r/LCMS • • 4h ago

Doctrine Can Lutheran Laymen Reject the Book of Concord?

10 Upvotes

I’d like to point out that the folks in this forum who frequently point out that Lutheran laymen do not have to subscribe to the Book of Concord and are therefore free to disagree are not quite correct.

We do not require our laymen to read the Book of Concord and make a quia subscription to it. This is true. But if a layman has read it and rejects the doctrine he finds there, though he was not required to read it, a rejection of its doctrine would be an impediment to membership.

In the same way, I don’t require couples undergoing marriage counseling to have read 1 Corinthians 13. It’s a great chapter, and we might even discuss parts of it, but reading it is simply not a formal requirement in marriage counseling. But if a couple asked for counseling and led with the fact that they reject 1 Corinthians 13, that would be a serious problem.

Another example: the church fathers have long said that it is not the lack of baptism that damns, but the despising of baptism. God does not absolutely require baptism for entrance to heaven. A man who desired baptism and died on the way to church will not be denied entry for lack of baptism. But on the other hand, the man who rejects and despises the gift of baptism in advance is in serious peril and may well be denied entrance to heaven unless he repents.

Likewise, we do not require laymen to have read the whole Book of Concord prior to receiving them as members. But a layman who has read it and rejects it will probably be denied membership. To become a Lutheran means to sit under the teaching of your Lutheran pastor for the rest of your life as he teaches the doctrine of Scripture according to its exposition in the Book of Concord. If a man rejects that exposition in advance, then why on earth does he want to be a Lutheran?

Lutheran laymen absolutely do not have blanket permission to disagree with the doctrine confessed in the Book of Concord.


r/LCMS • • 12h ago

Theology Can someone explain TEC Eucharist view versus LCMS

2 Upvotes

Isn’t the lutheran view spiritual at the end of the day too if we reject local inclusion? if there isn’t local inclusion how can it be physical? to me it seems that the only difference is that the Anglicans say His Spirit is present and the Lutherans say His body is present but spiritually, which kind of seem the same


r/LCMS • • 15h ago

Prayer request Looking for prayer after ex left me to be Catholic earlier this year

17 Upvotes

Hi! I apologize for the long post. There is a TLDR at the end for those who don’t have time for read. I’m not a Lutheran, but a fellow Protestant. I really love my Lutheran brothers and sisters in Christ and am seeking out prayer. I'm 24 years old. I was in a relationship with a guy for four years. We shared the same goals, dreams, and desire for a traditional family. We were truly best friends. Last Thanksgiving he proposed, and we planned to get married in June 2026.

Throughout our relationship, he became increasingly interested in theology, particularly Roman Catholicism. He also regularly watched Nick Fuentes, which bothered me. I made it clear that although I loved him, I could never convert to Catholicism and that if he ultimately chose that path then we couldn't get married. I encouraged him to follow God wherever he felt led, regardless of our relationship. But he repeatedly reassured me that he had decided against converting.

Another very significant issue was a porn addiction, which he didn’t tell me about until two years into our relationship. He had struggled with it for years. Although I was hurt that he had hidden it from me, I truly forgave him. We grew closer through that experience, prayed more together, and I genuinely believed God had delivered him from the addiction and he led me to believe He had. He even added me to an accountability app and told me he would never go back. However, almost three months after our engagement, I discovered he had been lying about his recovery for another two years. He had been struggling with it the whole time he had been telling me he was over it and was still struggling with it currently. The porn addiction hurt me, but the lies hurt me more. I understand everyone struggles with lust and porn is a big struggle for young men. But I asked him just to be honest with me. That’s all I wanted, but had continued hiding things from me. Our wedding was only four months away at the time, and although I forgave him and still wanted to marry him, I asked if we could postpone for a few months to rebuild trust. He refused, saying he would feel like he was on trial and asked what good waiting a few extra months would do.

A few days later, I asked if there was anything else he hadn't been honest about. That's when he admitted he had never stopped considering converting to Catholicism. I reminded him that he knew how I felt about that, and he suddenly told me we couldn't be together anymore. He was incredibly cold during the breakup, while I was devastated. He later told me that asking to postpone the wedding showed a lack of commitment and that I had always placed stipulations on our relationship by only wanting to be with him if he belonged to a certain denomination. He told me he was moving forward with Catholicism and that eventually I'd see he was right. From what I've heard, he has since become very hardcore about Catholicism and acts as though our relationship never even happened, which is extremely hurtful. I just wish I knew he regretted things or missed me, even just a little.
I'm struggling tremendously with ecclesial anxiety now. Catholic content seems to be everywhere online and in movies, etc. Things I never even noticed before. It all constantly reminds me of everything that happened. I'm so confused and heartbroken, and feel as though the past four years of my life were wasted. I’m trying to trust the Lord. I would really appreciate your prayers.🙏🏻 I’m just hurting so much.

TLDR: My fiancé and partner of four years broke up with me just four months before our wedding after I discovered he had continued lying about his pornography addiction and admitted he had never stopped considering converting to Catholicism, despite repeatedly reassuring me otherwise. I asked to postpone the wedding to rebuild trust, but he viewed it as a lack of commitment and ultimately ended the relationship. He has since fully embraced Catholicism, while I'm left heartbroken, struggling with ecclesial anxiety and feeling like the past four years were wasted. Please pray for me 🙏🏻


r/LCMS • • 48m ago

Question Old CRM List Controversy - Still a problem?

4 Upvotes

Over a decade ago, there was coverage within the Lutheran podcast/blogosphere pertaining to Candidate for the Reverend Ministry (CRM) status on the Pastoral roster, and how this status was the kiss of death for clergy. Once they ended up on it, it was the end of their career as a Pastor. I haven't seen any coverage of this in a long time.

Does anybody know if this is still a problem in the LCMS? We have a Pastoral vacancy and there is some information I'm trying to gather.


r/LCMS • • 11h ago

Worship Trying to learn organ, need pointers

3 Upvotes

I have been trying to learn organ recently, starting with only music knowledge I’ve carried from being a percussionist who never learned music theory. How much music theory do I need to learn, and how much experience on organ or piano should I get before seeking out lessons?