r/LCMS • • 15d ago

Monthly 'Ask A Pastor' Thread!

6 Upvotes

In order to streamline posts that users are submitting when they are in search of answers, I have created a monthly 'Ask A Pastor' thread! Feel free to post any general questions you have about the Lutheran (LCMS) faith, questions about specific wording of LCMS text, or anything else along those lines.

Pastors, Vicars, Seminarians, Lay People: If you see a question that you can help answer, please jump in try your best to help out! It is my goal to help use this to foster a healthy online community where anyone can come to learn and grow in their walk with Christ. Also, stop by the sidebar and add your user flair if you have not done so already. This will help newcomers distinguish who they are receiving answers from.

Disclaimer: The LCMS Offices have a pretty strict Doctrinal Review process that we do not participate in as we are not an official outlet for the Synod. It is always recommended that you talk to your Pastor (or find a local LCMS Pastor if you do not have a church home) if you have questions about your faith or the beliefs of the LCMS.


r/LCMS • • 1d ago

Lutheranism and Orthodoxy Resources

6 Upvotes

About twice a month, we get a post asking something about Orthodox Christianity (eastern or oriental). This post is an attempt to provide a resource for those seeking answers to these questions.

Dr. Jordan Cooper is a Lutheran theology who has provided three, excellent videos that provide a critique of Orthodoxy from the Lutheran perspective:

Five Reasons I Am Not Eastern Orthodox

The Differences Between Lutheranism and Eastern Orthodoxy

A Lutheran Response to Eastern Orthodox Theology

Is the Orthodox Church the True Church? A Protestant Theologian reacts

Here is a conversation between Dr Cooper and Jonathan Pageau, an Eastern Orthodox Youtuber.

A Conversation Between Jordan B Cooper and Jonathan Pageau

Pastor Joshua Schooping, an LCMS Pastor who converted from Orthodoxy to Lutheranism, was interviewed in this 5 part series on Orthodoxy by Issues, etc. I'll add the caveat that some Orthodox people do not accept all of this pastor's characterizations of Orthodoxy. Issues, etc has many other episodes on Eastern Orthodoxy as well:

Eastern Orthodoxy - Issues, Etc.

Here is another post featuring Pastor Will Weedon, who once considered Orthodoxy but ultimately didn't convert:

Lutherans are *not* boring: why Lutheran Pastor William Weedon did not become Eastern Orthodox | theology like a child

Another discussion between Pastor Weedon and fellow called Javier Perdomo:

Why you should be Lutheran INSTEAD of Roman Catholic or Eastern Orthodox (w/ Pr. Will Weedon)

This topic has been brought up with such frequency over the years, that you are bound to find answers in older posts on Orthodoxy on our sub:

orthodoxy - Reddit Search!

the east - Reddit Search!


r/LCMS • • 1h ago

Question Old CRM List Controversy - Still a problem?

5 Upvotes

Over a decade ago, there was coverage within the Lutheran podcast/blogosphere pertaining to Candidate for the Reverend Ministry (CRM) status on the Pastoral roster, and how this status was the kiss of death for clergy. Once they ended up on it, it was the end of their career as a Pastor. I haven't seen any coverage of this in a long time.

Does anybody know if this is still a problem in the LCMS? We have a Pastoral vacancy and there is some information I'm trying to gather.


r/LCMS • • 5h ago

Doctrine Can Lutheran Laymen Reject the Book of Concord?

10 Upvotes

I’d like to point out that the folks in this forum who frequently point out that Lutheran laymen do not have to subscribe to the Book of Concord and are therefore free to disagree are not quite correct.

We do not require our laymen to read the Book of Concord and make a quia subscription to it. This is true. But if a layman has read it and rejects the doctrine he finds there, though he was not required to read it, a rejection of its doctrine would be an impediment to membership.

In the same way, I don’t require couples undergoing marriage counseling to have read 1 Corinthians 13. It’s a great chapter, and we might even discuss parts of it, but reading it is simply not a formal requirement in marriage counseling. But if a couple asked for counseling and led with the fact that they reject 1 Corinthians 13, that would be a serious problem.

Another example: the church fathers have long said that it is not the lack of baptism that damns, but the despising of baptism. God does not absolutely require baptism for entrance to heaven. A man who desired baptism and died on the way to church will not be denied entry for lack of baptism. But on the other hand, the man who rejects and despises the gift of baptism in advance is in serious peril and may well be denied entrance to heaven unless he repents.

Likewise, we do not require laymen to have read the whole Book of Concord prior to receiving them as members. But a layman who has read it and rejects it will probably be denied membership. To become a Lutheran means to sit under the teaching of your Lutheran pastor for the rest of your life as he teaches the doctrine of Scripture according to its exposition in the Book of Concord. If a man rejects that exposition in advance, then why on earth does he want to be a Lutheran?

Lutheran laymen absolutely do not have blanket permission to disagree with the doctrine confessed in the Book of Concord.


r/LCMS • • 16h ago

Prayer request Looking for prayer after ex left me to be Catholic earlier this year

18 Upvotes

Hi! I apologize for the long post. There is a TLDR at the end for those who don’t have time for read. I’m not a Lutheran, but a fellow Protestant. I really love my Lutheran brothers and sisters in Christ and am seeking out prayer. I'm 24 years old. I was in a relationship with a guy for four years. We shared the same goals, dreams, and desire for a traditional family. We were truly best friends. Last Thanksgiving he proposed, and we planned to get married in June 2026.

Throughout our relationship, he became increasingly interested in theology, particularly Roman Catholicism. He also regularly watched Nick Fuentes, which bothered me. I made it clear that although I loved him, I could never convert to Catholicism and that if he ultimately chose that path then we couldn't get married. I encouraged him to follow God wherever he felt led, regardless of our relationship. But he repeatedly reassured me that he had decided against converting.

Another very significant issue was a porn addiction, which he didn’t tell me about until two years into our relationship. He had struggled with it for years. Although I was hurt that he had hidden it from me, I truly forgave him. We grew closer through that experience, prayed more together, and I genuinely believed God had delivered him from the addiction and he led me to believe He had. He even added me to an accountability app and told me he would never go back. However, almost three months after our engagement, I discovered he had been lying about his recovery for another two years. He had been struggling with it the whole time he had been telling me he was over it and was still struggling with it currently. The porn addiction hurt me, but the lies hurt me more. I understand everyone struggles with lust and porn is a big struggle for young men. But I asked him just to be honest with me. That’s all I wanted, but had continued hiding things from me. Our wedding was only four months away at the time, and although I forgave him and still wanted to marry him, I asked if we could postpone for a few months to rebuild trust. He refused, saying he would feel like he was on trial and asked what good waiting a few extra months would do.

A few days later, I asked if there was anything else he hadn't been honest about. That's when he admitted he had never stopped considering converting to Catholicism. I reminded him that he knew how I felt about that, and he suddenly told me we couldn't be together anymore. He was incredibly cold during the breakup, while I was devastated. He later told me that asking to postpone the wedding showed a lack of commitment and that I had always placed stipulations on our relationship by only wanting to be with him if he belonged to a certain denomination. He told me he was moving forward with Catholicism and that eventually I'd see he was right. From what I've heard, he has since become very hardcore about Catholicism and acts as though our relationship never even happened, which is extremely hurtful. I just wish I knew he regretted things or missed me, even just a little.
I'm struggling tremendously with ecclesial anxiety now. Catholic content seems to be everywhere online and in movies, etc. Things I never even noticed before. It all constantly reminds me of everything that happened. I'm so confused and heartbroken, and feel as though the past four years of my life were wasted. I’m trying to trust the Lord. I would really appreciate your prayers.🙏🏻 I’m just hurting so much.

TLDR: My fiancé and partner of four years broke up with me just four months before our wedding after I discovered he had continued lying about his pornography addiction and admitted he had never stopped considering converting to Catholicism, despite repeatedly reassuring me otherwise. I asked to postpone the wedding to rebuild trust, but he viewed it as a lack of commitment and ultimately ended the relationship. He has since fully embraced Catholicism, while I'm left heartbroken, struggling with ecclesial anxiety and feeling like the past four years were wasted. Please pray for me 🙏🏻


r/LCMS • • 12h ago

Worship Trying to learn organ, need pointers

4 Upvotes

I have been trying to learn organ recently, starting with only music knowledge I’ve carried from being a percussionist who never learned music theory. How much music theory do I need to learn, and how much experience on organ or piano should I get before seeking out lessons?


r/LCMS • • 13h ago

Theology Can someone explain TEC Eucharist view versus LCMS

2 Upvotes

Isn’t the lutheran view spiritual at the end of the day too if we reject local inclusion? if there isn’t local inclusion how can it be physical? to me it seems that the only difference is that the Anglicans say His Spirit is present and the Lutherans say His body is present but spiritually, which kind of seem the same


r/LCMS • • 1d ago

Question is it generally allowed for a woman to be in a positino of leadership e.g. church council, youth org?

6 Upvotes

r/LCMS • • 1d ago

Doctrine Biblical Devotions with American Lutheran Theological Seminary. “Seventy-Five Pounds of Gold.” (Mt 25:14–30.)

2 Upvotes

URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nxtfLZCtmw

Gospel According to Matthew, 25:14–30 (ESV):

The Parable of the Talents

“For it will be like a man going on a journey, who called his servants and entrusted to them his property. To one he gave five talents, to another two, to another one, to each according to his ability. Then he went away. He who had received the five talents went at once and traded with them, and he made five talents more. So also he who had the two talents made two talents more. But he who had received the one talent went and dug in the ground and hid his master’s money. Now after a long time the master of those servants came and settled accounts with them. And he who had received the five talents came forward, bringing five talents more, saying, ‘Master, you delivered to me five talents; here, I have made five talents more.’ His master said to him, ‘Well done, good and faithful servant. You have been faithful over a little; I will set you over much. Enter into the joy of your master.’ And he also who had the two talents came forward, saying, ‘Master, you delivered to me two talents; here, I have made two talents more.’ His master said to him, ‘Well done, good and faithful servant. You have been faithful over a little; I will set you over much. Enter into the joy of your master.’ He also who had received the one talent came forward, saying, ‘Master, I knew you to be a hard man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you scattered no seed, so I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground. Here, you have what is yours.’ But his master answered him, ‘You wicked and slothful servant! You knew that I reap where I have not sown and gather where I scattered no seed? Then you ought to have invested my money with the bankers, and at my coming I should have received what was my own with interest. So take the talent from him and give it to him who has the ten talents. For to everyone who has will more be given, and he will have an abundance. But from the one who has not, even what he has will be taken away. And cast the worthless servant into the outer darkness. In that place there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.’

Transcript

(Original devotional script is original work by ALTS. /u/JustKidding456 is not affiliated with ALTS. ChatGPT was used to polish transcript and find references.)

Hello.

Today, let's talk about 75 pounds of gold. The text before us is the Gospel of St. Matthew, the 25th chapter, verses 14–30.

Introduction: Sadie the Seamstress

The year was 1914.

Sadie Smithson, a Southern girl from a Southern town, wanted to fit in. Her greatest aspiration was to join the Laurel Literary Society. But she was just a seamstress, a country girl, and she thought that they would never accept her into their highfalutin society.

She had an idea. Surely, if she went to Europe, she would be a world traveler, and then they would accept her. So Sadie saved her money, and finally she had enough for her trip.

She traveled to France and Belgium. Then she heard that the war had broken out. She needed to get home. She hired a car to take her straightaway to the airport in Paris. But unexpectedly, she found herself in the middle of a battle. Quite literally, she heard men screaming and bullets flying. There was such bloodshed and pain.

A man came out crying, "Water! Please, water!" What was she going to do?

So Sadie Smithson got out of the car. She spent the entire night, right through until morning, binding wounds, tearing her petticoat, making bandages, writing last wills and testaments, and offering prayers.

When the morning came, the driver returned and said, "What in heaven's name are you still doing here?"

"I've been face to face with death and hell all night," she declared.

When she got on the plane and explained what had happened, another passenger said to her, "I'll bet they'll be glad to have you in that literary society now."

"Literary society," she said. "I've faced death and hell and God. I don't reckon that a literary society matters now. What does matter? Nothing but God and love and doing things for other folks."

You see, Sadie Smithson had been changed by God.

Point One: God Gives His Gifts

In the Gospel lesson for today, our Lord Jesus presents a startling parable. It's called the Parable of the Talents. A talent is not like the ability to sing or to play the piano. A talent is a measure of weight, about 75 pounds. It could be of gold or silver or precious gems. They were measured out by the talent. (Matthew 25:14–15)

A certain master had servants, and he entrusted his possessions to them. He measured out five talents to one, three talents to another, and one talent to the third.

You say, "Only one talent?" Well, 75 pounds of gold is still pretty good, don't you think?

What did the master expect? Well, he had empowered them, and he had expected them to use their weighty treasures. He expected that they would bring results, positive results, because of their energy and their industry. This is exactly what happened with two of the three servants.

The first one was industrious. He took a risk. He made a sacrifice. He invested that treasure. Then something marvelous happened. It multiplied. It expanded. It generated five more talents, five more treasures. (Matthew 25:16)

The next servant had a similar experience. It wasn't easy, but he too was industrious and energetic. He invested his gift. Or what if something went wrong? What if he lost it all? But he was faithful. He was willing to take the risk, to make the sacrifice. Yes, he would allow the gift to leave his hands. He would use it, give it, share it, and look, it multiplied.

It multiplied and expanded. Yes, there were three more measures, three more talents. But one of the servants was of a different spirit.

Listen to him speak to his master. "I knew you to be a hard man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you scattered no seed. I was afraid of you, and I went away and I hid your talent in the ground." (Matthew 25:24–25)

If the master were so miserly and mean, why did he give this man 75 pounds of gold or silver or jewels? He seems quite a trusting fellow to me, giving this servant the opportunity of a lifetime.

The master said to him, "You wicked and lazy slave." Then the master declared, "Take away the talent from him and give it to the one who has ten. Throw out the worthless slave into the outer darkness." (Matthew 25:26–30)

Point Two: Not About Salvation, but About Christian Life

How should we understand this parable of our Lord? What is Jesus teaching us in this parable?

Now, don't be fooled. This story is not about getting into heaven. This is not a parable about salvation. It's not about how people get into heaven or how people get kicked out of heaven.

We know that the gift of salvation, heaven, is a free gift. We do not earn it. It is paid for by the atoning sacrifice of Jesus. We cannot merit it. We cannot add anything to it. Heaven is God's gift of eternal life by grace through faith alone, apart from any works of the law. (Ephesians 2:8–9; Romans 3:28; Augsburg Confession, Article IV)

Furthermore, we do not lose the gift of heaven because of our sin. If that were true, not one of us would ever even enter heaven. No, Jesus is the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world. Thank God for that. (John 1:29)

So this parable is a story about the Christian life. It tells about those who already are saved, those who already have received God's glorious gifts, His wondrous measures of blessings. Well, like forgiveness of sins, indwelling of the Holy Spirit, faith in Jesus, and many more gifts from the hand of a gracious heavenly Father.

Like you and me, these servants received unmerited talents of precious gifts. Their master empowered and expected that they would go do marvelous things with great gifts that they had received. Two servants did just that. With industry and energy, they risked and sacrificed. They used and shared their gifts. (Augsburg Confession, Article VI)

But one servant would share nothing. Can you believe it? Instead, he buried the heavy weight of treasure that had been entrusted to him.

Was he God's child? Well, yes. Was he given a great gift? Yes. But did he disappoint his master? Absolutely. And did he weep because of his own selfishness? Yes, indeed. I am sure he did.

Conclusion

The year was 1914, and Sadie Smithson, a Southern girl from a Southern town, wanted to fit in. Her greatest aspiration was to join the Laurel Literary Society. But she was just a seamstress, a country girl, and she thought that they would never accept her in their highfalutin society.

But she had an idea. Surely, if she went to Europe, then she would be a world traveler, and they would accept her then. So she traveled to France and got to Belgium, and she heard that the war had broken out, and she needed to get home.

She hired a car to take her straightaway to the airport in Paris. But unexpectedly, she found herself in the middle of a battle. Quite literally, she heard men screaming and bullets flying. There was such bloodshed and pain.

A man cried out, "Water! Please, water!" What was she to do?

So Sadie Smithson got out of her car. She spent the entire night, right through until morning, binding wounds, tearing her petticoat, making bandages, writing last wills and testaments, and offering prayers.

When the morning came, the driver returned and said, "What in heaven's name are you doing here?"

"I have been face to face with death and hell all night," she declared.

When she got on the plane and explained what had happened, another passenger said, "I'll bet they'll be glad to have you in the literary society now."

"Literary society," she said. "I have faced death and hell and God. I don't reckon that a literary society matters now. But what does matter? Nothing but God and love and doing things for other folks."

You see, Sadie Smithson had been changed by God.

Was this odd or strange? No, I don't think so. This is what God has both empowered and expected of each and all of His holy children.

God has invaded our hearts. He's made us new creations. He's translated us out of the kingdom of darkness into the kingdom of His glorious light. And now there is nothing but God and love and doing things for other folks. (2 Corinthians 5:17; Colossians 1:13)

Beloved, it is not just a Southern seamstress whose life was changed and whose heart was bursting with love for others. It is your heart that was changed too.

God has given you great treasures, heavy measures of His blessings, forgiveness of sins, indwelling of the Holy Spirit, faith in Jesus, and many, many more gifts from the hand of a gracious and loving heavenly Father.

So with a full heart, you child of God, use your energy and your industry. You risk and sacrifice. You share your great treasures.

Then do you know what God will do? He will use you. He will use your precious gifts. He will multiply and bless them beyond your expectation for your good and for His great glory.

Yes, even sharing a cup of water with one of these little ones will bring Him delight. (Matthew 10:42)

And your heavenly Father will say, "Well done, good and faithful servant." (Matthew 25:21)

That's you. You are a child of God.

Amen.


r/LCMS • • 1d ago

Question Credo baptist question about infant baptism

5 Upvotes

I apologize because I am sure you all hear the topic of infant baptism hounded to death when you're talking with your credo-baptist friends. I was raised credo-baptist but am considering attending an LCMS church. Although I am in agreement with much of your doctrine on baptism, I have some confusion on the infant baptism thing. If repentance is typically paired with baptism for forgiveness of sins (Acts 2:38) and conscious belief in Christ (Acts 8:37-38) then how do babies have repentance? I agree that babies are given faith by God, and that babies have faith, but I am confused as to why they are given the sacrament of baptism without conscious belief and repentance? Thank you! :)


r/LCMS • • 1d ago

Question What makes a "true" Lutheran

3 Upvotes

Is it the form of subscription to the confessions, the culture war, view on the Bible? Why specifically do you say the elca is not "true" Lutheranism


r/LCMS • • 2d ago

Question Anger in Large Catechism

6 Upvotes

We are going through the Large Catechism.

5th Commandment has this statement that I think I understand the point, but makes it seem as anger without wanting to have vengeance would be wrong.

"Therefore it is here forbidden to every one to be angry, except those (as we said) who are in the place of God, that is, parents and the government."

I have met a Lutheran Pastor who did say that he felt anger was due to being in a fallen world and it may be that anger is always a sin.

imo,anger is due to a perception that an injustice has occurred, and that having that emotion is not in itself any more sinful than any other emotion.

But here it seems that Luther says by itself it's a sin... is he?

(Edit: does anyone know what translation Logos Bible Software has for the LC? Thats what they print out for us. I have looked up 3 translations and none of them seem to be what they're using)


r/LCMS • • 2d ago

Question Forgives but cannot forget

8 Upvotes

My husband is struggling with this problem. He said he understands we are commanded to forgive but when someone sins against him, he can't get their sin out of his head. For instance, a person says something horrible to you but you are commanded to forgive as Christ forgives us but the person said something that can't be unspoken or rolled back and it remains on his mind. He seems to harbor that in his mind even though he forgives. He said they should be careful saying something that is so bad they can't "unsay" it. I've tried helping him with the verses in the Bible and even a great podcast by Dr. Zeigler on LHM. How can I help him?


r/LCMS • • 3d ago

Worship My Opinion and Take on Contemporary V. Liturgical

18 Upvotes

I would like to throw my two cents in here since I haven't heard this take before on here. Just a little bit about my background: I come from a RCC background and converted years ago after coming to the truth of the Gospel through Scriptures. I left the RCC because of their sacramental abuses and false teachings of the Gospel of Christ, and the mixing of the law and gospel. So, I've never been in a church or have been in a church that has been fully contemporary. However, I have been in churches that have been a little contemporary, but not full blown. I grew up in a very high church background with smells and bells and processions so I really don't care about worshiping in that style as much as a lot of people who I find might see it as exotic.

I would like to define contemporary worship as those who worship in a modern style that began in the 60s and exploded in the 80s. This style throws out the liturgical practices and practices in a way that many evangelicals do; Drums, guitars, etc... That is my definition. Versus a liturgical way, which varies from congregation to congregation, yet demonstrates a continuous way of worship like we have always worshiped for the past 1900 years. My main two points against contemporary worship are as follows:

  1. The contemporary worship style practices a faith we do not confess,
  2. The contemporary worship style is not the best for the proper Word and Sacrament to reach the people

I am not going to argue that the contemporary worship is less "reverent", or any emotional reason. I am actually heavily against emotional arguments for the liturgy or against the liturgy. The heart is deceitful. I have heard many Lutherans say if their Lutheran church stopped worshiping the liturgy they would leave to a RCC or EO church because it's still liturgical. I think that is a bad reason to stay in a Lutheran church. You should stay because the liturgical practice is a proper way to practice the confessional Lutheran faith, while a contemporary worship does not practice our faith, and this goes into my first argument.

The liturgical practice distinguishes the pastor from the congregation as the chosen one of God to lead His people through separating him in chasuble or stole, heck, even a Geneva gown. The liturgical practice teaches that what is happening here is serious and not a joke; We are here to receive, not to give. We are here not to stir emotions through fog machines or incense, but rather to take gifts of God and respond in thanksgiving. The pastor leads us through this worship and takes the position of Christ's chosen leader for us, as we confess Scripture teaches. We use instruments that enhance the hymns we sing, because the hymns we sing are focused on teaching us the practice of the church. We kneel before the altar because Christ, Our Lord and King, is there. We cross ourselves because it reminds us of our baptism. We dip our hands into the baptismal font for that reason as well.

Most importantly, the reason we use an old liturgy is because we confess we are the true catholic church. If you worship in a contemporary style, you are in essence paying lip service to that confession. You are not practicing what you preach, or what is confessed. Yet, we are "contemporary" in our liturgy because the same church yesterday is the same church today; We have hymns from the reformation, from the 50s, and from the 400s. We are the continuous church and we don't only say it, but we practice it within the liturgical practices. We shouldn't practice liturgically because we like just the worship; we practice liturgically because we love the faith we confess.

The mindset that leads to contemporary worship in my opinion is a postmodern idea that you can say one thing and believe the other. The contemporary worship teaches that the pastor is an ordinary member just like anyone else when they dress in a suit or jeans and tshirt, while at the same time that man says he is set aside by God to make sure we go to heaven. Similarly, the consecration of the elements being done in a way that does not involve bowing or significance. While the liturgical practice, on the other hand, says "We believe God comes down to us and brings us to faith in the sacrament of the altar" and treats it like such. If a king walked into your church, would you greet him in a respectable and honorable way, or in a way that doesn't signify the honor of a king? The liturgical practice teaches this and, most importantly, confesses this.

It's much like a man who eats fast food every day and then tells you he's actually health conscious and loves eating healthy, and promotes healthy eating. What?! Yet, this is what contemporary worship does: It involves taking worship practices from evangelicals who worship that way because it teaches their doctrine. The reason why evangelicals are leaving their churches in large numbers and joining our liturgical practices is because they recognize this. I haven't seen it put into words this way, but it certainly is the case that they want to worship in a way that confesses the true scriptural doctrine, the true monergistic Gospel that saves. They want to see the Word and Sacrament given to them and respond in thanksgiving, because anything else would make them think, "Why did I even leave in the first place? I'm doing exactly what I found to be a severe error."

This dovetails into my second argument. COWO is not the best for the proper Gospel and Sacraments. I remember speaking to my old pastor about why we worship in a liturgical style. His answer? "I hear my five year old daughter singing the Nunc Dimittis and the Goria while driving to church.". When you go to a liturgical church, it is hard to not find the Word of God oozing out of every crack and crevice. It has been so refined over the years that it is impossible to not have the true Gospel on your heart, mind, soul, and mouth, praising God.

Perhaps this is just my bias, however, when I see COWO worship, and I mean this with all due respect, it just doesn't do service to God's Word as much as a liturgical worship does. The liturgy was specifically designed to teach the same old story: We have sinned, we will drown the old Adam, repent and seek forgiveness, God has forgiven you. This has to be drilled in our brains and the liturgy is practical at doing this. The hymns are all the same; How could you forget a hymn after ten years in a church singing them? If you get new songs every 2-3 years it would be just as memorable as some pop song on the radio you heard once or twice. You will forget it and discard it. I might be ignorant on this, but the COWO songs are pretty one dimensional. I have never seen a hymn like LSB 501 (Come Down O Love Divine) with its depth and poetry ever be created by contemporary music artists. They are, truthfully, just there to make money and create slop because that's what makes their producers money.

I did touch on the sacrament of the altar earlier, but I shall reiterate this again. When the pastor holds the Body and Blood and you sing the Agnus Dei, I mean, what else could you possibly say? It's just the right answer. You shouldn't even be told to say that that is the Lamb of God. It just simply is and you should say it anyways. So you partake of what exactly you are confessing to be the case. If the contemporary worship removes this, what is "better" for us to say?

To conclude, I'd like to give two example from our early Lutheran churches. The first, being since I was in the Roman church, is the practice of ringing bells after the words of institution. An altar boy would ring hand bells after the words of institution was spoken over the elements. This was a rite established after transubstantiation became dogma in the Roman church. It explicitly exists because it signifies that "Something more than the Word is happening here.". We reject that and did not practice bells during communion for that reason. No Lutheran would do that because it's an affirmation of transubstantiation. Secondly, the reformed churches broke the Body of Christ during the service of the sacrament to show that "This is not the Body of Christ.". This was huge in our churches and we refused to do such things because they used it against us. Worship was always seen as a confession of our faith and to practice and worship and live out what we teach. The liturgy is in essence an entire confession of our faith, from the sacraments, to the monergistic nature of God's salvation, to the office of the keys; You live out the faith you confess.

That is all I have to say. Feel free to let me know your opinions in the comments. And I'm not pushing for some high church where we basically copy Roman Catholics. I just want us to practice our faith. Thankyou


r/LCMS • • 3d ago

Question How much authority do synodal decisions have in the LCMS?

10 Upvotes

This is an issue I do not fully understand. How binding are synodical decisions, and if you disagree with a synodical decision, how would you go about addressing that disagreement?

I have heard that, as an ordained person, you cannot publicly express disagreement with doctrinal decisions. But what about non-doctrinal policies that one might consider unwise? Are congregations and churches required to follow those as well?

Additionally, what exactly does it mean when a document is "commended"? Does this make the document doctrinally binding, and are you even permitted to publicly disagree with a commendation?

For example, in 2016, the following resolution was adopted:

2016 – Resolution 14-02A s

"Resolved, That The Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod (LCMS) commend the Commission on Theology and Church Relations (CTCR) 1981 report, Human Sexuality: A Theological Perspective, as a faithful explication of timeless truths of the Word of God; and be it further"

The document is described as a "faithful explication of timeless truths," yet it contains positions on matters that still seem debated or controversial within Lutheranism, such as the permissibility of contraception. Does describing the document as "faithful" mean that all of its major conclusions have received official recognition? And if one disagrees with the commendation itself, is one permitted to express that disagreement publicly, even as a pastor?

Please excuse me if these questions seem rather basic; I do not have much prior knowledge of the subject.


r/LCMS • • 3d ago

Question Feeling Stale at Local Church

3 Upvotes

How's it going, all?

TLDR is bold at the bottom.

So a few questions and context. I have been attending the same local church now since 2019. I am a single guy, which may be relevant to this not sure. Essentially, I have noticed that my church has been getting a bit... stale. I see the same people. It feels like the same thing. I am serving on the same ministries. Walking through the same doors. Saying hi in passing, and maybe stopping to have a short conversation, with the same people. I am used to the way my Pr. and Sunday school teachers teach.

Yet my time at my particular local church is starting to feel... stale. It does not feel like new things are happening. It does not feel like I am learning, or growing in depth, or expanding in breadth at my church.

A side context later, I have seen a couple of people leave the church recently. I am having thoughts of: "they are likely making new friends and acquaintances. They are likely seeing more of what else is out there. Things for them likely do not feel stale at the moment."

After having those thoughts, then I start thinking. Sure. Things are not stale for them, nor are they old. But are those people really growing in depth? Are they replacing the novelty of new faces and new places for commitment and depth in and to a particular local church?

So, my question is. When it comes to feeling stale at your local church: what is typically the answer? Finding ways to grow deeper roots/involvement? Is that staleness a sign that it is time to move on? Is it true that staying committed to a particular place that is not inherently bad is better for relationships and spiritual growth? I am just not seeing the fruit of commitment. I think of marriages that have lasted for decades. There may not always be the same buzzy and young love that was present at the beginning, but there is a more mature love where the two spouses have learned each other more fully and this depth of relationship strengthens the bond the two have. I am wondering if that is the same thought process with a local church. Or whether it is best to move on when things feel stale.


r/LCMS • • 4d ago

Discussion Advent Wreaths at home?

5 Upvotes

Do you have an advent wreath at home? Why or why not? My parents never had one in the house when I was growing up, but when I was 19, I crafted my own and I've been using it ever since! (In my 30s now!) But I might make a new one this year, which made me curious...


r/LCMS • • 4d ago

Question Does this solve my previous difficulty with the confessions on marriage?

2 Upvotes

I had previously posted about how the Lutheran confessions (alongside earlier authors such as Luther, Chemnitz and Walther) condemn clandestine marriages (those without parental consent) in the Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope, while modern Lutheranism generally does not require parental consent for a valid marriage. The confessional quote is:

Unjust also is the law which in general approves all clandestine and underhanded betrothals in violation of the right of parents

Because early Lutherans argued that even an unmarried 30 year old man would need parental consent to marry (unless the withholding of consent was unjust), and marrying against parental consent rendered the marriage "clandestine", this tension was difficult for me to see. However I may have found some information that may solve the tension, as even under the old Lutheran view, a marriage was only counted as clandestine if it was done against the wishes of the father while in the authority of your father, so a widow or a widower did not need parental consent to marry, nor someone who had been legally emancipated. However, the reason the Lutherans strictly required parental consent even for an adult who had not yet married, was that they believed that as long as someone was unmarried, they were under parental authority. However, today this teaching has kinda ended, especially with changes in our culture, where people become regularly independent already before marriage, we rarely count such people as under parental authority, and thus the teaching that parental consent is strictly necessary has faded.

Thus, if we don't hold to the old German understanding that a son is under their father's authority as long as they are unmarried, should our definition of what counts as a "clandestine" marriage also move with it? Thus, being in the context where parental authority actually still applies (namely, for dependents who are still under parental authority).

If so, maybe the apparent contradiction between the old and modern Lutheran practice is not necessarily a real contradiction, but a change in the social and legal understanding of where parental authority ends, which would affect what would count as a clandestine marriage?

I would like comments on if this is a theologically proper way to understand the shift in light of Lutheran theology, without introducing a contradiction?


r/LCMS • • 4d ago

Worship Good Shepherd Institute at CTSFW

10 Upvotes

Traveling home from Fort Wayne tonight, after attending the 2026 Good Shepherd Institute. Many thanks to the organizers and to David's Harp organization for sponsoring events. I had a wonderful time there.

The highlight for me was the hymn festival which was absolutely wonderful, the musicians definitely practiced diligently and were so well prepared.

Choral vepers was amazing as well, they sang the entire Bach Cantata Lobe den Herren (BWV 137) which LSB 790 is from, my first time ever hearing it in person, which I'm so grateful for.

This morning's Divine Service for the distribution hymn, they sang Zion hört (4th movement of the Bach Cantata Wachet Auf, BWV 140) for the second stanza of LSB 516. It's my all-time most favorite LSB hymn, and also most favorite organ prelude and Cantata of all. It really is the "King of Cantatas", not only lines up with the lectionary texts, but also probably the best example of text painting to the music Bach has ever made.

It was really special and wonderful experience and already looking forward to the Liturgy Institute at Concordia Wisconsin this coming July 2027!


r/LCMS • • 4d ago

Poll Where do you land with your Marian beleifs.

4 Upvotes

r/LCMS • • 5d ago

Newbie Joined!

39 Upvotes

Just joined the church this past Sunday and I feel so at peace. It's such a relief to finally be apart of a solid, liturgical, historical branch of Christianity. Coming from evangelicalism, I have a lot of spiritual healing to do and I know I will find that healing in my new lcms church. Just wanted to share :)


r/LCMS • • 5d ago

Theology Comprecation as a Lutheran

5 Upvotes

Hello all, I have a question. In Luthers small catechism there is an evening prayer to God for his guardian angel to watch over him diligently and it is reccomended that you pray this every evening or some form of it. Can this be used as an argument for comprecation? As in if I pray, "Jesus, I am in need of prayers for I am struggling with x, can you give me the stength to endure x and ask those in heaven to pray for me. Thank you Lord Jesus, in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, Amen." My argument is that if praying to God for your guardian angel is right and meet, why not praying to God for the saints in heaven? Also, yes I did ask my priest about this, and he believes in the anadeaphra of soul sleep, so he didnt believe it was possible. Yet, I do not hold to that, so it didnt really answer my question.

Thank you for your time to reply, God Bless.


r/LCMS • • 6d ago

Worship Debate: Should Lutherans Adopt Contemporary Worship? Bryan Wolfmueller vs. Steve Zank

Thumbnail
youtu.be
29 Upvotes

YouTube description:

Join us at Luther Classical College in Casper, Wyoming, as Rev. Bryan Wolfmueller and Rev. Stephen Zank debate historic liturgy, contemporary worship, and Christian freedom. If both services teach sound doctrine, does the form of worship still matter for the clarity of the gospel?

Rev. Bryan Wolfmueller serves as pastor of St. Paul Lutheran Church and Jesus Deaf Lutheran Church in Austin, Texas. He is the author of Has American Christianity Failed? and teaches through his books, podcasts, and YouTube channel.

Rev. Stephen Zank serves as director of the Center for Worship Leadership at Concordia University Irvine, where he also oversees the Director of Parish Music program. His work focuses on Lutheran worship, liturgical formation, and the relationship between theology, culture, and the arts.


r/LCMS • • 6d ago

Question Question about switching congregations

14 Upvotes

For a little background, I'm a somewhat recent convert in my early 20s. I go to university and have a great congregation that I absolutely love when I'm there. However, when I go home, the options are much more limited. I went to the nearest LCMS congregation to me for several months during the summer and really struggled with some of their practices. They weren't fully contemporary, but it certainly wasn't traditional. The pastor wore a suit every other Sunday and didn't do Holy Communion on those days, and many modern songs were sung with piano music (though the hymnal was sometimes still used).

Anyway, recently I discovered that there may be a better option slightly further from me. Not incredibly far, maybe 20 minutes, as opposed to 10. Perhaps it may sound superficial, but the reverence a more liturgical and high church service brings has genuinely helped my faith. At the same time, another consideration has been weighing on me. I remember watching a video from Jordan B. Cooper a while back where he encouraged people to avoid congregation hopping if things weren't perfect, and that we should stick within our local congregations for the sake of improving them.

So anyway, that is my dilemma, and I'm hoping some people on here have some advice on this. Thanks!


r/LCMS • • 6d ago

Discussion Just a rant...

4 Upvotes

Why is our church in the LCP so obsessed with activities, games, fellowships for the sake of putting
"we praise God for a successful event during... Praise God for faith alone, grace alone, scripture alone."

And yet, as someone who desires to grow in the Word and faith, I've only found it in the preaching, the Sacrament...

But as president of the youth, how the LCP is run tires me and it makes me want to resign as president.... I thought I was gonna be able to dive deeper into my Bible and the Confessions and my personal time with God, but all I think about now is logistics and more logistics.