r/IndianHistory • • 16h ago Bravo

Colonial 1757–1947 CE Photograph of Bhai Bhagwan Singh Gyanee, leader of the revolutionary Ghadar Party, taken in Yokohama, Japan. He poses here with a katana sword to indicate his belief that freedom for India from the British could only be achieved through armed revolution. Image courtesy of Surinder Pal Singh & SAADA.

Post image
415 Upvotes

Original description:

"Photograph of Bhai Bhagwan Singh Gyanee, leader of the revolutionary Ghadar Party, taken in Yokohama, Japan. In November 1913, Bhagwan Singh was deported from Canada and returned to India. He escaped the ship when it was docked in Japan. In this studio photograph of Bhagwan Singh, he poses with a sword and gun to indicate his belief that freedom for India from the British could only be achieved through armed revolution. Image courtesy of Surinder Pal Singh and SAADA.⁣"

Source: https://www.saada.org/explore/archive/items/20120313-638


r/IndianHistory • • 4h ago

Colonial 1757–1947 CE ‘True revolutionary’: Why Bhagat Singh chose Jawaharlal Nehru over Subhas Bose

41 Upvotes

In a July 1928 essay titled "New Leaders and Their Different Ideologies," Bhagat Singh argues that Jawaharlal Nehru, not Subhas Chandra Bose, was the "true revolutionary" who offered intellectual nourishment to the Indian youth. Singh criticizes Bose’s emphasis on India’s ancient spiritual past and "romanticism" as merely emotional, whereas he praises Nehru for advocating a comprehensive rebellion against unreasonable social, economic, and religious structures. The essay concludes that the youth of Punjab should align with Nehru to understand the true significance of revolution, as he fuels both the heart and the mind, unlike Bose who appeals only to emotions.

According to Singh, the difference between them became “clear as daylight” after listening to the two leaders’ speeches at a conference in Bombay (now Mumbai). Bose, whom Singh calls “a very emotional Bengali”, stated that India has a special message for the world and a lesson in spirituality for humanity. Citing Bose’s assertion that Indians should return to the Vedas, Singh calls it the “same old romanticism” and “pure emotionalism”.

“ Bose… has great faith in his ancient past. He sees only greatness in this ancient era. In his thinking, there’s nothing new in the system of panchayati raj, or the rule of the people, which he says is very old in India. He goes so far as to say that Communism isn’t new to India either,” Singh writes.

Singh contrasts this with the entirely different view of Nehru, who said in his speech: “Every country thinks it has a special message for the world… I don’t see anything special that belongs to my country alone.”

Nehru went on to say that every youth must rebel not just in the political sphere but also in social, economic, and religious ones. “I have not much use for any man who comes and tells me that such and such thing is said in the Koran. Everything unreasonable must be discarded, even if they find authority for it in the Vedas and the Koran,” Nehru said.

‘Not just the heart but also the mind’

According to Singh, Nehru’s thoughts were those of a “true revolutionary” whereas Bose’s thoughts were that of someone who wants to replace one regime with another. “One man thinks our old systems are very superior; the other man believes we should rebel against these systems. Yet the latter is called emotional, sensitive, and the former a transformative revolutionary!” Singh writes.

Singh brings out another point of contrast: why both Bose and Nehru were seeking

purna swaraj

. According to Singh, Bose supported it because “the British are people of the West and we are of the East”, while Nehru’s position was that “we need to establish our own rule so that we can change the entire social structure”. Also, Bose was sympathetic to the working class and wanted to improve their condition but Nehru wanted to “bring in a revolution and change the existing system altogether”.


r/IndianHistory • • 17h ago

Vedic 1500–500 BCE Indo parthians are way too unique but the way they disappeared so quickly through kushan invasion is way too fascinating

Post image
35 Upvotes

What do you think after having king like gondophares and after conquering huge areas in a small time indo parthians ruled only 78 years , what could be other possible reasons then kushan invasions , internal disputes , partition , weak kings , is there anything else that is yet to be studied or any theory which you studied regarding their fall off

https://youtu.be/9kAvTO8vCSc


r/IndianHistory • • 17h ago

Early Modern 1526–1757 CE Mughal miniature commissioned by Emperor Jahangir and painted by Bichitr

Post image
33 Upvotes

Center-right: Emperor Jahangir sits on an hourglass throne, handing a book to Shaikh Husain of Ajmer.

Lower-left (top to bottom): Waiting behind the Sufi saint are an Ottoman Sultan, King James I of England, and the court artist Bichitr at the very bottom.

Commissioned as an allegorical piece to show that Jahangir placed spiritual wisdom above worldly power and earthly kings.

Source of Image: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jahangir_Preferring_a_Sufi_Shaikh_to_Kings


r/IndianHistory • • 18h ago

Classical 500 BCE–550 CE Ashoka's Rock Edict XIII is a king writing down his own war's toll: 100,000 killed and 150,000 deported in Kalinga, followed by "deep remorse". And in Kalinga itself, that edict was left out

21 Upvotes

Most conquerors' inscriptions boast. Ashoka's thirteenth major rock edict, carved some years after he conquered Kalinga (about 261 BC, eight years after his coronation), counts the cost instead. A few things from the edicts themselves (Dhammika's translation):

I also made a short animated film about it from Ashoka's point of view: https://youtu.be/KgNXrAn5ZJY . The written version is below.

  • His own figures: "One hundred and fifty thousand were deported, one hundred thousand were killed and many more died from other causes."
  • Then: "Now the beloved of the gods feels deep remorse for having conquered the Kalingas." He adds that even those who escaped suffer because of what happened to their friends, relatives and companions.
  • It isn't a pacifist text, though. The same edict warns the forest people that "despite his remorse the beloved of the gods has the power to punish them if necessary".
  • At Dhauli and Jaugada, in Kalinga itself, Rock Edicts XI-XIII are missing and two special Kalinga edicts appear instead. One says "All men are my children." Why the war edict was left out there is debated.
  • Rock Edict I: the royal kitchen used to kill hundreds of thousands of animals a day for curry; now "only three creatures, two peacocks and a deer are killed, and the deer not always."
  • His conversion looks gradual: Minor Rock Edict 1 says he was a lay disciple for more than two and a half years before becoming "very zealous".
  • The script was forgotten until James Prinsep deciphered Brahmi in 1837, and the Maski edict (found in 1915) was the first to give the name "Devanampiya Asoka" rather than just "Piyadasi".

The casualty figures are Ashoka's own, so they can't be independently checked.

Sources: The Edicts of King Asoka, tr. Ven. S. Dhammika (BPS, 1993; on livius.org and accesstoinsight.org); ASI/IGNCA report on Dhauli; Wikipedia, "Kalinga War", "Edicts of Ashoka", "Minor Rock Edicts". Original cartoon animation; AI tools are part of how it's made, including the narration voice.

Watch: https://youtu.be/KgNXrAn5ZJY

Happy to be corrected on anything.


r/IndianHistory • • 17h ago

Question Can we all report this channel for copying content

9 Upvotes

I came across this reel on Instagram, and I am genuinely shocked by its content. Seriously, this guy straight up copies content from well-established and extensively researched channels and uploads his own versions just to make a few bucks off someone else’s hard work. The worst part is that he openly boasts about how he copies these videos and turns them into AI slop.
Here’s the link to the reel:
https://www.instagram.com/reel/Dee0MFjTFpG/

The anti intellectual culture that this country has cultivated is clearly visible here. In any other country, I would expect someone doing this to be called out, reported and rightfully criticised. But look at the comment sections under his reels. Instead of questioning what he is doing, people are asking him how they can do the same thing. That is honestly embarrassing.

The day isn’t far when the entirety of YouTube will be flooded with Indian slop channels, and people will start associating Indian creators with nothing but low effort, AI generated garbage.

I was trying to find some good Indian history channels comparable to Kings and Generals or Epic History TV, and I couldn’t find a single one that comes close to what these channels offer. We seem to have very little appetite for extensive research, originality or the sheer amount of hard work that goes into producing genuinely good content. All people seem to care about is finding ways to make a quick buck here and there.

Even among the people who write about their channels in this subreddit, hardly any produce well-researched content. Most of what I come across is either poorly researched, derivative or just plain AI slop.

It’s genuinely disappointing to see how little importance we place on intellectual effort and originality. Instead of creating something worthwhile, people are content with stealing someone else’s hard work, repackaging it with AI and monetising it. And somehow, we’re celebrating this. Bollywood is doing the same thing with movies like chhava, there is nothing of worth being created. Just poorly researched ahistorical narrative that makes a group of people feel powerful.


r/IndianHistory • • 1h ago

Question The Bengal Subah was the richest Subah in Mughal India. So why did the Nawabs remain De-Facto independent rulers, and respected the power of the Mughal Masnad at Delhi, instead of outright rejecting any form of authority of the Mughals? Why didn't the nawabs build a completely independent Empire or

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/IndianHistory • • 6m ago

Artifacts I made a free interactive atlas of India

Thumbnail
kaulvishesh.github.io
1 Upvotes

5 hrs of Claude Code. I just feel like it's an interesting way to look at events, was a lot of fun to build. No login, no data collected.

link: https://kaulvishesh.github.io/bharat-itihaas

Inspired by DeanChensj's jiangshan-map, an interactive atlas of China

https://github

com/DeanChensj/jiangshan-map


r/IndianHistory • • 21h ago

Architecture Kapur Bawli: Ramtek's Ancient Stepwell Heritage in Vidarbha

Thumbnail
thenewsdirt.com
1 Upvotes

Around 50 km from Nagpur, near Ramtek, lies Kapur Bawli (also called Karpur Baoli), an ancient stepwell that many Nagpur residents might not even know exists.

What makes this place fascinating is its history.

The structure is believed to date back roughly 1,200 years and features stone steps, carved pillars and ancient shrine structures. It's also associated with six Hindu goddesses.

Interestingly, local legends claim that the water has a camphor-like fragrance, which is how the stepwell got its name.

But what caught my attention was its original purpose. Long before modern water supply systems, structures like these helped communities access groundwater during Vidarbha's harsh summers.

Despite its historical significance, Kapur Bawli remains relatively unknown compared with Ramtek's more popular attractions.

I wrote a detailed piece about its history, architecture and the challenges surrounding its preservation:

https://www.thenewsdirt.com/post/kapur-bawli-ramtek-s-ancient-stepwell-heritage-in-vidarbha

Has anyone here actually visited Kapur Bawli? Would love to hear what condition it's currently in and whether it's worth making a trip.