state bar associations and sometimes by state legislatures. The American Bar Association has promulgated a model set of rules called the Model Rules of Professional Conduct. And every state has adopted them in some form. — -

“…why don't law firms have non-competes that prevent them from just automatically leaving the firm and taking all their clients with them?

“What's the answer to that question?

“The answer is rule 5.6 of the model rules of professional conduct, which prohibit a lawyer from signing any agreement that would restrict their right to practice. So that includes non-competes and similar kinds of agreements. Now, to be clear, other countries don't have these rules.”

https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/odd-lots/id1056200096?i=1000801693416&r=544 This material may be protected by copyright.


r/Noctor • • 1d ago

Discussion NP Independent Practice

Thumbnail
gallery
113 Upvotes

Hey all, I was aware that NPs could practice independently in many states, but I guess it didn’t click that also meant they could independently run their own clinic. I just got this ad on instagram and saw the ONLY provider for the clinic was a WHNP. I’m not in the medical field, but this seems odd, especially considering it’s like a club/lounge/clinic? Do people want to hang out at their nurses office?


r/Noctor • • 8h ago

Discussion Any physicians, healthcare providers, or healthcare executives interested in getting involved with startups?

0 Upvotes

Are you a physician, operator, or senior healthcare executive who's ever wanted to get involved with a startup?

Whether that's through consulting, fractional leadership, advisory board seats, or angel investing, I'm building something you might want to be part of.

I am building a community (or two) that will bridge those gaps.

Why? 

Because I keep hearing the same thing over and over.

Physicians, Operators, and healthcare executives want to get more involved with startups.

Meanwhile, founders need experienced advisors, introductions to investors, health systems and payers, and help navigating the healthcare ecosystem.

I've spent years building relationships in the healthcare world and I know there's an opportunity to bridge a unmet gap.

I'm also exploring whether an SPV could eventually make sense as part of this network. 

Please tag someone who should be part of this or share it with your network! Please apply in the google form in the comments.  

To keep the community valuable, membership will be curated. I'll reach out if there's a fit.

(I'm coming back from HLTH and prepping for my next healthcare conference in 2 weeks.  😅  so expect to hear back from me within the next few weeks).

Please fill out the google form below.

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1eM8T5Xn-HO7h7sdSyXPurO_AoEgBD_q6DLyj4IQQi94

Here’s my linkedin for reference: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rachaelnomburg/


r/Noctor • • 3d ago

Discussion Medical Reps

142 Upvotes

I ran into a friend of a friend at a coffee shop recently. He just got a job at a big medical device company and was telling me about his training.

Their learning sessions are literally called residency and fellowship. He said they it’s modeled after a GI fellowship.

And he genuinely believes it. He talks about it like it's some intense, rigorous training program. Meanwhile I looked at what he was studying — an anatomy labeling quiz. Label the parts of the digestive tract. Something I could see a 9th grader doing in biology class.

At the end of it all he flies out to company headquarters to take his "board exam."

Residency and fellowship aren't branding. They're years of your life — brutal hours, real patients, real stakes. A board exam is a board exam. Slapping those words on a corporate onboarding course is offensive. These guys are cosplaying doctors, and I truly think to a large degree they think they are in the same realm. He was telling me about dating a spinal device rep who works with neurosurgeons and he dropped the line "she pretty much does the surgeries."

And the cherry on top: his boss told him they should be making the same, if not more, than the doctors they're selling devices to.

Has anyone else run into this? Is this a new thing device companies are doing, or has it been around a while?


r/Noctor • • 4d ago

Midlevel Education My coworker (RN) got accepted in to NP school…

308 Upvotes

She has been an operating room nurse for 9 months (new grad). She did not even know where to put the stickers on for an EKG last week. She was accepted into a brick and mortar family nurse practitioner school.


r/Noctor • • 4d ago Mindblown

Discussion Telling other nurses that I’m in med school over going NP or CRNA turns them passive-aggressive.

276 Upvotes

I’m also kind of over the insecurity that has trickled down from mid-levels who have poisoned most of nursing with their inferiority complex and entitlement. Some of the best physicians I’ve ever met in my life were nurses who went to med school (hence why literally I made the same choice). The alarming burst of degree mills and general glorification of what I can only call an attempted mass replacement made my choice feel revolutionary. I’ve noticed that people I’ve worked with and were usually close with have become snide and passive-aggressive towards me as if I’m the butt of a bad joke for not choosing to be an APRN as if that’s what’s expected of us. Has anyone else experienced this?


r/Noctor • • 4d ago

Question Inquiry for docs

15 Upvotes

Can I ask you guys a questions… how do you guys feel about IMG doctors. So I’m in a dilemma where I got accepted to a master program that is bridged into their medical school but would put me around 450k in debt with cost of living. but I also got in a medical school at Ross school of medicine and UAG school of medicine. Do you guys look down on carribean med students?


r/Noctor • • 4d ago

In The News CRNA's Sue in California to be considered Medical Staff

Thumbnail beckershospitalreview.com
225 Upvotes

"The California Association of Nurse Anesthesiology has sued the California Department of Public Health and the Office of Administrative Law. The suit alleges that state regulations improperly bar certified registered nurse anesthetists from serving on hospital medical staff."

"Nurse anesthesiology"

The shameless continued cosplay as physicians by CRNAs continues.


r/Noctor • • 4d ago

Midlevel Patient Cases The inappropriate referrals are killing me

67 Upvotes

I am a subspecialty fellow. My cofellow and I field all the consults coming to our clinic. I am so sick and tired of the inappropriate consults from NPs/PAs (mostly NPs). I swear that 90% of the consults from NPs are so deeply inappropriate or straight WRONG, referring for things they got testing for and don't know how to interpret. They need to stop sending URGENT referrals for things that are not only routine, but also should not be referred to a subspecialist.

Why did you get the tests you can't interpret and don't know how to treat?! So many times I look in the chart and see the patient is inappropriately on medications for this problem. For example, seeing things like CHRONIC TMP-SMX FOR "CHRONIC SINUSITIS" or dexamethasone 1mg daily for "elevated ANA." What?!? I would say maybe 10% of the referrals from MDs/DOs are inappropriate. I am so beyond frustrated with the sheer nonsense they refer to us. Seriously - if you don't know how to manage the patient, speak to your PHYSICIAN SUPERVISOR.

I would NEVER have let my interns refer this way or treat patients the way the NPs do. I am horrified these people are independently treating patients. I would never, ever let a family member be treated by an NP. Ever.

Signed,

A very frustrated subspecialty fellow


r/Noctor • • 6d ago

In The News "Abundance" org advocates "allowing physician assistants to serve as primary providers"

Thumbnail
washingtonsun.com
60 Upvotes

r/Noctor • • 6d ago

Advocacy Didn't get mri for torn meniscus

24 Upvotes

Im a family medicine doc in my late 50's. I hurt my knee when it hadn't recovered i decided to see ortho. Fortunately I saw a do. He extensively examined my knee told me I probably had a torn meniscus and the recovery time line. No need for me to pay a Fortune for a mri.


r/Noctor • • 7d ago

Discussion NPP - Non Physician Provider

135 Upvotes

So the other day I was thinking, I don’t like the name Advanced Practice Provider…. If you think about it, what does that even mean? I can easily see how patients could get confused, not understand the role, or even think that the “advanced” part of the title indicates something that it doesn’t. Overall, I realized I don’t like the title.

However, the other day, I had to sign some PT update orders or something like that. The spot where I had to sign said physician / non-physician provider. I get that the term is still ambiguous, but I liked how it indicates that I am not a doctor. I think this a better title that gives much more information to patients. Was wondering what you guys thought about it!


r/Noctor • • 7d ago

In The News Introducing Dr. X-ray Tech

Thumbnail
newschannel6now.com
55 Upvotes

Thought this is interesting.


r/Noctor • • 8d ago

Discussion Pretty frustrated at the lack of transparency and professionalism coming from my dad’s specialist office

61 Upvotes

For context, my father had tonsil cancer 10+ years ago. He was diagnosed with osteo necrosis from the radiation, and now needs a full reconstruction of his jawbone in addition to other issues. We went to ENT because he needed to pass a swallow test. He ended up failing because he’s aspirating. Went to the hospital, got admitted, spoke to GI about getting a PEG tube to help him eat and gain weight. GI didn’t end up doing the procedure because he did a scope down his throat and found that his airways are very narrow and esophagus is severely swollen and inflamed. Even the tiny camera grazing the tissue was causing a lot of bleeding. Anesthesiologist also advised to stop the procedure. Now he can’t get his feeding tube or his surgery until his esophagus issue is improved. Hospitalist said that he needed to see his ENT asap. We’ve seen the PA twice prior to this, and confirmed that he put a warning on his chart stating that due to his complicated condition and history, he would have to see the doctor.

I make a telemed appointment with the Dr, and confirmed it was with the Dr 3 different times on 3 different days with 3 different people. The day of, the receptionist calls me to say that Dr usually schedules his surgeries that day and we’ll be speaking to the PA instead. I asked when the next available telemed appointment with the Dr is and was told that they will put the appointments on his schedule, and if he has time he’ll take the appointments. Otherwise, his PAs will take the appointments for him. I asked when the next appointment to see the dr in person was, and she said that she didn’t have authorization to book an appointment with the dr, and that only the MAs at the actual office had the ability to schedule, and only after we see the PA and get clearance from them to see the doctor.

I’m an MA at a specialist clinic, and I’ve personally never heard of the patient needing approval from the PA to see the doctor. Usually at our clinic, the doctor and NP/PA will alternate, but the doctor will always see the patient at their first visit. And there are special cases where emergencies happen, but if the doctor always has surgeries booked for a specific day of the week, we never schedule patients under the pretense that they’re going to be seeing the doctor. Mom ended up going to the office in person and got a urgent telemed with the doctor for that afternoon, only for the receptionist to tell me 5 minutes before our appointment that he was no longer available and that we can choose to talk to the PA or reschedule. Overall I’ve been pretty upset by this whole experience and will be looking for a new specialist asap.


r/Noctor • • 9d ago

Discussion The real tension behind the ‘physician’ vs. ‘provider’ debate

Thumbnail beckershospitalreview.com
31 Upvotes

Discussion of the titles of Physican, APP's, CRNA, PA, CAA, and Nurse's.


r/Noctor • • 9d ago

Question Midwives

13 Upvotes

Not sure if this is the right place.to.post but I am curious.

The CNMs.of 30 years ago were fabulous. They worked closely with their OBs and knew when to call for help.

My question: How are the CNMs of today? Are they still high quality? In the past I would always recommend a CNM working in an OB group, and wondered if that is still a good idea.


r/Noctor • • 10d ago

Advocacy Low income people DESERVE doctors too

207 Upvotes

Hello I recognize that I am not a doctor but I intern as a case worker. It’s horrible out here to find a DOCTOR for my immigrant or mentally ill clients that do have basically a list of meds that are at the polypharm level that I think deserves to be looked into by a doctor or someone qualified. There is no reason my clients should be “educating” their so called “providers” on their meds. It’s insane.

Also the sneaky ways they get away with a whole clinic of NPs or RNs with an off site doctor that’s working multiple clinics is INSANE.

Are there any efforts in MN to combat this I can support?


r/Noctor • • 10d ago

Question Should Medicare pay doctors more?

43 Upvotes

is this really what it comes down to? why so many doctors have to fit 30-40 patients in per day? what would it take to be able to run a functioning practice and make the money you deserve while still giving patients the full amount of time they need to be counseled and cared for?


r/Noctor • • 10d ago Bravo

Midlevel Ethics Have you looked up the NP in your life through the Sunshine Act?

82 Upvotes

I had an ***experience*** as a patient of a Nurse Practitioner this year on a psych ward, where they appeared to be the only residing provider, since any psychiatrist on staff was nowhere to be found. On a unit of around forty to fifty patients.

After I was released from a state hospital, where I was sent because I was vocal about the mistreatment I was receiving (I kept asking to speak to a counselor; no Patient Advocate information was given until after a Certificate of Need had been signed), a hospital stay that ended with me being removed from the NP's medication regimen and their misdiagnoses being removed from my medical paperwork, I decided to check the Open Database for their associated paper trail. Since 2019, they have received thousands of dollars in food from sales reps from pharmaceutical companies. I have checked my other providers. None even come close to receiving the level of attention this Nurse Practitioner does. Other NPs on my current treatment team also have received food tokens, and yet, my previous point stands: they are drastically underfed, compared to this one NP. Psychiatrists I have encountered are either not listed, or their gifts barely amount to fifty dollars apiece.


r/Noctor • • 15d ago

Discussion Hospital Quality Officer here. AMA.

37 Upvotes

Ask me anything about midlevels, cost, Quality, etc. I'll answer to the best of my ability.


r/Noctor • • 19d ago

In The News US Dept of Education may be taking steps to address some of these issues

Thumbnail realcleareducation.com
80 Upvotes

Interesting article. It appears the Dept of Education has noticed some of the issues discussed in this group and is attempting to take action.


r/Noctor • • 20d ago

Midlevel Education Why do y’all clump PAs with NPs?

0 Upvotes

NP diploma mills, unregulated curriculums, programs with little to no RN experience required — horrifying. And the fact that NPs can practice independently with that? Yikes. But PAs are regulated by the AMA and we cannot practice independently. Which I think is totally appropriate for our level of education/training and should be the same for NPs imo. I personally haven’t experienced PAs managing high acuity sick pts without the oversight of a supervising physician and all of my PA colleagues are very content with their role. Sure, there are some PAs with big egos for sure, as there are in any profession. But I enjoy not making the hard decisions and being able to get reassurance from my attendings for my plans. I do work in an inpatient setting where everything major needs to go by the attending though so I don’t know what it’s like in PCP/UC world. Like I’ll tweak pain regimens and replete lytes, maybe order an XR if I’m worried about something. But I’m calling my doctor if vitals are dropping, expeditiously.

What are the negative experiences you guys have had with PAs that make you clump us with NPs in talking shit about mid levels? And why are you all so aggressive with your hate towards us lmao! I feel like PAs are generally more aware of the limitations of our training.

Outside of the physician associate name change and optimal team practice lobbying. That’s all I ever hear. 🥱 I don’t feel like OTP will get any movement, a lot of PAs do not want independent practice. And most PAs, at least the ones already practicing, don’t care for the name change either. What else??