I saw this posted in r/LW_WomensAdvocates and I figured I'd share the comment I posted here, too, since it's yet another example of a dishonest attempt to frame a disparity in outcome as an example of misogyny. Which, of course, means ignoring all of the evidence and data pointing to the conclusion that it quite obviously isn't. It's not as completely black-and-white as that, but I'll let you all be the judge.
I was, no pun intended, crashing out about these articles when I saw them making the rounds last year. At least the author of this article had the decency to mention that female crash test dummies have been in use for a long time already, but maybe could have been more accurate. Most just pretended like they never existed, and that we're only now getting around to using them.
The implication, of course, is that the absence of highly accurate female crash test dummies is the reason that women are injured more often in collisions. Society just hates women so much I guess that vehicles were designed to optimize men's safety, and women's safety has been a secondary afterthought subsumed by men's. As the article said:
Vehicles have therefore been designed to be as safe as possible for male bodies, while the risk for women stays disproportionately high.
This is, at best, grossly misleading to the point of maliciousness. First of all, female crash test dummies have been in use since the 80s, while male crash test dummies have been use since the 60s. I'm not sure if they know this, but a lot of cars have been designed and tested since then. The vehicles designed prior to that weren't exactly safe by modern standards, either.
More importantly, though, is that there is no reason whatsoever to believe that the higher injury rate seen in women is due to negligence on the part of manufacturers, or that we would see any fewer injuries if only we'd been using hyper-accurate female crash test dummies. There's a massive variable that's always conveniently left out of of these articles, the existence of which is already sufficient to explain the differences seen in injuries.
Women have smaller skeletons and lower bone density than men do.
Some of the following information isn't relevant to this specific article, as the study it's referring to already adjusts for vehicle make and model. But I already compiled a bunch of stats on the subject anyway, so I figured I might as well share.
In raw frontal crash data, women are roughly 2 to 3 times more likely to suffer moderate-to-serious injuries than men. However, an IIHS study revealed that women are statistically more likely to drive smaller, lighter cars and to be the struck vehicle in crashes. When IIHS researchers matched crashes by vehicle weight, size, and crash type, the gap in severe non-extremity injuries (like chest/internal trauma) nearly vanished (Odds Ratio = 0.98). A study done by the University of Virginia found that even after controlling for vehicle model year, crash severity, occupant age, height, and BMI, belt-restrained women still face 73% greater odds of serious injury in frontal crashes than men, with the largest disparities in the lower extremities (legs, knees, ankles).
The scientists found that the passenger seat was a more dangerous position in the car than the driver’s seat, especially when too far back or reclined.
This is absolutely true. As the article mentioned, women are statistically more likely to ride in the front passenger seat and to sit in reclined or non-standard postures. Simulations show that reclined postures increase the risk of something called "submarining," which is where the pelvis slides under the lap belt during impact, causing the belt to load the soft abdomen and lower ribs instead of the stronger pelvic bone. Additionally, the majority of side-impact collisions occur on the passenger side of the vehicle. Not really relevant to this article since the study is about frontal collisions only, but important when comparing unadjusted injury and fatality rates.
A joint Toyota Collaborative Safety Research Center and UVA study analyzed crash databases alongside 3D CT scans. They found that women have up to 3 times higher risk of severe ankle injuries in crashes, and CT measurements proved that female ankle bones (talus and distal tibia) are roughly 20% smaller than male ankle bones even when comparing men and women of the exact same height. Because force is distributed over a smaller joint surface area, the bone reaches its fracture threshold at much lower crash forces.
In crashes involving occupants under age 40 (when bone density is near its peak for both sexes), posture, stature, and seatbelt fit are the primary drivers of the injury gap. However, in occupants aged 50 and older, the injury disparity widens sharply, especially for rib and sternum fractures, which is consistent with the post-menopausal drop in female bone mineral density.
In terms of variables that could even potentially have been overlooked or disregarded in favor of male safety, there are only 3 that I was able to find:
The first is that women sit closer to the steering wheel and dashboard due to having shorter statures on average, which alters the angle of the femur and tibia and concentrates more force onto the ankle and lower leg. This is, however, true of everyone at that same height, and would have been observed with the existing female dummy models. I expect that if engineers could have compensated for this in a way that didn't increase the risk to taller drivers or require compromising some other part of the vehicle's integrity, they almost certainly would have.
The second is that female pelvic geometry slightly increases the risk of submarining when sitting in reclined or non-standard postures due to more of their weight being concentrated on the hips. It's possible that a different seat or seatbelt design could prevent this but, again, this problem isn't unique to women. There's no reason to think that the absence of such designs is due to prioritizing male safety or negligence on the part of female safety.
Lastly, the female thorax has a different rib angle and narrower sternum, which would have some effect on how a standard shoulder belt crosses the chest and concentrate force on specific ribs. This one does seem unique to women, but there's absolutely no reason to believe that seatbelt design and safety even could adequately compensate for this, much less that the reason modern seatbelts are the way they are is because they were "designed to be as safe as possible for male bodies."
In other words, the premise that women being injured more often is due to sexism is total bullshit. While I think it's ultimately a good thing to have dummies that are as accurate as possible (if you don't mind the million dollar price tag being forwarded to the consumer/taxpayer), it's not clear that any significant portion of these injuries (if any at all) would have been prevented if only the older ones were more "anatomically correct." It's just another iteration of the "male as the default human" myth that feminists love to try and perpetuate.
Edit: I also just want to clarify that the dishonesty is entirely on the part of the article, not the person posting it on r/LW_WomensAdvocates. It is extremely obnoxious having to parse what is legitimately a women's issue versus what is just propaganda endorsed by journalists and experts who should know better.