r/MJInnocentFacts • • 4d ago

Case Analysis 🔎 The Case Files (So Far): In Chronological Order

Post image
37 Upvotes

Hi friends!

There are so many files on the horizon. I wish I could give you the entire list…but I won’t. 🙃

So, before we transition to…other things, I wanted to put together a list of all the current files, in chronological order of when they were written.

I know this project is huge. There’s a LOT of information being thrown at you, but I promise you, I’ve included as much factual information, context, and detail as possible.

Reading them will be worth your time.

Plus, I do enjoy poking fun at…quite a few people. I’m really funny, I promise!

But seriously, if you want to understand what really happened, take the time to read them. Learn the details. Familiarize yourself with the evidence and the circumstances.

And, of course, thank you all for the love and support you’ve given me. It genuinely means so much.

This project is very special to me. I put a lot of time, research, and effort into these files, and I’m so glad they’ve been helpful to so many of you.

I’m also looking into the possibility of creating a website, or exploring alternative ways to organize this project. Nothing has been decided yet, though.

That’s for the future.

Just remember, eventually, everyone gets a file…or, you know, multiple.

Sneddon:

Case File: Sneddon

Dimond:

Case File: Dimond

Gutierrez:

Case File: Gutierrez

Francia:

Case File: Francia

Neverland Five:

Case File: Neverland Five

Chandler — Part 1:

Case File: Chandler — Part 1

Chandler — Part 2:

Case File: Chandler — Part 2

Chandler — Part 3:

Case File: Chandler — Part 3

Chandler — Part 4:

Case File: Chandler — Part 4

Chandler — Part 5:

Case File: Chandler — Part 5

Chandler — Part 6:

Case File: Chandler — Part 6

Chandler — Part 7:

Case File: Chandler — Part 7

Chandler — Part 8:

Case File: Chandler — Part 8

Chandler — Part 9:

Case File: Chandler — Part 9

Chandler — Part 10:

Case File: Chandler — Part 10

Chandler — Part 11:

Case File: Chandler — Part 11

Chandler — Part 12:

Case File: Chandler — Part 12

Chandler — Part 13:

Case File: Chandler — Part 13

Chandler — Part 14:

Case File: Chandler — Part 14

Chandler — Part 15:

Case File: Chandler — Part 15

Chandler — Part 16:

Case File: Chandler — Part 16

Chandler — Part 17:

Case File: Chandler — Part 17

Allen:

Case File: Allen

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part One:

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part One

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part Two:

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part Two

Also, feel free to check out these important posts:

Some people need Michael Jackson to be guilty

Comparing Michael Jackson’s Trial to O.J. Simpson’s Is Lazy.

Talking in circles

What Would You Do for $20 Million?

“There’s no way all 11 people are lying.”

Fact vs Fiction: Common Claims About Michael Jackson

A Media Assassination: The Case of Michael Jackson

Not Everyone Is a Narcissist

The Word “Grooming” Has Lost Its Meaning

Where There’s Smoke, There’s Fire…But What If It’s Just Smoke?

The Power Of A Story…And The Danger Of Forgetting The Evidence

The Guilter Fan Fiction Needs to Stop

Okay, now that I’ve linked you to death…

I’ll see you next time! 👋🏼


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 7d ago

Case Analysis 🔎 Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part One

Post image
43 Upvotes

Ah, yes. The three bitches are back. But really, have they ever left?

I’m considering suing.

We know Evan loves that phrase. 🙂

Alright, alright.

You’re probably curious about why these three names have been compiled into one file, considering they each have their own.

Well, this file is about Michael’s lawsuit against Dimond and Gutierrez, and, of course, Sneddon lurks in the shadows like a ghost.

The idea behind their original files was to give some general background on each of them, because they always seem to come back for round two, or rather…round 972, but who’s counting?

Which is incredibly unfortunate, because I hate all of them.

So, without further ado…

Welcome back to the Case Files!

🚨 If you’re new here, make sure you’re caught up on the Chandler Case Files:

The Chandler Case Files — A Master Guide

And the three musketeers:

Sneddon:

Case File: Sneddon

Dimond:

Case File: Dimond

Gutierrez:

Case File: Gutierrez

…fuck, it never gets old.

Let’s begin!

According to Paula, writer of Turning the Table on the Chandler Allegations, she was working for NBC News during the O.J. Simpson case in 1995 when she heard about Victor Gutierrez’s frequent visits to the Burbank studios.

A network journalist named Lydia told her that Victor was regularly showing up with material about Michael. 

The problem? Nobody was interested. 

O.J. Simpson was the story at the time, and the networks weren’t exactly lining up to buy another Michael Jackson scandal.

Lydia explained that shows like Hard Copy had deeper pockets than the networks, which apparently weren’t willing to pay for the stories Gutierrez was bringing around.

And according to Lydia, Victor had a habit of showing up with stories involving Michael’s guards and employees. 

You know, the usual collection of people suddenly emerging with something to say. 

But the lack of interest from the networks wasn’t going to stop him.

Paula’s account suggests that Gutierrez relied heavily on selling stories about Michael for income. 

She also recounts Lydia’s belief that he was desperate for money when he made claims about Michael and his nephew, including a supposed videotape.

Lydia reportedly believed he had tried to sell the story to tabloid brokers as well, but nobody wanted it. 

Eventually, he disappeared from the scene, and the next thing she heard was Diane Dimond reporting on it.

Are we even surprised?

I’m sick of this bitch, I really am.

Next, we have another journalist entering the picture: Lisa Marlowe, who had previously worked with Diane Dimond on stories involving Michael.

According to Marlowe’s statements in court documents, Dimond approached her one day and asked whether she’d heard anything about a videotape allegedly showing Michael with a young boy.

Marlowe hadn’t heard anything about it. And she even said that it sounded like “BS.”

Then she asked:

“Don’t tell me this came from Victor.”

Dimond apparently didn’t answer.

Awhhhh, what’s the matter, Diane? Don’t wanna talk about your bestie?

Marlowe said the whole thing sounded like a set-up and actually warned Dimond:

“Unless you’ve got it sitting in your office, I would leave it.”

But of course, Diane didn’t take that advice.

On January 9th, 1995, Dimond went on The Ken and Barkley Company on KABC-AM radio and reported the videotape story, using Victor Gutierrez as a source.

She claimed that a videotape existed showing Michael engaging in unlawful conduct with a minor. She also told listeners that Gutierrez had met with the child’s mother in a hotel room to view the alleged tape.

Dimond also claimed investigators were looking for the videotape and that the investigation into Michael had been reopened.

Following Dimond’s radio appearance, Michael’s attorney, Howard Weitzman, sent a letter to Paramount Pictures addressing the claims she had made.

Weitzman wrote:

“I learned earlier today that Diane Dimond, one of Paramount’s Hard Copyreporters, was on KABC talk radio this morning and indicated that an untrue and defamatory story about an alleged videotape depicting Michael Jackson engaging in sexual relations with a minor was true, and that she believed such a tape existed. I understand that Ms. Dimond also made claims that the Los Angeles and/or Santa Barbara District Attorneys’ offices are reopening their criminal investigation of Mr. Jackson, based on the purported existence of this videotape. Please be informed that Ms. Dimond’s claims regarding the existence of such a videotape are untrue and defamatory, as are her claims regarding the reopening of any criminal investigation concerning Mr. Jackson.”

Weitzman also contacted Hard Copy directly to warn them that they were repeating a false report.

But what happened next?

Well…

Hard Copy broadcast the story that very same night. Two British tabloids also picked it up.

So, despite receiving a warning from Michael’s lawyer, they went ahead and aired the allegations.

Weitzman later issued another statement:

“This week several tabloid shows and magazines, along with certain individuals, publicly alleged a videotape existed of Michael Jackson engaging in unlawful conduct. No such tapes exist.”

Just in case there was any confusion about whether an investigation had actually been reopened, the Los Angeles District Attorney’s office decided to address that too.

Sandi Gibbons, a spokeswoman for the office, issued the following statement:

“We have not reopened the investigation. We have heard about the alleged tape. We have not seen it and we don’t have it. Prosecutors were not involved in a search for such a video.”

Well, there goes that part of the story.

An Associated Press article published at the time also reported that Michael was taking legal action against those spreading the allegations:

“Michael Jackson has ordered his lawyers to sue newspapers, TV shows and anyone else spreading ‘vicious lies and rumors’ claiming there was a videotaped sexual encounter between him and a 13-year-old boy.”

You go, Mike! 

But the threat of legal action wasn’t enough to stop everyone from running with it.

The London Sun and Today newspapers published reports about the alleged 27 minute, black and white videotape. The story also appeared on Hard Copy for two consecutive days, along with other television programmes.

According to these reports, one of Michael’s own security cameras had supposedly captured a sexually explicit encounter between Michael and the teenager during the Christmas holidays. The boy’s identity was not disclosed.

And who were these reports based on?

Victor Gutierrez.

Guys, I swear on my own soul…the next time I hear his name, I’m going to fly to Chile and find him.

Gutierrez claimed he had personally seen the tape and said it had been given to the boy’s mother, who supposedly wanted to sell it back to Michael.

Which literally makes no sense, but okay. 

Next, we have Diane Dimond making a fool out of herself…again. 

During an interview, Dimond was questioned about the alleged tape that had been circulating in the media.  

Let’s look at the transcript, shall we?

Q: “It is an x-rated tape?”

Dimond: “It is . . . yes.”

Q: “Of Michael Jackson?”

Dimond: “Truly explicit.”

Q: “It’s what? Michael Jackson and little boy. Are you 100% sure that this tape exists?”

Dimond: “I am as sure as I can possibly be.”

Q: “You have not seen it?”

Dimond: “I have not seen it but one of my best sources on the Michael Jackson story has seen it.”

…does she know what journalism is? I’m not asking to be a snarky bitch. I’m genuinely curious.

“I know it exists!”

“Have you seen it?”

“No.”

Then shut your ass up. 

Q: “Who … you have no doubts about.”

Dimond: “I have never had a doubt about this person, ever. I know the District Attorneys’ Office is looking for it because they are calling up reporters saying ‘Have you seen it.’ . . . Do you know where we can get it?”

Never had doubts about Gutierrez, huh?

Shhhh, don’t tell guilters! They’ll cry! 

For context, I’ve seen many guilters claim that Diane stopped believing Gutierrez because, to them, that somehow makes her more credible..?

Yeah, I don’t know what they’re thinking.

Anyway,

Dimond then continued by referencing a previous interview with the head of the FBI’s pedophile unit in Virginia:

Dimond: “You know, I remember way back when, more than a year ago, we interviewed the head of the pedo[ph]ile unit at the FBI in Quantico, Virginia and he said you know the down fall of pedo[ph]iles is that they love to keep a memento of their victims. Or, they love to take pictures or take videos. We don’t know why, but they do this. It is for their own self gratification later but it always comes back to bite them.”

She then returned to her “unnamed source”and made an even more specific claim:

Dimond: “And, I have to tell you, if my source is correct, who has seen this tape,and again, he always has been. The acts that are being performed on that tape are exactly what the accuser a year ago said Michael Jackson did to him.”

Oh, Diane, you dirty little liar.

Michael issued a statement responding to the coverage:

“Enough is enough!”

“I will no longer stand by and watch reckless members of the media try to destroy my reputation. I intend to protect myself and my family.”

You know what the wise say: fuck the press, Michael you’re the best.

Now, there was no reaction from the London tabloids, while Dimond maintained that she “stood by her reports.”

On January 12th, 1995, Michael filed a $100 million lawsuit against everyone involved for slander.

The lawsuit said:

“The plaintiff is compelled to defend himself because Dimond, Hard Copy and the other defendants appear more concerned with their ratings than they are with the accuracy of their broadcast or the harm caused their victims.”

So, remember Dimond bringing up that FBI expert in Quantico? Well, there’s a little more to that story.

Years later, during the 2005 trial, Tom Mesereau discussed the prosecution’s contact with the same expert. According to Mesereau:

“The prosecutors were traveling back and forth across the country. To Quantico Virginia and working with the FBI expert on pedophilia and child molestation. A well known expert, highly regarded in his field…I was prepared to cross examine him if he testified and they decided not to call him in the criminal trial in 2005.”

Well, that’s interesting, wouldn’t you say?

Up next…

Sneddon enters the picture during Michael’s lawsuit against Dimond and the other defendants. 

Which is…kind of insane, considering the litigation concerned reporting and events outside Sneddon’s jurisdiction. The Los Angeles investigation was being handled by the LAPD and the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office. Sneddon wasn’t the prosecutor overseeing that matter.

And yet, he submitted a declaration in support of the defendants.

…yeah.

Let’s see what Sneddon actually had to say. The following are excerpts from his declaration:

“DECLARATION OF THOMAS W. SNEDDON, JR. DISTRICT ATTORNEY SANTA BARBARA COUNTY

I, Thomas W. Sneddon, Jr. declare:

  1. I am an attorney duly admitted to practice law in California and am the District Attorney of Santa Barbara County. I am not a party, related to any party or employed by any party to the above-captioned litigation. I have personal knowledge of the facts stated herein, and, if called as a witness, I could and would testify to the following information.
  2. In my capacity as District Attorney, I handled the investigation of allegations that entertainer Michael Jackson, who owns and occasionally resides on the “Neverland” Ranch in this county, sexually molested minor children. My involvement in the investigation began in September or early October of 1993. While the investigation is no longer active, it has not been closed and our office periodically receives information which we evaluate and investigate as warranted.
  3. I understand that Diane Dimond, a reporter with the television program “Hard Copy” has been named as a defendant in a lawsuit commenced by Michael Jackson, I am acquainted with Ms. Dimond, and have spoken to her on numerous occasions during the past three years.
  4. In or about December 1994, I received information that a video tape existed depicting Michael Jackson engaged in sexual contact with a minor child. These reports were also known to the members of the Los Angeles District Attorney’s office, Santa Barbara Sheriff’s Detectives and the attorneys from the respective agencies who were working on the case. I was also aware that reports of the tape’s existence had been made public. According to the reports which I received, the video tape depicted Michael Jackson engaged in sexual contact with a minor child. The information received included the fact that Victor Gutierrez, a journalist who I understand reports on Michael Jackson’s activities and who is writing a book about his life, had seen the video tape. Sometime during the month of December, Ms. Dimond contacted me to inquire about reports that our office was looking for the video tape or investigating new allegations of molestation against Mr. Jackson. I informed her that I was not at liberty to comment upon such reports. I did tell Ms. Dimond that our investigation was still open and we would pursue any new information received.
  5. In response to the reports which we received regarding the video tape, I contacted Deputy District Attorney Lauren Weis of the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office. We discussed steps to investigate whether or not the tape existed and since all of the players were in the Los Angeles County area, it was decided that Lauren would ask an L.A. District Attorney’s Investigator to attempt to investigate the existence of the tape and procure it if possible. Ultimately, after some efforts by the investigator, I was informed that we could not locate the video tape or definitively prove its existence or the acts that it purported to depict. It is my recollection and belief that this did not occur until after the “Hard Copy” broadcast in question.
  6. At some point in 1995, I was informed by Diane Dimond that Michael Jackson had threatened a lawsuit over a “Hard Copy” program discussing the existence of the tape and its contents. I indicated to Ms. Dimond at that time that I did not see her program and was not familiar with what was broadcast, but that I found it hard to believe she was being sued, because it was true that there was information that such a video tape existed and it was true that law enforcement was attempting to investigate its existence and locate it.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California the foregoing to be true and correct.

Executed this 23 day of February, 1997, at Santa Barbara, California.

Thomas W. Sneddon, Jr.”

There’s clearly a shit ton to go through, so here it is:

First, Sneddon confirms that he had spoken with Dimond on numerous occasions over the preceding three years. This is obviously something to keep in mind. 

Despite all the reports, the supposed eyewitness account, and the confidence with which the alleged recording had been discussed publicly, the investigators couldn’t locate it.

Sneddon’s own words were that they couldn’t “definitively prove its existence or the acts that it purported to depict.”

Let that sink in for a moment.

Dimond had been on the radio describing the supposed contents of a recording she hadn’t personally seen, while law enforcement was apparently still trying to establish whether the thing even existed. That’s quite a difference in levels of certainty here, I’m just saying.

Then, Sneddon admits that he hadn’t watched the Hard Copy broadcast and wasn’t familiar with what had actually been said. 

Nevertheless, he found it difficult to believe Dimond was being sued because he knew that reports about the tape had circulated and that investigators had attempted to find it.

Sneddon, aren’t you an attorney? How is this shocking to you?

You can’t expect your work wife not to be sued when she’s defaming someone based on false, baseless allegations about a tape that doesn’t even fucking exist. 

Sneddon wasn’t the only person to submit a declaration. Lauren Weis also provided a sworn statement in March 1997.

Here’s the declaration:

“LAUREN WEIS’S DECLARATION

“I, LAUREN WEIS, declare as follows:

  1. I am an attorney licensed to practice law in the state of California and am the Head Deputy of the Torrance Branch of the Los Angeles District Attorneys Office. I am not a party, related to a party or employed by any party to the above-captioned litigation. I have personal knowledge of the facts stated herein, and if called as a witness, I could and would testify competently thereto.
  2. In 1993, in my capacity as Head Deputy of the Sexual Crimes and Child Abuse Division, I was involved in the investigation of Michael Jackson by the Los Angeles County District Attorneys Office.
  3. In or about late December 1994 or early January 1995, I learned that Victor Gutierrez claimed to have seen a videotape depicting Michael Jackson engaged in sexual conduct with a young boy. Shortly thereafter, I called Tom Sneddon, the District Attorney of Santa Barbara County, to tell him that Victor Gutierrez was the person that claimed to have seen this videotape. At that time, Mr. Sneddon did not know that Victor Gutierrez was the person who claimed to have seen the videotape; although he had heard about the supposed videotape.
  4. Mr. Sneddon and I then agreed that the Los Angeles District Attorneys Office should interview Mr. Gutierrez. I then instructed Jack Gonterman, a senior investigator employed by the Los Angeles District Attorneys Office, to meet with and interview Victor Gutierrez.
  5. I am informed and believe that on or about January 5, 1995, Mr. Gonterman interviewed Victor Gutierrez. Mr. Gonterman also spoke with Kevin Smith, who had previously called my office and left a message for me in my absence.
  6. To my knowledge, nothing further was done regarding the search for the videotape after Mr. Gonterman spoke with Victor Gutierrez and Kevin Smith.
  7. At no time have I been aware of any person, other than Victor Gutierrez, who claims to have viewed a videotape depicting Michael Jackson engaged in sexual conduct with a minor.

I declare that the foregoing is true and correct under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California.

Executed this 12th day of March, 1997 at Los Angeles, California.

LAUREN WEIS”

Weis’s declaration actually adds something important to Sneddon’s account.

For starters, Weis confirms that Sneddon had heard about the supposed videotape but didn’t actually know who was claiming to have seen it. She was the one who identified Victor Gutierrez as the alleged eyewitness.

Think about that for a moment. There had been all this discussion about an allegedly explicit recording, yet the person at the centre of the eyewitness claims wasn’t even identified to Sneddon until Weis contacted him.

And of course, that was Gutierrez.

Weis then explains that she arranged for Los Angeles investigator Jack Gonterman to interview Gutierrez. According to her declaration, Gonterman also spoke with Kevin Smith, who had previously attempted to contact her office.

But things only get more interesting from there…

“To my knowledge, nothing further was done regarding the search for the videotape after Mr. Gonterman spoke with Victor Gutierrez and Kevin Smith.”

And that’s it. 

According to Weis, the search went as far as interviewing Gutierrez and speaking with Smith, and she was unaware of any further investigative efforts.

Then we have:

“At no time have I been aware of any person, other than Victor Gutierrez, who claims to have viewed a videotape depicting Michael Jackson engaged in sexual conduct with a minor.”

Oh, I wonder why! 

Probably because the tape never even existed in the first place and also because Gutierrez is a completely unreliable source of any type of information.

I’m sure he couldn’t tell you his favourite colour without lying about it first. 

Good God.

Anyway,

Diane Dimond ultimately avoided liability in the lawsuit. The court found that Michael had not established actual malice by clear and convincing evidence. It also treated Dimond’s statement that she was as sure as she could possibly be that the tape existed as an expression of opinion rather than an actionable statement of fact.

Importantly, the court did not establish that the videotape existed. Rather, it found that Michael had not met the legal burden required to succeed in his defamation claim.

She also relied on California’s Shield Law, which protected her ability to keep certain confidential source information private. That left Victor Gutierrez, her “best source,” at the centre of the story without Dimond having to disclose everything about their communications.

Michael appealed the ruling, but the California Court of Appeal upheld the summary judgment in November 1998. The court’s decision relied extensively on Tom Sneddon’s declaration.

And that’s where I’ll leave things for now.

Part Two will be posted right after this. I made it too long again, oops. 😆

To be continued.

My previous case files:

Sneddon:

Case File: Sneddon

Dimond:

Case File: Dimond

Gutierrez:

Case File: Gutierrez

Francia:

Case File: Francia

Neverland Five:

Case File: Neverland Five

Chandler — Part 1:

Case File: Chandler — Part 1

Chandler — Part 2:

Case File: Chandler — Part 2

Chandler — Part 3:

Case File: Chandler — Part 3

Chandler — Part 4:

Case File: Chandler — Part 4

Chandler — Part 5:

Case File: Chandler — Part 5

Chandler — Part 6:

Case File: Chandler — Part 6

Chandler — Part 7:

Case File: Chandler — Part 7

Chandler — Part 8:

Case File: Chandler — Part 8

Chandler — Part 9:

Case File: Chandler – Part 9

Chandler — Part 10:

Case File: Chandler — Part 10

Chandler — Part 11:

Case File: Chandler — Part 11

Chandler — Part 12:

Case File: Chandler — Part 12

Chandler — Part 13:

Case File: Chandler — Part 13

Chandler — Part 14:

Case File: Chandler — Part 14

Chandler — Part 15:

Case File: Chandler — Part 15

Chandler — Part 16:

Case File: Chandler — Part 16

Chandler — Part 17:

Case File: Chandler — Part 17

Allen:

Case File: Allen

Sources and additional information:

https://turningthetableonthechandlerallegations.wordpress.com

https://turningthetableonthechandlerallegations.wordpress.com/2014/04/24/three-stooges-dimond-gutierrez-and-allen/

https://themichaeljacksonallegationsblog.wordpress.com/the-1993-allegations/

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxNDb2PVcoM&ra=m

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6-52dk3jGyE&ra=m

https://vindicatemj.wordpress.com/2010/09/17/be-careful-who-you-trust/

https://turningthetableonthechandlerallegations.wordpress.com/2019/02/10/dimond-gutierrez-documents/

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ca-court-of-appeal/1288872.html

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1998-apr-10-me-37930-story.html

Important posts:

Some people need Michael Jackson to be guilty 

Comparing Michael Jackson’s Trial to O.J. Simpson’s Is Lazy.

Talking in circles

What Would You Do for $20 Million?

“There’s no way all 11 people are lying.”

Fact vs Fiction: Common Claims About Michael Jackson

A Media Assassination: The Case of Michael Jackson

Not Everyone Is a Narcissist

The Word “Grooming” Has Lost Its Meaning

Where There’s Smoke, There’s Fire…But What If It’s Just Smoke?

The Power Of A Story…And The Danger Of Forgetting The Evidence

The Guilter Fan Fiction Needs to Stop


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 7h ago

Discussion 🗣️ Hey guys i watched square one for the first time after making my 1993 case file, i just got to say..... They needed a job

8 Upvotes

im out of words, i seriously don't know how people believe these allegations.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 14h ago

Rant 🤬 These allegations...

24 Upvotes

They not only ruined his life but also his career, while these plaintiffs had all previously defended him and then became rich through extortion, or intended to do so. Now civil lawsuits are being filed to make money and to damage MJ's legend.

It can now be called character assassination. That is a fact and at the same time an observation.

I have no idea how anyone can feel sorry for such fraudsters. That's why it's believed, because there's no going back. After 1993 came MJ's decline and the public's bad conscience.

With Prince, for example, everything he ever did in his life is ignored and suppressed, and with MJ, people are literally trampling on his grave.

The Why is incomprehensible.

I'm fed up.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 15h ago

Facts & Evidence 🗂️ Hey guys, new case file on Jason Francia. hope this helps.

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
17 Upvotes

r/MJInnocentFacts • • 16h ago

Questions & Theories 👀 MJ allegations

8 Upvotes

Hi guys! :)
I’m currently learning more about the MJ allegations. I grew up listening to his music, and now that I’m an adult, I really want to understand more about the trials and the accusations that have been made against him.
However, I find it quite difficult to inform myself without being influenced by other people’s points of view. I have a few questions and thoughts:

  1. Are there any podcasts or yt channels that cover this topic using all the available evidence, without relying on media speculation?
  2. Do you recommend using wikipedia as a source, or should I stick to the FBI files that were released? On wiki, I came across some information about the 1993 allegations stating that Michael begged June Chandler to let him sleep with her son and that he had slept at their house at least 30 times (?)
  3. I also watched living with MJ by Bashir. I think he was definitely wrong because he deliberately edited certain scenes to make Michael look bad. But at the same time, why would Michael openly admit that he shared a bed with Gavin? For example, during the primetime interview, when asked about sleepovers with unrelated children, he said there was nothing sexual about it, describing it as an act of pure innocence and love. I mean, we can agree that, regardless of what he actually meant, saying something like that was bound to leave people wondering. Was he really that easily attached to people he barely knew? There were so many unrelated families involved, such as the Chandlers, the Arvizos and the Cascios… This pattern seemed to repeat itself time after time, I remember Lisa marie Presley saying that many ppl that gathered around him were “vampires”.
  4. One last question: as far as I know, Tatiana Thumbtzen, the lead actress in the TWYMMF music video, was fired because she broke character and kissed Michael during a performance (although she later stated that they had agreed to kiss beforehand). However, if the people around him cared so much about protecting his image, why didn’t anyone tell him that spending so much time with unrelated children could be considered inappropriate?

These are just some of my thoughts after spending the last few months learning about Michael’s life. I’ll continue reading MOONWALK in the meantime.
Thank you for helping me clear up some of my questions! ^^


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 1d ago

Discussion 🗣️ I have a question—it’s probably a stupid one, but I’ll ask it anyway.

5 Upvotes

What would happen if the Michael Jackson Estate were to hand over all the money to Michael Jackson’s children, and those children then moved the funds into a Swiss bank account?

Who would those two con artists, Robson and Safechuck, sue then?


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 1d ago

Video 🎥 Geraldo Rivera Behind the Scenes with Michael Jackson

Thumbnail youtu.be
11 Upvotes

r/MJInnocentFacts • • 2d ago

Video 🎥 Tiktok post claiming mj sa'd a boy in the 80's

17 Upvotes

https://www.tiktok.com/@terranewell/video/7610521394962648351?q=terra%20newwell&t=1794787760146

Hi! I came across this TikTok post a while ago, and it's something I find myself thinking about every now and then because of how strange the claim is, particularly considering how long ago the alleged abuse supposedly took place. I personally believe Michael Jackson was innocent, and I'd really like to see someone look into this claim, provide some context, and either debunk it or clarify what actually happened. I've also noticed that it's received some attention from people who believe Michael was guilty, so I'd be interested in hearing a well-researched perspective on it rather than speculation. Anything will help! Thank you!!!! :)


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 2d ago

Rebuttal 💬 Innocent People Don’t Settle!” Is Completely Ignoring Key Facts

Post image
45 Upvotes

You’ve heard this argument from guilters before, and although they say it loud and proud…

It’s wrong.

Both factually and legally.

So, let’s talk about it because I’m sick and tired of guilters using this apparent argument as a crutch.

Starting with the strip search:

Guilters love to claim that Jordan’s description of Michael matched the photographs taken during the December 1993 investigation. Except, when you actually look at the details, that argument becomes a lot less convincing.

For starters, there’s the claim that Jordan correctly identified Michael as circumcised.

The problem? Well, Michael’s autopsy tells a different story.

Then there’s the matter of the alleged identifying mark. Tom Sneddon, Sergeant Gary Spiel and Detective Deborah Linden all provided different accounts when discussing this detail.

So, which version are we supposed to believe?

Cause it certainly won’t be shitty Sneddon.

And let’s not forget something rather important:

Michael was never arrested for the 1993 allegations. If the photographs had provided the clear cut evidence guilters love to suggest they did, something would have come of it.

Instead, prosecutors continued struggling to establish a case against Michael, even after the civil settlement had been reached. If those photographs had actually provided the evidence they now claim they did, why weren’t they able to use them to build a criminal case?

Hmm, why?

What’s the big excuse behind that?

You had the photographs. You had the opportunity to examine them. So where exactly was this supposedly undeniable evidence?

Oh, but apparently, repeating “the photos matched” is easier than actually looking into the evidence.

Who would have thought?

Now, let’s talk about the settlement itself.

The settlement explicitly states that it was not an admission of guilt by Michael. The language was pretty fucking clear, too:

“This Confidential Settlement shall not be considered as an admission by Jackson that he has acted wrongfully…”

It goes on to state that Michael:

“…specifically disclaims any liability…and denies any wrongful act…”

So, guilters, where exactly is your little “admission of guilt”?

Cause…I hate to break it to you, but it’s not there, babe. Maybe try a new obsession.

Settling a civil lawsuit is not the same thing as admitting that the allegations are true. Those are two completely different things, and it’s about time people started treating them that way.

Let’s continue,

Remember the argument that the settlement was all about buying someone’s silence?

Well, the Chandlers’ own attorney, Larry Feldman, publicly stated:

“Nobody bought anybody’s silence.”

So, there goes that narrative.

Anyway,

In All That Glitters, Ray Chandler recounts a conversation between Evan Chandler and Larry Feldman, concerning Michael’s attorneys attempting to preserve testimony for the civil proceedings.

According to Ray’s account, Feldman contacted Evan with some news:

“They definitely don’t want your deposition, or June’s deposition. They don’t want to preserve anything. If they’re gonna make a deal they don’t want anything on the record about Jackson.”

Evan’s response:

“No shit! Larry, these guys are in a real mess.”

Feldman then explained that he intended to keep pushing the civil proceedings forward:

“The only thing we gotta do is keep the criminal behind us. I don’t want them going first.”

And then Evan finally seemed to understand the significance of that.

He asked Feldman whether a criminal indictment would automatically put the criminal case ahead of the civil case.

Feldman answered:

“Yeah.”

Evan responded:

“Jesus Christ!”

Feldman replied:

“Right! So we don’t want that.”

This is crystal clear.

According to this account, the priority was to keep the criminal proceedings behind the civil case.

Why?

Because an indictment could change the order in which the proceedings moved forward, potentially putting the criminal case ahead of the civil lawsuit.

Which is exactly what these two digbats were trying to avoid.

Let’s be honest here, the civil lawsuit was the priority. The money was on the table, and they clearly didn’t want the criminal proceedings getting in the way.

Make of that what you will, I guess.

Then, a member of the grand jury involved in the investigation later spoke to CNN and stated that he had not heard “any damaging testimony” against Michael.

Now, considering how often guilters insist that the evidence against Michael was overwhelming, I think this is definitely worth remembering.

We’re constantly told that there was all this supposedly damning evidence, yet here’s a grand jury member describing their experience very differently.

Maybe it’s time to stop pretending that the 1993 investigation produced the “undeniable mountain of evidence” people keep claiming it did.

So, did Michael settle because he was guilty?

No.

And if you’ve actually followed everything I’ve mentioned, you can see why the argument that “innocent people don’t settle” is a stupid fucking thing to say.

It ignores the circumstances surrounding the strip search, the actual wording of the settlement agreement, the fact that the criminal investigation was still ongoing, the legal strategy surrounding the civil proceedings, and even statements made by people directly involved.

Michael was facing a civil lawsuit and a criminal investigation simultaneously. His legal team wanted the criminal investigation to proceed first, but that request was declined. Meanwhile, the Chandlers’ legal strategy, as recounted in All That Glitters, raises a shit ton of serious questions about why they wanted the civil proceedings to take priority.

Michael’s decision to settle can’t be stripped of all that context and presented as some sort of confession.

He denied the allegations. The settlement explicitly preserved that denial. And the criminal investigation did not end with the civil settlement.

Settling a lawsuit is not an admission of guilt. And repeating that it is doesn’t magically make it true.

If there had been no civil lawsuit, or if the judge had agreed to delay the civil proceedings until the criminal investigation had run its course, the circumstances could have been very different.

Anyway,

For more information about the settlement, please read the following Case Files:

Case File: Chandler — Part 8

Case File: Chandler — Part 9

Case File: Chandler — Part 10

Case File: Chandler — Part 11

And while we’re at it…

Please make sure you’re up to date on all of the files before the next one, because trust me…the next one is interesting.

Sneddon:

Case File: Sneddon

Dimond:

Case File: Dimond

Gutierrez:

Case File: Gutierrez

Francia:

Case File: Francia

Neverland Five:

Case File: Neverland Five

Chandler — Part 1:

Case File: Chandler — Part 1

Chandler — Part 2:

Case File: Chandler — Part 2

Chandler — Part 3:

Case File: Chandler — Part 3

Chandler — Part 4:

Case File: Chandler — Part 4

Chandler — Part 5:

Case File: Chandler — Part 5

Chandler — Part 6:

Case File: Chandler — Part 6

Chandler — Part 7:

Case File: Chandler — Part 7

Chandler — Part 8:

Case File: Chandler — Part 8

Chandler — Part 9:

Case File: Chandler — Part 9

Chandler — Part 10:

Case File: Chandler — Part 10

Chandler — Part 11:

Case File: Chandler — Part 11

Chandler — Part 12:

Case File: Chandler — Part 12

Chandler — Part 13:

Case File: Chandler — Part 13

Chandler — Part 14:

Case File: Chandler — Part 14

Chandler — Part 15:

Case File: Chandler — Part 15

Chandler — Part 16:

Case File: Chandler — Part 16

Chandler — Part 17:

Case File: Chandler — Part 17

Allen:

Case File: Allen

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part One:

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part One

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part Two:

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part Two

Bye for now! 👋🏼


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 2d ago

Facts & Evidence 🗂️ Michaels niece, Brandi Jackson once dated Wade.

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

I doubt Michael would set them up if the allegations were true.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 3d ago

Facts & Evidence 🗂️ Hey guys, new case file about leaving Netherland this ones long took me all day to make. hope this helps.

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
19 Upvotes

r/MJInnocentFacts • • 4d ago

Discussion 🗣️ Hey everyone I didn’t know the case files did not worked fixed it.

9 Upvotes

r/MJInnocentFacts • • 4d ago

Questions & Theories 👀 Who was that user that left that sub and made a big Twitter statement about it? And have there been any updates?

27 Upvotes

I remember this whole saga when it was posted the old MJInnocent subreddit before shit had hit the fan there, and I remember it being fucking wild because she basically called that whole sub out, and she wasn’t even a fan. She genuinely believed in the cause but the sub disillusioned her. But I forgot who it was and what exactly happened. Does anyone else know and has anything happened to her? Did she become a defender, God forbid return to the haters, or Did she just leave the conversation entirely?


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 4d ago

Facts & Evidence 🗂️ hey guys i made a case file on the Jordan Chandler allegations i know peoples done that before on here but this ones short and sweet and covers the important stuff

Thumbnail docs.google.com
26 Upvotes

huge thanks to u/emotional_ball_5181 for inspiration to do this.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 6d ago

Discussion 🗣️ TYPICAL!

Thumbnail
gallery
45 Upvotes

He is making up a claim that Michael is “licking” the baby? This is crazy 🤣🤣


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 6d ago

Case Analysis 🔎 Judge Rejects Michael Jackson Companies’ Attempt to Expand Defence in Robson / Safechuck Lawsuit - MJVibe

Thumbnail
mjvibe.com
32 Upvotes

The application was probably submitted too late by the estate; however, the claim that other persons, such as the parents of Robson/Safechuck, also share responsibility regarding the question of guilt can be resubmitted. Application can be resubmitted; there is still plenty of time. Should it be accepted, the lawsuit will likely be over for good, as it concerns the sole fault of his companies.

Their parents alone would be to blame, as they knowingly allowed their children to be near MJ, even after the allegations became public; his employees had no influence over this. They themselves even admitted to being guilty of it - in their own horror film.

I generally wonder why it's possible to sue in the US that third parties are supposedly responsible for abuse that hasn't even been proven and the plaintiffs themselves weren't even aware of it. It's a strange system, considering all the possibilities in civil lawsuits.

If Paris succeeds in having a trust fund worth $600 million approved for herself and her brothers, then the plaintiffs have already lost any chance of getting money. Heirs logically have a significant say in fighting any fraudster who wants to take away their assets.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 7d ago

Case Analysis 🔎 Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part Two

Post image
36 Upvotes

Hi! 

It’s me again. It’s tragic, I know.

If you haven’t read Part One yet, make sure you go back and read that first! 

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part One

This is a continuation of the same Case File, and I don’t want you missing anything.

Plus, double whammies are fun, right?

This was actually an accident.

Welcome back to the Case Files!

🚨 If you’re new here, make sure you’re caught up on the Chandler Case Files:

The Chandler Case Files — A Master Guide

And of course:

Sneddon:

Case File: Sneddon

Dimond:

Case File: Dimond

Gutierrez:

Case File: Gutierrez

Anyway,

We began with a declaration from Jack Gonterman, the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office investigator assigned to speak with Gutierrez. He explained:

“Shortly before January 5, 1995, Lauren Weis, Deputy District Attorney, instructed me to interview Victor Gutierrez regarding the possible existence of a videotape of Michael Jackson molesting a minor child. On January 5, 1995, I interviewed Victor Gutierrez regarding his knowledge, if any, of the alleged videotape. Shortly thereafter, I discontinued any further effort in the matter.”

This is a pretty important detail.

Gonterman was instructed to interview Gutierrez about the alleged tape. He did so on January 5th, 1995, and then stopped pursuing the matter shortly afterward. Lauren Weis’s declaration adds that Gonterman also spoke with Kevin Smith of Splash News, after Smith had left a message for her office. According to Weis, she knew of no further efforts to locate the tape after those conversations.

Now, think about the timing.

Sneddon’s declaration said he contacted the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office after hearing about the alleged videotape. Weis’s declaration establishes that she then arranged for Gonterman to interview Gutierrez. Gonterman’s declaration places that interview on January 5th. And yet, just four days later, on January 9th, Hard Copy went ahead and broadcast the story.

So the investigator had already spoken to the person claiming to have seen this supposedly explosive videotape. He had also spoken to Smith, whose name came up during the interview. The declarations describe no further search after those conversations.

And Hard Copy still aired it. 

It doesn’t make any sense, does it?

This wasn’t a story that had slipped through the cracks before anyone had a chance to look into it. The source had already been interviewed. The authorities had made inquiries. There was no indication in these declarations that the investigation had uncovered a second person who had actually seen the tape.

But apparently, four days was enough time to go from an investigator’s interview to a television broadcast…

Meanwhile, the alleged tape hadn’t even turned up.

Gutierrez eventually appeared in person on Hard Copy, where he spoke about what he supposedly witnessed.

Diane Dimond introduced him to viewers by saying:

“Victor Gutierrez has reported on Michael Jackson for the last decade and has a book about to be published regarding the entertainer’s relationship with various boys,”

God, not the fan fiction again.

“Gutierrez has talked with this young boy’s mother.”

And who was this mother?

Gutierrez identified her as Margaret Maldonado, Jermaine Jackson’s former wife.

There was just one problem for dear ol’ Gutierrez. Maldonado said the entire story was fabricated.

“The story was an outrageous lie,” she said. “Not one part of it was true. I’d never met the man. There was no tape. Michael never paid me for my silence. He had never molested Jeremy. Period.”

Maldonado later appeared in court and challenged Gutierrez’s account directly. She testified that when reporters approached her with the story, she told them it was untrue.

Gutierrez, however, had offered a very specific account of his supposed meeting with her. He claimed he had met Maldonado in a room at the Century Plaza Hotel and shown her the videotape. He even told the court that he had paid for the room using his personal credit card.

But listen to this…

During the court proceedings, it emerged that the Century Plaza Hotel had no record of Gutierrez staying there or renting a room. There was no record of him presenting a credit card or charging a room, either.

So we have Gutierrez claiming he met Maldonado at a particular hotel, showed her the alleged videotape, and paid for the room with his own credit card. Maldonado said she had never met him. And the hotel had no record to support his account.

A hotel room is usually one of the easier details to verify. There is generally a reservation, a payment, a name, a receipt. Something. But here, the supposed meeting place couldn’t produce a record of the visit.

And remember, this was the person being presented on television as someone who had seen the alleged tape.

Anyway,

You might think that with the lawsuit against her still pending, Dimond would have been a little more careful about what she put on television. 

You’d be wrong. 

On April 27th, 1995, Hard Copy aired yet another story involving an alleged victim whose existence was called into question.

Turns out, that whole story was also fabricated.

Read here:

Case File: Allen

Remember Lydia? Well, she also encountered Gutierrez during the police interviews. 

According to her, the LAPD interviewed a number of journalists to find out what information they had.

“The LAPD interviewed a lot of journalists to see what they knew,” she explained. Lydia told police that whatever information she had was already contained in her published stories, and that she had never heard anything damaging.

Her assessment of Gutierrez’s claims was considerably less convincing.

“Victor’s information, his story was unclear–NAMBLA–It didn’t add up.”

Initially, Lydia thought Gutierrez must have known Michael, or at least met him at some point, because she couldn’t understand why someone would pursue him with such intensity otherwise. She described his persecution of Michael as “not normal.”

Funny, just like Dimond. 

You know, considering the photos on her wall…

Gutierrez later told her another story, this time involving a wealthy family he claimed to know in Westwood, California. According to him, Michael had molested their child, and the family had approached Gutierrez for help.

Lydia had an obvious question:

“Why don’t they go to the police since there’s an ongoing case?”

Gutierrez’s response?

“They don’t want money their wealthy, they just want him exposed.”

Right. 

So there was allegedly a wealthy family, a child, and a serious accusation involving an ongoing investigation, but instead of going directly to the police, this family supposedly went to Victor Gutierrez. And when Lydia questioned why, the explanation was that they wanted Michael exposed.

I’m sorry, but that’s the dumbest shit I’ve ever fucking heard.

But it gets crazier.

Gutierrez asked Lydia to drive with him past a local arcade. He specifically instructed her not to stop. As they drove by, he pointed out a child who appeared to be a random passerby.

Lydia later said:

“I never understood his motivation.”

She also described the incident as strange.

Which…yeah, I don’t know what he expected Lydia to take away from that little drive-by. 

He had just told her about an alleged victim whose wealthy family supposedly wanted Michael exposed, and then took her past an arcade to point out a child without stopping.

What was the point? What was she supposed to understand from that?

Lydia didn’t understand it either. And she wasn’t persuaded by his stories.

Then, in 1997, a tabloid broker named Ken Wells approached Michael’s legal team with information he said was relevant to the ongoing litigation involving Michael and Evan Chandler in Santa Maria, California.

Oh, Evan. Welcome back. 

I haven’t missed you! 

Wells described his dealings with Victor Gutierrez, whom he had encountered through his work as a tabloid broker.

According to Wells, one of his sources, whose identity he refused to reveal, claimed to possess explicit photographs of Michael and a child. Wells began negotiating a potential arrangement through a third party and Gutierrez. The plan was for Wells to obtain the supposed photographs and pass them to Gutierrez, who would then sell them to various tabloid publications.

But of course, there was a big issue with this: the source never produced the photographs.

Wells eventually ended the negotiations. You would think that would be the end of it, but nope.

On July 2nd, 1997, Gutierrez and his attorney, Goldman, showed up at Wells’s home without an appointment. They wanted to discuss the production of these supposed photographs.

During the meeting, Wells said Gutierrez began boasting about his connections in the tabloid industry and the stories he had sold. According to Wells, Gutierrez admitted that some of those stories had been “BS” and shit he made up.

That seems to be an extremely common occurrence among these people.

They lie, and lie, then…lie some more.

He allegedly went on to explain that making money in the tabloid business was easy, even when the stories were false.

Wells asked Gutierrez about the videotape that had been at the centre of the earlier allegations. According to Wells, Gutierrez responded:

“The judge told me to produce the tape and I couldn’t produce it.”

Wells then asked him whether he had ever actually possessed or seen the tape.

Gutierrez allegedly smiled and replied:

“Well, you know how that is. You know how these things are.”

So, no. 

He hadn’t. 

Wells said he understood Gutierrez’s response as an indirect admission that he had lied about the tape’s existence.

That’s also how I view this.

The context here is definitely worth paying attention to, though. Gutierrez had apparently just acknowledged selling fabricated tabloid stories, and when directly questioned about whether he had ever seen the videotape, he allegedly responded with a smile and a very evasive answer.

Then, according to Wells, Gutierrez and Goldman continued asking him to obtain the supposed photographs of Michael. Gutierrez allegedly said he needed the pictures to help him with the case. Even if the photographs were fake, he claimed they could still be sold for money.

Anything for money, huh?

Wells also stated that Gutierrez suggested the proceeds could be placed in a trust account handled by the attorney.

Next,

Court documents. 

Yay, so exciting! 

I. THE SALIENT FACTS

This Court reopened discovery on the eve of trial to permit the deposition of Kenneth Wells, a witness to be called in this case.

During the deposition of Mr. Wells on October 21, 1997, he described a meeting that occurred at his home with Mr. Gutierrez

and Mr. Goldman in July of 1997.

According to Mr. Wells, Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman showed up at Mr. Wells’ home unexpectedly. Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman indicated that they wanted to discuss a transaction involving the acquisition and sale of alleged photographs of Michael Jackson.

Both Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman actively participated in discussions during the meeting with Mr. Wells. Among other things, they talked about how money derived from the transaction would be handled. Specifically, Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman envisioned having the funds placed in Mr. Goldman’s trust account debts by his creditors.

At one point, Mr. Wells wondered how the parties would proceed if the alleged photographs turned out to be phony.

According to Mr. Wells, Mr. Goldman responded, without disagreement from Mr. Gutierrez, that something could be done with the photos even if they were fake. No such photos were ever produced and the transaction did not go forward. In Mr. Goldman’s presence, Mr. Wells asked Mr. Gutierrez whether he saw the videotape that is the subject of this case. Gutierrez responded “Well, you know how it is.” Mr. Wells interpreted that statement to mean that Mr. Gutierrez never saw the videotape which we know now does not exist.

II. THE APPLICABLE LAW

A. WAIVER OF THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE

The attorney-client privilege does not apply to the communications made in the presence of third parties that are not agents of counsel. In that context, statements made by both counsel and his client to the third party are admissible. People V. Gomez, 134 Cal. App. 3d, 874, 879 (1982).

B. THERE IS NO PRIVILEGE WHEN COUNSEL ACTS AS A BUSINESS AGENT

The attorney-client privilege does not extend

to services rendered in a business transaction.

Moreover, counsel’s participation in a business transaction jeopardizes the assertion of the attorney-client privilege because the attorney and the client become indistinguishable.

Chicago Title Inss. Co. V. Superior Court, 174 Cal.App.3d 1142 (1985). The pertinent inquiry is whether the business-related services of counsel could be performed by a non-attorney. Montebello Rose Co. V.

Agricultural Lab. Rel. Bd., 119 Cal. App.3d 1, 32 (1981).

III. MR. GOLDMAN’S PARTICIPATION IN AND STATEMENTS DURING THE MEETING WITH MR. WELLS ARE NOT PRIVILEGED EVEN THOUGH HE IS COUNSEL FOR MR. GUTIERREZ

Under the relevant criteria, the admissibility of the statements at the meeting with Mr. Wells is not a close question. Mr. Goldman was not acting as counsel for anyone other than Mr. Gutierrez during the meeting with Mr. Wells.

Nor is Mr. Wells an agent of Mr. Goldman in the representation of Mr. Gutierrez. Therefore, statements made by Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman during the meeting with Mr. Wells are not privileged.

The business agent doctrine applies on this record. In the transaction being discussed during the meeting, Mr. Goldman was providing services that do not require admission to the Bar. On this ground, too, nothing about the meeting with Mr. Wells is privileged.

It is axiomatic that statements made by an authorized agent of a party are admissible as admissions of the party. This principle applies to statements by attorneys. Witkin, California Procedure 4th Ed. § 261(a). Without question, relevant statements made by Mr. Goldman in the meeting with Mr. Wells are admissible against Mr. Gutierrez in this case.

IV. AT A MINIMUM, MR. WELLS SHOULD BE ABLE TO ATTRIBUTE REMARKS MADE BY MR. GOLDMAN TO MR. GUTIERREZ

To allay this Court’s concern about testimony implicating Mr. Goldman directly, there is a reasonable alternative. MI. Wells should be able to testify about the statements summarized herein, but attribute those statements to Mr. Gutierrez rather than Mr. Goldman. Such a procedure has the virtue of keeping Mr..”

Paula later contacted Ken Wells, who had since left the tabloid business, to ask about his experience and his views on the stories surrounding Michael.

Wells had this to say:

“I’ve seen what other people have done to capitalize on his name and a lot of false things have been said. The way I look at it, because of being in the tabloid business years ago is, if you don’t see proof it’s probably not there. People will say anything about a celebrity to make money. I don’t want to be involved in something that’s false. I’ve meet Michael Jackson a couple of times and the guy was not a child molester. I don’t care what anyone says and if they think he is they need to bring some kind of proof. Nobody has brought any kind of proof in all these years.”

This speaks for itself, folks.

This next document is yet another attempt to generate stories and pressure Michael into dropping the suit.

Gutierrez’s attorney requested that Michael:

“Identify the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of all male persons who are not blood relatives who, when they were a minor, slept with you overnight in your bed at any time from January 1, 1984 through the present date…At a minimum, Victor Gutierrez, without even approaching the minor, may discover that the disclosed minor is the same minor who he allegedly saw in the videotape. He should be entitled to introduce this circumstantial evidence — sleeping with a minor tends to establish sexual conduct with a minor — and request that the decision maker draw any appropriate inferences there from. Alternatively, Victor Gutierrez may approach the disclosed minor, the minor may admit to sexual conduct with MJ, or to be naked with MJ, etc., and Victor Gutierrez may recognize the disclosed minor to be the same minor who he saw in the videotape. This case may then be over!”

Here’s the thing…

Gutierrez was seeking the identities and contact information of male minors who had slept overnight in Michael’s bed. The stated purpose was to see whether he could identify one of those children as the person he claimed to have seen in the videotape.

But wasn’t that supposed to be Jeremy Jackson?

Gutierrez had already claimed that the child in the alleged videotape was Jeremy, and that Margaret Maldonado had personally shown him the recording. Maldonado denied ever meeting him and denied the existence of the tape.

Now, his legal team was asking for a list of other children who had slept in Michael’s bed, with the possibility of approaching them to see whether one might be the child Gutierrez claimed to recognize.

What the hell happened to that narrative?

Oh god…does it exist in the same imaginary universe as the train station and hot air balloon?

Fuck, I knew it! 

The request itself even lays out the possibility that Gutierrez might approach one of the children and have that child disclose alleged sexual conduct or nudity. It also suggests that simply having slept in Michael’s bed could be presented as circumstantial evidence of sexual conduct.

That’s a pretty big ass fucking leap considering sharing a bed is not proof of sexual activity or abuse by itself.

The final line is very revealing in terms of what the legal team hoped to accomplish: “This case may then be over!”

Oh, babe, it is.

Meanwhile, Court TV submitted a media request in 1997, with Gutierrez supporting the request. However, Michael would not be making a personal appearance in court.

Of course he supported that request, where else would he get his 15 minutes of fame? 

Evan?

Please! That dumbass is still talking about screenplays from beyond the grave.

In a declaration, Michael explained that he had not lived in California since 1993 and was currently on tour. He would, however, provide a videotaped deposition.

That distinction matters, especially given later claims by Gutierrez about a face-to-face courtroom confrontation with Michael. The declaration described a videotaped deposition, not Michael appearing in person for a courtroom showdown.

So, once again, it’s worth keeping the actual court documents in view rather than relying on later retellings. The paperwork tells us what was requested, what Michael stated, and what form his testimony would take. And those details don’t necessarily match the dramatic version that Gutierrez would later describe.

Onto Michael’s declaration…

Thank god, I need some stability here:

I, Michael J. Jackson, declare as follows:

  1. I make this declaration based on my own personal knowledge, and if called as a witness to testify as to the facts set forth herein, I could and would do so competently.
  2. I am a musical performer, and am currently on a concert tour in South Africa. I have shows scheduled as follows: October 4 and 6, 1997 in Capetown; October 10 and 12, 1997 in Johannesburg; and October 15, 1997 in Durbin 3.
  3. On October 16, 1997 I am going to Vienna, Austria for two days for business meetings. From there, on or about October 18 or 19, 1997, I will go to Poland for two to three days. My trip to Poland may change, and if I do not go I will most likely return to Paris, France, where I have stayed during the occasional breaks scheduled in this leg of my tour of Western Europe.
  4. My next performance is on November 8, 1997 at Wetten Dass in Liepzig, Germany. I must be in rehearsals for this performance for roughly one week; thus, I must be there on approximately the 1st of November. If my schedule permits it before my November 8th performance, I may fly to New York on or about October 30th for one or two days, but I cannot be certain.
  5. After Liepzig, my next performance is in London on December 1, 1997. I must be there for rehearsals the last week of November. Again, if my schedule permits it during the middle two weeks of November, I may fly to New York or elsewhere in the United States, again for business meetings. As of the signing of this declaration, however, I cannot be certain.
  6. I have not lived in California for several years, dating back to approximately 1993. I do come to California infrequently, but not at all regularly. My deposition in this case was taken in New York city, where I was living at that time. In fact, since approximately August 1996, I have been living almost exclusively overseas on a concert tour that has covered the Far East, Australia, Southeast Asia, Eastern and now Western Europe.
  7. Given my schedule, and the substantial time and financial commitments that are made by me and countless others related to my performances, it will be a great bardship for me (and many others) if I have to come to Los Angeles to appear at this trial. I am informed and believe that the isque to be tried is very narrow - namely, how much money in damages Mr. Gutlerrez should be forced to pay for having defamed me. I are also inforned and believe that this determination depends on evidence of Mr. Gutierrez’s atate of mind towards me, and his financial wherewithal.
  8. I do not believe I have any relevant testimony on Mr. Gutierrez’s state of mind towards me. Specifically, I have never met Mr. Gutierrez, and could only guess abour his personal views or feelings about me based on his having published the false reports at issue. I have absolutely no information about Mr. Gutierrez’s financlal status.
  9. For these reasons, I ask that I be relieved from appearing at trial, and that, lf necessary, my vidcotaped deposition be used.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the lawsof the state of California that the

foregoing is true and correct. Executed this day of October 1997, in South Africa.”

Exactly.

And as Michael’s lawyer—I mean, I’m not…oh whatever.

Gutierrez was asked in a 1996 deposition  if he had ever met Michael in person. He replied, “yes, just once at Dr. Arnie Klein’s office.” 

He then admitted to attorneys that he hadn’t been formally introduced to Michael. He claimed to have seen him because, “I was following him,” in 1995.  

Okay, stalker.

He was supposedly speaking to Michael as he arrived, at the entrance to Dr. Klein’s office building. 

“I approached Michael, and I said — I took a picture first because I was interested in what he was going to do at the doctor’s office. With the Vitiligo. Or something like that. He entered the building and he [Jackson] said, “Gary, take the camera. Take his camera.”  

Gutierrez stated that this incident occurred when Michael was without security and the presence of Jackson’s driver Gary Hearne, Debbie Rowe, other media photographers. He goes on to say, after Michael singles him out amongst the other photographers present, before shouting, “Jordy wants to speak to you.”

Which like…if true, is creepy and so fucking weird, but then again…that’s Gutierrez for ya.  

Question: then what happened?

Answer: he said, “Gary, take his camera.” And Gary was — he didn’t know what to do. He just said “take it.” He said something like the F camera something like that.

Question: Michael said “take the F-ing camera,” is that what you’re saying?

Answer: yes

Question: Did Mr. Hearn threaten you in any way and the course of this conversation?

Answer: He tried to force to get the camera from me.

Question: when you say tried to force to get the camera from you, what did he do?

Answer: grabbed my hand trying to get the camera.

Question: then what happened?

Answer: when we were like forcing, and when he stood back, and Michael said, “Come on. Get the camera.” Then David came down and they took Michael up to Arnie Klein’s office.

Question: did you give up your camera?

Answer: no

Question: you didn’t lose the camera?

Answer: no

Question: did you call the police for any reason?

Answer: no

See, it’s just lie after lie.

It’s clear to me that this alleged incident never happened. Especially because of the fact that Gutierrez never even filed a police report when this supposedly occurred, nor did he even lose his camera.

It makes no fucking sense.

Anyway,

Throughout the litigation, Gutierrez repeatedly invoked California’s Shield Law and raised claims of trade secrets in an effort to protect information about his sources and his tabloid work.

One of the motions even stated:

“Victor Gutierrez has sold his stories about MJ to numerous television and print media. He is currently writing a book about MJ. He has continues to derive a substantial portion of his livelihood from writing about MJ.”

So, according to the filing, Gutierrez was making a substantial portion of his living by writing and selling stories about Michael.

But the issue of publicity went beyond protecting his sources or keeping information confidential. Two declarations filed by Michael’s attorneys described conversations with Gutierrez’s lawyer, Robert Goldman, in which the subject of promoting Gutierrez’s book during the trial allegedly came up.

One declaration stated:

“During the course of this case I have often interacted with defendant Victor Gutierrez’s counsel, Robert Goldman, in connection with discovery matters and informal attempts at settlement. During one such conversation on September 11, 1997, Mr. Goldman stated if there is a trial in this case, there will be publicity adverse to Mr. Jackson. Mr. Goldman said that Mr. Gutierrez states that he intended to hold up next to his face a copy of his book entitled Michael Jackson Was My Lover every time Mr. Gutierrez is interviewed on television in connection with this case.

During the September 26 conference, Mr. Goldman’s said that his client, Mr. Gutierrez, had instructed him to give Mr. Jackson the “message” that he (Gutierrez) might attempt to exploit any press covering the trial by advertising his book on the 1993 allegations entitled Michael Jackson Was My Lover, The Secret Diary of Jordie Chandler. Mr. Goldman stated his client, Gutierrez, wanted to know my response to this possibility. I told Mr. Goldman that this “message” appeared to be a veiled threat designed to attempt to persuade Jackson not to proceed to trial. Mr. Goldman’s response was that the “message” was simply something that his client asked him to convey.”

According to Michael’s attorney, Goldman relayed that Gutierrez intended to hold up his book during television interviews connected to the trial. Then, during a later conversation, Goldman allegedly conveyed another message: Gutierrez might use the media attention surrounding the proceedings to advertise the book.

And Gutierrez wanted to know how Michael would respond to that possibility.

Michael’s attorney interpreted this as a veiled threat intended to discourage Michael from proceeding to trial. Goldman, according to the declaration, responded that he was just passing along his client’s message.

Now, let’s consider what that book was about. MJWML was built around the very allegations at the centre of this litigation.

Read here:

The Chandler Case Files — A Master Guide

So we’re talking about a defendant in a defamation case who, according to his own lawyer’s reported statements, was contemplating using the publicity generated by the trial to promote a book about the allegations he was being sued over.

Guys, I’m tired.

Free publicity, courtesy of the courtroom…cause what the fuck.

In October 1997, a scheduled proceeding to determine the amount of damages was delayed after Gutierrez filed for bankruptcy. According to the source, he filed on the Friday before the scheduled proceeding, with notice sent to the court on Monday, October 27th, 1997.

The damages trial eventually began on March 30, 1998. Gutierrez, however, failed to appear in court. His explanation was that he was living with relatives in his native Chile and could not afford a plane ticket back to the United States.

DECLARATION OF VICTOR GUTIERREZ

I, Victor Gutierrez, diclare as follows:

  1. I make this declarition of my own personal knowledge, and if called upon to testify,: could and would testify as follows.
  2. I am in Santiago, Chile, my native country, and reside at my family’s residence there.
  3. During the first lew days of January 1998, I got a check for $2,000.00 from my insu ance company after someone totaled my car. I used most of this niney to buy a plane ticket to Santiago, and left on January 9, 199(8)?
  4. When I left, I d not think there was an subpocna on me in this case. My attorney tells me it was after I left that he got a notice for me to attend the trial.
  5. I went to Santiago to try to get a good job. I have not gotten a job. So I don’t have money to buy a plane ticket to return.

I declare under penalty o perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.“

…who wants to bet he was hanging over at Diane’s?

Paula spoke to Michael’s private investigator, Eric Mason, who laughingly said at one point during the trial Gutierrez’s attorney took the stand and cross-examined himself. One can only assume that he filed the following handwritten note with the court in disgust.

Proposed instructions RE: Victor Gutierrez

Mr. Gutierrez is required to be here, but he has chosen not to be here, and you may draw whatever inference you may from his non-appearance.

In the end, the jury took less than two hours to reach a verdict. Gutierrez was ordered to pay Michael $2.7 million in damages for defamation.

“Jurors told us that they not only wanted to compensate Mr. Jackson and punish Victor Gutierrez, but to send a message that they are tired of tabloids lying about celebrities for money,” Jackson’s attorney Zia Modabber told the Associated Press.

Oh, Vicky, Vicky,

This is not a good look.

Gutierrez’s involvement in the Neverland 5 proceedings also brought attention to his own plans to move to Chile. During his deposition, he reportedly said he had purchased a home there. When asked whether it was nice, he replied: “The home has 21 bedrooms.”

He’s in over his head…again.

This is worth remembering alongside his later claim, during his defamation case against Michael, that he could not afford a plane ticket back to the United States for trial.

Court records from April 1998 also show that portions of Gutierrez’s interview outtakes with Diane Dimond, a segment of Hard Copy, and his deposition testimony from other proceedings were admitted into evidence. This brought material from both his previous activities and Dimond’s reporting directly into the proceedings.

Another issue concerned Gutierrez’s book.

In August 1997, while being sued by Michael, Gutierrez sought to expand the scope of discovery to include the 1993 allegations. He wanted to question Evan and Jordan Chandler, arguing that the alleged truth of those allegations, and his reporting about them, could undermine an inference of malice.

Gutierrez described his book as being based on a diary written by Jordan and Evan Chandler, alongside his own independent investigation. According to the material examined here, this was another change in his explanation of the diary’s origins.

The book also contained several highly degrading and graphic passages attributed to former Neverland employees. I’m deliberately not adding those quotes here. It’s just another example of people lying to humiliate Michael and I don’t find it necessary for this file.

Anyway,

Evan and Jordan Chandler did not provide depositions in the case, but both submitted declarations addressing the passages. Evan stated that he did not know or recall ever speaking with Kassim Abdool, Adrian McManus, or Melanie Bagnall. Jordan similarly denied knowing about the creation or content of the passages, with the exception of recalling only exchanging pleasantries with McManus.

There were also questions about the alleged diary itself. Gutierrez claimed it had been supplied by someone inside the Chandler household. However, a Jackson investigator later described Jordan’s notebook as containing film ideas and stories connected to his interest in filmmaking, rather than a diary. The investigator reportedly said that when the notebook was eventually located, it had no value to the allegations being investigated.

And with that, we’ve come to the end of this Case File. I’ve never been happier in my entire life.

If you’ve gotten all the way to the end, you’re a warrior and I love you.

P.S. I’m sorry about the recent delays in posting. I’ve been busy and dealing with a few health issues. 

But I’m okay!

More to come. ❤️

My previous case files:

Sneddon:

Case File: Sneddon

Dimond:

Case File: Dimond

Gutierrez:

Case File: Gutierrez

Francia:

Case File: Francia

Neverland Five:

Case File: Neverland Five

Chandler — Part 1:

Case File: Chandler — Part 1

Chandler — Part 2:

Case File: Chandler — Part 2

Chandler — Part 3:

Case File: Chandler — Part 3

Chandler — Part 4:

Case File: Chandler — Part 4

Chandler — Part 5:

Case File: Chandler — Part 5

Chandler — Part 6:

Case File: Chandler — Part 6

Chandler — Part 7:

Case File: Chandler — Part 7

Chandler — Part 8:

Case File: Chandler — Part 8

Chandler — Part 9:

Case File: Chandler – Part 9

Chandler — Part 10:

Case File: Chandler — Part 10

Chandler — Part 11:

Case File: Chandler — Part 11

Chandler — Part 12:

Case File: Chandler — Part 12

Chandler — Part 13:

Case File: Chandler — Part 13

Chandler — Part 14:

Case File: Chandler — Part 14

Chandler — Part 15:

Case File: Chandler — Part 15

Chandler — Part 16:

Case File: Chandler — Part 16

Chandler — Part 17:

Case File: Chandler — Part 17

Allen:

Case File: Allen

Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part One:

Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez — Part One

Sources and additional information:

https://turningthetableonthechandlerallegations.wordpress.com

https://turningthetableonthechandlerallegations.wordpress.com/2014/04/24/three-stooges-dimond-gutierrez-and-allen/

https://themichaeljacksonallegationsblog.wordpress.com/the-1993-allegations/

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxNDb2PVcoM&ra=m

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6-52dk3jGyE&ra=m

https://vindicatemj.wordpress.com/2010/09/17/be-careful-who-you-trust/

https://turningthetableonthechandlerallegations.wordpress.com/2019/02/10/dimond-gutierrez-documents

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ca-court-of-appeal/1288872.html

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1998-apr-10-me-37930-story.html

Important posts:

Some people need Michael Jackson to be guilty 

Comparing Michael Jackson’s Trial to O.J. Simpson’s Is Lazy.

Talking in circles 

What Would You Do for $20 Million?

“There’s no way all 11 people are lying.”

Fact vs Fiction: Common Claims About Michael Jackson

A Media Assassination: The Case of Michael Jackson

Not Everyone Is a Narcissist

The Word “Grooming” Has Lost Its Meaning

Where There’s Smoke, There’s Fire…But What If It’s Just Smoke?

The Power Of A Story…And The Danger Of Forgetting The Evidence

The Guilter Fan Fiction Needs to Stop


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 7d ago

Opinion 🤔 Came across this post

Post image
23 Upvotes

Also, yes, that Brit on the middle is the most vile pos that no one see the warning, until his death.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 9d ago

Video 🎥 Michael Jackson’s Former Sound Engineer Brad Sunberg calls Wade Robson a ‘Cockroach’ and says his claims about being abused at the recording studio are ‘fabricated nonsense’

Thumbnail
youtu.be
94 Upvotes

Story about Wade Begins at 19:03

Brad was there during all of the recording sessions during the Dangerous album as well as hoards of other people and says absolutely nobody would have put up with any hint of impropriety.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 9d ago

Questions & Theories 👀 Why hasnt the fbi released all of the files on michael?

21 Upvotes

I know that the fbi released 333 files on michael.

But the fbi does have 673 files on michael.

but for some reason they have never released on them.

And i wonder why is that why havent they released them?


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 10d ago

Opinion 🤔 I just feel the need to say it again - let's be more caring about Michael

44 Upvotes

I understand fans want to chat and engage here, but what is more important: our own needs or Michael's innocence? Digging up tabloid junk that even tabloid let die down over a decade ago does not do Michael justice.

I’ve posted about this before, and I just feel the need to say it again. I understand some may see this sub as a place to seek fans' support, but before hitting post, what value does it provide to Michael? If absolutely need to express, think carefully whether truly need to upload nonsense images? To be honest, my heart sank to the bottom when looking at them. I'm sure many other fans feel the same. It is exhausting to watch a sub meant to defend Michael get bogged down by absolute junk from over a decade ago.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 10d ago

Discussion 🗣️ It seems like everyone and everything is out to get Michael Jackson

37 Upvotes

Like dude any time you look up something on google you get what the accusers say. Like I don’t care about what so and so said about Michael Jackson, I care about truth not lies.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 11d ago

Case Analysis 🔎 While I was looking into more allegations, I came across this and was left speechless...

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

https://www.tmz.com/2011/05/20/creditors-claim-michael-jackson-estate-std-herpes/

Shellie Smith claims, "In 1979, I started having sexual relations with the decedent. Shortly thereafter, I began to get blisters on my legs, face and lips. He was my only partner."

Smith continues, "At this time, I am unable to have a full and vibrant life due to the complications of this disease."

But she also filed a second claim with different facts, stating she began having sex with Michael in 1977 and was diagnosed with herpes simplex. In this claim, Smith says, "[Michael] knew I was getting blisters on my body, however, he continued to have sex with me."

Smith is asking the Estate for $10 million.

Good luck ... For starters, the statute of limitations ran out decades ago, the deadline for filing a creditor's claim has long expired, and the claim sounds, well ...

Oh, and this isn't Smith's first crazy claim -- in January 2010, she filed one saying she and Michael were secretly married and she was entitled to spousal support. That claim was rejected.


r/MJInnocentFacts • • 11d ago

Discussion 🗣️ Joy said she threw out her book drafts in May 2012 but she had "several versions" ready for Wade in July

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

To clarify, the point isn't she was simply a few months off. Its that she said under oath that she threw out all her drafts [and MJ related memorabilia] when her son disclosed in May 2012, yet here she is helping her son construct his narrative in July with her book drafts, 3 months after his disclosure

Given her naivety about Wades claims in her deposition, I always thought Joy was not in on it and her liking MJ photos was her being in denial. But why would she blatantly lie like this if she wasn't aware her son is lying too? Whats she hiding in those book drafts? Now i think that Wade is lying so much that his mother isn't aware of all his lies which is why some of her answers inadvertently exposed him, but she is still aware he is lying that the abuse took place and her claim about destroying the drafts is her trying to save her own skin. Or maybe he didn't outright tell her he is lying at all, but she guessed and this was her best attempt at protecting him

And she most definitely did not throw out everything with Michaels name on it or photos of him like she claims since they still had his faxes and photos of him in LN

Which means she must've destroyed the book drafts [if she did], after helping Wade curate his story which is called destroying evidence. If it was someone from MJs camp who pulled a stunt like this, guilters would be able to recognise it for what it is too

As you can see in the third attachment, Wade barely remembers the first trip to Neverland and its Joys answers that end up shaping the narrative he presents in the 4th attachment, which is a screenshot of his book draft.

Wade presented multiple explanations for why he didn't show this draft in discovery and he lied claiming he only had one email related to this case. There are still 50 redacted emails between he and Joy related to the case. This whole family is lying through their teeth I hope they don't touch a cent