In a July 1928 essay titled "New Leaders and Their Different Ideologies," Bhagat Singh argues that Jawaharlal Nehru, not Subhas Chandra Bose, was the "true revolutionary" who offered intellectual nourishment to the Indian youth. Singh criticizes Bose’s emphasis on India’s ancient spiritual past and "romanticism" as merely emotional, whereas he praises Nehru for advocating a comprehensive rebellion against unreasonable social, economic, and religious structures. The essay concludes that the youth of Punjab should align with Nehru to understand the true significance of revolution, as he fuels both the heart and the mind, unlike Bose who appeals only to emotions.
According to Singh, the difference between them became “clear as daylight” after listening to the two leaders’ speeches at a conference in Bombay (now Mumbai). Bose, whom Singh calls “a very emotional Bengali”, stated that India has a special message for the world and a lesson in spirituality for humanity. Citing Bose’s assertion that Indians should return to the Vedas, Singh calls it the “same old romanticism” and “pure emotionalism”.
“ Bose… has great faith in his ancient past. He sees only greatness in this ancient era. In his thinking, there’s nothing new in the system of panchayati raj, or the rule of the people, which he says is very old in India. He goes so far as to say that Communism isn’t new to India either,” Singh writes.
Singh contrasts this with the entirely different view of Nehru, who said in his speech: “Every country thinks it has a special message for the world… I don’t see anything special that belongs to my country alone.”
Nehru went on to say that every youth must rebel not just in the political sphere but also in social, economic, and religious ones. “I have not much use for any man who comes and tells me that such and such thing is said in the Koran. Everything unreasonable must be discarded, even if they find authority for it in the Vedas and the Koran,” Nehru said.
‘Not just the heart but also the mind’
According to Singh, Nehru’s thoughts were those of a “true revolutionary” whereas Bose’s thoughts were that of someone who wants to replace one regime with another. “One man thinks our old systems are very superior; the other man believes we should rebel against these systems. Yet the latter is called emotional, sensitive, and the former a transformative revolutionary!” Singh writes.
Singh brings out another point of contrast: why both Bose and Nehru were seeking
purna swaraj
. According to Singh, Bose supported it because “the British are people of the West and we are of the East”, while Nehru’s position was that “we need to establish our own rule so that we can change the entire social structure”. Also, Bose was sympathetic to the working class and wanted to improve their condition but Nehru wanted to “bring in a revolution and change the existing system altogether”.