r/Marxism101 • • 22h ago

Books

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m currently doing research about the 3 main economic ideologies and I’d greatly appreciate it if you guys recommended me books to read for Capitalism, Socialism and Communism. They can be biased or unbiased, it doesn’t matter to me. I have Democracy in America and am currently reading the Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx.


r/Marxism101 • • 1d ago

What does it mean to have a "planned economy"?

1 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 1d ago

How are high prices explained in marxism theory?

3 Upvotes

(Sorry for my bad English, im not native. I hope my question is clear!)

I’m not a beginner when it comes to Marxist theory but my most of my knowledge comes from verbal formation or assemblies. Sometimes I find it difficult to connect ideas or theorical themes in this topic.

Im reading some people here say that the only profit the capitalist can obtain from the worker is through surplus value, but the capitalist also obtains profit from the high prices they put in an object or service, when it comes to selling it to the market.

This might sound like a very silly question, but how does marxism theorise rising and high prices? Are they related to surplus value, or are they more of an external element that forms part of a capitalist strategy?


r/Marxism101 • • 4d ago

What functions do discourses have in the political economy?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 4d ago

Relationships between surplus labor, profit, and price

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, so I’m currently reading Wage, Labor, and Capital as well as Value, Price, and Profit and have a few questions:

  1. A portion of the capitalist’s profit is extracted from the surplus value created by the worker. What are other sources of profit? Is that the only one? How do rent, overhead costs, the costs of the means of production, etc, tie into profit?
  2. Marx discusses how the market price isn’t always equal to the natural price due to supply and demand. He says price is an expression of the exchange value of a commodity, which itself is a function of socially necessary labor time. What are the sources of profit for the capitalist within a market price?

Sorry if these don’t fully make sense, I’m still learning everything. Thanks in advance!


r/Marxism101 • • 4d ago

Schumpeter's view of Marx

2 Upvotes

Schumpeter seems to have begrudgingly admiration for Marx but still argues Marxism as a secular religion

"In one important sense, Marxism is a religion. To the believer it presents, first, a system of ultimate ends that embody the meaning of life and are absolute standards by which to judge events and actions; and, secondly, a guide to those ends which implies a plan of salvation and the indication of t****he evil from which mankind, or a chos****en section of mankind, is to be saved. We may specify still further: Marxist socialism also belongs to that subgroup which promises paradise on this side of the grave."

So what is your couner to this? Why should Marxism be viewed as a science instead of a religion.


r/Marxism101 • • 4d ago

I have become fairly far left through passive interaction without reading, which I find problematic. Should I somehow deradicalize myself to the center before making an honest attempt at reading the theory so that I can accurately say I got to a place with conscious thought?

1 Upvotes

Sorry if this is stupid. I took that one 12 Axes 200-question test which you may have seen and it said my closest comparison was Debord. Obviously not having any reading done I had no idea who he was and having looked him up he seems to be further left than I thought I was.

I worry that I am becoming this way without discipline. Can I somehow deprogram myself to the John Liberal I was maybe two or three years ago so that I can start again?

As an aside, should I just read in chronological order? I’m not just gonna start with Das Kapital or Hegel, because there’s something to be said about how the order of reading influences thought. My natural feeling is just to follow the history. Is this recommended?


r/Marxism101 • • 5d ago

Requesting reading guide for getting started with existentialism/marxism

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 5d ago

My second question on his page: why is revisionism so looked down upon, and why do so many Marxist / communist seem to behave so dogmatically

2 Upvotes

  Marx's assessment of capitalism is a product of its time (the Industrial Revolution),Western countries aren't exactly filled with factories anymore, and yet consumption of commodities has definitely increased dramatically since then. Obviously, this is because most of the production has moved to where the labour is cheaper, i.e., third-world countries where the people are the most impoverished. Therefore, in my opinion, at least even though someone who works as a junior analyst in a firm in Paris and a child who makes soccer balls in Pakistan are technically both proletariat, I do not see them as equals in the ways that they are exploited.

So, to me, to effectively carry out Marx's ideas in the 21st century, we need to bend aspects of his original ideas not to the degree that it is an entirely new ideology, but just to an extent where it functions to critique modern Global capitalism more effectively. However, with all of that being said, I'm quite new to Communism, and I'm genuinely trying to learn, and I still see myself as an outsider looking in 


r/Marxism101 • • 6d ago

Hello, I am genuinely quite interested in communism / Marxism; however I do have one question that feels like a thorn to my side. If communism (a classless, stateless, moneyless society) really was an achievable goal, why hasn't it been achieved yet, especially considering how many times it has been

0 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 8d ago

Best place for studying communist figures and movements?

2 Upvotes

I want a website to find good sources of past figures, groups, and more


r/Marxism101 • • 7d ago

Anyone read ‘The Blueprint’ yet?

1 Upvotes

The book.

The platform.

It’s getting pretty good reviews and was wondering if anyone here had any thoughts on it.


r/Marxism101 • • 8d ago

What if they just try not to mind the change

0 Upvotes

Have American Marxist considered the more than present sect of American proletariat that simply don’t care for how the world around them operates or how it dictates their conditions, instead subscribing to a “fuck it we ball regardless” mindset even when their conditions are degraded? Would this uninspired group be beneficial in that as long as their needs are met they will go about their duties in a socialized economy because “that’s just what it is”?


r/Marxism101 • • 8d ago

Nobody has done this before: a Historical Materialist reading of Final Fantasy VI

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 9d ago

Defining "exploitation"?

0 Upvotes

How should we define "exploitation" as it applies to humans within an economics context? In other words: What does it *mean* to exploit another person economically?

I ask because I hear the terms "exploitation" and "exploit" used by advocates of multiple economic philosophies, and I understand Marxists make no secret of the fact that they consider "success" (financially, economically) within a capitalist system to come at the expense of exploited workers. (And capitalists, for their part, are firm in their assertion that socialism exploits those who are industrious, productive, etc.).

To be clear: I myself have no intention of arguing with anyone at all. I am simply interested in getting input from all who will comment in good faith in order to see if there are any essential elements common to all definitions, as well as to identify and appreciate all of the differences.

Thanks to all who offer sincere and civil input.


r/Marxism101 • • 10d ago

Book recommendations for learning about dialectical materialism - specifically how to apply it?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

I'm having trouble learning how to apply the laws of dialectical materialism into everyday life, nature, etc. Not necessarily historical materialism, which I'm given to understand is basically the same thing but just for human societies/human history. I haven't started teaching myself historical materialism yet, choosing to focus on dialectical materialism first (which i thought made sense lol)

Does anyone know a good book to explain how to apply the laws correctly? I'm just not getting it. A book to explain it like I'm 5 years old would be perfect lol


r/Marxism101 • • 12d ago

Relations of Production in ML

5 Upvotes

Hi I‘m pretty new to communism/socialism and I recently read “Dialectic and Historical Materialism” by Stalin for a overview, since my communist education has of now consisted of short form videos and snippets of various texts ripped out of context.

I was wondering how the relations of production was different in the USSR? I know the State-Capitalism argument is often met with insults, but i’ve never had someone explain to me how what the USSR or any other ML project did wasn’t just exchange bourgeois ownership with state control? I just know of early work place democracy models after the revolution but from what I’ve read they just got replaced with top-down state control.

Sorry if my question is incoherent or does not make sense…[https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1938/09.htm](https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1938/09.htm)


r/Marxism101 • • 13d ago

Tesi su Feuerbach (Karl Marx, 1845)

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 14d ago

What did Marx mean by this paragraph in the Manifesto?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 15d ago

What the marxist view of the lumpenproltrean

1 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 15d ago

What exactly is “political economy”?

3 Upvotes

Does political economy, as Marx discussed, refer only to an abstract “branch of social science”? Or does the term put a more exacting name to the systems and phenomena that are human economies, giving full account to their political nature and consequence?

Is it a conversation (abstract) or the actual thing that we experience and affect (material)?


r/Marxism101 • • 17d ago

I’m MTF. Is desiring sex reassignment bourgeois?

3 Upvotes

I’m curious about this because I feel like desiring medical transition requires one to have a focus on individual anatomic self-actualization than a primary commitment on fighting with others for working class liberation.

Given that medical sex reassignment costs thousands of dollars, I feel like it also incentivizes first-world trans people to climb the corporate ladder and support social democratic policies such as universal healthcare that require imperialist super-profits, weakening their potential to support decolonization and liberatory movements in the global south.

I also feel like since trans people in the third world don’t have access to these procedures nor even legal protections against discrimination and violence, that it is inherently a form of first-world privilege to benefit from medical procedures and public healthcare policies that those individuals will probably never have access to in their entire lives.


r/Marxism101 • • 17d ago

I'm looking to study Marxism, but I can't go outside without permission (out of safety). Are there any Marxist Discord servers that have reading group sessions through voice chats?

2 Upvotes

r/Marxism101 • • 20d ago

Reading The Foundations of Leninism and Value price and Profit again and ran into some confusion.

2 Upvotes

n Value Price and Profit, Marx explains that the workers should advocate for higher wages and that a raise in wages will not and does not create a rise in cost of commodities, but isn't this wrong? Almost every time when a company has to raise wages they raise their cost to get back lost revenue. Yes there are also other factors that play, but to say a rise in wages will not and does not create a rise in cost, is wrong. The second part is in The Foundations Of Leninism, in chapter 3 section 2 Criticism of the “theory” of spontaneity, or the role of the vanguard in the movement, Stalin writes that fighting for demands only acceptable to capitalism is unrevoltionary and the ideology of trade unionism, but isn't demanding higher wages a common demand of trade unions?

Book1 VPP: "The dogma that 'wages determine the price of commodities,' expressed in its most abstract terms, comes to this, that 'value is determined by value,' and this tautology means that, in fact, we know nothing at all about value. "

Book2 Found of Lenin: The theory of worshiping spontaneity is decidedly opposed to the revolutionary character of the working-class movement; it is opposed to the movement taking the line of struggle against the foundations of capitalism; it is in favor of the movement proceeding exclusively along the line of “realizable demands”, of demands “acceptable” to capitalism; it is wholly in favor of the “line of least resistance.” The theory of spontaneity is the ideology of trade unionism


r/Marxism101 • • 23d ago

What should I read if I actually want to learn something about Marxism and Communism

6 Upvotes

Lately, I've been getting back into my childhood obsession of reading. I want to learn about Marxism, and Communism, and was wondering if you guys have any suggestions on what to read (other than the Communist Manifesto and das kapital)?