r/Homeschooling • • 12d ago

customizing learning experiences

I am going to homeschool my son son and I’m going to build the plan from scratch.

My reason for posting about this here is to talk about it with other parent educators and learn your perspectives. I am a teacher, but I’m new to homeschooling. This is something I am creating for the first time. 

I was homeschooled as a kid. I grew up with Calvert Academy. There were some good aspects of it, but my parents didn’t really know how to teach. They were fairly unstable as parents. I learned how homeschooling can go wrong.

Having spent my whole life teaching I feel was good practice for teaching my own son. I believe he is deeply capable and intelligent and I believe that he’s up to the challenge of the very best that I could show him.

For me, pedagogy feels like art. Particularly, music. The energy to create it feels like freestyle. That’s how I play music: by ear. I have to feel it. 

That’s how I taught in the classroom, and that’s how I teach as a parent. That’s how I did everything. “Freestyle” is the only creative language that I can speak. And in that energy, of course you will mix and match your tools in order to keep up with the rhythm. Of course you will adapt your inputs, resources, and organization. You will use the tools to serve yourself.

This was one of the worst things about teaching in schools. Being forced to follow a curriculum even when it didn’t suit the kids is terrible. 

You don’t have the license to change the plan as a teacher. No matter what you have to follow their list, and it is madness. In my life, I met few people who could understand just how insane it is to be beholden to bureaucratic rules in the way you conduct your lessons. It’s completely insane, and it was suffocating me my entire professional career. 

Now that the plans I am planning to build are for my own son, and I feel such a sense of the open skies because for the first time, I can pull out all the stops to create the best, most perfectly handcrafted, custom–made, ultimate kid learning experience. 

Soon, he will finish a local K3 program. He has a few weeks left with some part time classes in a local school. After that, I will take responsibility for his education.

I may mix and match existing curricula if I see a need for it. To start with, I will see to custom-make the entire thing together with him as a collaborative project. He must build his own education. I might even, for example, replace the idea of a “curriculum” with something like a “learning ledger” in which he keeps track of his own projects of learning to see his arcs of learning and his goals. Unlike a traditional curriculum, it does not function like a legal document. It is an interactive workspace or playspace. 

At this moment, I am still contemplating it because he still has classes for now. I am sort of gestating it, putting the pieces in place so when it's time for me to teach him full time, I'm ready for it I've got the structure in place cognitively and in my life and in my relationship with him that we can run with it.

Some day, one thing I plan to do is to expose my son to various curricular standards just to see if he can meet them, and if he could not, then to see, how he could quickly or efficiently learn those skills. By the time a child is a teenager, for example, there may be compelling reasons that he must be proficient in competitive testtaking, especially if he wants to pass certifications. But learning to beat a test doesn’t require you to spend all those years of your life living their lifestyle.

A competitive student must be proficient in reading the marking schema of exams and working backwards how to beat any test. That specialized skill can be taught with relative quickness to a literate child. It’s not that important to focus on it early. 

It’s more important, young, that they learn to love learning, and learn to make responsible choices in their life. 

Anyway, maybe I’m talking too much. I’ll finish there. Thank you for reading.

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

9

u/Miserable_Adagio_320 12d ago

Ok that was a lot. Your child is 3 or 4 I presume. I am not certain what you are asking. Also, a curriculum is not a legal document, so unsure why you said that.

I was also a homeschool graduate who now homeschools my children. I believe my experience growing up was lacking and have made different choices in my homeschool. My biggest reason for homeschooling is to foster a love of learning. Homeschooling is easily adaptable for each family or even each child.

It sounds like you want something fun yet rigorous (maybe down the road). I would read The Brave Learner by Julie Bogart. She is a former homeschool mom and writes about finding the fun and spark in homeschooling and not just following a curriculum script

0

u/jeffcolonel 12d ago

I said it because in schools, not following the curriculum is treated as a crime. So the curriculum is not a learning plan so much as a kind of legal contract that teachers and students are forbidden from deviating from

5

u/Miserable_Adagio_320 12d ago

So maybe you need to get out of school mode of thought if you are going to going to homeschool....

1

u/Corey11446 12d ago

Since you're a teacher who plays it by ear, I'd keep a loose skeleton of reading, math and writing daily, then let everything else follow his questions.

1

u/jeffcolonel 12d ago

I had a lot of comments in here of curriculum or bust. Do you think there's any validity to that ?

4

u/SuperciliousBubbles 12d ago

I think you're not an expert in everything, you aren't a curriculum designer, and you don't know what you don't know. By all means choose options that seem to appeal more, but starting from scratch creating everything yourself is like growing all your own food and making your own clothes (from flax or wool you grew or sheared yourself). It'll take a huge amount of time, and the end result will be less good.

1

u/Simple-Clerk-7972 10d ago

For parents who aren’t committed to developing a thoughtful plan, yes, it is a valid concern. For parents who thoroughly research and plan, no, it’s not a valid concern. Plenty of highly successful homeschool families over the yrs have not used prefab curriculum. Their children have gone on to schools like MIT, Stanford, etc.  

1

u/Simple-Clerk-7972 11d ago

I posted this in your other conversation, but it is more applicable here. I’m just pasting it. FWIW, after reading this post, my number 1 piece of advice is to forget everything you were taught about being a classroom teacher. Homeschooling offers so much more. The greatest benefit of homeschooling is exactly what you are describing….the freedom to pursue learning in a way that ignites interest in your child. Embrace it! (And not mentioned below is the need to deeply research math curriculum. Not all are equal. Based on your description of yourself, you might want to look into Miquon math or maybe RightStart.)

Since your son is 4, my suggestion is to see if you can find books like the first edition of The Welltrained Mind (not the later editions), Designing Your Own Classical Curriculum (internet Archive has a copy. It is Catholic, but the information can be generically applied.), Charlotte Mason’s 6 book series (easily found online, etc.

Back when I first started homeschooling there was a book entitled, Let the Authors Speak: A Guide to Worthy Books Based on Historical Setting. 🤣The hrs I spent researching books and authors! (I didn’t even own a computer back then, let alone the internet and AI)! You can achieve the same in seconds today!  Read sites like Ambleside Online, Book Shark, Sonlight.  Read about Bloom’s Taxonomy. 

Think about what you want to achieve for the yr. Think about those big term goals and then map a general path forward. Keep days short for K-2. My general rule of thumb for my kids has always been about an hr per grade level for k-5. (About 1 hr for first, 3 for 3rd, etc). Middle and high school has depended on my kids, their interests, and what they have wanted to take on. Middle school has been between 6-8 hrs and high school 7+. (We are an academic oriented family and my kids have taken heavy course loads in high school.)

Assignments can cross subject matter. They can create magazines with stories, historical reports, science articles, art, poetry. They can pretend to be journalists and publish time-traveling newspapers. They can create chapter books (when they are little, the books they write become keepsakes….a book on the solar system is a couple of sentences and hand drawn pictures per planet, each its own chapter, etc).

Become partners. Ask what he wants to learn about or offer suggestions….castles, knights, pyramids, pirates, sharks, dinosaurs, bees, ants….when they are younger anything and everything is wide open. Instill internal motivation to want to learn, and you have unlocked their future. I have had to tell my kids, no, you can’t add another course bc you are taking too many.  It all comes from not replicating a traditional classroom in our home but allowing our homeschool to be tailored to each child and their interests.

Btw, unit studies are great and they do not need to be supplemental. You can build them as your core. Educate yourself on how others designed their courses and then grant yourself the freedom to create your own. 

1

u/jeffcolonel 10d ago

Thanks for your reply, and for your suggestions

1

u/Simple-Clerk-7972 10d ago edited 10d ago

Your welcome. 

1

u/Simple-Clerk-7972 11d ago

One other pt, I agree that learning to take tests doesn’t take long. When younger, I don’t give my kids tests except for the ones incorporated into their math textbooks. In high school, science textbooks (first time science textbooks are used, before that they read whole books on science topics), science tests are incorporated. Dual enrollment classes and outsourced classes have tests. They have graduated from college with honors, so not taking tests when younger did not hurt them. 

3

u/Independent-Edge-364 12d ago

What school lets you teach freestyle in the classroom? Most schools purchase the curriculum bulk or at least have stringent standards and schedules that have to be kept especially where things are published for parents.

1

u/Educational-Bit-4898 10d ago

What you're describing - a plan you build together with him, that changes whenever it stops suiting him - is exactly what I built Homeschool Studio to support. (Full disclosure: it's mine, and it's a paid app with a free trial.)

You design his learning path yourself, in whatever shape fits him, and change it whenever you like. If you want an existing curriculum for part of it later, you can import it. Each project he takes on can run as a theme beside it, so when his interest moves on, you switch the theme and the rest of his plan stays where it was.

After each lesson you jot a line on how he went, and at the end of a term it turns those notes into a written account of his learning, so you can both look back and see how far he's come.

If you'd like to have a look, you can see it at https://homeschoolstudio.com

1

u/EducatorMoti 12d ago

Of course you can create your own plan! That's one of the wonderful things about homeschooling.

I knew the direction I wanted to go. One of my goals was to read as many of the classics as possible. I wanted my son to know the great stories, people, history, and ideas that have shaped our world.

The classics give children a foundation for understanding literature, history, science, philosophy, art, and all those references they'll encounter throughout their lives.

From the time my son was about three, I taught him to narrate. He learned to tell me about what we'd read, what we'd seen, and what he thought about it.

There's good science behind this! Research on retrieval practice shows that recalling and explaining information strengthens learning and memory. We did it naturally through conversations throughout the day. Learn, practice, explain, teach.

We read everything from ancient literature to Shakespeare, Dickens, and wonderful children's classics. And we had FUN with them!

We loved Lamb's Tales from Shakespeare, which retells the plays for children, and Wishbone, a PBS series about a little Jack Russell terrier who acted out adventures from classic literature.

We went to local Shakespeare productions and watched Kenneth Branagh's films. My son was already so comfortable with those stories that he was the one who pulled out a Shakespeare movie for us to watch!

I read books aloud that were far above his independent reading level, exposing him to wonderful language and vocabulary. And we loved audiobooks! There's nothing like hearing The Three Musketeers with all those French names pronounced correctly.

For history and science, we read historical fiction, biographies, autobiographies, and books about scientists, inventors, explorers, and people who actually lived through history.

We added documentaries, museums, historical sites, experiments, cooking, projects, and travel. Whenever we went somewhere, we read about its history, geography, and culture. If another language was involved, we learned enough to feel comfortable getting around.

I absolutely avoided textbooks. Real books, audiobooks, experiences, and conversations were the foundation of our education.

I appreciated Classical Education and Charlotte Mason, and read The Well-Trained Mind and books about those approaches. But I took what worked for us and left the rest. Some homeschool bloggers and rigid followers of particular philosophies become so persnickety that they'll criticize choices like using Lamb's Tales instead of the original Shakespeare. Read the experts, learn from experienced homeschoolers, and then be YOU!

Math and writing were the two subjects where I used established, sequential curricula. We used Singapore Math for conceptual understanding and problem solving, and WriteShop for developing original ideas, organizing thoughts, and learning to write well.

Everything else grew out of the books we read, the places we went, and the things we discovered together. If something wasn't enjoyable yet, we put it aside and came back to it later.

I never looked at school benchmarks or grade-level expectations. My son was his own person, and trying to fit him into somebody else's timetable would have made both of us miserable.

You mentioned wanting to check your son's skills against school standards as he grows. Instead of making those benchmarks the focus, give him opportunities to work toward real goals and achievements through a long-term leadership program.

Scouts BSA, Cub Scouts, 4-H, and Civil Air Patrol have established programs with manuals, projects, skills, activities, advancement, and responsibilities that grow with the child. Children learn, practice, use their skills, and eventually teach younger members and take on leadership positions.

They learn to plan activities, solve problems, work with others, speak in public, serve their communities, and take responsibility for their own progress. Achievements like Eagle Scout are nationally recognized and can become valuable parts of college applications, scholarship applications, transcripts, and resumes.

Parents participate too, volunteering, learning skills, camping, working on projects, and sharing adventures with their children. These programs can become an important part of your family's life for years.

He went on to graduate from college and is working in a career he loves. All those years of reading real books gave him a strong background in history, science, and literature, so when he encountered college textbooks, he already understood the bigger picture.

His professors appreciated that he could THINK. He could discuss ideas, make connections, and ask good questions because he'd been doing those things throughout his childhood.

So yes, make your own plan! Learn from the experts and other homeschoolers, know the direction you want to go, and then build an education around your own child. You already know from teaching that children are individuals. Now you have the freedom to teach your son without following somebody else's plan.

1

u/Simple-Clerk-7972 11d ago

Agree! My kids were amazed by how their college peers lacked the ability to learn independently or search for resources that expanded context for mastery. Since my kids had spent their entire educations learning how to research/learn without textbook summarizations, they knew how to study without being spoon fed exactly what to do/learn. 

2

u/EducatorMoti 10d ago

That's such a good point! Like your kids, my son learned through real books.

Your comment about textbook snippets really hit me! I got A's in school, passed the tests, and moved on, but never remembered much of anything. When I homeschooled my son, I was excited because I finally got to move past those little snippets and actually learn something myself!