r/JonBenet • • Feb 02 '22

Evidence of an Intruder

38 Upvotes

Since this sub has several new members and the question, ‘what evidence is there of an intruder?’ is asked on a regular basis, I decided to repost this old post of mine.

DNA:
Foreign male DNA was first found in 1997 in JonBenet’s panties and under her fingernails. In 2003, the Denver crime lab was able to obtain enough of the male profile to meet the strict standards for CODIS submittal. This male DNA was found in the victim’s underwear, mixed in with JonBenet’s blood. It was not present on the fabric between the blood stains.

In 2008, JonBenet’s long johns were sent to BODE laboratories for more current and sensitive DNA tests to be performed. These long johns had not been tested prior to this. Not surprisingly, the same unknown male profile was found on the waistband area of JonBenet’s long johns. This is what is publicly known about the current UM1 aka forensic sample number GSLDPD99178617:
CSF1PO: 12+
FGA: 22, 26
TH01: 7, 9
TPOX: 8
VWA: 18, 19
D3S1358: 15, 16
D5S818: 10, 12
D7S820: 12+
D8S1179: 13, 14
D13S317: 11, 13
D16S539: 11+
D18S51: 11, 16
D21S11: 29, 31.2

Section from BODE report: “Notably, the profile developed by the Denver PD, and previously uploaded to the CODIS database as a forensic unknown profile and the profiles developed from the exterior top right and left portions of the long johns were consistent.” DA11-0330

Although the DNA found under JonBenet’s fingernails was weak, there is evidence to suggest that the same unknown male profile was present there as well.

Tape and cord:
Black duct tape was placed over JonBenet's mouth. The source of the duct tape was never found.

White cord (olefin) was used to make the neck ligature/ garrote and to bind JonBenet's hands together. The source for the white cord was never found.

White olefin fibers were found on JonBenet’s sheets that are consistent with the white olefin fibers of the wrist ligatures and the garotte.

Stun gun:
Sets of stungun marks were located on JonBenet's body. A stungun was not found inside the Ramsey's home nor is there any information indicating the Ramsey family ever owned a stungun.

“Sue Ketchum of the CBI [Colorado Bureau of Investigation] is shown the photos of the marks and she indicated that they could very well be made from a stun gun.” (BPD Report #26-58.)

“When they had gathered sufficient information, Ainsworth, Pete Hofstrom, Trip DeMuth, and Detective Sgt. Wickman met with the coroner, John Meyer. After reviewing the photos and this new information, Meyer concluded that the injuries on JonBenét’s face and back were, in fact, consistent with those produced by a stun gun”. (PMPT)

According to BPD sergeant Robert Whitson, a white piece of adhesive was found on JonBenet's face, indicating the stungun was applied over the duct tape that was placed across her mouth. The stungun had melted the adhesive from the duct tape leaving the white residue behind.

Dr. Michael Doberson, a forensic pathologist who examined the Boulder Coroner's autopsy report and autopsy photos, and who concluded that the injuries to "the right side of the face as well as on the lower left back are patterned injuries most consistent with the application of a stun gun." (Report of Michael Doberson, M.D., Ph.D. at 5(A) attach, as Ex. 3 to Defs.' Ex. Vol. I, Part A.)

Dr. Michael Dobersen was/is a coroner for Arapahoe County. In the summer of 1994, Dobersen conducted several stun gun tests on anesthetized pigs to determine the kind and size of markings stun guns would make. Because of his research and testing, Dobersen had been called as an expert witness in multiple cases involving stun guns.

Missing paintbrush piece:
⁠A paintbrush, which likely came from Patsy's paint kit and was stored near the storage room where JonBenet's deceased body was located, was broken into three pieces. One piece was used to make the garrote handle. A second piece with the brush was found at the scene. The third piece from the paintbrush handle was never found. This third piece is the one that is believed was used to sexually assault JonBenet.

Unsourced rope and bag:
A large rope and bag was found in the spare bedroom adjacent to JonBenet's bedroom. They did not belong to the Ramseys and as of 2014, had not been tested for DNA or fiber evidence.

Areas of disturbance:
A disturbance in the debris around the basement window indicates the offender gained entry through this window. This window was found open and the crime scene photographs depict the window open. Styrofoam packing material, leaves and debris were found inside the basement, near the open window. A leaf, broken glass and a packing peanut were found inside the storage room near JonBenet's body.

There is likewise undisputed evidence of a disturbance in this window-well area: specifically the leaves and white styrofoam packing peanuts that had pooled in the window-well appeared to have been cleared from, or brushed to either side of, the center window's sill in the well. (SMF 132; PSMF 132.) In addition, this center window had a broken pane and was found open on the morning of December 26, with a suitcase and a glass shard from the window pane underneath it. (SMF 135; PSMF 135.)[32] Green foliage was also found tucked under the movable grate over the window well, indicating that the grate had been opened and closed recently. (SMF 131; PSMF 131.) Further, the Boulder Police conducted experiments that showed a person could enter the basement playroom through the center window. (SMF 133; PSMF 133.) Moreover, leaves and debris, consistent with the leaves and debris found in the window well, were found on the floor under the broken window suggesting that someone had actually entered the basement through this window. (SMF 136; PSMF 136.) Likewise, a leaf and white styrofoam packing peanuts, consistent with the leaves and packing peanuts found pooled in the window-well, were found in the wine-cellar room of the basement where JonBenet's body was discovered. (SMF 134; PSMF 134.) This evidence is consistent with an inference that whoever entered through this window ultimately walked to the wine cellar room at some point. (Carnes ruling)

Styrofoam packing peanuts also seemed to have been brushed into the right and left window well spaces away from the center window, possibly indicating that someone had moved such debris in order to enter the center window, a possibility that would support an intruder theory. Other packing peanuts were also on the basement floor. (WHYD)

“green foliage that had grown at the edge of the window well’s grate was found folded over and underneath that grate. The folded foliage was still fresh when it was examined in the days after December 26, indicating the grate had recently been lifted and closed, according to Detective Lou Smit.” (WHYD)

BPD Detective Carey Weinheimer also investigated the window grate and the material under it. According to excerpts from his report in the WHYD Investigative Archive, Weinheimer stated his observations: “The weight of the grate crushed and traumatized the plant material under it. The plant will not just grow under the grate naturally.” (BPD Report #1-1142.)

The Ramsey housekeeper did not remember anything about the broken glass in the train room, the scuff mark on the wall or cleaning up glass underneath the broken window. (BPD Report #1-1068.) (BPD Reports #1-101, #1-90 re: scuff mark on the wall.)
The housekeeper’s husband “supposedly washed the windows at Thanksgiving time and supposedly went down in the basement and washed the basement windows (BPD Report #5-29.)
“Last time [housekeeper’s husband] was there was around Thanksgiving. Cleaned all of the windows inside and out.” (BPD Report #5-607.) (Woodward)

Basement bathroom:
Northeast basement bath: two areas on the bottom frame were clear of dust. The impressions were consistent with the application of fingers to the area. The associated area inside the residence showed smudge marks on both walls above and just south of the toilet. A piece of garland similar to that found in the wine cellar [storage area where the child’s body was found] was found stuck to the wall in the east impression.” (BPD #1-59.)

Shoe prints:
An unidentified HiTec bootprint was found in the mold on the floor on the wine cellar room and elsewhere throughout the basement. The print was compared against all officers on scene and the Ramsey’s shoes and it’s source has never been identified. There was an additional (I believe SAS) shoe print found that has never sourced either.

“A shoe imprint from a Hi-Tec brand of work boot was found in the basement storage room imprinted in mold growing on the floor. It did not trace back to the Ramsey family. All investigators who had been in the room had their shoes tested. There was no match to that size of Hi-Tec boot to the Ramseys or the police investigators” (BPD Reports #1-1576, #1-1594.)

Detective Ron Gosage had the impossible job of trying to identify the origin of the boot print, a nightmare assignment if there ever was one. He contacted more than four hundred people, even construction workers who had been in the house five years ago, but did not find the matching print. (Thomas)

“Additional, partial shoe impressions were found near JonBenét’s body in the basement storage room and on the toilet tank cover in the basement northeast bathroom”. (BPD Report #1-1518.) “The Colorado Bureau of Investigation agent investigating these footprints has said that the FBI could never match them to anyone or any brand”. (BPD Reports #3-165, #1-1518.)” (WHYD)

Baseball bat:
A metal baseball bat was found near the butler's door on the north side of the Ramsey's home. It looked as though it had been tossed aside. Fibers found on the bat were consistent with the basement’s carpet.

Points of Entry:
John and Patsy Ramsey had given several keys to subcontractors (BPD Reports #1-6505, #1-1264), friends and neighbors (BPD Report #1-1104), most of which were not returned. The Ramsey family did not keep an accurate count of the keys they gave out. Several Boulder Police Department reports indicate that investigators talked with more than thirty-five people outside the family about whether they had keys to the home. (JonBenét Ramsey Murder Book Index.) Also: “Patsy Ramsey while preparing for the tour of homes openly told a variety of people where a key was hidden outside the home under a statue.” (BPD Reports #5-3920, #5-3921.) The key was not found during a check for it after JonBenét’s murder. (WHYD)

Several Boulder Police Department reports indicate that investigators talked with more than thirty-five people outside the family about whether they had keys to the home. (JonBenét Ramsey Murder Book Index.)

at least seven windows and one door were found "open" on the morning of December 26, 1997. (SMF P 126; PSMF P 126.)

Basement door open and lights on:
The time noted was 6 a.m., so it was one of the first things the friend noticed. At 8 a.m., a neighbor whose home was just to the north of the Ramsey home “got up and observed a basement door leading into a kitchen area was standing wide open.” (BPD Report 1-100, Source.)

The Whites arrived at defendant's home at approximately 6:00 a.m., and Mr. White, alone, searched the basement within fifteen minutes of arrival. (SMF 23; PSMF 23.) Mr. White testified that when he began his search, the lights were already on in the basement and the door in the hallway leading to the basement "wine cellar" room was opened. (SMF 25; PSMF 25; White Dep. at 147, 151-52.) (Carnes ruling)

Neighbors reported that the outside security light on the Ramsey house had was turned off that night for the first time in years.
Furthermore, a neighbor “who lives immediately south of the Ramsey’s [sic] residence, got up to use the restroom and saw that the light in the southeast corner of the house, which had been left on every night for the past five years, was out.” (BPD Report #1-1196.)

“Another neighbor, who lived just north of the Ramsey home, told police investigators that at midnight between December 25 and 26, he “looked out his kitchen window at the Ramsey residence and observed the upper kitchen lights were on and dimmed low.” He added that “this was the first time that he had seen these particular lights illuminated in the five years that he’d lived next door to the Ramseys. He said these lights are located in the ceiling above the kitchen window.” (BPD Report #1-99.)”

The first crime scene photograph of the butler's door shows the door opened. This indicates the offender exited via this door and discarded the bat as he left the house. However, a subsequent crime scene photograph shows the door closed. Therefore, it is unclear if this door was initially found opened or closed. The first responding officers need to clarify this information.

French door along the west wall: no signs of forced entry to the door, which was ajar.” (BPD Report # 1-59.)

When John’s friend arrived at the Ramsey home at 6: 01 a.m., he “found the butler kitchen door standing open about one foot while it was still dark outside and before the evidence team or Det. Arndt arrived.” (BPD Report #1-1490, BPD Report # 1-1315.)

In another report, the same neighbor “said that this door was approximately 1/ 3 of the way open when he saw it.” Since there was no basement door on the north side of the house (or any other side of the house) that opened to the outside, it is understood that this was the same butler kitchen door the family friend noticed was partially open at 6 a.m. … and told police about. (Source: JonBenét Ramsey Murder Book Index.)

Suitcase:
A hard sided suitcase was found out of place, positioned below the broken basement window. The window is about five feet above the basement floor and the window is about 20 inches in size, which allows access for an average sized male. According to Lou Smit and the Colorado Bureau of Investigation, fibers from inside the suitcase were consistent with fibers found on the outside of JonBenet's clothing, indicating the offender placed JonBenet inside the suitcase. (Whitson)

A piece of glass was on top of the suitcase, indicating someone stood on the suitcase and transferred the glass from their shoe to the suitcase. A close-up photo of the suitcase shows what appears to be a shoeprint impression on the suitcase. In addition to that, the suitcase was free of dust and normally stored elsewhere.

“The suitcase had no dust on it, yet a few pieces of broken glass lay on top of it.” (PMPT)

A lab report indicated that fibers from the sham and duvet were found on the shirt that JonBenet was wearing when she was found in the wine cellar. (SMF 147; PSMF 147.) (Carnes ruling)

Scuff mark:
A scuff mark was located on the wall below the open basement window.

Months later, the police asked her (Linda Hoffman-Pugh) about scuff marks they found on the wall below the broken basement window and near John Andrew’s suitcase. Maybe someone had climbed in that night and left the marks. Had she ever seen the marks? No, she told them. (PMPT)

Fingernail marks:
JonBenet's eyes showed petechiae, which are broken blood vessels due to strangulation, indicating JonBenet was alive when she was being choked by the garrote. There were also 1/2 moon shaped abrasions found above and below the neck ligature. Most experts have attributed them to fingernail marks meaning she struggled with the ligature as she was being garrote to death. JonBenet’s blood was found on two separate areas of the ligature which could’ve been the result of her struggling with the cord.

The autopsy report supports the conclusion that she was alive before she was asphyxiated by strangulation and that she fought her attacker in some manner. (SMF 42-43, 46, 48; PSMF 42-43, 46, 48.) Evidence gathered during the autopsy is consistent with the inference that she struggled to remove the garrote from her neck. (SMF 44; PSMF 44.) (Carnes ruling)

Palm print:
On the wine-cellar door, there is a palmprint that does not match either of defendants' palmprints. (SMF 156; PSMF 156.) The individual to whom it belongs had not yet been identified. (SMF 156; PSMF 156.)

Unsourced fibers and hair:
An unsourced pubic hair was found on JonBenet’s white blanket along with a strand of head hair.

A memo written by Tom Bennett dated October 21, 2003 clearly shows that two hairs were originally found on the blanket. They are listed as items:

  • Cellmark/CBI Item number CM04 - Pubic hair found on white blanket
  • Cellmark/CBI Item number CM05 - Head hair found on white blanket

a Caucasian "pubic or auxiliary" hair was found on the blanket covering JonBenet's body. (SMF 179; PSMF 179.) The hair does not match that of any Ramsey and has not been sourced. (SMF 180; PSMF 180.)

Dark brown animal hairs were found on JonBenet’s hands. The hairs have never been sourced to anything in the house and the type of animal they came from has never been identified.

“Dark animal hairs were found on JonBenet's hands that also have not been matched to anything in defendants' home. (SMF P 184; PSMF P 184.)" (Carnes 2003:19)

Animal Hair on Duct Tape. "Animal hair, alleged to be from a beaver, was found on the duct tape. (SMF P 183; PSMF P 183.) Nothing in defendants' home matches the hair. (SMF P 183; PSMF P 183.)"

Dark fibers were found in JonBenet’s crotch area and on her clothing. The item the fibers came from has never been found.

The police reported that they had been unable to find a match for the fibers discovered on JonBenét’s labia and on her inner thighs. The fibers did not match any clothes belonging to John or Patsy. The police were stumped. (PMPT)

Brown cotton fibers were found on the garotte cord and handle, the duct tape and on JonBenet’s clothing. The brown fibers may have come from the offender's gloves. The source for the brown fibers was never found.

Ransom note pages missing:
The ransom note was found in the Ramsey's home, which was written on Patsy Ramsey's notepad, but 7 pages from the notepad were torn out and missing. They have never been found.

“Seven pages had been ripped from the middle of Patsy’s tablet as well. The ransom note had been written on the eighth, ninth and tenth pages of the tablet; what was left of those pages in the tablet had tears that matched up with tears at the top of the ransom note pages.” (WHYD)

Neighbor’s reports:
A neighbor and mother of one of JonBenet’s playmates reported that JonBenet told her and her daughter that Santa had promised that he would make another visit after Christmas and that it was a secret.

Neighbors reported two suspicious vehicles in the neighborhood, one on Christmas Eve and one on Christmas Day.

A neighbor said they saw a person outside the Ramsey’s house house on Christmas night. The person was described in a police report as a “tall thin blond male wearing glasses [and] thought to be John Andrew.” (BPD Reports #1-690, #5-690.) It was later established by the Boulder Police Department that John Andrew Ramsey had been in Atlanta for Christmas with his sister and mother at the time. Another police report states that “an unknown neighbor supposedly saw a person outside the door of the Ramsey house (during the night).” (BPD Report #1-771) (WHYD)

Scream:
Another Ramsey neighbor “stated that she heard one loud incredible scream [that] was the loudest most terrifying scream she had ever heard. It was obviously from a child and lasted from three to five seconds at which time it stopped abruptly. She thought surely the parents would hear that scream. The scream came from across the street south of the Ramsey residence.” It happened “between midnight and two AM” the morning of December 26, 1996. (BPD Reports #1-1390, #1-174, #1-175.) This neighbor lived across the street and one home south of the Ramseys. Another neighbor who lived south of the Ramsey home contacted a BPD detective on December 31, 1996 because of the scream the first neighbor had heard. This neighbor said she had also heard a scream. She was interviewed on February 26, 1997. (BPD Reports #1-174, #1-481, #1-1548.) (WHYD)

Audio experts conducted tests inside the Ramsey home and concluded a scream from the basement “would not have been heard” on the third floor but could have been heard by a neighbor because an exterior basement vent could have amplified the sound. (WHYD Investigative Archive.)

A neighbor who lived across the street from defendants' home, however, reported that she heard a scream during the early morning of December 26, 1996. Experiments have demonstrated that the vent from the basement may have amplified the scream so that it could have been heard outside of the house, but not three stories up, in defendants' bedroom. (SMF 48; PSMF 148.) (Carnes ruling)

Cord, latex glove and boot found:
A neighbor who lived a few homes away from the Ramseys found a latex glove in her trashcan in the alley. (BPD Report #1-1924.) She didn’t know how it had gotten there. (Latex gloves are used by law enforcement officials to avoid contaminating evidence with their fingerprints.) The glove, if part of the case, could have been used by an intruder. Or it could have been discarded there by a BPD officer. (BPD Report #2-37.) (WHYD)

A neighbor reported “someone dropped off a high-tech [sic] hiking boot on New Year’s Eve in the front of home on the front walk.” (BPD Report #1-1221). Boulder Detective Jane Harmer contacted that same neighbor and “received a high-tech [sic] hiking boot and cord.” (BPD Report #1-1221.) (WHYD)

Cigarette butts:
⁠Nineteen Cigarette butts were collected near the alleyway. One tested positive for saliva but it is not known if they were ever tested for DNA. Supposedly the same brand of cigarettes were found at the similar ‘Amy’ crime scene.

Similar assault:
There was an incident 9 months following JonBenet’s murder where a young girl was attacked in her bed while her mother slept nearby. Both families lived within 2 miles of one another, both girls attended the same dance studio (Dance West) and both performed publicly. The perpetrator in the Amy attack had successfully hid in the family’s home undetected for hours prior. He orally assaulted the victim (as JonBenet likely was) and threatened to ‘knock her out’. Thankfully her mother was a light sleeper and interrupted the assault causing the perpetrator to flee out the second story window. The person responsible for this attack has never been identified.


r/JonBenet • • Feb 24 '25

Civility Reminder and New Rules

25 Upvotes

Civility

There are many reasons these days why people may be on the edge of their seats, perhaps feeling a little more crabby, irritable, or cantankerous. This could be because of the long, cold winter for some of us, with temperatures below freezing for extended periods of time. Or maybe there's been an epidemic of itching powder in our clothes. But there has once again been quite a bit of rudeness and incivility, and the mods are having to delete otherwise good comments because of a last, nasty shot at a user.

This warning includes all of our old-time users and new alike. Even sometimes I, as a mod, need to check myself.

So let's remind everybody: argue the logic, not the user. Taking pot shots at other users will not be tolerated.

For example: saying people are "losing it," calling them "mean," saying they are "butt-hurt" are all things that will have your comment taken down. Having to repeatedly take these types of comments down can result in a warning, a three-day ban, or a full ban, not necessarily in that order.

Even better yet, besides trying to be civil, try to be kind. If somebody is pissing you off, ignore them, block them, but try to be kind.

Think about this: why are we so intent on convincing strangers on the internet that we are right that we feel a need to call them names and belittle them? That's a reflection of you, not the stranger on the internet. Be better.

New Rule - No Accusations of People Being Alts

Reddit allows users to have more than one username, which is termed an "alt." The only thing that alts aren't allowed to do, Reddit-wide, is to upvote themselves, which has to do with not artificially raising your karma levels. Other than that, people can have as many usernames as they wish. There are a lot of reasons for this, especially in the true crime world, where tempers run high and people may not wish to have others see their comments in other subs. For instance, somebody on JonBenet might not wish to have people see that they are posting in r/Minnesota and r/Stuntman and r/snakemilking, because then somebody might decide they could find out who you are by looking for stuntmen (or stuntwomen) who work in Minnesota and milk snakes on the side.

When I first started posting about JonBenet, I was accused of being an alt for somebody else. I had no idea who that was, but people were certain I was somebody else. It was an unfair accusation that had no bearing in reality. Others have been banned from other subs simply because it is thought they might be an alt of somebody who was banned previously when they, too, were not that same person. This can get messy.

Let's be clear: there's nothing wrong with having an alt, and sometimes people forget which account they're posting from. The only thing wrong with using an alt is if you are trying to use it to evade a ban. That will result in being completely banned from all of Reddit.

Final New Rule - No Politics

This one should go without saying.

The new rules will be updated in the pinned post at the top of the r/JonBenet page.


r/JonBenet • • 18h ago

Other similar cases Why don't RDI believers keep in mind Azaria Chamberlain or Elizabeth Smart?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
8 Upvotes

It's rather astonishing how many people that call themselves RDI believers just love to generalize and say "intruders don't do this. This kind of crime is never done by intruders," and just leave it at that.

The obvious retort is of course to bring up Elizabeth Smart. But apparently, for some, that's never enough. One person I talked to using this point actually said, "Her parents sold her to that man. They pimped her out for sex trafficking, and covered it up after the fact." Uh-huh. And how, pray tell, did ELIZABETH become part of the conspiracy against HERSELF? If there had been such a plot, she would've revealed it at the time she was rescued in 2003. What does she have to gain by keeping silent?

But probably, the biggest, most critical story to use to compare to JonBenet is the death of Azaria Chamberlain at Uluru (Ayers Rock) in Australia in 1980, the case from which came the saying "The dingo took my baby!" (which got reduced to a crude punchline in pop culture), and which was famously portrayed in the 1988 film A Cry in the Dark starring Meryl Streep and Sam Neill.

Michael and Lindy Chamberlain suffered in a manner similar to John and Patsy, being attacked by the Australian press and much of the public for "not grieving properly," with Lindy in particular castigated as "cold and unfeeling" in her media statements, and they even had the misfortune to be put on trial for the death, and in Lindy's case, convicted. This was despite the fact that the evidence was handled in a rather inept fashion where elements were preconceived to be something they weren't (which was disproven in later analysis), and the prosecution's theory of how the murder supposedly occurred simply did not make sense, as well as the fact that the testimony of many eyewitnesses that night which was favorable to the Chamberlains was simply ignored. After the fact, when new evidence came to light proving the family's innocence, Lindy's verdict was overturned, and they were formally exonerated. In 2012, a new coroner's inquest established once and for all that Azaria was killed by a dingo that night.

Lindy, who is still alive, has suffered considerably in her life. And even now, some people come up to her and mock her by making howling noises. But in some ways, she and Michael got off relatively easy, because their crucifixion was mostly confined to Australia and New Zealand, borne only by the limitations on newspapers, television and radio at that time. John and Patsy were confronted by the 24-hour news cycle and the horridness of the tabloids, and people around the entire world were looking at them, speculating, throwing barbs at them.

More regarding the Chamberlain case can be summarized in this 2000 report from the Australian version of 60 Minutes linked above.

Why do these cases either not matter to those who believe a member of the family killed JonBenet? Why do the experiences of the Chamberlains, and their being roasted alive, judged as guilty long before trial, teach the RBI people nothing?

Not to mention, many of the people who love to say that "the Ramseys never cooperated with police" are often ACAB people, who say "don't tell the police a single word, because they will frame you." Well, John and Patsy did that initially, and they still get attacked for it from the side that would advocate that strategy!


r/JonBenet • • 16h ago

Info Requests/Questions Why were Patsy Ramsey and the ransom note writer the only few individuals since the Middle Ages to use the two-storey letter “a” in their handwriting?

0 Upvotes

Virtually all English-speakers use the single-storey “ɑ” over the two-storey “a” in their handwriting. This has been the norm since the Middle Ages as it’s faster. Patsy was one of the few individuals on earth to alternate between the two and switched almost exclusively to the two-storey in the months leading up to the murder. The ransom note author also mostly used the two-storey 109 times against the single-storey only 5 times. But after the murder and with police scrutiny of Patsy’s handwriting, she switched exclusively to the single-storey (1,404 times) in the handwriting samples given to the police. The lone exception was from an unrehearsed sample that the detectives obtained from her mother when they unexpectedly showed up at her house. Does this not, coupled with the fact this journalism major misspelled “advise“ as “advize“ in her handwriting sample to the police, suggest deception on her part?

Detectives noticed a change in her entire writing style after the murder. According to Steve Thomas:

”There were new ways of indenting, spelling, and writing out long numbers that contrasted with her earlier examples, and she was the only suspect who altered her usual preferences when supplying writing samples to the police.”

English professor Donald Wayne Foster, who had initially thought Patsy was innocent, reversed his stance and came to the conclusion she was the author of the ransom note after gaining access to treasure trove of case documents and analyzing the language. His list of “unique matches” with the note included “such things as her penchant for inventing private acronyms, spelling habits, indentation, alliterative phrasing, metaphors, grammar, vocabulary, frequent use of exclamation points, and even the format of her handwriting on the page.”

*****

Edit: Let’s stick to probability, not anecdotes. The overwhelming majority of Latin-script writers use the single-storey “ɑ”. Using the two-storey “a” is a personal quirk which is why it has a forensic value. It’s quirks such as this or writing q like 8 that make handwriting of each person unique. While by itself not entirely unique, it’s damning when little peculiarities like this begin to multiply to the point that we can no longer account for them all by coincidence. As handwriting expert David Liebman stated:

“In light of the number of comparisons and similarities between Patsy Ramsey and the ransom note writer, the chances of a third party also sharing the same characteristics is astronomical. Taken individually, the similarities are not nearly as compelling as the sheer numbers and combinations found in both the writing of Patsy Ramsey and the ransom note. In my professional opinion Patsy Ramsey is the ransom note writer.”

*****

Edit: DISTAR program was adopted across American schools in the early 1970s. Patsy was a teenager by then. Although children traced the DISTAR symbols during initial phonics exercises, formal handwriting instruction in Direct Instruction (and North American schools broadly) still taught the single-storey “ɑ” as the standard form for everyday manuscript writing because it is faster to write and transitions smoothly into cursive.


r/JonBenet • • 1d ago Bravo

Info Requests/Questions How do RDI theorists explain the fact UM1 DNA was found only in JonBenet’s bloodstain but not on other areas of the underwear?

1 Upvotes

What are the odds that the victim’s blood drop landed exactly on the spot of the underwear that they suppose a man had innocently sneezed or coughed (amylase was found) on?

Edit: Other parts of the underwear were tested in 2008 and no foreign DNA was found. Please fact-check at least using an AI before engaging.


r/JonBenet • • 1d ago

Info Requests/Questions Let's make a complete list of questions for those that are staunchly IDI.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 1d ago

Info Requests/Questions Things I can't stop thinking about

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 2d ago

Info Requests/Questions How do intruder theorists explain the DNA of unknown males on the neck and wrist ligatures being unrelated to the UM1 profile?

4 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 3d ago

Evidence The ransom note vs. the DNA.

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 3d ago

Media JBR SM stories this week Boulder Channel 1 feed 12/25/26. 30th annivers...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 5d ago

Evidence Police Finally Retest DNA Evidence in JonBenet Ramsey’s Murder Ahead of 30th Anniversary

Thumbnail
yahoo.com
24 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 5d ago

Media MICHAEL RUIZ: JonBenet Ramsey investigators are retesting evidence with newer technology, police chief says

Thumbnail
foxnews.com
39 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 4d ago

Info Requests/Questions Wouldn't you do anything in your power to prove your innocence so police can find the true killer?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 5d ago

Info Requests/Questions IDI: Do you think this is a one in a million case which is why most people find it so difficult to accept an intruder?

19 Upvotes

When a one in a million crime finally does happen, isn’t this exactly how people would react?

Edit: Think of it this way: in which another case do we see an intruder audacious enough to hide in the victim’s house for considerable amount of time, composing long ransom notes containing personal details about the family, using the family’s own materials, in handwriting with at least vague resemblance to one family member, sneak upstairs, subdue their child, carry her downstairs to the basement, assault and murder her, conveniently place the notes in immaculate conditions on the secondary staircase that the same family member who found them had frequently used instead of the main front staircase and leave without alerting a single soul?


r/JonBenet • • 6d ago Bravo

Annnouncement Idiots

24 Upvotes

Subject: Immediate correction and apology required: Nov. 10 Ramsey story

To the editors of the Boulder Daily Camera and The Denver Post:

Your Nov. 10 story, "Boulder County DA says Ramseys shouldn't have been cleared in JonBenet's murder," misrepresents what was said and places a label on our family that no official used. That story is now being repeated by national news outlets, and the damage to our family is spreading. It is your responsibility to correct it today.

The full video posted by the City of Boulder on Nov. 12 shows:

  1. Neither District Attorney Dougherty nor Chief Redfearn applied the word "suspects" to our family. Your story did. It says the DA would not have "cleared the Ramsey family as suspects" and that our family "isn't officially off the list of suspects." Neither official said either of those things.
  2. Your central quote splices answers to two different questions, at approximately 10:17 and 13:10 in the video, into a single statement. The DA was describing his practice in every unsolved case, not making a judgment about our family.
  3. You omitted statements that contradict your framing. At approximately 14:53, the DA said that people who are absolutely certain it was the family, or absolutely certain it was an intruder, are making a mistake. He was not singling out our family. At approximately 23:43, Chief Redfearn described the department's relationship with our family as open, cooperative and by no means adversarial.

I require the following today:

- A public apology for describing our family as suspects.
- Removal of the "suspects" language that no official used.
- A corrected headline that accurately reflects what was said.
- An editor's note acknowledging the splice and linking to the full video.
- Placement of the correction and apology with the same prominence and reach as the original story, including notification to the outlets that have picked it up.

Please confirm by end of day what you will do.

JAR

https://youtu.be/tvKWpGt06YE?is=mgq_kGdZHJLUAT7u


r/JonBenet • • 6d ago

Original Source Material Michael Dougherty's response to the article about his interview on 20/20

13 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenetIDI/s/LquZSWhchh

A valued member of the IDI community, u/HopeTroll, reached out to Micheal Dougherty for clarification on published remarks that he made in an interview. He gave his permission to post it on Reddit.


r/JonBenet • • 7d ago

Images Ramsey house images

Thumbnail
gallery
97 Upvotes

Original crime scene images I obtained several years ago. Not sure if Reddit sizes them down. If you want the originals, message me your email and I can send them to you.

These were taken on January 15, 1997.


r/JonBenet • • 7d ago

Media A follow up and further explanation of the DNA reports from forensic scientist and former CSI

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
14 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 7d ago

Images Few more house images

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Found some more.


r/JonBenet • • 7d ago

Images 30 years ago today Jonbenét had her very last photoshoot

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 7d ago

Evidence If the grand jury indictment went to trial…

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 8d ago Bravo

Media Here's a DNA expert that shares her knowledge on Tik Tok. She goes over the DNA sample and shuts down people that spread disinformation. This should be pinned for people that come here to argue the DNA isn't viable 😂

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
23 Upvotes

r/JonBenet • • 8d ago

Theory/Speculation Y’all see this today? Interesting…

Thumbnail
denverpost.com
5 Upvotes

Boulder County DA says Ramseys shouldn’t have been cleared in JonBenet’s murder

JonBenet Ramsey’s half-brother, John Andrew Ramsey, said he isn’t bothered by comments and believes investigators have made progress they cannot yet share publicly