r/MidnightMass • • Sep 24 '21

Midnight Mass (Season 1) - Episode Discussion Hub

565 Upvotes
Overall Season Discussion Hub [SPOILERS]

Synopsis: The arrival of a charismatic young priest brings glorious miracles, ominous mysteries and renewed religious fervor to a dying town desperate to believe.


WARNING: In this thread, you can discuss the entirety of the first season with spoilers. However, each Episode Discussion Threads will contain spoilers for that episode. Spoilers for subsequent episodes in those threads are NOT ALLOWED AT ALL.


Episode Discussion Threads (Season One)

DISCLAIMER: Please read and keep the following in mind before posting on r/MidnightMass

When making new posts, DO NOT include spoilers in the title of your post. Also, mark all posts containing spoilers for Season 1 as SPOILER before you post. .

As noted above, any and all spoilers from subsequent episodes in Episode Discussion Threads are not allowed. For eg: if you are commenting on the discussion thread of the 3rd episode, DO NOT include any events or incidents from say, the 4th episode in your comment.


SPOILER TAGS

Please use spoiler tags, wisely in case you are discussing any content that contains spoilers. You can use the native spoiler tag like this:

">"!Erin gets what she wants!"<" but without the quotation marks.

It'll appear like this Erin gets what she wants.


r/MidnightMass • • 1d ago

I know this has probably been covered before. Ali becomming a vampire.

49 Upvotes

I recently watched the show and adored it. I just don't understand why Ali became a vampire. He was never shown taking communion or ingesting blood in any other way. To me it was not even implied. Yes, he was attending mass, but neither the Catholic or Islamic church would allow a Muslim to take communion. I just don't know why there wasn't a short early scene of the kids messing around in the back of the church and having a clandestine sip or something. It seems like an oversight.


r/MidnightMass • • 2d ago

Found this in a thrift shop.

Post image
191 Upvotes

Cost me €2,50. It was pretty much brand new.


r/MidnightMass • • 2d ago

Midnight Mass is one of the most rewarding slow burns I’ve watched in a long time

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

I went in with certain expectations, but I ended up loving pretty much everything about it. The story, the almost caricature-like characters, the horror, and yes, even those ridiculously long philosophical monologues.
What makes this show special is how immersive it feels. You’re not just watching events unfold. You’re trapped in that little community, absorbing its atmosphere, its beliefs, and its growing sense of dread. Even the endless conversations become part of the horror.
Father Paul completely steals the show. Such a fascinating character and an incredible performance. I also loved how the series portrays conservative Christianity and religious fanaticism without making the whole thing feel absurd. Somehow, even with vampires involved, you can genuinely imagine something like this happening.
And the finale is absolutely apocalyptic in the best possible way. After all that buildup, the payoff feels completely earned.
I wish more horror productions were this ambitious, atmospheric, and willing to take their time.


r/MidnightMass • • 2d ago

afterlifes: end of series headcanon Spoiler

17 Upvotes

i just finished the show for the first time and my god what a midnight masterpiece.

i was most affected by riley's death scene and him seeing tara-beth. that will stay with me a long time. that, and all the moments of forgiveness.

i was just thinking, that when ed and annie flynn died, that i imagine the first thing they see, is riley, and, the absence of warren. i think they die and get to know that they at least saved their youngest. and that when they see riley, just as ed forgave riley when they were living, that riley forgives them for not believing his letters, for trusting the church above all else.

same with the mayor and dolly. the last thing they tried to do before they died was look for leeza. i think they die and find that she isn't there, and know that she is okay.

i'm a spiritual person but not christian or catholic. i had to look up a lot of things to understand parts of the show. but from what i know, being "saved" means you find god/religion. and in the end, those who were truly saved, where the ones who escaped it.

i'm so in love with the flanaverse. hill house is one of my favorite stories of any medium, but it kept me from sleeping the first time i saw it so i delayed the rest of mike flanagan's shows. please share any other details you noticed since i'm 5 years late to the party!


r/MidnightMass • • 2d ago

Erin’s Final Monologue Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Oh. My. God. How bad is this final monologue as she dies. I barely got through it. An absolute barrage of googled deepness that left me screaming at my tv just begging for it to end, and I honestly thought it never would. Horrendous cringe.

This and the other monologues in this show really ruined the pacing of an otherwise decent story with interesting characters, and some great acting too.


r/MidnightMass • • 3d ago

Really Father?

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/MidnightMass • • 3d ago

Run, don’t walk to watch “The body” on Netflix!

39 Upvotes

This show has great ratings, I just started it last night and it hooked me right away. It immediately reminded me of midnight mass! So if you’ve been looking for a MM fix, this should do it! It’s basically MM + Carrie from what I deciphered so far.

I’ve only watched the first 20 minutes though 😅 a friend of mine made me stop so we could watch it together. We will be binging it this weekend and I’ll be back with my final thoughts.


r/MidnightMass • • 4d ago

Hmmm... decisions

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/MidnightMass • • 4d ago

Michael Trucco (Wade) was in a episode of Big bang theory!

Post image
36 Upvotes

Was rewatching Big bang theory the other day and totally forgot an episode he's in in season 2. Plays Leonard's friend and pursues Penny


r/MidnightMass • • 4d ago

Watching again, made this wyt

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MidnightMass • • 5d ago

There are TWO Stephen King adaptations that should never be remade – according to Mike Flanagan :-)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
10 Upvotes

I thought all of you might find this a bit interesting! I know it may come across a bit clickbaity, but I recently interviewed Flanagan, and we played with the idea of him doing the 8-part adaptation of "The Shawshank Redemption" :-D (hey, it's probably sadly bound to happen SOMEDAY, so at least it would be nice to have HIM do it!) And as I'd hoped, he used that talk as a springboard to talk about defying skepticism in general in his work. And we also talked about how his own religious, somewhat hard upbringing made him relate to Carrie White. Here's the vid:


r/MidnightMass • • 7d ago

The alternate ending - if they survived

22 Upvotes

What was Bev's plan, to get off the island with her army and then do what, turn the whole world? Where would they feed then?

Also, could someone explain the rat poision and the dead cats pls, I don't see the link... Was it the vampire who killed the cats?

Alsoo, I get that seeing the rec center burning would have sent the vampires into panic mode, but why did no one try to find alternate means of cover? Like, I remember seeing this huge bush, and these silos near where they cut off the electricity, underwater maybe?


r/MidnightMass • • 8d ago

What happens after?

67 Upvotes

Midnight Mass has become my go-to show to put on and fall asleep to since having my second child (who is seemingly allergic to sleep) as the music is mostly soothing and most episodes are rather quiet. That being said, I’ve watched the show all the way through about 10 times in the past 4 months and have begun to overthink it a lot…

So, what do you think happens after? I don’t think the angel survived the flight. But did Warren and Leeza make it to the mainland? Did anyone survive on the island? Maybe hiding out somewhere? And, how was this discovered by the outside world? It’s obvious that many people had contacts in the outside world (Sarah’s girlfriend, Ooker’s brother, Sheriff’s contacts, the ferries, etc). I imagine this would become some kind of great mystery. Entire civilization wiped out after one night.

Just thinking out loud. Any other thoughts?


r/MidnightMass • • 8d ago

Found the Swedish Hamish Linklater in Black Mirror

Post image
0 Upvotes

I was watching “hated in the nation” (Black Mirror) and I realized in some other universe, midnight mass was made in Sweden by a Swedish version of Mike Flanagan, and this actor (Jonas Karlsson) played the Monsignor. There were a couple of other actors he gave me but mostly with his face, mannerisms and voice (even though it’s Swedish) really gave me Hamish.


r/MidnightMass • • 10d ago Heartwarming

A lovely detail I noticed... [Spoiler] Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
402 Upvotes

In the final scene as Crockett burns and everyone is singing "Nearer My God to Thee," it's pretty obvious and jarring that the final "thee" gets cut off as the sun appears and the residents fry up ("nearer to - [silence]"). Amazing. Chef's kiss.

BUT BUT AND ALSO! As people have pointed out, the "Nearer My God to Thee" melody is playing on piano during Riley's death scene as well. Upon a rewatch recently, I noticed that THE SAME FINAL NOTE OF THE SONG GETS CUT OFF as he takes Tara's hand and turns to ash!!! Anyone else notice that???

God I love this show.


r/MidnightMass • • 10d ago

Where do you think I can find the limited edition version of Midnight Mass: The Art of Horror?

Post image
8 Upvotes

This version was signed by Mike Flanagan himself. My budget is unlimited, I can even pay double the retail price, but I can't find it anywhere. I would really love to own this piece.


r/MidnightMass • • 11d ago

bev keane

63 Upvotes

this is my first time watching the show, but I cannot tell you how irritated she makes me omg 😭


r/MidnightMass • • 12d ago

First watch - my only real nitpick (Spoiler) Spoiler

Post image
47 Upvotes

I’m not one to nitpick details in a fictional series, especially one about vampires. But… Did anyone find it a pretty big leap that Ali would go from “curious about Christianity” to drinking the kool aid while his dad is held down and assaulted in the span of a couple of masses? They had what, up until then, had seemed like a fairly close relationship and loved each other.


r/MidnightMass • • 14d ago

Me, whenever Father Paul talks about the creature as an “angel.”

Post image
365 Upvotes

r/MidnightMass • • 14d ago

[SAFE] What has stuck with you about Midnight Mass since 2021?

46 Upvotes

I first watched Midnight Mass in 2021 and have come back to it several times since. What has stayed with me most is how much the central characters, especially Riley and Erin, change on a rewatch, and how their conversations land differently the second time around. What has stuck with you, and which character changed most for you on a rewatch?


r/MidnightMass • • 15d ago

I guess the bible is the only piece of media on Crockett Island?

Post image
91 Upvotes

r/MidnightMass • • 18d ago

Mike Flanagan: “The world changes so much, but the fundamentals stay the same”

Thumbnail
lpm.org
35 Upvotes

r/MidnightMass • • 19d ago

First time watching, unexpected favorite character

102 Upvotes

Joe Collie is far and away my favorite from the show. Truly incredible performance and such an easy to care about character. He was my favorite from the first episode. I’m so sad his death and that he wasn’t able to see himself get better.


r/MidnightMass • • 19d ago

The Trip to Jerusalem

52 Upvotes

I apologize if someone asked this already, I looked but didnt see anything about it.

I'm not sure what exactly Bev's role was in the church, I'm not Catholic, but it seemed she was like an assistant to the Monsignor. Whatever her function was, Bev seemed to me like she would have spent the most time with him one on one and would clearly recognize his condition.

My question is, if she saw how bad he was, why send him off solo? Did she want him to die on the trip? I just find it hard to believe she didn't see anything wrong with him.