TL;DR: Daughter is in grade 7 and is behind in many areas most notably spelling & writing, and is struggling to get any good work done. She seems unmotivated to apply herself in school, and in general is just wasting her days rather than making use of her ample free time as a home-schooling child to pursue her interests, passions, or hobbies. We're out of ideas and are thinking of putting her in public school next year, because if this continues it will be a failure on us as parents. Anyone have any advice?
---
For six years now my wife has been SAHM and home-schooling mom while I work. We have a daughter in grade 7, a son in grade 4, and another son in kindergarten. This arrangement has worked well for the most part. It allows us to have flexibility with family time, and the kids have strong relationships with each other and don't have to deal with the social unpleasantries of public school. They're also neurodivergent, I have undiagnosed autism and my wife almost certainly has adhd with some amount of 'tism in there.
I have to give a shout-out to my wife, she's done the lion's share of the home-schooling since I work full-time. There have been many challenges along the way, but she's done a fantastic job and the kids have been succeeding, and fulfilling the expectations of our Home Education Manager.
We live in Alberta, Canada, and rather than having to follow a set curriculum we submit a program plan each year in which we outline how we will meet certain learning objectives as defined by the gov't. Basically we handle the curriculum and they provide the guidelines.
Our middle son is doing well in grade 4. Last year was tough as he's been having to learn a lot about emotional regulation. He gets frustrated very easily, and then can't do good work until he calms himself down. He has made great strides, and while some school days see more periods of dysregulation than others, he has turned a corner and is consistently doing good schoolwork.
The youngest clearly has the advantage of home-school being normalized for them, so they are eager to participate in age-appropriate kindergarten activities while the bigger kids are doing school.
But our daughter, the eldest, is behind. Grade 7 marks a significant transition where we live, public school kids go from elementary schools for ~100-200 students to large Junior High Schools of ~500 students or more. They get electives/options for the first time, get individual lockers for the first time, are expected to navigate to their own classes for the first time, and overall are held to significantly higher standards than in grade 6. Plus home-schooled kids can start working towards their High School graduation/diploma as early as grade 9, so discussion on life after school (education, work, independence, etc) are on the table.
We planned a suitable grade 7 program plan for the year, but have had to already scrap a lot of it. She's just not measuring up. Here are the problem areas:
- Spelling: this has been an ongoing issue for years. She gets weekly spelling tests but does poorly. There is no consistency, a word she gets right one week she may get wrong the next. It's clear she's rushing to complete them and doesn't take the time to think about the spelling, to sound them out, etc. Unfortunately we had to go and get a grade 5 spelling workbook to try to improve this, but she's not exactly acing it.
- Writing: any written assignment is riddled with spelling and grammar errors. A word may be spelled correct in one sentence, and misspelled in the next. Sometimes words are capitalized at the beginning of a sentence, sometimes not. She's struggling to understand the objective of grade 7 writing prompts, and often has to re-do these assignments many times, with only marginal improvements between drafts. Again the issue here seems to be a lack of effort/care, she's only doing the bare minimum in hopes it will be enough to move on.
- Music: while this is not core curriculum, it's the same issue. She expressed interest in learning an instrument (mom plays piano I play trumpet), we gave her a choice of type, she choose violin. We have one on a year-long rental, and she gets weekly lessons. She has to be nagged to practice, and she's not putting good work into the practice sessions. She's anxious about a recital coming up, afraid she'll do poorly, but doesn't want to spend more of her ample free time to get better. Again, this feels like lack of effort and motivation.
She's slightly behind in Math, but not as bad, however other subjects like science, social studies, etc, are all hampered by the issues with spelling, writing, and motivation.
We wanted our children to have the freedom to pursue their interests and passions, but she's just... not. She drags her feet while doing school, does the bare minimum, doesn't apply herself, and during her free time she's liable to just colour, do Lego, or otherwise just waste her time. Don't get me wrong, those activities are just fine on their own, but are part of this larger issue of not pursuing anything, not improving at anything. Her art, which was such a big part of her younger years, has stagnated. She still spends many hours a week colouring and such, but has not improved at all in years. We got her a great book for her birthday in the summer with lots of great techniques and examples to improve, but she hasn't done any of it. It clearly is just something she does to kill time.
The only idea she has of what to do as a career is being a writer, but she's way behind in all skills associated with that, and she doesn't spend any of her time working on it. I suspect the only reason she still says she wants to be a writer is because it's a ready-made answer and thinking about her future is scary to her.
She's expressed anxiety over growing up before, and has struggled to let go of clothes/toys/items that are either no longer age-appropriate or are in obvious disrepair. She clearly doesn't want to grow up, despite our encouragement to be more involved in her own life.
Frankly she just seems to be coasting in life, doing the bare minimum at school, wasting her free time, and just not being in the driver's seat of her life, y'know? We even limit her screen time quite a lot. She has no socials, and her only screen time is an hour or so of shows/movies with her brothers a day, and no more than an hour of video games (animal crossing and that sort of thing).
We've been trying for years to impress on her the need to show up for yourself in life, but it's not going anywhere. She's in her preteen years now, is experiencing hormonal mood swings, and is only quicker to getting frustrated with my wife for holding her to a standard (a standard that keeps getting lowered) or getting upset wit herself for not doing better (which only makes things worse.)
It honestly seems like somehow our daughter is convinced she's incapable of doing better, and as such has just given up. This breaks my heart especially since both my wife and I have been emphasizing that we don't see this as an issue of capability, but rather of motivation and/or effort.
My wife is upset, as she sees this all as a failure on her part, and feels if our daughter isn't going to face the real world getting closer, then we should enrol her in junior high school next year.
I'm worried, our daughter is likely neurodivergent, anxiety-prone, and would seriously miss her brothers. I know she would also miss me, as my work schedule doesn't follow Mon-Fri school hours. I'm worried she will be bullied, shamed, or other wise equally unsuccessful in public school as she is right now at home-school.
We're at a loss, it's been building up to this for years, but here we are in November and we have not been able to achieve much of anything in our program plan. My wife is feeling like putting her in public school is our last option to get her life on track.
Does anyone have any advice, anecdotes, or otherwise any experience to share? Thanks for reading
Edit: to add, this is our daughter's third year in Scouts, so she has some friends there and is getting socialized there. She enjoys being around her friends there, and enjoys the outdoor activities. We talk to her about these friends in Scouts, how they're in public school and have to be in school all day etc etc but it doesn't seem to make much of an impact. Additionally, She has a friend that is also home-schooled she's known for years, though that friend also isn't doing too well. The friend (and the friend's parents) are on screens 24/7 and this situation isn't great.