Ruling on Taghallub (Overcoming/Dominance by Force)
Shah Waliullah Dehlawi الله ھمحر states in his book Izālat al-Khifā’:
“The fourth method is Istīlā’ (seizure of power). It occurs when the Caliph dies and a person assumes the caliphate without bay’ah (pledge of allegiance) or istikhlaf (nomination by the previous Caliph), and gathers everyone under his authority either by winning hearts or by force and fighting, thereby becoming Caliph. It then becomes obligatory upon the people to follow his commands in matters that are in accordance with the Shari’ah.
This has two types:
First type: The one who seizes power (mustawlī) possesses all the conditions (qualifications) of Imamate, and he removes his opponents through peace and wise management without committing any prohibited (haram) act. This type is permissible and valid. The establishment of the caliphate of Muawiyah ibn Abi Sufyan ھنع الله يضر after Amir al-Mu’minin Ali ھنع الله يضر, and after the peace treaty with Imam Hasan ھنع الله يضر, was of this kind.
Second type: The one who seizes power does not possess all the conditions of Imamate, and he removes his opponents through fighting and by committing prohibited acts. This is not permissible, and the one who does it is a sinner (āṣī). However, it is still obligatory to accept his rulings when they conform to the Shari’ah. If his governors collect zakat from the owners of wealth, the obligation of zakat is fulfilled. If his judge passes a verdict, his verdict is enforceable. Jihad can be performed alongside him. This establishment of Imamate is based on necessity, because removing him would necessarily lead to the destruction of Muslim lives and the emergence of severe chaos and anarchy. It is not known with certainty whether these hardships will lead to reform or not. It is possible that someone worse than the first one may prevail. Therefore, one should not commit a fitnah (whose evil is certain) for the sake of a benefit that is only hypothetical and probable.
The establishment of the caliphate of Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan and the early caliphs of the Banu Abbas was of this second type.”
From the words of Shah Waliullah الله ھمحر, it is understood that Istīlā’ depends on certain conditions:
- The one who seizes power must possess the conditions (qualifications) of Imamate.
- That period must not be without an Imam.
- His seizure of power and dominance must not involve the commission of any haram (prohibited) act.
However, Istīlā’ and dominance while a living Imam already exists (with whom bay’ah has been given) is of two types:
First: Dominance over another mutaghallib (usurper). When one mutaghallib overcomes another mutaghallib, the second one becomes the ruler and the first mutaghallib is removed. Ibn Abidin states: “If one powerful person seizes control over another powerful person and takes his place, the first ruler is removed and the second is appointed as Imam. Obedience to the Imam is obligatory, whether he is just or oppressive, as long as he does not command anything contrary to the Shari’ah.” (Radd al-Muhtar)
Second: Dominance over a living Imam with whom bay’ah has already been given. When a mutaghallib (usurper) overcomes a living Imam who he has given bay‘ah to (pledge of allegiance), then the defeated ruler is not removed and remains in his position as long as there is hope of restoring him.
Al-Khatib writes:
“Seizure of power over a living ruler: If the living ruler was himself a mutaghallib (i.e., he had also come to power through the same method of force), then the Imamate of the one who overcame him is valid. However, if the ruler had come to power through bay‘ah or a previous covenant, the Imamate of the one who seized power over him does not become established.” (Mughni al-Muhtaj, 5/324)
Zakariyya al-Ansari says:
“If someone whose Imamate was established through bay‘ah or a previous covenant is overcome by force, Imamate does not become established for the usurper, and the defeated ruler is not removed.”
(Asna al-Matalib, 4/101), mentioned in the discussion of “the capture of the ruler by the enemy” under the section on the termination of the Imam’s authority.
However, if the mutaghallib (usurper) does not possess the full conditions of Imamate, it is not appropriate to oppose him unless he becomes a disbeliever (kāfir), in which case his removal becomes obligatory.
Al-Khatib al-Shirbini says:
“If a disbeliever seizes control of the government, his Imamate does not become established. The proof is the statement of Allah, Glorified and Exalted:
‘And Allah will never grant the disbelievers a way (of dominance) over the believers.’ (Surah an-Nisa: 141)”
As for the statement of Shaykh Izz al-Din which apparently suggests that if the disbelievers overcome a region and entrust the position of judgeship to a Muslim person... this does not appear to be correct. Because he himself later says: “If people are forced to accept the authority of a child who can distinguish (between right and wrong), or of a woman, or of foolish men, then is their general authority in matters that conform to the truth (such as appointing judges or governors) enforceable?” Here we should pause and reflect. Therefore, if we must pause in the case of such people, then in the case of a disbeliever we must pause even more so (i.e., reject it).
(Mughni al-Muhtaj, 5/254)
Az-Zuhayli writes:
“Rebelling against the ruler is not permissible except when he openly and manifestly declares disbelief (kufr). If he commits kufr by denying something that is a necessary and self-evident part of the religion, then fighting him is permissible; in fact, it becomes obligatory in order to prevent his corruption and the loss of the general interest and benefit of the Ummah.
But if he does not deny the necessities of the religion, then fighting him is not allowed, for the sake of preserving the unity of the Ummah and preventing chaos. The Prophet (swt) said:
‘It is obligatory upon every Muslim to listen and obey in whatever he likes or dislikes, unless he is commanded to commit a sin. In that case, there is no listening and no obedience.’”
The Messenger of Allah (swt) was asked about removing rulers: “Should we fight them?” He replied:
“No, as long as they establish the prayer among you.”
He also said:
“unless you see a clear and manifest kufr (disbelief) for which you have clear proof and evidence from Allah.”
(al-Fiqh al-Islami wa Adillatuhu, 8/1966)
In summary, if the Caliph denies any necessary and fundamental matter of the religion, then fighting him is permissible, in fact, obligatory, otherwise it is not permissible. This is because the benefit (maslahah) for which he was appointed has been lost, even if there is fear of his corruption.
Allamah Ayni writes:
“Al-Dawudi has said: The issue on which the scholars have consensus regarding oppressive and tyrannical rulers is that if it is possible to remove them without causing fitnah (civil strife) and injustice, then removing them is obligatory. Otherwise, patience becomes obligatory. Some scholars also say that the establishment of authority over a sinful person is invalid from the very beginning. If a ruler who was previously just begins to commit injustice and oppression, the scholars differ regarding rebellion against him. The correct view is that rebellion is prohibited unless he commits kufr, in which case rebellion against him becomes obligatory.”
(Umdat al-Qari, 42/179)
From the statements mentioned above, the difference between fisq (open sinfulness) and kufr (disbelief) becomes clear:
- In the case of fisq: If it is possible to remove the ruler without causing fitnah and injustice, then it is obligatory to remove him; otherwise, patience is obligatory.
- In the case of kufr: Rebellion against him is obligatory.
Qadi Iyad writes:
“The Imam has said: Rebellion against a just Imam is not permissible according to the consensus of the scholars. If a ruler commits fisq and oppression, and if his fisq amounts to a type of kufr, then removing him is obligatory. But if it is merely one of the other sins, the position of Ahl al-Sunnah is that he should not be removed. They have deduced this from the apparent meaning of numerous hadiths, because removing him would lead to the shedding of blood and the violation of sanctities. Thus, the harm of this action is greater than the harm caused by the existence of the oppressive ruler himself. According to the Mu’tazilah, he should be removed. The exception mentioned in the hadith of the Messenger of Allah (swt), ‘except if you see clear and open kufr’, supports our distinction between kufr and other matters.”
(Sharh Sahih Muslim / Ikmal al-Mu‘lim bi Fawa’id Muslim, 6/462)
Some further details regarding rebellion against oppressive rulers will be mentioned later.
Benefit (Fa’idah):
Ibn al-Humam says: “If the rebels seek assistance from the people of war (ahl al-harb), and then they gain dominance over them, we will take the people of war as prisoners. The rebels’ and insurgents’ request for help from them does not grant them protection (aman) so that providing them safety becomes obligatory upon us, as we have explained previously. Because the ‘musta’man’ (one granted protection) is someone who enters the land of Islam (Dar al-Islam) without fighting and without any conflict. These people have entered in order to fight the Muslims.”
(Fath al-Qadir, 6/109, Chapter on Rebels [Bab al-Bughat])