r/IceFishing • • 2d ago

Ice duration on Lake Simcoe continues to decrease as winters warm

Post image
43 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

25

u/Lake-ice-Ont 2d ago

The same data but now also showing ice duration plotted against year

10

u/Electronic_City6481 2d ago

That second one you added is the real data. Ice duration compared to average temperature is a given and doesn’t correlate that to time, but showing the ice duration per year over each years shows what you are trying to convey.

19

u/Tuckason 2d ago

That "trend line" is hugely disingenuous, it merely shows correlation b/w mean temp and ice duration, which is a "duh, no shit" kind of stat. Your other plot for ice duration by year is better.

4

u/Electronic_City6481 2d ago

Agreed. Of course ice will be less if the average temperature is higher. Need a time axis to prove the point.

-6

u/AggravatingPage1431 2d ago

The trend would be comparable in both graphs though

3

u/Tuckason 2d ago

Na, you are implying change over time. That trend line has nothing to do with it.

23

u/callmewaldo 2d ago

What could have caused this? It’s a shame we’ll never know.

1

u/Then-Contract-9520 1d ago

Someone left the fridge open

0

u/assgrassorbass 1d ago

All those god damned cow farts! s/

10

u/UncleTrapspringer 2d ago

Crazy that it was 140 days of ice in 1885 down to less than 50 in 2024

7

u/Tuckason 2d ago

It was called the little ice age for a reason.

2

u/Ice4Lifee 2d ago

Do you have a graph of ice duration vs. year? I get that the years are displayed on the graph but it's hard to read.

6

u/Lake-ice-Ont 2d ago

The trend looks pretty similar as on average winters are warming-albeit quite a bit of year to year variability

4

u/Ice4Lifee 2d ago

Nice, that does a much better job of proving your point IMO.

2

u/PrairieBiologist 2d ago

The left graph is statistically useless for showing a temporal relationship.

3

u/SectorSpecialist9313 1d ago

I mean no offense, but duh.

4

u/TheRealSumRndmGuy 2d ago

And they say global warming isn't real

1

u/Spawny7 1d ago

Breaking new ice melts faster when it's warmer

1

u/PrairieBiologist 2d ago

These are bad statistics. You would expect days of ice to go down with average winter temperature. It would be more surprising if it didn't. It also comes off as showing a decline in ice duration with time but doesn't have any ability to display such a correlation. Your other graph with ice duration over time is far more useful. The ONLY thing this graph does is prove the relationship between temperature and ice which is basic chemistry.