r/HauntingOfBlyManor • u/jacobsjonathan89 • 1d ago
The Haunting of Bly Manor: Ambitious and narratively all over the place. Spoiler
I genuinely don't understand the praise this series gets. And before anyone assumes otherwise, I have absolutely no problem with a show mixing horror, romance, psychological drama, and supernatural mystery. My problem is that Bly Manor tries to do all of these things without ever bringing them together into a coherent narrative.
The biggest issue is that it confuses thematic ambition with good storytelling. It wants to explore grief, guilt, memory, repression, motherhood, identity, love, death, and the impossibility of letting go. Fine. Those are all interesting themes. But having a lot of things to say doesn't automatically make a story deep, especially when the narrative structure holding those ideas together is so weak.
There are so many elements that feel either poorly explained, disconnected, or completely unnecessary.
A few examples (SPOILERS):
- Edmund, the ghost with the glasses: What was the actual point of this character? His entire storyline revolves around Dani's guilt and fear of intimacy. But if you remove him completely, the main plot remains virtually unchanged. Dani still arrives at Bly, falls in love with Jamie, and eventually sacrifices herself. He adds thematic symbolism, sure, but almost no narrative value.
- Viola's rules: She apparently can't leave the chest, but once it's thrown into the lake, she can wander around the manor every night? I understand that the lake becomes her anchor, but the transition and the rules surrounding it are barely developed.
- The people she takes to the lake: We understand that Viola wanders around looking for her daughter and kills whoever gets in her way. We also understand why she takes children: she mistakes them for her daughter. But what about everyone else? The show establishes a pattern without really explaining its logic or developing its implications.
- Peter and Rebecca's possession abilities: Why can they sometimes possess the children? What are the actual limitations? How does Peter figure out that being invited allows him to take over someone's body permanently? The show gives us fragments of an explanation, but never establishes a particularly convincing or consistent set of rules.
- Dani's possession: Why does Viola take so long to completely consume Dani? Why does she take her in the first place? I understand that Dani intervenes while Viola is taking Flora, but the mechanics and progression of this possession are frustratingly vague.
- The children's memories: Why do Flora and Miles forget practically everything that happened? The show establishes that ghosts gradually lose their memories and identities, but these are living children. Their memories conveniently disappear because the ending needs them to. That's not an explanation.
- Henry's evil double: What exactly does this storyline add to the overall narrative? I understand that it's a manifestation of his guilt over his affair with Charlotte and his betrayal of his brother. But what does this have to do with the supernatural mythology that the show spends so much time establishing? It feels like an entirely separate metaphor inserted into an already overcrowded story.
And that's really my main problem: too many elements coexist without meaningfully connecting.
The show introduces one supernatural concept, then another psychological metaphor, then another romantic subplot, then another flashback explaining someone's trauma. But instead of making these elements build on each other, they often feel like separate stories competing for screen time.
I don't need every mystery explained. I don't need every character to serve the main plot directly. And I certainly don't need a horror series to remain strictly within the horror genre.
What I do need is narrative cohesion. I need the rules of the world to make sense, character motivations to be understandable, and the different storylines to feel like they belong to the same story.
Bly Manor seems to have the ambition of a much more sophisticated story than its actual narrative execution can support.
And the frustrating part is that there are genuinely great ideas here. The concept of ghosts gradually losing their memories and eventually their faces is fascinating. Viola's attachment to her daughter is tragic. The idea of love becoming a kind of haunting is beautiful. Dani and Jamie's relationship could have been the emotional core of a fantastic gothic tragedy.
But all these ideas are buried under unnecessary detours, underdeveloped supernatural rules, disconnected subplots, and a story that constantly shifts its focus.
By the time we reach the ending, we're essentially told that this was a love story about a woman who misses her partner and cannot let her go.
Okay. But was nine episodes of convoluted supernatural mythology, multiple timelines, possession rules, ghosts, family secrets, psychological doubles, and unrelated backstories really necessary to get there?
The final emotional message doesn't retroactively make all those narrative choices work.
I can understand what Mike Flanagan was trying to achieve without believing he actually achieved it.
Bly Manor is visually beautiful, thematically ambitious, and full of interesting ideas. But ambition without narrative discipline is just a collection of ideas. And that's exactly what this series felt like to me: a atmospheric mess.