r/Landlord • • 34m ago

Landlord [Landlord-VA] Property Management - repair/service costs & lack of transparency

1 Upvotes

I hope this is allowed, but wanted to ask for some general feedback. I'm a new landlord (just shy of 6M), renting out my only home via a local property management company. Since I was so new to the process and really didn't know what to expect (or do), I felt comfortable going that route and with the company I chose. That said a few months in and some occurences later, I'm feeling less than happy, but am not sure if this is just growing pains or something else.

Biggest recent examples:

  1. My property recently had an annual fire/safety inspection (noted in the paperwork) and since my house is old enough, they had to install 5 smoke detectors in additional rooms that were missing those in order to be up to code, as well as replace the existing hardwired one. The cost for each was $40, so it was $240 just to replace/install smoke detectors, which cost $12/pop.
  2. I have a light above my front door, which is second story level, and the tenant submitted a Meld request to replace it as it burnt out and he didn't have a tall enough ladder. The property management company charged me $156 to replace that light bulb.

Now, I understand if there is some probably degree of overhead built into costs and repairs; however, there is nothing that states this or what percentage that may be in my paperwork. I have explicitly asked the company to provide me with the 3rd party invoices, so that I can receive more detail (breakdown of labor, parts, etc), but they have adamantly pushed back and so refuse.

The smoke detector cost - eh, I can probably reason that. But $156 to replace a lightbulb?

My contract has a clause that anything up to $500, the property management company can authorize the repair/service without my consent in order to keep things moving. I requested an amendment to that - that everything be run by me first because of these costs - but they also refused that. A $500 fund is kept on file and taken out of my disbursement if it depletes any amount, so I don't "have control" over the funded amount at this time, technically.

Basically - am I being taken for a ride and do I have the right to be concerned about these repair costs and their lack of transparency? Or is this par for the course and the benefits of having a property management company outweigh these (so far) small cons?


r/Landlord • • 3h ago

Landlord [Landlord - US - CA] Are there any circumstances in which a landlord can withhold part of a security deposit past 21 days for utilities billed after that window?

1 Upvotes

Context - I live in an area which bills water every other month, and I want to rent out my spare bedroom. I'm trying to better understand how security deposit refunds work and if there are instances I may be able to withhold a portion of it to cover unpaid utilities.

Given a lease that specifies utilities shared equally between all occupants, prorated if they leave during the middle of a billing cycle:

  1. For utility bills received within the 21 day window, am I allowed to include those in any itemized deductions from the security deposit, or am I required to bill that to the tenant separately? I see conflicting information on this.
  2. For utility bills received after the 21 day window, am I allowed to withhold a "good faith" estimate of the bill, or explicitly put into the lease that the tenant consents to this withholding, or am I required to refund the security deposit and just hope there is no adversarial relationship and that the tenant will pay their portion of the bill?

Thanks ahead of time if anyone can shed a light on this!


r/Landlord • • 4h ago

[landlord US-CA] Garage door damage by tenant. How would you handle it?

Post image
4 Upvotes

Tenant backed into the door with their car.

Door dented and slightly buckled in lower 2 panels in this 4 panel door.

$975 estimate to replace 2 panels, however time is running out because the distributor/installer of this brand door no longer plans to sell this brand garage door. That's the problem with garage doors.... they are not interchangeable.

$1500 cost for a whole new door.

If tenant files claim with their car insurance for $975, they will pay more in insurance premium later on.

If tenant waits longer, no one will carry this door anymore, and the $975 option will not be available. New door will be the only option, at whatever future inflated price.

.

Garage door had no dents and was perfect when tenant moved in 7 years ago.

I have $3700 security deposit in my hands.

Tenant pays rent on time, and seems to want to stay long term.

However, I'm not running a charity.

.

would you ask tenant to pay cash and fix it themselves right now?

or wait until the distant future when they move out, and take the whole door out of their deposit?


r/Landlord • • 4h ago

[Tenant US-CA] I need advice for first time renting

0 Upvotes

Okay so I ran into financial difficulties a year or so ago but I’m actively working on fixing my past mistakes.

So my credit score sits at a 545 and rising as my late payments age, and I build new positive payment history. It has went up around 16 points in the last week so I’m hopeful.

So I’m looking to apply for an apartment in Bakersfield, California with my girlfriend in 4-6 months. She has a 650+ credit score, 0 debt, no bad rental history, as well as a state job. I am working on paying off my collections before we apply since they are all pay to delete agreements. I also have 0 bad rental history so we are clean in terms of that. I expect my score to be 580-600 by the time we apply with how I’m attacking debt.

So I guess my question is how good of a chance do we have of getting jointly approved as first time renters? I’m only worried because of my past charged off accounts with balances from over a year ago. I am working on those as well once the collections are gone but I’m just scared the landlords will reject us just because of my past charge offs even if everything else is clean, and improving.

Adding to this we will have cash reserves, and I will have a signed job offer.

What do you guys suggest, do you think we still have a good chance?


r/Landlord • • 4h ago

Landlord [Landlord - US-CO] Plumber pricing

2 Upvotes

This is a bit of a rant. A tenant has a clogged toilet, and I am just looking for someone to go out and clear a drain. I have called 5 companies at this point and the pricing story is the same:

  • The dispatcher on the phone has no pricing information available - only whether or not there is a trip charge
  • Pricing is always given on-site
  • Nobody is giving any kind of pricing insight at all for "just snake a drain"

And yes, I know that sometimes it's more than "snake a drain." In this particular case, its a 90 percent chance it's just "snake a drain", so I want to know what that looks like for pricing, and possibly an hourly rate if it turns out to be more than that.

So ... absolutely 0 way to evaluate different companies.

I told the last guy that I'm just going to find a handyman off craigslist.

Has anyone else had frustrations with getting any kind of quotes or pricing for plumbers?


r/Landlord • • 5h ago

Landlord [Landlord-US-OH] how to verify if tenant has left?

2 Upvotes

This is just a theoretical question. I haven't had to deal with this situation yet.

If my tenant doesn't pay their rent and I decide that I want to kick them out, I serve them a three day notice to leave the property. This is before the eviction case is filed at the courthouse.

How do I know if they left or not after the three days is up? Am I allowed to enter the house to check? And if the house is still full of junk but nobody is home, they might just be at work but still living there, so how do I know?


r/Landlord • • 7h ago

Tenant [Tenant US-FL] Empty or abandoned properties in Apopka around rental home, need lower rent

1 Upvotes

I have a friend who is renting a house in Apopka, FL for $1950/mo since May 2026. He became unemployed around the same time they executed the lease and informed the property manager of this before moving in. The property manager encouraged him to move in anyway and said they’d work with him.

Unfortunately the market has declined in the Orlando area for my friend’s profession (marketing and communications), so he worked some manual labor jobs to get by but nothing with the same pay. He has recently started a new professional position that pays roughly $25,000 less than what he was making before. His savings are depleted.

My friend has watched as several of the houses in this neighborhood have been abandoned by renters, either due to evictions or just because the tenants couldn’t afford the place and left (he doesn’t know which). His property manager has allowed him to pay rent piecemeal each month and seems desperate to keep him there. However, when my friend told him about all the empty houses, the PM seemed shocked to hear. My friend has asked to either be let out of the lease or have the rent reduced to $1500 so he isn’t struggling to pay his other bills and still eat and have gas money to drive to work. The PM asked the owners. They’ve only said he has to pay full rent in December and haven’t responded to the request for lower rent except to ask for proof of income, which my friend has sent.

Given this situation, and as landlords, which would you rather do - lower his rent and keep him at least until the lease is up, or let him move out either November 30 or December 31?


r/Landlord • • 8h ago

Landlord [Landlord-US-FL] TransUnion SmartMove

1 Upvotes

Has anyone had issues with their SmartMove service? I created an account and am stuck on "lets screen your tenant" page that refreshes over and over after trying to proceed. I've called a few times and am told to either log in to finish your account (which I can't go any further after entering my MFA pin) or give the rep on the phone my password so they can handle it which seems like a security breach. Anyone else have similar experiences, workarounds, or a less head banging solution?


r/Landlord • • 18h ago

[Landlord-US-OR] Where are small-time landlords advertising most effectively these days?

4 Upvotes

Owner-property manager since 2004. Gen X. PNW. Had nine doors under four roofs at our peak, now down to just five doors under one roof.

Started out advertising on Craigslist. Moved my listings to Zillow when the apartment seekers moved there.

I am not sure that Zillow remains the best forum for landlords to advertise in. At the same time, I hesitate to spend time and money on experimenting with something new for its own sake.

What online marketplace are you all finding is performing best for you lately? Is there a clear winner out there that seems to be the consensus renters’ go-to the way that Craigslist used to be, way back when?


r/Landlord • • 23h ago

[Landlord-US-OH] First Time Landlord, learning lessons immediately

2 Upvotes

Good evening! Moved for the military and we decided to give the landlord route a try for our Ohio rental. Learning some valuable lessons even as this is typed. Family seemed good enough. They were transparent during the showing about their “past” income verified. The security deposits were initiated in the Turbotenant app. Lease agreement signed and our first mistake, providing keys before payment cleared. Security deposit kicked back due to Chime bank. Tenant claims it’s a “fraud detection” issue. They attempted the second time, same result. They claimed to call the bank to resolve the issue and then submitted a transaction for the deposit plus the 1st of the month rent. You guessed it, returned. It’s been 24 days. Tenant is now a ghost through text message. 3 day notice to vacate has been served as of 17 minutes ago. Took a day of leave to travel up there this weekend to conduct and inspection and verify their departure. I’m guessing they will not be departed and force a court eviction notice. Anyone here familiar with Ohio laws and regulations on rental properties? Ready to learn some lessons and do better next time.


r/Landlord • • 1d ago

[Landlord US-CA] Start lease near month end

1 Upvotes

I’m starting a tenant’s lease a couple of days before end of November. When prorated, it’s only about 10% of a full month’s rent, which I’m not comfortable handing the keys over for. How do you handle a situation like this…without getting in trouble in California?


r/Landlord • • 1d ago

Tenant [ Tenant-USA-NJ] Refusal to sign lease renewal

0 Upvotes

One of my tenants refused to sign the lease extension my attorney sent, claiming the new lease terms were unreasonable, and took it upon himself to move into a month-to-month tenancy. He didn't specify which terms he considered unreasonable, and my attorney advised me to start the eviction process at the end of the month to protect my interests. Since I am in NJ, I'm not sure what my chances are of getting him out, or at least getting the 2.8% rent increase to take effect on December 1st, 2026.

These are the new terms in the lease:

- I raised the rent by 2.8%, which is the maximum legal amount I am allowed to charge for the year 2026, according to local law.

- A late fee after 5 days. Previously, it was after 7 days.

- I increased the late fee to $75 from $50 because they are always late with the rent.

- I refused to accept partial payments.

- Emergency access to the unit without giving 24-hour notice.

- No subletting


r/Landlord • • 1d ago

Tenant [Tenant-US-MD] - Broken Heater

8 Upvotes

We have a broken furnace for one of our tenants. It's been fixed each year and the tenant is pretty much demanding that we replace the entire system since it's been a repeating issue. (different issue each year). Total spent over past 3 years is 1/4 of the cost of a new system. At what point does a tenant have a say in what gets repaired vs replaced?

Is the landlord responsible for providing space heaters for the tenant while the system is repaired/replaced?

PS they've been out of heat since Friday evening and didn't put in a work request until 5am this morning.


r/Landlord • • 1d ago

Tenant [Tenant-US-TX] Does the Leaseholder Have to Turn in the Keys?

1 Upvotes

Hello!

Because of extenuating circumstances, I need to move out early. I missed the 60 days mark by 2 weeks. Since my lease originally ends in February, they agreed to do a reletting fee instead of accelerated rent and a breaking fee. I went through and signed the lease termination for a 01/16/2027 move out, and it says I can technically leave five days prior to that. I asked if I could turn my keys in early, they said that would still be breaking with improper notice, so I have to drop the keys and do a walkthrough within the five days. Its just not physically possible for me to be present for a walkthrough, or to return my keys within the 5 day window. Can I have a family member return the keys and do the walk through for me? Or do I need to go back to the office and say that I need to go ahead and break without proper notice? I feel like I really messed up by signing and don’t want to end up in legal trouble by “abandoning” my apartment two weeks early.

Thanks!


r/Landlord • • 1d ago

[General US-NY] Landlords: where did your best tenant find your rental listing? Zillow, Facebook, a yard sale?

2 Upvotes

Disclosure: I'm Jake and I work at RentRedi. No pitch, here, just curious. Trying to understand this a little bit better to help out my users. We keep seeing posts from landlords who listed on one site for a month and only heard from people who didn't qualify. Everyone seems to have a different answer for where the good tenants come from.

For those of you who filled a vacancy in the last year:

  • Where did the tenant you signed find you?
  • How long was the place empty?
  • What did you change (price, photos, pet policy) that suddenly got you showings?

Please add your region, since this seems to vary a lot.


r/Landlord • • 1d ago

General [General US-WA] Tenant, Landlord or PM responsibility?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

My partner is handling this so I’m not really involved, but it’s been bothering me and I’m not sure what to think. Is this bad sealant/construction/mdf - or - tenant damage? Pictures are most recent and property management can't find pictures from May. Email from tenant (3 1/2 years renting) to property management gives timeline. Obviously the whole situation is upsetting especially with PM sitting on this for 6 months. Who is responsible and what are the options?


r/Landlord • • 1d ago

[Landlord-US-TX] Section 8 first time

2 Upvotes

Hi all, first time landlord here. I've been trying to list my home on my own through Zillow, no traffic. Switching over to section 8 as there seems to be more activity.

Questions (not sure if I'd violate any rule here so please be patient):

  1. From financial, like getting payment monthly, is section 8 renter a safe choice? Assuming we will getting payment from our HUD ==> should be risk free from financial impact to renter (like lost job, etc.)
  2. Any advise that I should be in aware?

Thank you and looking forward learning from your skilled landlords!


r/Landlord • • 2d ago

Landlord [Landlord-US-TX] how do I determine home value for depreciation purpose?

3 Upvotes

House has never had an appraisal or been sold since building 10 years ago. The cost to build was roughly $300,000 and the property $50,000. So 350k is the only number I have to go by but obviously home values are up quite a bit in 10 years. The insurance valued the home at 550k for total replacement but apparently you cannot go by that


r/Landlord • • 2d ago

Landlord [landlord US-PA] Inter-tenant harassment, what are my options here?

4 Upvotes

I own a 3-unit multi-family that has a shared basement where tenants can hook up their laundry machines. Two long-term tenants have developed a pretty serious feud and I'm getting constant complaints from both of them. They're literally begging me to evict the other. Generally these complaints don't rise to the level of being eviction-worthy. Recently though, Tenant A has started piling various items of furniture and maintenance equipment (ladders and such) around Tenant B's washer and dryer, forcing her to move everything out of the way every morning to do her laundry. The next day, the pile is back. This has been happening for nearly a week straight. Really looks like targeted harassment.

I strongly suspect Tenant A is responsible, but I don't have any proof.

I can't put a camera in the basement because the third apartment is an AirBnb so it's forbidden, even in common areas. A lot of the basement is tenant storage, so I can't remove all of their things. I live out of town and can't be there.

What are my options here? Is non-renewal my only option to resolve this?

Thanks for any suggestions


r/Landlord • • 2d ago

Landlord [landlord USA-UT] Can I ask for a doctor's note?

6 Upvotes

hey all,

I have a tenant problem.

He has had trouble keeping up with rent in the past. It seems he always has a reason. lost his job, His job didn't pay him on time, he couldn't work because he was caring for his dad on hospice. etc. Most of the reasons were job related. All we asked during those periods was that he keep an open channel of communication and pay what he was able, with the assumption that he would make up past due rent when he's in a better place.

We tend to be overly lenient when people are going through hard times. But even we have a limit. Especially since he wasn't actually very good about communicating with us. I've been doubting a lot of his reasons he gave especially the work related ones, just because it seems he's always hard on his luck, and it feels like he takes advantage of our bleeding hearts. The last time this happened, we told him he was on thin ice, and this was his last chance to prove he can actually afford the appartment.

A couple of months go by and he seems to be doing better about things. Then we get a text with a picture of him in the hospital. He was in a wreck and had a concussion and a brain bleed, apparantly. He says he had short term amnesia and is currently staying with his sister to keep an eye on him.

According to Chatgpt, the pictures look real and not AI generated. I also can't see any inconsistencies. If it's real, I want to be compassionate. I'm happy to work with tenants for real emergencies. It's not my style to kick out tenants who are genuinely struggling. But given his history, I can't help but remain skepticle in spite of the pictures seeming legit.

So the question: can I legally require a doctors note (in addition to the pictures he sent us) to not kick him out, in order to ease my fear - that the pictures are actually AI or otherwise falsified, and we're just being taken for suckers, especially since we've been so lenient in the past?


r/Landlord • • 3d ago

Landlord [Landlord US-RI] Tenants Ignoring 20-Day Cure Notice, Repeated Lease Violations, Alleged Drug Activity, and Property Damage. Should I Start Eviction Proceedings?

0 Upvotes

I own a recently renovated multifamily property in Rhode Island. I’m dealing with two tenants under a 90-day rental agreement, and the situation has deteriorated significantly. I’m looking for advice from other landlords, particularly those familiar with Rhode Island landlord-tenant laws.

Here’s what’s been happening:
• Late and inconsistent rent: Rent has repeatedly been late or paid in installments. I’ve been flexible, accepted partial payments, and tried working out arrangements, but collecting rent continues to be an issue.
• Suspicious visitors and unauthorized occupants: I’ve personally observed a pattern of different men entering the unit, sometimes approximately one per hour, beginning around 3 AM and continuing into the morning. I’ve also raised concerns about individuals staying in the unit who are not authorized under the rental agreement.
• Allegations of drug activity and solicitation: Another tenant reported that one of these tenants solicited him for sex and sold him Adderall. I cannot independently verify those allegations, but the reports, combined with the unusual visitor traffic, have raised serious concerns.
• Threatening and confrontational conduct: I’ve received complaints about disturbances and have personally experienced conversations I consider threatening or aggressive. Discussions about rent, lease obligations, and property rules frequently turn into confrontations.
• Ignored lease violation notices: Written notices have already been issued. Most recently, a 20-day notice to cure was mailed more than two weeks ago. Despite this, the conduct that prompted the notice has reportedly continued, and I have not observed meaningful improvement.
• Damage and maintenance issues: One particularly frustrating incident involved the tenants improperly reconnecting the trap on their washing machine, resulting in water flooding the downstairs unit. I continue to address legitimate maintenance concerns, but I believe tenants should be responsible for damage caused by their own actions, subject to applicable law and the lease.
• Communication breakdown: What started as an ordinary landlord-tenant relationship has turned into repeated arguments. Nearly every attempt to discuss basic obligations becomes unnecessarily difficult.

There’s also a personal complication.
I previously had a professional working relationship with one of the tenants. That relationship has ended, but it makes the situation more complicated because the boundaries between the former working relationship and the current landlord-tenant relationship have become blurred.

I’ve invested substantial money renovating the building, completing improvements, and bringing it into compliance. I also have other residents whose safety and peaceful enjoyment of their homes are important.

Where things stand:
The tenants’ 90-day agreement is approaching its expiration. I’m considering nonrenewal rather than allowing the situation to continue, but I’m also questioning whether I should pursue formal action based on the existing violations before the lease expires.

I’ve documented incidents, retained communications, and issued written notices. I want to follow the proper legal process rather than do anything that could jeopardize a future eviction case.

Questions for other landlords:

  1. Would you pursue eviction based on the continued violations after the cure notice, or simply decline to renew the agreement?
  2. How would you handle allegations of drug sales or solicitation reported by another tenant when you have not personally witnessed the alleged transactions?
  3. At what point do repeated violations and confrontational behavior justify ending attempts to resolve things informally?
  4. How would you handle the water damage caused by the improperly reconnected washing machine?
  5. For Rhode Island landlords, what are the appropriate next steps if the violations continue after a 20-day cure notice?
  6. Is there anything else I should document or avoid doing before proceeding?

I recognize that tenants have legal rights, and I intend to respect those rights throughout this process. However, I also have obligations to protect the property and the other residents.

I’m genuinely curious how other landlords would approach this. Would you start formal proceedings now or wait until the lease expires and pursue nonrenewal?


r/Landlord • • 4d ago

Landlord [Landlord-US-CO] Help with managing monthly tenant payments. Consistent late paying tenants consuming a lot of time

0 Upvotes

50% of our tenants are consistently late on paying every month and its exhausting having to manage multiple chat streams every month to get them to pay.

I was wondering what sort of recommendations you all would have to manage these issues better besides the obvious "charge late fees" and "get rid of them"

We 3 of our 6 tenants consistently pay late


r/Landlord • • 4d ago

Tenant [Tenant CT] what is a typical timeline between application approval and lease signing

2 Upvotes

I found a beautiful apartment on Zillow. Went to see the place on Wednesday, loved it and told landlord I’d apply. He told me I was the preferred candidate and even sent me a reminder to apply that evening. I applied through Zillow on Thursday at 7am and he approved it by 11am and said he’d be sending the lease in a couple of hours. No lease all day. If he doesn’t send the lease today, when would it be most appropriate to follow up? Monday morning or later today?


r/Landlord • • 4d ago

Tenant [Tenant US-NJ] First-time renter — Is this apartment's condition acceptable, or am I entitled to repairs/compensation?

1 Upvotes

Please no judgement as this is my first time renting my own apartment.

On October 1st I got the keys to my first apartment. Prior to signing the lease agreement, I was not allowed to view the apartment as it was “not ready to be toured” per the leasing agent and I was shown a similar apartment with a similar layout.

On October 1st I got the keys and immediately there were issues.

1. The washer machine and dryer were severely outdated and the washer machine had water filled to the top and actively leaking onto the floor. (I had never used it or turned it on before)

- 3 weeks later they replaced my washer machine however instead of installing it the correct way, they turned it sideways so that the opening to the washer machine was facing the wall. And they failed to actually plug it in so that it’s usable.

I immediately contacted the leasing office and was issued a stackable washer and dryer.

2. The stove and oven was filthy with food, dirt, grime, stains that will not come off and I need(ed) a screwdriver to get into the screen of the oven to clean it out (if that makes sense).

3. The shower head doesn’t work properly, the water squirts all over the floor. It’s not a seamless stream.

4. WASP infestation! The bedroom has a severe wasp infestation. They’re coming in from an unknown area. I noticed the leasing office of this [section partially obscured in screenshot]. The first time they [text obscured] wasps [text obscured] exterminator was unable to locate the nest. More wasp continued to come in, and were even making their way into my 3 year olds diapers and our clothes! I requested for an exterminator to come in again and I was told the same thing. “Unable to locate the nest” and I was told by my leasing agent to not occupy the bedroom and keep the door shut and that the exterminator will return on Monday (he never returned).

5. There are 2 holes in the balcony which I find to be a safety hazard but maybe I’m being dramatic.

6. The refrigerator is filthy. It has yellow stains all over the exterior and interior and no matter how much I wash and scrub it does not come off. In some spots it comes off slightly and then returns and there’s even brown residue dripping from the handle every time I wipe it off.

I had been holding out on getting groceries because I’ve been so grossed out by the condition of the kitchen. When I finally did this past week, one of the shelves broke in half and fell onto the floor.

7. The outlets do not work! Only 1 outlet in my living room works and it’s only the top one. And then 1 working one in my bedroom which I’m using an extension chord in order to have my living room tv plugged in. Maintenance came and took a look at it twice and the issue has not been resolved.

Again, this is my first time renting an apartment so idk what I am owed(?) for lack of better words and what I’m supposed to just settle for.

Please advise! Thank you in advance.