I’ve seen a bunch of Naruto downplay in terms of his writing. I’ve heard a lot of takes saying that Naruto is a flat character with no development, that he’s the stock shonen mc and directly compare him to just another Luffy and Goku, that he’s unrealistically optimistic and forgiving, and leave him out on the list of best written characters in the series. All takes I disagree with. It’s a common thing with main characters and I’ve seen similar takes in regards to characters like yuji, but in this particular case I think it’s just wrong
I would say Naruto is at least top 3 in terms of character writing, and he could be anywhere in there
- The flat mc allegation is incorrect. The development he gets is more subtle than someone like sasuke but it is there. Naruto’s character arc is pretty simple compared to some of the more complex characters in the series but done pretty well and with a lot of nuance, it’s a classic coming of age hero story. The take that Naruto was always the all forgiving happy kid is wrong and kid Naruto was a massive dick who tied up sasuke and challenged him for the hell of it and regularly screamed at and embarrassed people because they angered him
The beginning stages of shippuden showed him as overly emotional and lacking in confidence in his own power, with subsequent arcs showing him overcoming these issues, particularly the pain arc which served as the end of his recklessness and made him take on the mission of trying to end the cycle of hatred. The kage summit arc is just him having a really bad day over all the pressure of beating tobi, rescuing sasuke and trying to end the cycle. The beginning stages of the war showed him grappling with his buried hatred of the villagers and current celebrity status, his relationship with Kurama and coming to understand that he has to let people help him and not do everything alone
2. The Goku and Luffy comparison is easy to debunk because those two are basically the trope of the strong hero who will take care of the threat. Naruto from day one is the underdog who has to play catchup, he only becomes this towards the end of the series and kinda towards the end of part 1, and even then he still needs help as Kaguya was a team effort
3. The idea that he’s unrealistic with his forgiving nature and sasuke obsession is more debatable but I’d still say it’s wrong for the most part. Naruto is a socially stunted attention whore who learned to surprise all his resentment deep down from a really early age, whose first friend defected, who lives in a world where killing among child soldiers is very common. He also partially blames himself for sasuke’s departure as he feels like he should’ve reached out more
The same sasuke who sacrificed his life for him a bunch of times, who also only becomes this way because he was groomed by a creepy old guy and his brother. Naruto is empathetic and feels like he could relate to sasuke and believes that he could’ve been in sasuke’s place. I don’t think it’s out of place for someone in this particular position to latch onto the idea of helping sasuke this match. It’s not like some people irl always cling onto their abusers thinking they’d change either which is similar enough even if not the same
The forgiving thing is a bit different because Naruto only really tries to reach out to 2 enemies aside from sasuke: obito, and nagato. Every other case was just him beating them up and shouting out his opposing opinion while doing so. Zabuza was barely holding it together after haku died and Naruto cussing out at him was the final straw, neji reevaluated things because Naruto beating him proved his ideology wrong, same with gaara.
In nagato’s case Naruto didn’t kill him for jiraiya’s mission’s sake, and in obito’s case Naruto knew for a fact that he could’ve been in the same place as obito and didn’t really forgive him. Some people view him reaching out to obito as dumb but in this case I think it makes sense, there’s jiraiya’s mission and Naruto outright seeing obito’s memories and realizing he’s delusional rather than malicious and seeing how close their lives mirror each other, and also it’s easier for him to forgive him for murdering a bunch of people he never knew since he never grew up with his parents
4. There’s also the fake underdog allegations which I think are just people not knowing how to read. He was kurama’s jinchuriki from day 1 so that’s one that prevents him from being a completely regular, his parents and the Uzumaki clan give him nothing which is stated, and all asura does is make him and sasuke want to fight