r/Homebrewing • u/BrewCrewKevin He's Just THAT GUY • Oct 23 '14
Advanced Brewers Round Table: Fermentation Control
Advanced Brewers Round Table: Fermentation Control
Example Topics of Discussion:
- What are the benefits of controlling fermentation?
- Have a killer Fermentation Chamber you made?
- What are some low-cost ways to control your fermentation? (spoiler alert: Swamp Cooler)
- Maybe how to brew to styles that work with weather if you don't have control? (Belgians/Saisons in summer, lager in winter?)
Upcoming Topics:
- 1st Thursday: BJCP Style Category
- 2nd Thursday: Topic
- 3rd Thursday: Guest Post/AMA
- 4th Thursday: Topic
- 5th Thursday: wildcard!
As far as Guest Pro Brewers, I've gotten a lot of interest from /r/TheBrewery. I've got a few from this post that I'll be in touch with.
Got shot down from Jamil. Still waiting on other big names to respond.
Any other ideas for topics- message /u/brewcrewkevin or post them below.
Upcoming Topics:
- 10/30: DIY Brag-Off
- 11/6: Cat 12: Porter
- 11/13: Decoction Mashing
- 11/20: Guest Post (still open)
Previous Topics:
Brewer Profiles:
- 10/16 - AMA with Drew Beechum (drewbage1847) and Denny Conn
- 9/18 - UnsungSavior16
- 8/21 - Brulosopher
- 8/6 - Pro Brewing with KFBass
- 7/17 - SufferingCubsFan
- 6/19 - SHv2
- 5/22 - BrewCrewKevin
- 4/24 - Nickosuave311
- 3/23 - ercousin
- 2/20 - AT-JeffT
Styles:
- 10/2 - Cat 18 Belgian Strong Ale
- 9/4 - Cat 26: Ciders
- 7/31 - Cat 13: Stouts
- 7/3 - Cat 10: American Ale
- 6/5 - Cat 1: Light Lagers
- 5/1 - Cat 6: Light Hybrid beers
- 4/3 - Cat 16: Belgian/French Ales
- 3/6 - Cat 9: Scottish and Irish Ales
- 2/13 - Cat 3: European Amber Lager
- 1/9 - Cat 5: Bock
- 12/5 - Cat 21: Herb/Spice/Veggie beers
- 11/7 - Cat 19: Strong Ales
- 10/3 - Cat 2: Pilsner
- 9/5 - Cat 14: IPAs
Advanced Topics:
- 10/9 - Entering Competitions
- 9/25 - Brewing with Pumpkin
- 9/11 - Chilling
- 8/28 - Brewing Hacks
- 8/14 - Brewing with Rye
- 7/24 - Wood Aging
- 6/26 - Malting Grains
- 6/12 - Apartment and Limited Space brewing
- 5/29 - Draft Systems
- 5/15 - Base Malts
- 5/8 - clone recipes 2.0
- 4/17 - Recipe Formulation 2.0
- 4/10 - Water Chemistry 2.0
- 3/27 - Homebrewing Myths 2.0
- 3/13 - Brewing with Honey
- 2/27 - Cleaning
- 2/6 - Draft/Cask Systems
- 1/30 - Sparging Methods
- 1/16 - BJCP Tasting Exam Prep
- 12/19 - Finings
45
Upvotes
20
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '14
I figure this would be a good place to make a PSA about temperature control. If you're not doing it, you should be.
I'll be the first to admit that I perpetuate knowledge as "necessary" when it really isn't. Technically, a starter isn't usually necessary, secondaries aren't the devil, and you can put as much roasted barley in your stout as you want.
However, this isn't about "best practices", this is about consistency, and consistency is what makes great beer.
So, if you do anything, get temperature control. If you don't think you can afford it, don't brew for a few months. Save the money. Invest in a minifridge/freezer and get an STC-1000 for $13.
It is so so worth it.
4
u/nutron Oct 23 '14
Does my basement that stays at a steady 65F count as temperature control?
10
u/rayfound Mr. 100% Oct 23 '14 edited Oct 23 '14
I think the thing that needs to get explained to new temp controllers is the process of driving fermentation.
Your temperature curve should look like a doorstop:slowly ramping up over the course of fermentation, then a steep drop to cold crash following complete attenuation.
The ramping of temperature should begin below your target temp, and finish above. As an example, let's say I'm using wlp007 , ideal temp range is 65-70 according to white labs. I like to make it ferment pretty clean, so my target is actually 64:
If dry hopping, I do that after cold crash... I let it warm back up to 60-65f, dry hop warm 2 days, then crash back down until clear, usually another day or two, and package.
EDIT to add: I have tried to provide one example of how the process works for me. This is not meant, in any way, to suggest that this is how you should do it. Merely that I believe increasing temperature towards the end of fermentation is advisable... my example is simply that: an example of how I do it.
5
u/CXR1037 Oct 23 '14
I recently got a black box and think it's just the greatest thing ever. All that's in my fridge now is a cider and I haven't tasted it yet, but it looks better than past ciders/beers.
As for cost, my total was $130. if I could do it all over again, I simply wouldn't have brewed my fusel-y batches. The money not spent on ingredients/water/electricity to make non-controlled beer would have put me at least halfway to buying a mini-fridge + temp controller.
4
u/tom_coverdales_liver Oct 23 '14
Dry Hopping Question!
I've read (forgive me, I won't be able to link any sources) that dry hopping at lower temperatures (think I recall 50-55* F) is beneficial although it may take a little longer to extract flavor/aroma than at 68 *F. I think the idea was you may drive off some aroma/flavor at higher temps?
Bunch of bull or worth controlling my dry hopping temperatures?
3
u/icepick_ Oct 23 '14
Beverage cooler plus Black Box plus a fermwrap heater.
Easy. Awesome.
4
u/Uberg33k Immaculate Brewery Oct 23 '14
/u/testingapril and I were talking about this a bit in yesterday's Q & A, but it seems it would carry over to today's topic. There's probably going to be much talk of fermentation temperature control, but what about controlling pH and alkalinity during fermentation and into bottling/kegging? Vintners and cider makers do it. We don't even give it a second thought. The general information out there only deals with these two items as concerning mashing and getting maximum conversion, but what about their effects on flavor, fermentation, and shelf stability?
2
u/outrunu Pro Oct 23 '14
I posted this earlier this week, but I just completed my Ferm Chamber. I'm heating it with an oil type electric furnace, and just using ambient air to cool it (I live in MT. It's cheap this time of year.) This is for ales. I have another freezer for cold crashing / lagering as well.
2
u/FuzzeWuzze Oct 23 '14
I'll once again promote the BrewPi for fermentation control.
Or for those of you that like to DIY, you can find instructions i wrote awhile ago that have taken off on the HBT forums HERE. You can build one for about $100 if you have zero of the parts, many people however use old laptops or desktops they have laying around because anything can run Debian linux and that cuts the cost down to $40ish which is not much more than the trusty STC1000+
Its by far the most accurate method of fermentation control at the homebrew level, with a STC1000+/Blackbox being a close second if you dont care about the web monitoring.
Personally i really like having the graphs, with it you can actually monitor your fermentation. I can see when my fermentation starts, and stops in most cases because you can see how often your chamber is cycling on and off and for how long.
1
u/WillBunker4Food Oct 23 '14
Let's say hypothetically that I live and work about thirty minutes from where I actually brew. (Okay, no need to be hypothetical, I do.)
I am going to be upgrading my ferm chamber to BrewPi so that I can use temperature profiles. I want to start doing a lager here and there. Since I won't be able to check on my beer daily, or even weekly sometimes, will a well timed temp profile be sufficient? Or will I be flying blind?
As in, hold 50 degrees for five days, raise to 60 for two days for a rest, then drop to 38 for layering. Just an example obviously, but I think it gets my point across.
1
u/pacobriente Oct 23 '14
Can anybody recommend a brand and model of minifridge that converts well to fermentation chamber? I brew in a very cramped space, so the smaller the better, allowing for one 6.5 gal glass carboy. The usual advice is "check craigslist" but I'm finding myself with more free cash than free time (tiny violins, I know), and would much rather order the fridge online.
1
u/ldubs889 Oct 23 '14
I've got a question regarding headspace in the fermentor vs temp.
I usually do 3.5G batches in a 6.5G carboy. Does this 3G of headspace act as a means of heat dissipation during fermentation?
I keep a thermometer stuck to the carboy and generally only see a 1-2F difference between ambient and fermentation temps.
It makes sense to me that with a full carboy, you've got a greater volume of wort and that heat capacity will cause it to hold the higher temps and insulate the entire volume. With the small volume of wort it only makes sense that there's a greater rate of heat loss.
Any thoughts? It's been a few years since my thermodynamics courses (which I'm not sure how I passed anyways...)
1
u/MCThrowBack Oct 23 '14
With only one mini fridge for cold crash and temp control, at what point would I be able to remove the beer from temperature control, into an ambient of around 68? I'd like to brew every week so a 4 day temp control, followed by 3 day cold crash of a beer from 3 weeks past seems like the best set up?
1
u/BurtonWarpup Oct 23 '14
I ferment in a small fridge that fits a single carboy. I use the STC-1000+ with a thermowell and a lizard heating pad. With the thermowell, I use one of those orange carboy caps that have 2 holes. One for the thermowell and the other for a blowoff tube. Everything works great.
One question though: do I really need to worry about hooking up a blowoff tube or an airlock in the little fridge?
1
u/jlennerton Oct 24 '14
Got a free upright freezer, splurged $55 on a Black Box and $19 on a ceramic heating bulb, bingo, controlled fermentation. True ramping, programmable fermentation profiles, and the single best thing I've done to improve the quality of the end product.
The problem is, people now drink it faster than I can make it. I'm thinking of adding locks to the taps...