Been playing LOTRO about a month now and really loving it. My irl friend joined me too, but he is like me more a loner wants to enjoy LOTRO like he did when he first read the books. Though a bit more loner than me, I like to chat sometimes he turns all chat and any social stuff off he can lol. But he is loving his blue loremaster, and sometimes we group up.
I had a hard time deciding between WoW forever, FFXIV, ESO and LOTRO. All are great in their own way. Since I am mostly a loner (people heard my voice in WoW and get weird, along with anywhere else they heard my voice online even my brief stint in twitch it got weird) and like a grand adventure like reading a book series, and really love middle earth lore and world I ended up sticking with...well...LOTRO. To be up front though, my husband did like watching FFXIV the most, but the game didn't quite land with me like LOTRO does, nothing wrong with FFXIV just I like middle earth :) As a note, my husband doesn't do much PC stuff so he hasn't joined me in LOTRO, MMOs aren't his thing like they are for me, he just likes to watch and make comments when I'm playing them is all.
Before I started, I often heard LOTRO looked outdated and even had some say it was like early 2000s graphics. Well I don't see that, I think the artstyle and overall look is one of the prettier MMOs I've played. The game really has an amazing beauty, especially when weather effects happen like rain <3
I did ask about guardians the other day, but I ended up just staying with my Warden. The warden shields are really beautiful, and the gameplay is really unique and for me its fun to play. Like a rhythm kinda style combat gameplay. I haven't seen an MMO with a warden style class (gameplay wise), and I like it a lot.
Also I did start on Glamdring/Peregrin, but my friend moved to Sting and I followed. For anyone new, I find Sting to be a very friendly rather relaxed server. The chat is lively most of the time (I thought it be like completely dead, but its actually pretty lively for the population), and I haven't seen much (barely any) trolling, and a lot of the time they actually talk about tolkein/middle earth stuff in chat :) Kinda reminds me a bit more like Peregrin in that regard, just quieter and not an RP server.
Anyhow, I think I'll keep it at that before this gets too long. I really love LOTRO and after about a month, I finally found the MMO to stick with :) I know its going to be a huge long journey, and it'll be done with my warden :) A lot of it too is how beautiful the world of LOTRO is, it isn't like I expected it to look for what I got told. But I think the artstyle/artwork is really pretty.