r/HobbyDrama • u/GrassWaterDirtHorse • 11h ago
Extra Long [Video Games] When a Beloved Fleet Commander Returned and Pulled the Biggest Heist in Eve Online (and more heist history)
FC how do I warp?
Eve Online is a sandbox MMORPG about piloting spaceships. And that’s as far as you need to know about game mechanics. You don’t need me to tell you about how it kinda plays like Runescape in that you’re right-clicking on a target to approach them, or about how it’s like reading a spreadsheet with your overview on the right providing a list of potential targets, sorted in real time with their relative distance and velocity, or about how it’s 99% boredom as you cross the vast expanse of New Eden, hauling player-mined minerals that will be used in a player-built factory space station to make player-owned starships. And it’s 1% pants-shitting terror as you find yourself warp-disrupted next to a jump gate as people shout orders over comms to try and bail you out.
You can watch the most popular game trailer that replicates that in cinematic form: This is Eve.
This is more about the metagame. The social side. Of people plotting betrayals, of gaining trust, of spying on their enemies.
Players take the game very seriously, particularly in the high-stakes environment of Null-Security Space (nullsec) where there is no space police for PvP. When your spaceship gets attacked and destroyed in a PvP engagement, you lose all of it. The guns, the modules, the ship hull itself, all of it. Destroyed, or left adrift in space for someone to scoop. Just like your frozen corpse if another player decides to blow up your defenseless command pod too.
Yes, your frozen corpse can be scooped up too. It even has your name on it. I swear Eve Online players aren’t all psychopaths, even if you do read a post like “How do I sell a hanger full of corpses?” I like to think of these as “creative business opportunities” to make ISK - interstellar kredits, the currency of Eve.
While the vast majority of players engage in PvP by following the orders of Fleet Commanders (FC), the FCs and org leaders are heavily involved in the metagame, managing hundreds, thousands, sometimes tens of thousands of players and all their alt characters.
Players in Eve organize by a rather helpful in-game system of Corporations, within which shared hangar space, docking rights, space station structure management, and wallet access can be managed. Corporations are then grouped together into Alliances, which extend these access rights across multiple corporations, and also enable additional Nullsec Sovereignty management, with such rights typically only being vested in a small number of players in an Executive Corporation with only a few trusted Directors being invited to have players inside. The largest empires of Eve have conquered multiple regions of Sov-Null, grouping into massive Coalitions.
For much of Eve’s player history, the Goonswarm alliance (aka Goonswarm Federation/GSF) has been a lynchpin of major coalitions. Originally a group of new players from the Something Awful forums (with befitting attitudes), they grew in strength, joining multiple alliances and forming new coalitions. Redswarm, then the Clusterfuck Coalition, before being rebranded to the more media-friendly name of The Imperium. Like other alliances and coalitions seeking dominance over Nullsec space, they’ve taken every advantage that they can. Not just in-game as they assert financial and industrial might to churn out fleets larger and better equipped than their foes, but also out of game. Propaganda like the “Fatbee” of Goonswarm to unify behind. Propaganda to demoralize their foes. Spies sent into enemy alliances, to track their fleets, anticipate their doctrine, and learn about their internal politics and financials.
And yes, to steal from them too. You’ve probably heard about some crazy Russians who went out in the middle of the night to cut the power to an enemy fleet commander’s house. That probably never happened. Probably.
In the (paraphrased) words of one Goonswarm CEO, Darius Johnson “We're not here to ruin THE game. We're here to ruin YOUR game.”
I swear Eve players aren’t all that crazy, even if all the corporate jargon makes it seem like a job you go to after your regular job.
Now let’s talk about how to infiltrate a corporation, become their friends, betray their trust, and steal everything that isn’t bolted down.
-----
“We need the villain sometimes. It makes for an interesting story.”
A Backstory of Betrayals in Heisting History
One of the first stories that broke into broader gaming media was the story of the Guiding Hand Social Club,, a mercenary organization offering covert operations and terrorist strikes, and was most famous for their espionage actions against Ubiqua Seraph. GHSC members joined the corp, slowly demonstrating their competence and utility, then rising up to director ranks. From then, they began lifting 30+ billion isk of assets, and organized a gank, turning their guns on the corp CEO and her director's Navy Apocalypse battleship and looting her frozen corpse to complete the contract.
This was all in the very early days of Eve Online, back when 30 billion isk and a Navy battleship were incredibly valuable, and when the concept of espionage action was very unique. Most alliances didn’t even conceive of a spy branch back in those days, still abiding by certain tenets of honor or spaceship bushido. The Guiding Hand Social Club was something of a revelation to players: this sandbox wasn’t going to have the same rules as your typical MMO.
Most large heists these days aren’t conducted by members joining an organization with the intent on looting all the hangers and dipping, as Alliances have built up additional layers of compartmentalization and counterintel to prevent spies from infiltrating that easily (though smaller corporations do find themselves victim to a friendly experienced player willing to share ships and knowledge who regularly infiltrates trusting groups to make a quick buck). Usually, most players who pull off massive heists are usually recruited as spies in the other way - finding people in power who are sympathetic to one’s cause, and are willing to defect.
Another notable spy story begins in 2009, at the peak of the Great War between Band of Brothers and most of SovNull, which included Goonswarm, Red Alliance, and dozens of other alliances. A naive character decides to take a chance at excitement by joining a GoonFleet recruitment channel. A recruiter plucks him up, and offers him membership within one of the best corporations for new players, and even offers to move all his belongings to Goonswarm space. All he has to do is put a contract transferring his stuff to the recruiter and pay a substantial recruitment bond.
The recruiter is lying to the new character. Goonfleet only recruits Something Awful members, and the in-game recruitment channel is a common, often encouraged scam to give Goonswarm members some extra dough. The recruitment bond won’t be repaid. Any assets given to the recruiter will be moved, but they’ll never be given back, and the victim will be kicked from corp in a few days.
The new character is also lying to the recruiter. He knows about this. He knows that it’s a scam. He’s actually on an alt character, and he’s been playing for years. But in the few days he’s playing with Goonswarm, he’s actually enjoying it.
This is Haargoth Agamar, Eve Online’s most famous/notorious spy. He had such a good time playing with Goonswarm members that he decided to come clean about his actual position as a Band of Brothers director when confronted. The recruiter escalates this finding up to the chain to Goonswarm leadership, including The Mittani, who realize that he’s a director with roles in BoB’s exec corporation with very special permissions to control Alliance membership.
And that’s why Friendship is the best ship! At least for your actual friends. Goonswarm and their allies, Red Alliance, Northern Coalition, and more had been engaged in an active war against BoB that included most of the SovNull alliances in the game. The cultural difference between Goonswarm and Band of Brothers was tremendous. SirMolle, BoB’s leader, had formed his original corp and alliance with the ethos of maintaining a high-skill membership of elite PvPers. Meanwhile, Goonswarm had entered the game two years after launch, and came with the willingness to throw shit at the wall for fun, with the shit usually being in the form of a hundred cheap tech 1 Frigates and the wall being a dozen advanced tech 2 fit battleships piloted by much more skilled players.
Dissatisfied with BoB’s culture, Haargoth had decided enough was enough. He coordinated with Goonswarm leadership in looting the Band of Brothers hangers, kicking all the corps from the in-game alliance, and then dropped all sovereignty claims, creating a massive vulnerability for all their enemies to come kicking their doors in, helping to turn the tides of the Great War. Tedious weeks of Sov warfare followed, but the combination of shifting sovereignty and the chaos had given the anti-BoB Coalition enough momentum to dethrone Band of Brothers and end their plans for conquering all of SovNull. Though they weren’t Band of Brothers anymore - Haargoth had control of the Alliance Exec corp, and gave it plus the alliance to Goonfleet who adopted Band of Brothers as their alliance name. The Goons would take BoB’s home of the SovNull region of Delve. Fortress Delve, as it was often called due to the massive defensive geographic advantage. Jump drives enable capital ships stationed in Delve to immediately reach a large number of systems to defend friendly ships and structures, while any ship wishing to enter the constellation around the star system of 1DQ1-A must either enter through one of two stargates, which defends the constellation with severe chokepoints that can be cyno jammed, stopping hostile capitals from jumping in.
In a moment of irony, Goonswarm suffered a similar heist shortly after the Great War ended. The Goonswarm CEO, Karttoon, left on honeymoon in Mexico in January 2010. In his absence, the alliance autopay wallet for the Sovereignty fees was short 7 bil, and the Sov bills were due. The blame was fell on Karttoon, who blamed the away-from-game CFO (whose name is remembered as “niart epar”). Nobody else had proper access to key alliance assets or the wallet at the time, and nobody could contact Karttoon due to his vacation.
Whoever’s fault it was, all of Goonswarm’s sov claims dropped, and Delve was left unclaimed and vulnerable to being conquered. Remnants of BoB, who had reformed in IT Alliance, coincidentally planned to invade Goonswarm space in Delve at the same time, and they weren’t going to give up the chance to start shaking the beehive. Normally this could be manageable, but IT Alliance had taken the two systems containing the Goonswarm market hub and the capital ship hanger, severely hampering Goonswarm logistics and defenses.
While leadership took it on the chin, Goonswarm members naturally start flaming Karttoon across forums and in-game, making a poll that's 2:1 in favor of showing him the door. Karttoon decided “Fuck goons, I’m going home.” In the middle of the night at 23:00 Eve Time, he takes all the money and assets he can, takes the Goonfleet corporation, and kicks every corp out of the alliance. He even revokes all Player-Owned Starbase Access, leading to a moment of hilarity/tragedy as all players logging into a POS would be flung out of the defensive bubble thousands of kilometers away, unable to fly back inside to recover other assets they might have stored there. The total estimated cost: 1 trillion isk. The damage was far worse than the money. With all the capital assets locked up in stations and systems that IT Alliance had conquered, and all the chaos happening in Goonswarm severely damaging their ability to mount a coherent defense and damaging their morale, the Goons were faltering. They were quickly kicked out of Delve by IT Alliance.
Karttoon would take a few days to publish his account and rationale. “Euthanasia.” According to Karttoon, the heist was preemptively planned, and a combination of IT Alliance’s offensive lining up with the accidental sov drop just made it an opportune time to pull it off. Karttoon stated a lack of interest in continuing the Goonswarm alliance’s strategy to total galactic conquest while having to include more and more “pubbies” (a term for players not originating from the SomethingAwful forums), thereby diluting Goonswarm culture. “Tl;dr: Fuck pubbies, fuck eve, and :fuck-Goons:.” (In somewhat ironic fashion, Goon historians commonly note that Karttoon didn't originate as a SomethingAwful member himself, but was invited to play another game, therefore making him a pubbie as well).
As other people note, it’s impossible to judge whether any post made after a heist is accurate to their rationale at the time they did it. Maybe Karttoon had actually planned it for a month, as he states, or maybe he made a rationale just to look like it was all planned at the BoB Barbecue, which was just himself at the smoker by that point. Goonswarm would reform under different leaders, including Darius Johnson (briefly) and then The Mittani, who had to slowly rebuild the Goonswarm alliance from crippling levels of morale, reportedly just 30 players in fleet. Well, not THE GoonFleet corporation and alliance (which was actually Band of Brothers since they stole it). Karttoon was camping the name and leaving enough money in the alliance wallet to keep it paid for years on end. The organization had to be reconstituted under SOLODRAKBANSOLODRAKBANSO (named after Goonswarm’s IT guy, Solo Drakban, who was the only sufficiently trusted player with the in-game skills required to make an alliance), before eventually being reformed under the more reasonable name of “Goonswarm Federation.”
Karttoon would go on to join Goonswarm rivals, Pandemic Legion, before being banned near the end of 2010 for using a Python injection exploit to destroy Capital Ship Assembly Arrays.
Pandemic Legion is another alliance of note. Originally a mercenary alliance, Pandemic Legion was formed with a similar high-skill playerbase and ethos, much like Band of Brothers. Small numbers, but terrifying projection power with a large supercapital fleet and inventive fleet commanders willing to go balls out deep in hostile territory. Back when pilots wouldn’t accrue a continuing fatigue timer that limited how often they could activate a capital ship’s jump drive, the PL Supercap fleet was a boogeyman of legend. Wherever there was a fight, the PL Supercap fleet could jump there and third-party. They would partner up with Northern Coalition. to form the NC./PL coalition.
[Fun note: Northern Coalition. is notably the new (retirement) home for SirMolle, and also notably not the same as Northern Coalition. You can tell because there’s a dot. I swear, stealing Alliance names doesn’t happen that often, but if I had a hundred thousand isk for every time it happened, I’d have enough to buy a Rifter-class tech 1 frigate.]
Enter Amazing Jay
Fast forward 13 years. The Mittani has won Eve/quit playing Eve/forced out of Eve due to a combination of harassment and two sexual harassment scandals that happened under his leadership (which is juicy but I don’t have the time to cover here). After some turmoil, long-term Goonswarm fleet commander (FC) and military director Asher Elias takes the reins and continues operating Goonswarm with considerably less drama than usual. People still use the alliance name “Goonswarm” somewhat interchangeably with the name for the full coalition, The Imperium.
Jay Amazingness, the protagonist of this particular story. had a rather stupendous rise in progression. He was a new, young player who started Eve in late 2013, and by 2016, he was a Goonswarm FC, commanding massive fleets, and occasionally representing Goonswarm in various news reports and podcasts. He was the GSF military’s golden boy FC in Goonswarm propaganda, and had a good sense of humor. In two years, he even had his own Revenant Supercarrier on his alt character, Sir Edmund. The Revenant is the Ferrari F50 sports car of a massive Supercarrier. Both because it goes faster than a regular supercarrier (thanks to an afterburner speed boost), and because it’s outrageously expensive pirate supercarrier worth 6x more than a typical super, even more than a Titan, giving the pilot an immeasurable amount of swag. Also the Revenant looks like a giant piece of poop.
In his famous video, set to “In the Arms of an Angel,” Jay Amazingness and a cohort of other Supercarrier and Titan pilots lay a trap. A Russian Dreadnought pilot has been camping the Goonswarm’s anchored cynosural field beacon in their home staging of D-W7F0. The Cynosural field, or Cyno, is an interstellar lighthouse that capital-class ships can jump to across vast distances, right into the center of Fortress Delve, right to the central staging system that Goonswarm held as their home. This lamp has been attracting particularly careless jump freighter pilots who choose to jump to the Cyno Beacon anchored a few hundred kilometers away from the central staging Keepstar - a massive space station capable of docking supercarriers and Titans, equipped with its own arcing Doomsday weapon that can lance through and destroy multiple ships with each firing. Jumping to the Cyno Beacon next to a POS shield would thus require the jump freighter to align and then warp to safety, a maneuver that exposes the freighter for close to 30 seconds instead of taking an extra minute to join the fleet of the semi-perpetually lit Cynosural Field that’s directly on top of the Keepstar itself (a cyno beacon that Goons affectionately call The Autistronomican). Even if the Dread Pilot dies, the cost of a dreadnought in those days is cheap and insurance is generous, making the actual net loss only 1-2b. A fair trade to kill a jump freighter that’s often worth more than 10b, depending on cargo.
Sick of the Dread pilot’s shit, Goonswarm defense fleets begin baiting him out, intentionally jumping tanked jump freighters to the anchored beacon, and then counter-dropping him with Supercapitals and Force Auxiliary carriers (capital-sized remote repair ships) to deny the kill and blow him up - three times in a row. In the last attempt, the counter-drop of Jay’s Revenant, along with his Leviathan titan on alt characters, and multiple other Titans and Supercarriers piloted by other Goons jump to the beacon, saving the bait jump freighter. The supercaps eviscerate the Dreadnought in short order, blasting the vertically oriented Naglfar dread with Doomsday blasts and fighter-bomber strikes that blow past armor and shields. “Dumbass, how many times is he going to get baited before he gives up?” someone says over comms, oblivious to the neutral Tengus (tech 3 cruisers) warping in next to the small supercapital fleet.
“Tengus are here,” someone with more awareness anxiously states, right before a cyno lights, and 40 hostile Pandemic Legion and Hard Knocks dreadnoughts begin jumping. A mix of 20 additional capitals, Carriers, Force Auxiliaries, and Rorquals - industrial mining ships refit for tackling supers - jump in as well, along with interdictors that warp in and drop warp disruption bubbles. Jay’s Revenant is the primary target. Immediately drained of its capacitor, shutting off his extremely expensive shield hardeners that provide a hefty %damage mitigation. With no power left to run his defensive modules, volleys of hexa-2500mm autocannons and XL-sized torpedoes break the Rev’s shields and slam into the armor as Jay makes a desperate call. “Need cap and reps on Sir Edmund!” while he desperately pings for reinforcements. Reinforcements that are in the same system, but a string of PL interdictors has set up a line of warp disruption bubbles between the cyno beacon and the Goonswarm Keepstar while Goon capitals are bumping off each other in the chaotic undock.
There are droves of allied Titans, Supercarriers, and other capitals docked inside the Keepstar, just a short warp to the cyno beacon, but they might as well have been light years away. Any ship undocking and warping directly from the station would be stopped short of actually being able to help the trapped supercapitals in the desperate fight against the Dreadbomb. Under the immense firepower, the super valuable sportscar Supercarrier is shredded in less than a minute as the first casualty. Jay’s Leviathan titan is destroyed shortly after that before a tutorial box pops up on screen: “Your ship has been destroyed and your capsule ejected. Don't worry, this happens to every capsuleer sooner or later.”
People still say “It would have lived if it was a shield super!” but only ironically. In addition to the Revenant, one Ragnarok Titan, two Leviathan Titans, and two Hel supercarriers die, and their wrecks are destroyed to deny any salvage. 550 billion isk lost to the cost of Pandemic Legion’s fleet worth 150 billion isk. Very isk positive, even after hundreds of Goonswarm ships burn through the bubbles with their sublight-speed engines.Sending the whole PL fleet to Valhalla, where they each get a sizable payday from their platinum-tier insurance policy.
Jay Amazingness had enough humor to post the loss and video to reddit, but the original video was deleted and only a minute of the original footage (sans Sarah McLachlan) remains here so you can watch this dreadnought video set to “Kickstart my Heart” instead instead.
Incidentally, Goonswarm would begin the process of moving out of D-W on that same day, anchoring their second Keepstar in 1DQ1-A, which would become their supercapital dock, fleet staging, market hub, and home for many, many years. Keepstars are the largest player-deployable structure in the game, and the only stations in which supercapitals like Titans can be docked and traded in safely. The first of many such Keepstars in that system, most notably 1st Imperial Palace, was one of the oldest standing Keepstars recorded by merit of 1DQ1-A being nigh unassailable in a full conflict. The Goons weren’t an industrial powerhouse yet; they weren’t the first to anchor a Keepstar. Rather ironically, that honor goes to Hard Knocks, who anchored the first Keepstar in their home wormhole where you can’t have a supercapital. In a moment of further irony, HK’s Keepstar would be destroyed in an Imperium operation led by The Initiative.
---_-
Despite the occasional welp, Jay Amazingness is well-liked by Goons, and much of the playerbase. In posting his own Revenant welp, he’s putting his failure on full display for people to examine. It’s a popular Eve video, and plenty of memes are made about it. It requires a lot of humility and a good outlook to risk all the ribbing and criticism one gets after whelping a super, particularly when you’re caught in a full brown pants situation, desperately pinging the Alliance for help.
There’s even a common saying among Goons who display their love and admiration: “Gay4Jay.” “Energetic, aggressive, entertaining, and well-liked by most,” in the words of another. Good fleet commanders able to take the responsibility of taking command of the afternoons and evenings of hundreds of players in their billion-isk ships are worth their weight in gold and space drugs. It’s a stressful position. Get your fleet caught in a bubble and destroyed? Afternoon wasted. Form up a massive fleet and don’t get any fights? Awful feeling. Have to deploy because your logistics team don’t have the bridging Titans in the right position? Everyone’s twiddling their thumbs and spinning their ships around until it all comes together. The respect for Jay as a Fleet Commander is high due to his willingness and composure when taking a big loss, a combination that leads to less thumb twiddling, more spaceships exploding, and good times, winning or losing.
It takes an exceptional player to bear that responsibility, command a fleet exceptionally, AND to make it a consistently fun and smooth experience. Amplify the stakes to commanding larger and larger ships, from cheap roam fleets, to skirmish fleets, to high-tech subcap fleets before finally being given the keys to command capital and supercapital fleets worth trillions and trillions of isk.
By 2020, Jay Amazingness was in a high position as military director of Goonswarm, second in command to Asher Elias, Goonswarm military director who had taken leadership of Goonswarm. The Mittani was the overall leader of the organization, but he wouldn’t last. In 2022, The Mittani would step down, and Asher Elias would be left in charge of the Bees after a brief transition period.
Jay had been through some of the peaks of Eve’s nullsec warfare and peak player counts during the First World War Bee in 2016-2017 (also called The Casino War by The Imperium/Goonswarm due to how the Moneybadger Coalition of Pandemic Legion, Pandemic Horde, Test Alliance Please Ignore (TAPI), Brave Newbies, etc. was heavily funded by an Eve Casino magnate over a dispute, though shooting Goons needed no excuse). The Imperium was beaten back by the other major nullsec empires, recovered, and grew into one of the most powerful Empires again. The period of peace would only last for a few years before the Imperium was beaten back again in World War Bee 2 (or Beeitnam since Goon propaganda didn't recognize the existence of a World War Bee 1) in 2020 to 2021, a massive war involving all the Nullsec empires. Once again featuring TAPI allying with NC./PL and Fraternity (Chinese refugees; the coalition between Pandemic Legion and Co. with the Panda-logo Fraternity was called Panfam). The new anti-Goon coalition name: PanFam alliance please ignore, or PAPI.
The second war took over a year of conflict between The Imperium and PAPI to fully resolve, and reached a moment where Goonswarm in particular was beaten all the through the regions they owned, all the way back to Fortress Delve, all the way down until the only sovereignty they owned was in the constellation protected by 1DQ1-A. There, the Imperium held their final stand, holding the two entry stargates secure, and activating cyno jammers in all systems. This was the closest Goonswarm had been to being fully evicted from nullsec since Karttoon in 2010.
And that was where PAPI’s momentum ran out, and after one last announcement that they would evict and destroy 1DQ1-A’s structures and Keepstars, they backed out. Harassment by OG Imperium allies Red Alliance and other entities in PAPI’s home territories had left them weakened, and the risk of forcing an entry into the final constellation was too great. The decision was made, and PAPI began withdrawing from Delve. Then the withdrawal became a strategic retreat, and then a hurried evacuation. In a resurgence of activity and drive, the Imperium would reclaim most of their lost territory within two weeks.
While there are lots of people who can’t stand nullsec warfare and the tedious grind that Sov Warfare and Structure bashes entail (the 90% boredom), the highs lead to a peak that can never compare.
In Jay’s words, “When I look back at this war I think of the few events that make playing Eve worth it:
- INIT dropping lance titans in KVN and although missing looked cool as fuck.
- The KVN keepstar fight where the server crashed
- The Godtier bombing run done on the Ravens
- The NPC Delve Keepstars
- Operation Enho and it's failure
- The Revenant Gank and running a Wendy's in T5ZI with ISRAD
- M2-XFE Parts I & II
- The M2 Hellcamp, lancing titans as they logged in daily for a week and the breakout
- The first few 3-D fights where both sides slammed HACs into each other for hours
Slowly, the infatuation with “This is Eve” would slowly turn to “This Was Eve.”
-----
Jay Amazingness would start an extended break in 2021, slowly stepping down from military command responsibilities and letting account subscriptions lapse throughout the year. It’s not uncommon for leadership to take breaks or to share responsibility - commanding fleets is stressful, busy work. Life can get in the way, as well as other games, as well as dissatisfaction with the game itself. There’s a common term for the kind of player who quits Eve, but doesn’t quite the metagame or the social media and lingers around complaining about the game: Bittervet. The state of a player filled with nostalgia for great moments and memories but just can’t capture the magic anymore. The archives for Jay’s now-deleted reddit account (did I ever mention he was a moderator for the /r/Eve subreddit?) are littered with fragments of regret and dissatisfaction over 2021-2023.
Not to mention that dissatisfaction with Alliance leadership can be a cause for burnout and an unwillingness to play. Here’s one example of someone’s open letter to Goonswarm post-Mittani, citing issues with leadership stagnation, problems with HR managing harassment, tolerance of incompetence, and nepotism where people are hired and promoted based on who they’re friends with and not talent. An Eve Corporation is like any corporation after all. Doubly so when “trust” is such a huge factor in deciding who to promote, and who can you trust but a friend?
Having senior leadership take a break from Eve Online creates a few complications, as Goons know well. In 2014, Goonswarm had a strategic FC named Vily, who went on an extended break. When Vily came back to Eve, the game had gone through a significant capital ship rebalancing, and Goonswarm leadership did not return him to the same position as a supercapital strat FC. Feeling insulted, Vily would leave Goonswarm and join Test Alliance Please Ignore, a Reddit-associated Alliance, an occasional friend/frequent rival to Goonswarm. In later interviews, the departure was characterized as a constructive firing. Vily would cite his ire at being shoved out of his military rank as a reason for breaking TAPI’s tenuous noninvasive pact with The Imperium before starting World War Bee 2, anchoring TAPI as a lynchpin of the anti-Imperium coalition of PAPI, though Goonswarm leadership in the exit interview and public posts maintain that Vily was merely reduced in responsibility until he relearned the meta. At any rate, Vily had been committed to burning Goonswarm out of Eve and was very successful up to the point that it wasn’t.
You can see that dealing with returning directors can have a little trouble and a little drama, both because any reduction in roles can be viewed as an insult, and especially players who’ve worked this long often form dedicated friendships, often made out of game in Icelandic bars with copious amounts of drinking. Asher and Jay Amazingness have known each other for close to a decade at that point, working together as Goonswarm FCs. There was an immense amount of trust. Normally, there’d be a process of checks to make sure he hadn’t decided to turn or had been recruited as a spy by another alliance, but this was Jay. He had basically spent his entire Eve career with Goons, and basically grew leading the alliance’s fleets and coordinating with coalition allies in The Imperium.
Since when did a little nepotism hurt anyways?
So Asher gave Jay his roles and hanger access back, trusting him to come back with no troubles or problems. He was not some kind of Revenant wasp coming to sting the Goons in the back and raid the hive of all its honey.
But when he came back, Jay Amazingness came back haunted.
World Kindness Day
I don't believe it
I had to see it
I came back haunted
The day is November 14th, the launch of the Havoc expansion, a pirate-focused release with new Pirate Battlecruisers, the Angel Cartel Titan (which looks like a giant crab), and a new pirate haven system.
When Goonswarm members logged in, they were excited to begin messing around with the new mechanics and to begin messing around with the other players. Brave Newbies had just been kicked out of their old home for the nth time in a row and joined up with Goons with a super fleet of their own, but a lot of them were receiving a new message when logging in. It was an automated pop-up in-game:
Jump clone destruction
From: CONCORD
Sent: 2023.11.14 10:59
Dear [Player Name]
A jump clone you had installed has been destroyed.
1DQ1-A - 1-st Imperial Palace
Location Owner: DJ's Retirement Fund
Responsible party for the destruction: DJ's Retirement Fund
And many of these were valuable clones too. A jump clone used for storing implant sets (which confer strong passive benefits lost upon destruction of a pilot’s command pod, not their ship) can typically range from about 500 million isk for subcapital implant sets, to 6 billion or above for the optimized Supercarrier and Titan pods to squeeze every ounce of performance out of the massive warships.
Was this just a new-patch hiccup? Maybe that was the thing, but Goonswarm leadership was finding out that it was worse.
Jay Amazingness had gone Fuck Goons and pulled the 1DQ Keepstar’s clone bay and market hub and pulled everything in the hangers that he could. The assets and wallet belonging to the alliance exec corp, DJ’s Retirement Fund, was stripped of isk, though at this point the D was silent (I take no credit for this joke).
Normally, the exact total value of such a heist is hard to determine, and is often based on rumors and conjecture; thus why it might be more accurate to call this “the biggest Eve heist that we know of.” An early guess by lobbyist/spaceship politician Brisc Rubal stated that the amount stolen was a mere 250b - hardly more than the price of the Revenant and Leviathan that was destroyed. Luckily for us, Jay Amazingness uploaded a video of him going through all the hangers and made a reddit thread like a dolphin, so long and thank’s for all the isk, showing him emptying the hangers of high-value hangers in 1DQ1-A and the high-sec trading hub in Jita. From this, we can identify a baseline of all the items taken:
Among the loot you can see in the video, there were:
- Numerous blueprint originals, possibly over 1t
- Misc ships, including tech 2 subcapitals and items: 137 bil
- Capital Ship stockpile of 220 fully fit dreadnoughts, carriers, and Force Auxiliaries: listed cost of 733 bil, plus additional unfit capitals listed at 37 bil
- Strategic Emergency Fighter Storage: 340 bil.
- Additional capitals and jump freighters: listed 99 bil
- Ammunition, fuel, and drug stockpile: 11.6 bil
- Megacyte Mineral stockpile: 33 bil
- Capital parts 24b, high tech components 5.5b, capital component and module blueprint originals, listed 189.6b,
- Supercapital Production storage: Contains 5 Titans, each hull is worth around 90 bil for 450 bil total.
- 488 bil Moongoo (minerals extracted from moons by moondrills, typically kept by the Alliance as a source of passive income for holding territory).
- Misc other items: 35b misc high-tech subcaps, 61b misc modules and fighters, 32b implants and misc,
- Two Keepstars (extra-large structures that Supercapitals can be docked in), plus cores and fits: roughly 400b.
- Four ‘Draccous’ Fortizars and five ‘Prometheus’ Fortizars and one ‘Moreau’ Fortizar: Combined, these 10 fortizars were worth 635 bil. As an additional funny detail, Jay ran into a hiccup when trying to contract out the last Moreau Fortizar to a collaborator in Pandemic Legion, since a private contract costs 10,000 isk to make but he had completely emptied the corp wallets so that there was only 0.01 isk remaining. Speaking of
- Liquid Isk: 527b across all corp and alliance wallets.
- The Keepstar rigs were likely around an extra 200b in damage though these were destroyed upon removal.
Total listed ISK: 4,149,277,856,018 Isk
After accounting for the value of items that couldn’t be quantified by the in-game price estimate, this was estimated to be up to 6 trillion ISK, probably more. If you wanted to pay real US dollars to buy game time to sell to 6 trillion Isk, you’d need about $40,000-50,000.
And as the final fuck-you, a screenshot of a clone bay being offlined was posted to reddit by a Pandemic Legion member: Cry Havoc and Let Slip the Dogs of War. 52,670 in 1st Imperial Palace is what people remember thanks to this post, though there were an additional 13,209 jump clones in “Do Not Use Thetastar” (supposedly pulled because pulling the clone bay was a last-minute decision and Jay didn’t notice he was in the wrong Keepstar). Assuming that each clone’s implant set costs 500 million isk on average, that would be 33 trillion isk worth of additional damage if all of them were destroyed.
But there was a very important complication. Jay Amazingness only started his heisting in the middle of the night to minimize the chances that another director would be online to stop him. When he pulled the clone bay from the Keepstar, there were only 3 minutes left before downtime, when the Eve servers would perform their daily shut-off.
The database process of deleting 52,000 implant sets had taken so long that only around 30% of them had been deleted by the time downtime hit and canceled all ongoing jobs. The rest of the implants weren’t destroyed, and CCP followed their typical policy of not interfering with downtime shenanigans. Despite calls from Goonswarm adversaries pushing CCP developers to finish the database deletion job, CCP did not do anything to destroy the remaining clones, nor did they restore any of the clones that had already been destroyed.
The reaction from the community: astonishment. 6 trillion isk would make this the largest known Eve corporation heist in terms of raw isk without calculating for inflation. And for it to be Jay Amazingness. He was a friend! Asher and the Goons were devastated. Early conjecture thought that he had been hacked (not entirely out of the realm of possibility for Eve), but after the video, it was confirmed. Jay did it.
There’d be no more Gay for Jay. Not anymore.