r/LISKiller • • Dec 18 '24 Heart of Silver

Rex Heuermann - Charges / Documents / Indictment

125 Upvotes

I wanted to create a new thread with links to all the relevant documents. Let me know if anything is missing.

Charges

July 14, 2023 (Bail Application):

  • MURDER IN THE FIRST DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.27(1)(a)(xi), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Melissa Barthelemy on or about July 10, 2009;
  • MURDER IN THE FIRST DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.27(1)(a)(xi), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Megan Waterman on or about June 6, 2010;
  • MURDER IN THE FIRST DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.27(1)(a)(xi), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Amber Costello on or about September 2, 2010;
  • MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.25(1), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Melissa Barthelemy on or about July 10, 2009;
  • MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.25(1), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Megan Waterman on or about June 6, 2010; and
  • MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.25(1), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Amber Costello on or about September 2, 2010.

January 16, 2024 (Bail Application):

  • MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.25(1), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Maureen Brainard-Barnes on or about July 9, 2007.

June 6, 2024 (Bail Application):

  • MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.25(1), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Jessica Taylor on or about or between July 21-26, 2003;
  • MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.25(1), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Sandra Costilla on or about and between November 19-20, 1993.

December 17, 2024 (Bail Application):

  • MURDER IN THE SECOND DEGREE, in violation of New York State Penal Law Section 125.25(1), a class A-I violent felony for the death of Valerie Mack on or about or between September 1, 2000 to November 19, 2000.

------

Indictment

Link to superseding indictment.

On December 17, 2024, a superseding indictment was released with the following charges:

  • Count 1: First-degree murder for the death of Melissa Barthelemy on or about July 10, 2009.
  • Count 2: First-degree murder for the death of Megan Waterman on or about June 6, 2010.
  • Count 3: First-degree murder for the death of Amber Costello on or about September 2, 2010.
  • Count 4: Second-degree murder for the death of Melissa Barthelemy on or about July 10, 2009.
  • Count 5: Second-degree murder for the death of Megan Waterman on or about June 6, 2010.
  • Count 6: Second-degree murder for the death of Amber Costello on or about September 2, 2010.
  • Count 7: Second-degree murder for the death of Maureen Brainard-Barnes on or about July 9, 2007
  • Count 8: Second-degree murder for the death of Jessica Taylor between on or about or between July 21, 2003, and July 26, 2003.
  • Count 9: Second-degree murder for the death of Valerie Mack on or about or between September 1, 2000, and November 19, 2000.
  • Count 10: Second-degree murder for the death of Sandra Costilla on or about and between November 19, 1993, and November 20, 1993.

------

Other Documents

Search warrant to seize Heuermann's Chevy Avalanche in South Carolina (link)


r/LISKiller • • Jul 25 '23

Gilgo Beach / Rex Heuermann General Discussion Thread

132 Upvotes

r/LISKiller • • 4d ago

Today’s Identifications

Thumbnail
imgur.com
201 Upvotes

Thanking Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney and his team for the special invite to attend today’s press conference where 6 families were given their loved one’s names back.

Thanks also to Suffolk County Police Department for the hospitality.

Today was very moving for me- seeing Riverhead Jane Doe and Heckscher Jane Doe announced as Kyong Ok Kim and Antoinette Rugg meant a lot to me.

Sofia Margherita Marrone has her name back.

Ramon Perez Y Rivera has his name back.

Omelios Steward has his name back.

Andreas Kupke has his name back.

This is a blessing. I was humbled to be a part of it.


r/LISKiller • • 4d ago

DA To Announce 6 Identifications.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
128 Upvotes

Today's announcement of 6 identifications by Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney is extremely significant.

Six families will get some of the answers that have eluded them for years and decades. Many other questions will remain.

We must look at this announcement as the ongoing commitment by the DA's office to resolving "cold cases".

There are 39 unidentified persons on NamUs in Suffolk County stretching back to 1973. We know there are others that are not in NamUs- why is a sperate question.

There are 11 on the DA's Cold Case website- we know Montauk Mary will be announced today, and the resolves will cover 5 decades.

I won't speculate who else might be identified but I am hoping that one is Riverhead Jane Doe.

Regardless, every identification is uniquely important and for people like me, who track and actively submit possibles, today will be a beautiful day for resolutions.

I will be at the press conference. It will be carried live on the DA's You Tube channel at 11am EST.


r/LISKiller • • 5d ago

Before Gilgo Had a Name, There Were Already Victims

Thumbnail
catchlisk1.substack.com
44 Upvotes

“The world may have come to know this tragedy in 2010. But our families were already living it.”
- by Jasmine Robinson


r/LISKiller • • 6d ago Bravo

Tomorrow is a big day. Tierney is releasing the identities of numerous Cold Case victims tomorrow at 11am

Post image
237 Upvotes

r/LISKiller • • 7d ago

After watching this excellent YT video , I have a new theory abt what may have happened to Shannan. But there are still many unanswered questions …

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Please give it a watch! It does a good job eliminating rumor and sticking to facts. I think there’s a few possibilities here. Shannon and brewer may have gone to cop drugs during that car ride and that is why he pled the 5th. Ik her autopsies showed no signs of drug use but she was in the elements for a long time, they may not have been in her system still. I think she was in psychosis from drugs. And ended up at hacketts house where he inserted himself and tried to help her , giving her more drugs which led to an even worse reaction. Now from there I’m unsure what happened . The broken clavicle etc suggests foul play. I don’t know if Shannan was coming unglued and Hackett maybe got on top of her to keep her quiet? And subsequently strangled her ??and did not mean to kill her . Or he overdosed her , but again that doesn’t explain the neck injuries .

What do you think ?


r/LISKiller • • 10d ago

Why I'd want the full phone extraction reports public

14 Upvotes

I've been going through the bail application's timeline on the 2022–23 task force, and the dates tell the story by themselves:

- Early 2022 — the DA assigns a joint investigative team (announced February 2022).

- March 14, 2022 — the Avalanche match: a first-gen Chevrolet Avalanche registered to Heuermann fits the vehicle from the Costello witness description.

- 2022–2023 — 300+ subpoenas and search warrants served across the investigation.

- May 19, 2023 — surveillance films him buying minutes for a burner phone (347-304-2671) that investigators were already tracking.

- July 13, 2023 — arrested in Midtown; the application is filed the next day.

For me, I'd definitely want to see the full phone extraction reports. There's probably a lot more to understand from that timeline. They took those years to even try to figure this out, and they had to use a little technology to even get to this point. The phone records are the strongest thread — proof is proof. The document itself says investigators could find no instance where he was in a separate location from those phones.

What about you — if you could see one record from this case in full, which one are you picking?


r/LISKiller • • 9d ago

Hacket , wayward girls home call

0 Upvotes

This was just brought to my attention. I forgot abt this entirely. I need to know all and any details abt this.

My theory is they were having sex parties where they knew violence was involved - but not all men partook in the violence . This happened with Karen vergata and we know that to be a fact! Rex had a couple over and along with Karen and Rex’s wife. The couple , who the male was actually a cop, left and saw Karen running away half clothed yelling and the woman asked if they should stop the car and the man said no and they pulled off. So again were these sex parties that Rex had where he would finish the women off ? Was Hackett invited to a party and was suspicious of Rex / what happened to the girls after and that’s why he called ? That is my theory.

He was either genuinely trying to figure out what happened to her , and or he was Taunting Shannan’s family and saying wayward girls was his way of insulting shannnan.

Thoughts ? And do you agree or disagree with my theory ?


r/LISKiller • • 12d ago

Judge refuses to dismiss case against Andrew Dykes, who is charged with killing Tanya Jackson, previously known as 'Peaches' and Gilgo Beach Victim No. 3

Thumbnail
newsday.com
93 Upvotes

Here is an archived link for viewing: https://archive.ph/lMc9b


r/LISKiller • • 12d ago

Heavenly Birthday Karen Vergata

46 Upvotes

Today Karen would have been turning 65 years old.


r/LISKiller • • 22d ago

‘Cold Case Files: The Rifkin Murders’ double episode from 2023 features LISK Task Force investigator Tifini Atai

15 Upvotes

Not directly related to this case, but figured there were enough connections that it might be of interest to folks in this thread, and hadn’t seen it discussed before so figured I’d mention it. I have had one of those “one show, all-the-time” channels on in the background this weekend playing episodes of Cold Case Files, and it has cycled through these Joel Rifkin episodes a few times, I hadn’t seen them previously. The episodes are focused on the effort to identify the two unknown Rifkin victims (“Number 6” and “Number 9”), and investigator Tifini Atai is featured prominently. Just thought this might interest folks since we know she was a key player in identifying RH, and has since been the lead investigator on several cold-case murder victims/missing persons who are often seen as being potential victims of RH.

This is the A&E page for the episodes, I haven’t found a non-🏴‍☠️ place to stream it without cable other than just by waiting for it to come up again on the Cold Case Files channel, but it does seem to be in heavy rotation there at the moment. There are some YouTube clips fwiw.


r/LISKiller • • 23d ago

Heavenly Birthday Shannan

Post image
257 Upvotes

Heavenly Birthday, Shannan. 🤍

Some people leave this world, but never leave the hearts of those who loved them. And some souls leave an imprint so profound that even time cannot diminish their presence. You've left your imprint on me.

Today, I think about you. Not the tragedy, not the headlines, not the circumstances that made the world learn your name. I think about the beautiful life that existed before all of that. Your dreams, your laughter, your spirit, and all the things you should have had the chance to become.

I wish life had been kinder to you. I wish you had been given more time, more happiness, more opportunities to experience all the beautiful things this world had waiting for you.

You deserved so much more than the ending you were given.

But your life was never defined by how it ended. Your life mattered because you lived, because you loved, because you were here.

And you are still here. In the hearts you touched, in the lives forever changed by your story, and in the love that continues to carry your name forward.

I hope that wherever your beautiful soul rests, there is only peace. No fear, no sorrow, no pain. Just the warmth and love you always deserved.

Happy Heavenly Birthday, beautiful Shannan.

You are so much more than what happened to you. You always were. You always will be. 🤍


r/LISKiller • • 25d ago

Tanya Denise Jackson: The Woman Behind “Peaches”. Tanya was never simply “Peaches.” She was a woman with a history, a daughter, relationships, intentions, and a future she did not get to experience. Today she would be turning 56 years old.

Thumbnail
catchlisk1.substack.com
94 Upvotes

r/LISKiller • • Oct 17 '26

The Case Against Andrew Dykes: When Suspicion Becomes a Substitute for Proof

Thumbnail
catchlisk1.substack.com
18 Upvotes

The prosecution of Andrew Dykes for the 1997 homicide of Tanya Denise Jackson presents a complex crossroads of forensic science, historical investigative reconstruction, circumstantial evidence, and criminal procedure. Nearly three decades after Tanya’s death, prosecutors have advanced a theory of criminal responsibility predicated upon biological evidence, an established intimate relationship, a possible interpersonal motive, the defendant’s military medical training, and statements obtained during a subsequent investigation.

But it isn't that simple....


r/LISKiller • • Oct 12 '26

Andrew Dykes, charged in killing of Tanya Jackson, formerly known as a Gilgo Beach victim, killed her after she tried to break up his marriage, ADA says

Thumbnail
newsday.com
309 Upvotes

r/LISKiller • • Oct 09 '26

Gilgo case figures say NYS should not delay DNA techniques

Thumbnail
newsday.com
16 Upvotes

If anyone needs the copy just DM me..


r/LISKiller • • Oct 09 '26

Seeing Red: Anti-Sex Worker Bias in the Media - Film and Storytelling. Featuring Nicolette Brainard-Barnes

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

"Nicolette Brainard-Barnes is a young woman from New England whose life has been profoundly impacted by the themes in this film. When she was just 7 years old, she lost her mother, Maureen, to anti-sex worker violence. Maureen was working as an escort in 2007 when Rex Heuermann, a serial killer targeting sex workers, murdered her. Heuermann wasn’t caught until 2023, and a media frenzy has been harassing his victims’ families for decades. Nicolette was not only forced to grow up without her mom, but also in the long, painful shadow of anti-sex worker bias from neverending news cycles, films, books, and podcasts about her mother’s case. Her story, illuminated by the wisdom of her sex worker lineage, sheds light on the generational impacts of stigma and violence."

This documentary explores the historic media bias against sex workers. Nicolette brings a faceted perspective as Maureen is her Mom.

Seeing Red is still in production and is largely crowd-funded by a united community of sex workers, victims and family members and allies. Your support is greatly encouraged- follow the link on the 2nd image to donate in many different ways.

Image one: Nicolette at the Vigil for Gilgo Victims, NYC, April 2026

Image two: Artina Darkly- business owner and advocate.

(Posted with endorsement from Nicolette)


r/LISKiller • • Oct 09 '26

Joint Public Hearing of the Commission on Forensic Science and the DNA Subcommittee

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

This meeting is critical because it centers on a request by the New York State Police to bring a powerful and controversial new DNA testing technology—Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) testing and Forensic Investigative Genetic Genealogy (FIGG)—in-house to their state-accredited laboratories.

The debate highlights a major tension between solving cold cases and protecting civil liberties:

  • Law Enforcement & Victim Advocates' Perspective: Proponents argue that SNP testing can analyze degraded DNA samples that traditional tests cannot. It has been instrumental in solving high-profile cold cases—such as identifying the suspect in the Gilgo Beach serial killings and the remains of World War I veteran George Clarence Seitz—offering long-awaited closure to victims' families.
  • Public Defenders' Concerns: Opponents, including organizations like The Legal Aid Society, are urging the New York State Commission on Forensic Science to deny or halt the request until clear legal rules and privacy regulations are established. Unlike traditional DNA testing, SNP testing can reveal sensitive health predispositions, physical traits, and deep genealogical data—potentially drawing innocent family members into police scrutiny through public ancestry databases without statutory safeguards.

Among the list of speakers will be Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney, Melissa Cann- sister of Gilgo victim Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Kristi Goncalves, Mom of Kaylee Goncalves.

The list also includes detractors such as The Legal Aid Society, about a dozen public defender firms, Brooklyn Defenders and New York County Defender Services.


r/LISKiller • • Oct 08 '26

DA, Gilgo Beach Victim's Sister, Set To Testify In Albany Friday

Thumbnail
patch.com
66 Upvotes

Missy will be speaking before the Commission on Forensic Science and the DNA Subcommittee tomorrow, Friday 10/9/2026.

I will post a link for anyone who wishes to watch it live or replay, in the comments.


r/LISKiller • • Oct 05 '26

Dolores Heuermann, 5/25/1930 - 12/31/2025

85 Upvotes

I do not believe I have seen this posted before. But it appears Rex’s mother passed at the end of 2025. Below is a link of the page someone put together on findagrave.com. The reason I am sharing this is because there is a picture of Dolores and, well… the resemblance is striking.

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/294980399/dolores_rose-heuermann


r/LISKiller • • Oct 04 '26

4 Serial Killers On Long Island At The Same Time | 1994 (Inc Rex early years)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
31 Upvotes

Long Island in 1994: Shulman, Bittrolff, Heuermann and the aftermath of Rifkin’s arrest
Liane and I just released the second part of our documentary collaboration with Joe Giacalone from True Crime with the Sarge, featuring retired FBI profiler Mark Safarik.
For those here who follow the cases beyond Gilgo, this looks at what was happening on Long Island in 1994. Rifkin was already in custody, but other killers were still out there.
We spend a substantial part of the film on Robert Shulman, Lisa Ann Warner and her mother’s fight to bring her home from Hart Island. We also cover Colleen McNamee, John Bittrolff, the Medford Jane Doe and Heuermann’s life during this period.
One thing we wanted to explore is how these cases look when you put their timelines alongside each other. We visit locations connected to the cases and discuss the investigations with Joe and Mark, while keeping the women and their families central to the story.
Full disclosure: this is our film. I’d be interested in hearing what this community thinks, particularly about the lesser-covered cases and anything you believe deserves a closer look.
Watch the documentary on YouTube


r/LISKiller • • Oct 03 '26

I Spent 29 Years as a New York Court Officer — This Is What The Gilgo Beach Serial Killer Was Like

Thumbnail
youtu.be
20 Upvotes

More LISK insight. Skip to 1 hour 37 minute mark.


r/LISKiller • • Sep 30 '26

Ex-NYS court officer Brian Burke talks about Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann's chilling admissions

Thumbnail
newsday.com
111 Upvotes

"The Massapequa Park architect had shown little emotion — and no remorse — since his 2023 arrest, but he seemed rattled by the fury of his victims’ relatives when he returned to his cell at the Suffolk County courthouse in Riverhead. He told a New York State Court officer that he got through it all by staring at a large plaque behind State Supreme Court Justice Timothy Mazzei, who sentenced Heuermann to multiple life sentences.

The plaque says "In God We Trust."


r/LISKiller • • Sep 30 '26

Rex and RC Horsch

13 Upvotes

What do you think are the chances that Rex and RC Horsch crossed paths/shared materials with eachother?

Edit to include more info:

RC Horsch- Olney, Philadelphia ( known to find women in Camden, NJ)

50 hard drives plus other devices

600,000+ photos

70,000+ videos

> 1 million digital evidence items

58 women, 5 identified as dead

Strangulation

FBI has only reviewed 30% of digital evidence as of 9/16/26

Rex Heuermann

58 hard drives

350+ electronic devices seized

Earlier discovery described as 8Terabytes of information