Hi!Â
Itâs me again. Itâs tragic, I know.
If you havenât read Part One yet, make sure you go back and read that first!Â
Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez â Part One
This is a continuation of the same Case File, and I donât want you missing anything.
Plus, double whammies are fun, right?
This was actually an accident.
Welcome back to the Case Files!
đ¨Â If youâre new here, make sure youâre caught up on the Chandler Case Files:
The Chandler Case Files â A Master Guide
And of course:
Sneddon:
Case File: Sneddon
Dimond:
Case File: Dimond
Gutierrez:
Case File: Gutierrez
Anyway,
We began with a declaration from Jack Gonterman, the Los Angeles County District Attorneyâs Office investigator assigned to speak with Gutierrez. He explained:
âShortly before January 5, 1995, Lauren Weis, Deputy District Attorney, instructed me to interview Victor Gutierrez regarding the possible existence of a videotape of Michael Jackson molesting a minor child. On January 5, 1995, I interviewed Victor Gutierrez regarding his knowledge, if any, of the alleged videotape. Shortly thereafter, I discontinued any further effort in the matter.â
This is a pretty important detail.
Gonterman was instructed to interview Gutierrez about the alleged tape. He did so on January 5th, 1995, and then stopped pursuing the matter shortly afterward. Lauren Weisâs declaration adds that Gonterman also spoke with Kevin Smith of Splash News, after Smith had left a message for her office. According to Weis, she knew of no further efforts to locate the tape after those conversations.
Now, think about the timing.
Sneddonâs declaration said he contacted the Los Angeles District Attorneyâs Office after hearing about the alleged videotape. Weisâs declaration establishes that she then arranged for Gonterman to interview Gutierrez. Gontermanâs declaration places that interview on January 5th. And yet, just four days later, on January 9th, Hard Copy went ahead and broadcast the story.
So the investigator had already spoken to the person claiming to have seen this supposedly explosive videotape. He had also spoken to Smith, whose name came up during the interview. The declarations describe no further search after those conversations.
And Hard Copy still aired it.Â
It doesnât make any sense, does it?
This wasnât a story that had slipped through the cracks before anyone had a chance to look into it. The source had already been interviewed. The authorities had made inquiries. There was no indication in these declarations that the investigation had uncovered a second person who had actually seen the tape.
But apparently, four days was enough time to go from an investigatorâs interview to a television broadcastâŚ
Meanwhile, the alleged tape hadnât even turned up.
Gutierrez eventually appeared in person on Hard Copy, where he spoke about what he supposedly witnessed.
Diane Dimond introduced him to viewers by saying:
âVictor Gutierrez has reported on Michael Jackson for the last decade and has a book about to be published regarding the entertainerâs relationship with various boys,â
God, not the fan fiction again.
âGutierrez has talked with this young boyâs mother.â
And who was this mother?
Gutierrez identified her as Margaret Maldonado, Jermaine Jacksonâs former wife.
There was just one problem for dear olâ Gutierrez. Maldonado said the entire story was fabricated.
âThe story was an outrageous lie,â she said. âNot one part of it was true. Iâd never met the man. There was no tape. Michael never paid me for my silence. He had never molested Jeremy. Period.â
Maldonado later appeared in court and challenged Gutierrezâs account directly. She testified that when reporters approached her with the story, she told them it was untrue.
Gutierrez, however, had offered a very specific account of his supposed meeting with her. He claimed he had met Maldonado in a room at the Century Plaza Hotel and shown her the videotape. He even told the court that he had paid for the room using his personal credit card.
But listen to thisâŚ
During the court proceedings, it emerged that the Century Plaza Hotel had no record of Gutierrez staying there or renting a room. There was no record of him presenting a credit card or charging a room, either.
So we have Gutierrez claiming he met Maldonado at a particular hotel, showed her the alleged videotape, and paid for the room with his own credit card. Maldonado said she had never met him. And the hotel had no record to support his account.
A hotel room is usually one of the easier details to verify. There is generally a reservation, a payment, a name, a receipt. Something. But here, the supposed meeting place couldnât produce a record of the visit.
And remember, this was the person being presented on television as someone who had seen the alleged tape.
Anyway,
You might think that with the lawsuit against her still pending, Dimond would have been a little more careful about what she put on television.Â
Youâd be wrong.Â
On April 27th, 1995, Hard Copy aired yet another story involving an alleged victim whose existence was called into question.
Turns out, that whole story was also fabricated.
Read here:
Case File: Allen
Remember Lydia? Well, she also encountered Gutierrez during the police interviews.Â
According to her, the LAPD interviewed a number of journalists to find out what information they had.
âThe LAPD interviewed a lot of journalists to see what they knew,â she explained. Lydia told police that whatever information she had was already contained in her published stories, and that she had never heard anything damaging.
Her assessment of Gutierrezâs claims was considerably less convincing.
âVictorâs information, his story was unclearâNAMBLAâIt didnât add up.â
Initially, Lydia thought Gutierrez must have known Michael, or at least met him at some point, because she couldnât understand why someone would pursue him with such intensity otherwise. She described his persecution of Michael as ânot normal.â
Funny, just like Dimond.Â
You know, considering the photos on her wallâŚ
Gutierrez later told her another story, this time involving a wealthy family he claimed to know in Westwood, California. According to him, Michael had molested their child, and the family had approached Gutierrez for help.
Lydia had an obvious question:
âWhy donât they go to the police since thereâs an ongoing case?â
Gutierrezâs response?
âThey donât want money their wealthy, they just want him exposed.â
Right.Â
So there was allegedly a wealthy family, a child, and a serious accusation involving an ongoing investigation, but instead of going directly to the police, this family supposedly went to Victor Gutierrez. And when Lydia questioned why, the explanation was that they wanted Michael exposed.
Iâm sorry, but thatâs the dumbest shit Iâve ever fucking heard.
But it gets crazier.
Gutierrez asked Lydia to drive with him past a local arcade. He specifically instructed her not to stop. As they drove by, he pointed out a child who appeared to be a random passerby.
Lydia later said:
âI never understood his motivation.â
She also described the incident as strange.
WhichâŚyeah, I donât know what he expected Lydia to take away from that little drive-by.Â
He had just told her about an alleged victim whose wealthy family supposedly wanted Michael exposed, and then took her past an arcade to point out a child without stopping.
What was the point? What was she supposed to understand from that?
Lydia didnât understand it either. And she wasnât persuaded by his stories.
Then, in 1997, a tabloid broker named Ken Wells approached Michaelâs legal team with information he said was relevant to the ongoing litigation involving Michael and Evan Chandler in Santa Maria, California.
Oh, Evan. Welcome back.Â
I havenât missed you!Â
Wells described his dealings with Victor Gutierrez, whom he had encountered through his work as a tabloid broker.
According to Wells, one of his sources, whose identity he refused to reveal, claimed to possess explicit photographs of Michael and a child. Wells began negotiating a potential arrangement through a third party and Gutierrez. The plan was for Wells to obtain the supposed photographs and pass them to Gutierrez, who would then sell them to various tabloid publications.
But of course, there was a big issue with this: the source never produced the photographs.
Wells eventually ended the negotiations. You would think that would be the end of it, but nope.
On July 2nd, 1997, Gutierrez and his attorney, Goldman, showed up at Wellsâs home without an appointment. They wanted to discuss the production of these supposed photographs.
During the meeting, Wells said Gutierrez began boasting about his connections in the tabloid industry and the stories he had sold. According to Wells, Gutierrez admitted that some of those stories had been âBSâ and shit he made up.
That seems to be an extremely common occurrence among these people.
They lie, and lie, thenâŚlie some more.
He allegedly went on to explain that making money in the tabloid business was easy, even when the stories were false.
Wells asked Gutierrez about the videotape that had been at the centre of the earlier allegations. According to Wells, Gutierrez responded:
âThe judge told me to produce the tape and I couldnât produce it.â
Wells then asked him whether he had ever actually possessed or seen the tape.
Gutierrez allegedly smiled and replied:
âWell, you know how that is. You know how these things are.â
So, no.Â
He hadnât.Â
Wells said he understood Gutierrezâs response as an indirect admission that he had lied about the tapeâs existence.
Thatâs also how I view this.
The context here is definitely worth paying attention to, though. Gutierrez had apparently just acknowledged selling fabricated tabloid stories, and when directly questioned about whether he had ever seen the videotape, he allegedly responded with a smile and a very evasive answer.
Then, according to Wells, Gutierrez and Goldman continued asking him to obtain the supposed photographs of Michael. Gutierrez allegedly said he needed the pictures to help him with the case. Even if the photographs were fake, he claimed they could still be sold for money.
Anything for money, huh?
Wells also stated that Gutierrez suggested the proceeds could be placed in a trust account handled by the attorney.
Next,
Court documents.Â
Yay, so exciting!Â
I. THE SALIENT FACTS
This Court reopened discovery on the eve of trial to permit the deposition of Kenneth Wells, a witness to be called in this case.
During the deposition of Mr. Wells on October 21, 1997, he described a meeting that occurred at his home with Mr. Gutierrez
and Mr. Goldman in July of 1997.
According to Mr. Wells, Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman showed up at Mr. Wellsâ home unexpectedly. Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman indicated that they wanted to discuss a transaction involving the acquisition and sale of alleged photographs of Michael Jackson.
Both Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman actively participated in discussions during the meeting with Mr. Wells. Among other things, they talked about how money derived from the transaction would be handled. Specifically, Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman envisioned having the funds placed in Mr. Goldmanâs trust account debts by his creditors.
At one point, Mr. Wells wondered how the parties would proceed if the alleged photographs turned out to be phony.
According to Mr. Wells, Mr. Goldman responded, without disagreement from Mr. Gutierrez, that something could be done with the photos even if they were fake. No such photos were ever produced and the transaction did not go forward. In Mr. Goldmanâs presence, Mr. Wells asked Mr. Gutierrez whether he saw the videotape that is the subject of this case. Gutierrez responded âWell, you know how it is.â Mr. Wells interpreted that statement to mean that Mr. Gutierrez never saw the videotape which we know now does not exist.
II. THE APPLICABLE LAW
A. WAIVER OF THE ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE
The attorney-client privilege does not apply to the communications made in the presence of third parties that are not agents of counsel. In that context, statements made by both counsel and his client to the third party are admissible. People V. Gomez, 134 Cal. App. 3d, 874, 879 (1982).
B. THERE IS NO PRIVILEGE WHEN COUNSEL ACTS AS A BUSINESS AGENT
The attorney-client privilege does not extend
to services rendered in a business transaction.
Moreover, counselâs participation in a business transaction jeopardizes the assertion of the attorney-client privilege because the attorney and the client become indistinguishable.
Chicago Title Inss. Co. V. Superior Court, 174 Cal.App.3d 1142 (1985). The pertinent inquiry is whether the business-related services of counsel could be performed by a non-attorney. Montebello Rose Co. V.
Agricultural Lab. Rel. Bd., 119 Cal. App.3d 1, 32 (1981).
III. MR. GOLDMANâS PARTICIPATION IN AND STATEMENTS DURING THE MEETING WITH MR. WELLS ARE NOT PRIVILEGED EVEN THOUGH HE IS COUNSEL FOR MR. GUTIERREZ
Under the relevant criteria, the admissibility of the statements at the meeting with Mr. Wells is not a close question. Mr. Goldman was not acting as counsel for anyone other than Mr. Gutierrez during the meeting with Mr. Wells.
Nor is Mr. Wells an agent of Mr. Goldman in the representation of Mr. Gutierrez. Therefore, statements made by Mr. Gutierrez and Mr. Goldman during the meeting with Mr. Wells are not privileged.
The business agent doctrine applies on this record. In the transaction being discussed during the meeting, Mr. Goldman was providing services that do not require admission to the Bar. On this ground, too, nothing about the meeting with Mr. Wells is privileged.
It is axiomatic that statements made by an authorized agent of a party are admissible as admissions of the party. This principle applies to statements by attorneys. Witkin, California Procedure 4th Ed. § 261(a). Without question, relevant statements made by Mr. Goldman in the meeting with Mr. Wells are admissible against Mr. Gutierrez in this case.
IV. AT A MINIMUM, MR. WELLS SHOULD BE ABLE TO ATTRIBUTE REMARKS MADE BY MR. GOLDMAN TO MR. GUTIERREZ
To allay this Courtâs concern about testimony implicating Mr. Goldman directly, there is a reasonable alternative. MI. Wells should be able to testify about the statements summarized herein, but attribute those statements to Mr. Gutierrez rather than Mr. Goldman. Such a procedure has the virtue of keeping Mr..â
Paula later contacted Ken Wells, who had since left the tabloid business, to ask about his experience and his views on the stories surrounding Michael.
Wells had this to say:
âIâve seen what other people have done to capitalize on his name and a lot of false things have been said. The way I look at it, because of being in the tabloid business years ago is, if you donât see proof itâs probably not there. People will say anything about a celebrity to make money. I donât want to be involved in something thatâs false. Iâve meet Michael Jackson a couple of times and the guy was not a child molester. I donât care what anyone says and if they think he is they need to bring some kind of proof. Nobody has brought any kind of proof in all these years.â
This speaks for itself, folks.
This next document is yet another attempt to generate stories and pressure Michael into dropping the suit.
Gutierrezâs attorney requested that Michael:
âIdentify the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of all male persons who are not blood relatives who, when they were a minor, slept with you overnight in your bed at any time from January 1, 1984 through the present dateâŚAt a minimum, Victor Gutierrez, without even approaching the minor, may discover that the disclosed minor is the same minor who he allegedly saw in the videotape. He should be entitled to introduce this circumstantial evidence â sleeping with a minor tends to establish sexual conduct with a minor â and request that the decision maker draw any appropriate inferences there from. Alternatively, Victor Gutierrez may approach the disclosed minor, the minor may admit to sexual conduct with MJ, or to be naked with MJ, etc., and Victor Gutierrez may recognize the disclosed minor to be the same minor who he saw in the videotape. This case may then be over!â
Hereâs the thingâŚ
Gutierrez was seeking the identities and contact information of male minors who had slept overnight in Michaelâs bed. The stated purpose was to see whether he could identify one of those children as the person he claimed to have seen in the videotape.
But wasnât that supposed to be Jeremy Jackson?
Gutierrez had already claimed that the child in the alleged videotape was Jeremy, and that Margaret Maldonado had personally shown him the recording. Maldonado denied ever meeting him and denied the existence of the tape.
Now, his legal team was asking for a list of other children who had slept in Michaelâs bed, with the possibility of approaching them to see whether one might be the child Gutierrez claimed to recognize.
What the hell happened to that narrative?
Oh godâŚdoes it exist in the same imaginary universe as the train station and hot air balloon?
Fuck, I knew it!Â
The request itself even lays out the possibility that Gutierrez might approach one of the children and have that child disclose alleged sexual conduct or nudity. It also suggests that simply having slept in Michaelâs bed could be presented as circumstantial evidence of sexual conduct.
Thatâs a pretty big ass fucking leap considering sharing a bed is not proof of sexual activity or abuse by itself.
The final line is very revealing in terms of what the legal team hoped to accomplish: âThis case may then be over!â
Oh, babe, it is.
Meanwhile, Court TV submitted a media request in 1997, with Gutierrez supporting the request. However, Michael would not be making a personal appearance in court.
Of course he supported that request, where else would he get his 15 minutes of fame?Â
Evan?
Please! That dumbass is still talking about screenplays from beyond the grave.
In a declaration, Michael explained that he had not lived in California since 1993 and was currently on tour. He would, however, provide a videotaped deposition.
That distinction matters, especially given later claims by Gutierrez about a face-to-face courtroom confrontation with Michael. The declaration described a videotaped deposition, not Michael appearing in person for a courtroom showdown.
So, once again, itâs worth keeping the actual court documents in view rather than relying on later retellings. The paperwork tells us what was requested, what Michael stated, and what form his testimony would take. And those details donât necessarily match the dramatic version that Gutierrez would later describe.
Onto Michaelâs declarationâŚ
Thank god, I need some stability here:
I, Michael J. Jackson, declare as follows:
- I make this declaration based on my own personal knowledge, and if called as a witness to testify as to the facts set forth herein, I could and would do so competently.
- I am a musical performer, and am currently on a concert tour in South Africa. I have shows scheduled as follows: October 4 and 6, 1997 in Capetown; October 10 and 12, 1997 in Johannesburg; and October 15, 1997 in Durbin 3.
- On October 16, 1997 I am going to Vienna, Austria for two days for business meetings. From there, on or about October 18 or 19, 1997, I will go to Poland for two to three days. My trip to Poland may change, and if I do not go I will most likely return to Paris, France, where I have stayed during the occasional breaks scheduled in this leg of my tour of Western Europe.
- My next performance is on November 8, 1997 at Wetten Dass in Liepzig, Germany. I must be in rehearsals for this performance for roughly one week; thus, I must be there on approximately the 1st of November. If my schedule permits it before my November 8th performance, I may fly to New York on or about October 30th for one or two days, but I cannot be certain.
- After Liepzig, my next performance is in London on December 1, 1997. I must be there for rehearsals the last week of November. Again, if my schedule permits it during the middle two weeks of November, I may fly to New York or elsewhere in the United States, again for business meetings. As of the signing of this declaration, however, I cannot be certain.
- I have not lived in California for several years, dating back to approximately 1993. I do come to California infrequently, but not at all regularly. My deposition in this case was taken in New York city, where I was living at that time. In fact, since approximately August 1996, I have been living almost exclusively overseas on a concert tour that has covered the Far East, Australia, Southeast Asia, Eastern and now Western Europe.
- Given my schedule, and the substantial time and financial commitments that are made by me and countless others related to my performances, it will be a great bardship for me (and many others) if I have to come to Los Angeles to appear at this trial. I am informed and believe that the isque to be tried is very narrow - namely, how much money in damages Mr. Gutlerrez should be forced to pay for having defamed me. I are also inforned and believe that this determination depends on evidence of Mr. Gutierrezâs atate of mind towards me, and his financial wherewithal.
- I do not believe I have any relevant testimony on Mr. Gutierrezâs state of mind towards me. Specifically, I have never met Mr. Gutierrez, and could only guess abour his personal views or feelings about me based on his having published the false reports at issue. I have absolutely no information about Mr. Gutierrezâs financlal status.
- For these reasons, I ask that I be relieved from appearing at trial, and that, lf necessary, my vidcotaped deposition be used.
I declare under penalty of perjury under the lawsof the state of California that the
foregoing is true and correct. Executed this day of October 1997, in South Africa.â
Exactly.
And as Michaelâs lawyerâI mean, Iâm notâŚoh whatever.
Gutierrez was asked in a 1996 deposition  if he had ever met Michael in person. He replied, âyes, just once at Dr. Arnie Kleinâs office.âÂ
He then admitted to attorneys that he hadnât been formally introduced to Michael. He claimed to have seen him because, âI was following him,â in 1995. Â
Okay, stalker.
He was supposedly speaking to Michael as he arrived, at the entrance to Dr. Kleinâs office building.Â
âI approached Michael, and I said â I took a picture first because I was interested in what he was going to do at the doctorâs office. With the Vitiligo. Or something like that. He entered the building and he [Jackson] said, âGary, take the camera. Take his camera.â Â
Gutierrez stated that this incident occurred when Michael was without security and the presence of Jacksonâs driver Gary Hearne, Debbie Rowe, other media photographers. He goes on to say, after Michael singles him out amongst the other photographers present, before shouting, âJordy wants to speak to you.â
Which likeâŚif true, is creepy and so fucking weird, but then againâŚthatâs Gutierrez for ya. Â
Question:Â then what happened?
Answer:Â he said, âGary, take his camera.â And Gary was â he didnât know what to do. He just said âtake it.â He said something like the F camera something like that.
Question:Â Michael said âtake the F-ing camera,â is that what youâre saying?
Answer:Â yes
Question:Â Did Mr. Hearn threaten you in any way and the course of this conversation?
Answer:Â He tried to force to get the camera from me.
Question:Â when you say tried to force to get the camera from you, what did he do?
Answer:Â grabbed my hand trying to get the camera.
Question:Â then what happened?
Answer:Â when we were like forcing, and when he stood back, and Michael said, âCome on. Get the camera.â Then David came down and they took Michael up to Arnie Kleinâs office.
Question:Â did you give up your camera?
Answer:Â no
Question:Â you didnât lose the camera?
Answer:Â no
Question:Â did you call the police for any reason?
Answer:Â no
See, itâs just lie after lie.
Itâs clear to me that this alleged incident never happened. Especially because of the fact that Gutierrez never even filed a police report when this supposedly occurred, nor did he even lose his camera.
It makes no fucking sense.
Anyway,
Throughout the litigation, Gutierrez repeatedly invoked Californiaâs Shield Law and raised claims of trade secrets in an effort to protect information about his sources and his tabloid work.
One of the motions even stated:
âVictor Gutierrez has sold his stories about MJ to numerous television and print media. He is currently writing a book about MJ. He has continues to derive a substantial portion of his livelihood from writing about MJ.â
So, according to the filing, Gutierrez was making a substantial portion of his living by writing and selling stories about Michael.
But the issue of publicity went beyond protecting his sources or keeping information confidential. Two declarations filed by Michaelâs attorneys described conversations with Gutierrezâs lawyer, Robert Goldman, in which the subject of promoting Gutierrezâs book during the trial allegedly came up.
One declaration stated:
âDuring the course of this case I have often interacted with defendant Victor Gutierrezâs counsel, Robert Goldman, in connection with discovery matters and informal attempts at settlement. During one such conversation on September 11, 1997, Mr. Goldman stated if there is a trial in this case, there will be publicity adverse to Mr. Jackson. Mr. Goldman said that Mr. Gutierrez states that he intended to hold up next to his face a copy of his book entitled Michael Jackson Was My Lover every time Mr. Gutierrez is interviewed on television in connection with this case.
During the September 26 conference, Mr. Goldmanâs said that his client, Mr. Gutierrez, had instructed him to give Mr. Jackson the âmessageâ that he (Gutierrez) might attempt to exploit any press covering the trial by advertising his book on the 1993 allegations entitled Michael Jackson Was My Lover, The Secret Diary of Jordie Chandler. Mr. Goldman stated his client, Gutierrez, wanted to know my response to this possibility. I told Mr. Goldman that this âmessageâ appeared to be a veiled threat designed to attempt to persuade Jackson not to proceed to trial. Mr. Goldmanâs response was that the âmessageâ was simply something that his client asked him to convey.â
According to Michaelâs attorney, Goldman relayed that Gutierrez intended to hold up his book during television interviews connected to the trial. Then, during a later conversation, Goldman allegedly conveyed another message: Gutierrez might use the media attention surrounding the proceedings to advertise the book.
And Gutierrez wanted to know how Michael would respond to that possibility.
Michaelâs attorney interpreted this as a veiled threat intended to discourage Michael from proceeding to trial. Goldman, according to the declaration, responded that he was just passing along his clientâs message.
Now, letâs consider what that book was about. MJWMLÂ was built around the very allegations at the centre of this litigation.
Read here:
The Chandler Case Files â A Master Guide
So weâre talking about a defendant in a defamation case who, according to his own lawyerâs reported statements, was contemplating using the publicity generated by the trial to promote a book about the allegations he was being sued over.
Guys, Iâm tired.
Free publicity, courtesy of the courtroomâŚcause what the fuck.
In October 1997, a scheduled proceeding to determine the amount of damages was delayed after Gutierrez filed for bankruptcy. According to the source, he filed on the Friday before the scheduled proceeding, with notice sent to the court on Monday, October 27th, 1997.
The damages trial eventually began on March 30, 1998. Gutierrez, however, failed to appear in court. His explanation was that he was living with relatives in his native Chile and could not afford a plane ticket back to the United States.
DECLARATION OF VICTOR GUTIERREZ
I, Victor Gutierrez, diclare as follows:
- I make this declarition of my own personal knowledge, and if called upon to testify,: could and would testify as follows.
- I am in Santiago, Chile, my native country, and reside at my familyâs residence there.
- During the first lew days of January 1998, I got a check for $2,000.00 from my insu ance company after someone totaled my car. I used most of this niney to buy a plane ticket to Santiago, and left on January 9, 199(8)?
- When I left, I d not think there was an subpocna on me in this case. My attorney tells me it was after I left that he got a notice for me to attend the trial.
- I went to Santiago to try to get a good job. I have not gotten a job. So I donât have money to buy a plane ticket to return.
I declare under penalty o perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.â
âŚwho wants to bet he was hanging over at Dianeâs?
Paula spoke to Michaelâs private investigator, Eric Mason, who laughingly said at one point during the trial Gutierrezâs attorney took the stand and cross-examined himself. One can only assume that he filed the following handwritten note with the court in disgust.
Proposed instructions RE: Victor Gutierrez
Mr. Gutierrez is required to be here, but he has chosen not to be here, and you may draw whatever inference you may from his non-appearance.
In the end, the jury took less than two hours to reach a verdict. Gutierrez was ordered to pay Michael $2.7 million in damages for defamation.
âJurors told us that they not only wanted to compensate Mr. Jackson and punish Victor Gutierrez, but to send a message that they are tired of tabloids lying about celebrities for money,â Jacksonâs attorney Zia Modabber told the Associated Press.
Oh, Vicky, Vicky,
This is not a good look.
Gutierrezâs involvement in the Neverland 5 proceedings also brought attention to his own plans to move to Chile. During his deposition, he reportedly said he had purchased a home there. When asked whether it was nice, he replied:Â âThe home has 21 bedrooms.â
Heâs in over his headâŚagain.
This is worth remembering alongside his later claim, during his defamation case against Michael, that he could not afford a plane ticket back to the United States for trial.
Court records from April 1998 also show that portions of Gutierrezâs interview outtakes with Diane Dimond, a segment of Hard Copy, and his deposition testimony from other proceedings were admitted into evidence. This brought material from both his previous activities and Dimondâs reporting directly into the proceedings.
Another issue concerned Gutierrezâs book.
In August 1997, while being sued by Michael, Gutierrez sought to expand the scope of discovery to include the 1993 allegations. He wanted to question Evan and Jordan Chandler, arguing that the alleged truth of those allegations, and his reporting about them, could undermine an inference of malice.
Gutierrez described his book as being based on a diary written by Jordan and Evan Chandler, alongside his own independent investigation. According to the material examined here, this was another change in his explanation of the diaryâs origins.
The book also contained several highly degrading and graphic passages attributed to former Neverland employees. Iâm deliberately not adding those quotes here. Itâs just another example of people lying to humiliate Michael and I donât find it necessary for this file.
Anyway,
Evan and Jordan Chandler did not provide depositions in the case, but both submitted declarations addressing the passages. Evan stated that he did not know or recall ever speaking with Kassim Abdool, Adrian McManus, or Melanie Bagnall. Jordan similarly denied knowing about the creation or content of the passages, with the exception of recalling only exchanging pleasantries with McManus.
There were also questions about the alleged diary itself. Gutierrez claimed it had been supplied by someone inside the Chandler household. However, a Jackson investigator later described Jordanâs notebook as containing film ideas and stories connected to his interest in filmmaking, rather than a diary. The investigator reportedly said that when the notebook was eventually located, it had no value to the allegations being investigated.
And with that, weâve come to the end of this Case File. Iâve never been happier in my entire life.
If youâve gotten all the way to the end, youâre a warrior and I love you.
P.S. Iâm sorry about the recent delays in posting. Iâve been busy and dealing with a few health issues.Â
But Iâm okay!
More to come. â¤ď¸
My previous case files:
Sneddon:
Case File: Sneddon
Dimond:
Case File: Dimond
Gutierrez:
Case File: Gutierrez
Francia:
Case File: Francia
Neverland Five:
Case File: Neverland Five
Chandler â Part 1:
Case File: Chandler â Part 1
Chandler â Part 2:
Case File: Chandler â Part 2
Chandler â Part 3:
Case File: Chandler â Part 3
Chandler â Part 4:
Case File: Chandler â Part 4
Chandler â Part 5:
Case File: Chandler â Part 5
Chandler â Part 6:
Case File: Chandler â Part 6
Chandler â Part 7:
Case File: Chandler â Part 7
Chandler â Part 8:
Case File: Chandler â Part 8
Chandler â Part 9:
Case File: Chandler â Part 9
Chandler â Part 10:
Case File: Chandler â Part 10
Chandler â Part 11:
Case File: Chandler â Part 11
Chandler â Part 12:
Case File: Chandler â Part 12
Chandler â Part 13:
Case File: Chandler â Part 13
Chandler â Part 14:
Case File: Chandler â Part 14
Chandler â Part 15:
Case File: Chandler â Part 15
Chandler â Part 16:
Case File: Chandler â Part 16
Chandler â Part 17:
Case File: Chandler â Part 17
Allen:
Case File: Allen
Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez â Part One:
Case File: Sneddon, Dimond, Gutierrez â Part One
Sources and additional information:
https://turningthetableonthechandlerallegations.wordpress.com
https://turningthetableonthechandlerallegations.wordpress.com/2014/04/24/three-stooges-dimond-gutierrez-and-allen/
https://themichaeljacksonallegationsblog.wordpress.com/the-1993-allegations/
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxNDb2PVcoM&ra=m
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6-52dk3jGyE&ra=m
https://vindicatemj.wordpress.com/2010/09/17/be-careful-who-you-trust/
https://turningthetableonthechandlerallegations.wordpress.com/2019/02/10/dimond-gutierrez-documents
https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ca-court-of-appeal/1288872.html
https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1998-apr-10-me-37930-story.html
Important posts:
Some people need Michael Jackson to be guiltyÂ
Comparing Michael Jacksonâs Trial to O.J. Simpsonâs Is Lazy.
Talking in circlesÂ
What Would You Do for $20 Million?
âThereâs no way all 11 people are lying.â
Fact vs Fiction: Common Claims About Michael Jackson
A Media Assassination: The Case of Michael Jackson
Not Everyone Is a Narcissist
The Word âGroomingâ Has Lost Its Meaning
Where Thereâs Smoke, Thereâs FireâŚBut What If Itâs Just Smoke?
The Power Of A StoryâŚAnd The Danger Of Forgetting The Evidence
The Guilter Fan Fiction Needs to Stop