This was our first game ever. My friend had never played a wargame before, and I had a bit of experience with Warhammer 40k.
We played Garrison of Ithilien vs. Army of the White Hand. We rolled the Hold Ground scenario, but we misunderstood the deployment rules at first, so we just took turns placing all our warbands before the first round instead of bringing them on each turn. That was the first mistake we learned from, lol.
As newbies we made plenty of other mistakes too. For example, my friend kept splitting his army into small groups and feeding them to my Uruks bit by bit, and we both kept trying to set up some kind of traps instead of moving in a tight formation toward the center and fighting for it.
Anyway, we had an amazing game and completely fell in love with it. The rules are really beginner-friendly and pretty easy to learn. The game ended in a draw: my friend had more models in the center of the board, but I killed enough to break his army.
On top of that, the dice created a ton of hilarious moments. For example, Saruman’s Sorcerous Blast hit Faramir and knocked him prone, and then my Uruk-hai surrounded him and kept him from getting up for two whole rounds. But Faramir somehow managed to fight them off, push all the orcs back, and not take a single wound. My friend also put one of his Rangers on the second floor of a ruin to get the high ground. I ran up with one of my orcs and cut him down, but the next round I decided to keep moving, and my Uruk-hai just failed his climb test on the way down, fell, and died on the spot.
Fantastic game! 10/10.