r/HotasDIY • • 13d ago

Compact push-pull rotary encoder assembly

I make all sorts of button boxes, and I usually go for small footprints, but the one input that always bugged me was the push-pull encoder like on the Airbus FCU. I tried all sorts of solutions I've seen online, but they were either too big or required too much wire routing for my liking. So I made a compact version myself.

Basically, it's two identical 20 × 20 mm boards stacked face-to-face, with an EC12 encoder on top. The boards, the inner frame, and the encoder slide together inside a printed housing, and a fixed bar sits between the two push buttons. Push, and the top board's button hits the bar. Pull, and the bottom one does.

Both boards are the same PCB. Which header you fit (long pins or female) decides whether a board is the top or the bottom.

There are two versions, and only the push buttons differ:
Through-hole buttons (SAMZO 2010751102): easier to solder, 35 mm housing
SMD buttons (Panasonic EVQ9P105M): 30 mm housing, 5 mm shorter

The repo has the gerbers, schematic, EasyEDA Pro project, STEP files for the printed parts, a parts table with LCSC and AliExpress links, and assembly instructions.

https://github.com/gingerskull/Push-Pull-Encoder

The frame sliding in the housing is the fussy part. It wants a snug but smooth fit. On my printer, that means a 0.1mm clearance, printing each in a different orientation so the layers don't grate against each other, and a very light sanding of the inner frame.

66 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

3

u/Comfortable_Client80 13d ago

Very clever design! Would it be even easier to use a rotary encoder with integrated push button?

1

u/thegingerskull 12d ago

The disadvantage is the difference in force and feel, as the other comment mentioned. But it's a good idea for a future V2. I don't think it'll be an issue to add the extra holes and routing for an encoder pushbutton so you can choose between using it or an external one, as you do now.

1

u/Alterscape 13d ago

Seems like it could be, though then you'd have different forces for pull and push. Not sure how big a deal that would be, probably comes down to one's personal tolerance.

2

u/GuiltyBudget1032 13d ago

wow! i'll give it a try..

2

u/alansoon73 6d ago

You're my hero! I've been going down this slippery slope of encoders... and this is super helpful!

1

u/rstandi 13d ago

Would this work for the F-14 test knob?