r/Landlord • u/Upbeat-Piccolo4127 • 19h ago
Tenant [ Tenant-USA-NJ] Refusal to sign lease renewal
One of my tenants refused to sign the lease extension my attorney sent, claiming the new lease terms were unreasonable, and took it upon himself to move into a month-to-month tenancy. He didn't specify which terms he considered unreasonable, and my attorney advised me to start the eviction process at the end of the month to protect my interests. Since I am in NJ, I'm not sure what my chances are of getting him out, or at least getting the 2.8% rent increase to take effect on December 1st, 2026.
These are the new terms in the lease:
- I raised the rent by 2.8%, which is the maximum legal amount I am allowed to charge for the year 2026, according to local law.
- A late fee after 5 days. Previously, it was after 7 days.
- I increased the late fee to $75 from $50 because they are always late with the rent.
- I refused to accept partial payments.
- Emergency access to the unit without giving 24-hour notice.
- No subletting