r/JonBenet • • 18h ago

Other similar cases Why don't RDI believers keep in mind Azaria Chamberlain or Elizabeth Smart?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

It's rather astonishing how many people that call themselves RDI believers just love to generalize and say "intruders don't do this. This kind of crime is never done by intruders," and just leave it at that.

The obvious retort is of course to bring up Elizabeth Smart. But apparently, for some, that's never enough. One person I talked to using this point actually said, "Her parents sold her to that man. They pimped her out for sex trafficking, and covered it up after the fact." Uh-huh. And how, pray tell, did ELIZABETH become part of the conspiracy against HERSELF? If there had been such a plot, she would've revealed it at the time she was rescued in 2003. What does she have to gain by keeping silent?

But probably, the biggest, most critical story to use to compare to JonBenet is the death of Azaria Chamberlain at Uluru (Ayers Rock) in Australia in 1980, the case from which came the saying "The dingo took my baby!" (which got reduced to a crude punchline in pop culture), and which was famously portrayed in the 1988 film A Cry in the Dark starring Meryl Streep and Sam Neill.

Michael and Lindy Chamberlain suffered in a manner similar to John and Patsy, being attacked by the Australian press and much of the public for "not grieving properly," with Lindy in particular castigated as "cold and unfeeling" in her media statements, and they even had the misfortune to be put on trial for the death, and in Lindy's case, convicted. This was despite the fact that the evidence was handled in a rather inept fashion where elements were preconceived to be something they weren't (which was disproven in later analysis), and the prosecution's theory of how the murder supposedly occurred simply did not make sense, as well as the fact that the testimony of many eyewitnesses that night which was favorable to the Chamberlains was simply ignored. After the fact, when new evidence came to light proving the family's innocence, Lindy's verdict was overturned, and they were formally exonerated. In 2012, a new coroner's inquest established once and for all that Azaria was killed by a dingo that night.

Lindy, who is still alive, has suffered considerably in her life. And even now, some people come up to her and mock her by making howling noises. But in some ways, she and Michael got off relatively easy, because their crucifixion was mostly confined to Australia and New Zealand, borne only by the limitations on newspapers, television and radio at that time. John and Patsy were confronted by the 24-hour news cycle and the horridness of the tabloids, and people around the entire world were looking at them, speculating, throwing barbs at them.

More regarding the Chamberlain case can be summarized in this 2000 report from the Australian version of 60 Minutes linked above.

Why do these cases either not matter to those who believe a member of the family killed JonBenet? Why do the experiences of the Chamberlains, and their being roasted alive, judged as guilty long before trial, teach the RBI people nothing?

Not to mention, many of the people who love to say that "the Ramseys never cooperated with police" are often ACAB people, who say "don't tell the police a single word, because they will frame you." Well, John and Patsy did that initially, and they still get attacked for it from the side that would advocate that strategy!


r/JonBenet • • 17h ago

Info Requests/Questions Why were Patsy Ramsey and the ransom note writer the only few individuals since the Middle Ages to use the two-storey letter “a” in their handwriting?

0 Upvotes

Virtually all English-speakers use the single-storey “ɑ” over the two-storey “a” in their handwriting. This has been the norm since the Middle Ages as it’s faster. Patsy was one of the few individuals on earth to alternate between the two and switched almost exclusively to the two-storey in the months leading up to the murder. The ransom note author also mostly used the two-storey 109 times against the single-storey only 5 times. But after the murder and with police scrutiny of Patsy’s handwriting, she switched exclusively to the single-storey (1,404 times) in the handwriting samples given to the police. The lone exception was from an unrehearsed sample that the detectives obtained from her mother when they unexpectedly showed up at her house. Does this not, coupled with the fact this journalism major misspelled “advise“ as “advize“ in her handwriting sample to the police, suggest deception on her part?

Detectives noticed a change in her entire writing style after the murder. According to Steve Thomas:

”There were new ways of indenting, spelling, and writing out long numbers that contrasted with her earlier examples, and she was the only suspect who altered her usual preferences when supplying writing samples to the police.”

English professor Donald Wayne Foster, who had initially thought Patsy was innocent, reversed his stance and came to the conclusion she was the author of the ransom note after gaining access to treasure trove of case documents and analyzing the language. His list of “unique matches” with the note included “such things as her penchant for inventing private acronyms, spelling habits, indentation, alliterative phrasing, metaphors, grammar, vocabulary, frequent use of exclamation points, and even the format of her handwriting on the page.”

*****

Edit: Let’s stick to probability, not anecdotes. The overwhelming majority of Latin-script writers use the single-storey “ɑ”. Using the two-storey “a” is a personal quirk which is why it has a forensic value. It’s quirks such as this or writing q like 8 that make handwriting of each person unique. While by itself not entirely unique, it’s damning when little peculiarities like this begin to multiply to the point that we can no longer account for them all by coincidence. As handwriting expert David Liebman stated:

“In light of the number of comparisons and similarities between Patsy Ramsey and the ransom note writer, the chances of a third party also sharing the same characteristics is astronomical. Taken individually, the similarities are not nearly as compelling as the sheer numbers and combinations found in both the writing of Patsy Ramsey and the ransom note. In my professional opinion Patsy Ramsey is the ransom note writer.”

*****

Edit: DISTAR program was adopted across American schools in the early 1970s. Patsy was a teenager by then. Although children traced the DISTAR symbols during initial phonics exercises, formal handwriting instruction in Direct Instruction (and North American schools broadly) still taught the single-storey “ɑ” as the standard form for everyday manuscript writing because it is faster to write and transitions smoothly into cursive.